Flxible Metro

Last updated
Flxible Metro/Grumman 870
Flxible Metro of Santa Clara County Transit on manufacturer-demo loan to Portland's TriMet in 1987.jpg
A Flxible Metro 40102-6C of Santa Clara County Transit (San Jose, California) in 1987
Overview
Manufacturer Flxible
Production1978–1983 (as Grumman 870)
1983–1995 (as Flxible Metro)
Assembly Delaware, Ohio
Powertrain
Engine Detroit Diesel or Cummins
Transmission ZF, Voith, or Allison
Dimensions
Length30 ft (9.14 m), 35 ft (10.67 m), or 40 ft (12.19 m)
Width96 in (2.44 m) or 102 in (2.59 m)
Height120 in (3.05 m)
Chronology
Predecessor Flxible New Look
SuccessorNone – (out of business)

The Flxible Metro is a transit bus that was assembled and manufactured by the Flxible Corporation from 1983 until 1995. From 1978 until early-1983, when Flxible was owned by Grumman, the model was known as the Grumman 870, with a Grumman nameplate. The earlier model 870 experienced a large number of major design defects and deficiencies, some of which led to the filing of lawsuits against the company by purchasers, and the successor "Metro" model addressed those defective design issues.

Contents

Over the combined 17-year production history, a total of 14,456 were built, of which 4,642 were model 870 and 9,814 were Metros. [1]

History

Flxible/Rohr 870 prototype at Alameda South Shore Center while testing with AC Transit, September 1976 Flxible 870 at Alameda South Shore Center Scan 275 (12192983725).jpg
Flxible/Rohr 870 prototype at Alameda South Shore Center while testing with AC Transit, September 1976

Under the ownership of Rohr Industries since 1970, while their very popular Flxible New Look was still in production, Rohr began development of what would become the Grumman 870 Advanced Design Bus. The Grumman 870 bus was one of two advanced-design buses (the other being the Rapid Transit Series (RTS II) developed by rival General Motors and later taken by MTS). [3] Both models were compromises by the Urban Mass Transit Administration (UMTA), which sought to develop a "Transbus" design that would be "attractive, roomy, comfortable", and easier for elderly and disabled customers to board, accepting these two models as compromises. At the time, the federal government would subsidize the purchase of only the 870 or the RTS II. [4] [5]

In 1978, Rohr sold Flxible to Grumman for US$55 million, with the sale including the sale of two prototypes of what would become the 870. In spite of the fact that the second prototype failed testing as the result of a cracked "A" frame, and with an endurance test not yet performed, Grumman decided that the 870 was ready for production, and discontinued the Flxible New Look almost as soon as the purchase closed [6] (more in "Litigation resulting" below). The first 870 rolled off the assembly line in spring 1978. [3] Under Grumman ownership, Grumman-Flxible (as the company was called at the time) received a major order of buses from the New York City Transit Authority along with other agencies. The NYC Transit Authority order, built in 1980, is notable because this batch would expose the design flaw in A-frame noted during testing: the inability of the bus to withstand wear and tear in cities where potholes were a problem, forcing all 870s built until that time to be taken out of service beginning that December while repairs to the A-frame were made, which would cost Grumman $7 million to fix. A total of 2,656 buses, including buses in Atlanta, Chicago, Connecticut, Houston, Los Angeles and Orange County, California needed to be fixed. [4]

Eventually, Grumman was forced to sell the line to General Automotive Corporation in 1983 for $41 million, a 25-percent loss after developing the "Flxible Metro" which addressed all of the shortcomings of the Model 870 in 1982. [7] Under the ownership of General Automotive, the Flxible nameplate was restored to the buses.[ citation needed ]

A 1992 Flxible Metro 40102-6C in Portland, Oregon, in 2013. TriMet was one of the last agencies operating Flxible Metro buses past 2010. 1992 Flxible bus, TriMet 1714, in downtown Portland in 2013.jpg
A 1992 Flxible Metro 40102-6C in Portland, Oregon, in 2013. TriMet was one of the last agencies operating Flxible Metro buses past 2010.

Production continued until late 1995, when financial problems prompted the company to suspend production and lay off most of its workforce at the Delaware, Ohio, factory. [8] The layoffs were initially planned to be temporary, but ultimately became permanent, [8] and in 1996 Flxible was forced into Chapter 11 bankruptcy and liquidated. Parent company General Automotive would meet the same fate as Flxible (bankruptcy and liquidation) the following year. [9]

The last Flxible Metros delivered were ones delivered in November 1995 to Monterey-Salinas Transit (Monterey, California), and the Baltimore Metropolitan Transit Authority (Baltimore, Maryland). However, neither of these orders included the Metro with the highest serial number (106591), which had been delivered the previous month to Columbus, Ohio. [8] The official production total for the Metro model from company records is 9,820, but there is strong evidence indicating that the last six of the 25-bus order for Baltimore were never built, and this makes the total more likely to be 9,814 units. [1]

In 1995, some used 870s were purchased from the Central Ohio Transit Authority (Columbus, Ohio) by Kirov, Russia, where they were used until 2004. [10]

Litigation resulting

New York City Transit Grumman 870 236, preserved as an historic vehicle NYC Transit Grumman Flxible 870 236.jpg
New York City Transit Grumman 870 236, preserved as an historic vehicle

The Grumman era of production would result in a number of lawsuits related to defects in the A-frame of the 870, involving either Flxible's former owner Rohr or the Metropolitan Transportation Authority of New York.

  1. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), in whose buses where the first cracked A-frame problem was noticed in early December 1980 at their Ulmer Park Depot, yanked its NYC Transit Authority fleet for the first time in 1980 (a separate batch for MSBA was built with the problem rectified the next year) and sued Grumman. This lawsuit would result in a settlement to fix all 870 buses built until that time (2,656 examples in all), along with an early termination of the build contract where the final 200 buses of the order were transferred to General Motors. [4] [5]
  2. In 1983, shortly before Grumman sold Flxible, Grumman would sue Rohr Industries for $500 million in federal court, claiming that it was not aware of design flaws in the 870 model before it began production shortly after the sale closed. Rohr was quickly granted summary judgment, which was upheld on appeal; the court noted that Grumman indeed had access to all of the testing information, including knowledge that testing was incomplete. [6]
  3. In 1984, following a fire in a Model 870 NYCTA bus number 411, David L. Gunn, on only his fifth day on the job with the MTA, ordered the Grumman 870 fleet within New York City off the road for the final time (the units for MSBA built in 1981, owned by Nassau County (NY), as well as the units built for the five private companies in the Borough of Queens, New York remained in service until the mid-1990s). That May, the MTA sued Grumman again (which by this time no longer owned the line), asking for $184 million in damages as the result in fraud and $140 million to purchase replacements, referring to the buses as "lemons". [11] [12] [13] This time, Grumman would countersue the MTA for $1 billion, claiming that poor maintenance was the cause, and took out full-page advertisements in local media attesting to this fact. [5] [11] The MTA would end up paying $56 million back to the Urban Mass Transit Administration for refusing to run the buses. The buses would sit for nearly two years at the Brooklyn Army Terminal until late 1985, when UMTA exchanged the payment for equity in MTA properties, allowing for 835 of the 851 buses to be sold. [14] 620 of the buses were rebuilt and sold to New Jersey Transit, 175 of these buses were also rebuilt and sold to the Queen City Metro of Cincinnati, Ohio, with the remaining 40 buses rebuilt and sold to a transit agency in Puerto Rico. The 16 unsold buses were held for evidence until the lawsuit was resolved; [5] one bus (236) was preserved, 13 were sold to the Pioneer Valley Transportation Authority of Springfield, Massachusetts in early 1985, and the remaining two were scrapped.

Model history

The model history of the Grumman 870/Flxible Metro is as follows:

Grumman-Flxible 870 (1978–1982)
Initially, the same model naming that was used for the Flxible New Look's third generation was retained.
Nominal seating capacityWidthEngine typeAir conditioning
35 = 30 ft
45 = 35 ft
53 = 40 ft
096 = 96 in
102 = 102 in
-6 = Detroit Diesel 6V711
-8 = Detroit Diesel 8V712
-0 = No air conditioning
-1 = Air conditioning
Beginning in April 1980, the model designation was revised, with the first two digits now indicating length instead of nominal seating capacity.
LengthWidthEngine typeAir conditioning
30 = 30 ft
35 = 35 ft
40 = 40 ft
096 = 96 in
102 = 102 in
-6 = Detroit Diesel 6V711
-8 = Detroit Diesel 8V712
-0 = No air conditioning
-1 = Air conditioning
Flxible Metro (1983–1996)
Following the purchase of Grumman by General Automotive, the model naming was revised to better identify the engines used.
LengthWidthEngine typeAir conditioning
30 = 30 ft
35 = 35 ft
40 = 40 ft
096 = 96 in
102 = 102 in
-4D = Detroit Diesel Series 50
-6C = Cummins L10
-6C8 = Cummins C8.3
-6M = Cummins M11E
-6N = Detroit Diesel 6V71 (1983-1992)
-6T = Detroit Diesel 6V92TA (1983-1992)
-6TL = Detroit Diesel 6V71TA (1983–1989)
or 6L71TA (1990–1992)
-0 = No air conditioning
-1 = Air conditioning
Notes
  1. Some 1981–1983 units used the Detroit Diesel 6V92TA, including 1981 models which went to New Jersey Transit and Santa Monica Municipal Bus Lines.
  2. Some 1978–1981 units used Cummins VTB903, including a few from 1978 which went to Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority.

A letter is often used to denote the different generations of the Metro:

  • A = 1983–1986
  • B = 1987–1991
  • C = 1992
  • D = 1993–3rd quarter 1994
  • E = 4th quarter 1994–1996

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grumman</span> 1929-1994 aerospace manufacturer

The Grumman Aircraft Engineering Corporation, later Grumman Aerospace Corporation, was a 20th century American producer of military and civilian aircraft. Founded on December 6, 1929, by Leroy Grumman and his business partners, it merged in 1994 with Northrop Corporation to form Northrop Grumman.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New York City Transit Authority</span> Bus and subway service operator

The New York City Transit Authority is a public-benefit corporation in the U.S. state of New York that operates public transportation in New York City. Part of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the busiest and largest transit system in North America, the NYCTA has a daily ridership of 8 million trips.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flxible</span> American manufacturer of coaches and buses from 1913 to 1996

The Flxible Co. was an American manufacturer of motorcycle sidecars, funeral cars, ambulances, intercity coaches and transit buses, based in the U.S. state of Ohio. It was founded in 1913 and closed in 1996. The company's production transitioned from highway coaches and other products to transit buses over the period 1953–1970, and during the years that followed, Flxible was one of the largest transit-bus manufacturers in North America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Twin Coach</span> American vehicle manufacturing company

Twin Coach was an American vehicle manufacturing company from 1927 to 1955, located in Kent, Ohio, and a maker of marine engines and airplane parts until the 1960s. It was formed by brothers Frank and William Fageol when they left the Fageol Motor Company in 1927. They established the company in Kent to manufacture and sell buses with a new concept design. The body structure of this new bus was unique in that the body also became the frame and two engines – "twin" engines – were used to allow for larger passenger loads. This concept was patented by William B. Fageol.

The Yellow Coach Manufacturing Company was an early manufacturer of passenger buses in the United States. Between 1923 and 1943, Yellow Coach built transit buses, electric-powered trolley buses, and parlor coaches.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rohr, Inc.</span>

Rohr, Inc. is an aerospace manufacturing company based in Chula Vista, California, south of San Diego. It is a wholly owned unit of the Collins Aerospace division of Raytheon Technologies; it was founded in 1940 by Frederick H. Rohr as Rohr Aircraft.

NJ Transit Bus Operations' and companies leasing buses from NJ Transit use various models of buses between 25 and 60 feet in length to provide service within the state of New Jersey. The lists and rosters below list current and past buses purchased new or inherited by NJ Transit for heavy duty fixed-route service.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">GM New Look bus</span> American public transit bus

The GM New Look bus is a municipal transit bus that was introduced in 1959 by the Truck and Coach Division of General Motors to replace the company's previous coach, retroactively known as the GM "old-look" transit bus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rapid Transit Series</span> American transit bus type

The Rapid Transit Series (RTS) city bus is a long-running series of transit buses that was originally manufactured by GMC Truck and Coach Division during 1977, in Pontiac, Michigan. First produced in 1977, the RTS was GMC's offering of an Advanced Design Bus design and is the descendant of GMC's prototype for the U.S. Department of Transportation's Transbus project. The RTS is notable for its then-futuristic styling featuring automobile-like curved body and window panels; the Advanced Design Buses were meant to be an interim solution between the high-floor transit buses that preceded them, such as the GMC New Look, and modern low-floor buses that would facilitate passenger boarding and accessibility. Most current buses are now made by specialized coach manufacturers with flat sides and windows.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orion V</span> Motor vehicle

The Orion V was a line of rigid high-floor transit buses available in 32', 35', and 40' lengths manufactured by Ontario Bus Industries between 1989 and 2009. The conventionally powered buses, either with longitudinally mounted diesel or natural gas engines, used a T-drive transmission coupling. The Orion V replaced the Orion I, and was in turn replaced by the low-floor Orion VI and Orion VII.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Los Angeles Metro bus fleet</span>

The Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority operates a vast fleet of buses for its Metro Bus and Metro Busway services. As of September 2019, Metro has the third largest bus fleet in North America with 2,320 buses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">GM "old-look" transit bus</span> GM bus manufactured from 1940 to 1969

The GM "old-look" transit bus was a transit bus that was introduced in 1940 by Yellow Coach beginning with the production of the model TG-3201 bus. Yellow Coach was an early bus builder that was partially owned by General Motors (GM) before being purchased outright in 1943 and folded into the GM Truck Division to form the GM Truck & Coach Division. The Yellow Coach badge gave way to the GM nameplate in 1944. Production of most "old-look" models was stopped upon the release of the GM New-Look bus in 1959, however some smaller "old-look" models continued to be built until 1969. Approximately 38,000 "old-look" buses were built during the 29-year production run. The "old-look" name is an unofficial retronym applied to this series of GM buses after the release of the GM New-Look series.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gillig Phantom</span> Series of buses produced by Gillig Corporation, United States from 1980 to 2008

The Gillig Phantom is a series of buses that was produced by an American manufacturer Gillig Corporation in Hayward, California. The successor to the long-running Gillig Transit Coach model line, the Phantom marked the transition of Gillig from a producer of yellow school buses to that of transit buses. The first transit bus assembled entirely by Gillig, the Phantom was produced exclusively as a high-floor bus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flxible New Look bus</span> American passenger transit bus

The Flxible New Look bus was a very popular transit bus introduced in 1959 by The Flxible Company, and produced from 1960 until 1978, when the New Look was replaced by the "870" Advanced Design Bus. Over its 17-year production run 13,121 Flxible New Look buses were manufactured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transpo '72</span>

U.S. International Transportation Exposition, better known as Transpo '72, was a trade show held on 300 acres (1.2 km2) of land at Dulles International Airport outside Washington, D.C., for nine days from May 27 to June 4, 1972. The $10 million event, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Transportation, was a showcase for all sorts of transportation-related technologies. Over a million visitors flocked to the show from all over the world. According to the Wall Street Journal, it was "the biggest show the government has put on since World War II."

Las Vegas Transit, also known as Las Vegas Transit System (LVTS), was a former operator of a small private bus system in Las Vegas, Nevada, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flyer 700/800/900 series</span> Canadian bus model series

The Flyer 700/800/900 series were a series of transit buses built in three generations by Western Flyer and its successors Flyer Industries and New Flyer, of Canada, between 1967 and 1987. Except for brief overlap during transition from one generation to the next, they were not in production concurrently. All individual model designations included a prefix of either D, for diesel propulsion, or E, for electrically powered trolleybuses, with the first digit indicating the generation and the last digit indicating a variant within the generation. The introductory model was the D700, originally released in 1967 for the Canadian transit market, and the last series group to be produced, D900, was discontinued in 1987. Flyer had become New Flyer only the year before, in 1986.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NABI SFW</span> American standard (high)-floor transit buses

The NABI SFW was a line of standard (high)-floor transit buses available in 40' rigid and 60' articulated nominal lengths, manufactured by the Ikarus USA joint venture, then by American Ikarus and North American Bus Industries (NABI) between 1989 and 2013. In addition to the different lengths, the buses were sold with a variety of prime movers, including conventional diesel and CNG combustion engines and hybrid diesel-electric power.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NABI CompoBus</span> Motor vehicle

The NABI CompoBus was a line of low-floor composite-bodied transit buses available in 40' and 45' rigid lengths manufactured by North American Bus Industries (NABI) between 2002 and 2013. In addition to the different available lengths, the buses were sold with a variety of prime movers, ranging from conventional diesel and LNG/CNG combustion engines to diesel-electric hybrid.

Transbus was announced in December 1970 as a United States Urban Mass Transportation Administration (UMTA) program to develop improvements to existing transit bus design; at the time, the US bus market was dominated by the GM New Look and Flxible New Look buses, and bus ridership was declining. The improvements had been suggested earlier by the National Academy of Sciences in 1968 to improve operating costs, reduce pollution, and stimulate ridership, and included innovations such as a low floor for easier entry and seats cantilevered from the wall to expand passenger space.

References

  1. 1 2 Ebert, Robert R. (2001). Flxible: A History of the Bus and the Company. Yellow Springs, Ohio: Antique Power, Inc. pp. 245–246. ISBN   0-9660751-2-9.
  2. "Newly designed buses tour District cities" (PDF). Transit-Times. Vol. 19, no. 4. AC Transit. October 1976. Retrieved 18 January 2019.
  3. 1 2 "History: A little history lesson about the Flxible company". Flxible Owners International. Retrieved 2014-08-10.
  4. 1 2 3 "Can Anyone Fx Those Flxibles?". Time magazine. March 30, 1981. Archived from the original on July 31, 2013. Retrieved 2014-08-10.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Feinman, Mark. "The New York City Transit Authority in the 1980s" . Retrieved 2 January 2009.
  6. 1 2 "Grumman Allied Industries v. Rohr Industries, Inc., - Alt Law". 31 October 1984. Archived from the original on August 29, 2008. Retrieved 2009-01-02.
  7. "Grumman Corporation - Company History" . Retrieved 2 January 2009.
  8. 1 2 3 Ebert (2001), pp. 215–216.
  9. Serwach, Joseph (May 12, 1997). "Bankruptcy blamed on Flxible's downfall". Crain's Detroit Business. Detroit, Michigan: Crain Communications. p. 3. Archived from the original on January 26, 2016. Retrieved 2014-08-14.(subscription may be required or content may be available in libraries that are in the U.S.)
  10. The Russian-language database of public transport - Grumman 870 buses in Kirov (Russia)
  11. 1 2 Anderson, Susan Heller; Carroll, Maurice (4 July 1984). "New York Day By Day - Grumman Tells Its Side of the Story". The New York Times. Retrieved 3 January 2009.
  12. Finder, Alan; Levine, Richard (13 May 1984). "The Region - Next Stop, Court". The New York Times. Retrieved 3 January 2009.
  13. "Corrections (May 12, 1984)". The New York Times. 12 May 1984. Retrieved 3 January 2009.
  14. "Kiley Gets Authority To Sell Flxible Buses". The New York Times. 22 December 1985. Retrieved 3 January 2009.

Further reading