Critical response
The review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes reported a 63% approval rating with an average rating of 5.2/10, based on 8 critic reviews. [27] Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 66 out of 100 based on 5 critics, indicating "generally favorable" reviews. [28]
Matthew Creith of TheWrap found Joshua Jackson's portrayal of Dr. Max Bankman as an easygoing and charming doctor engaging and relatable, particularly as he adjusts to his new environment post-COVID. He praised the chemistry between Jackson and his co-star Phillipa Soo, saying it adds depth to their characters while navigating both medical emergencies and personal interactions. Creith noted that while the series starts strong, it trends toward a more surface-level exploration of the glamorous cruise lifestyle, prompting curiosity about how the show will develop throughout the season. [29] Craig Mathieson of The Age gave Doctor Odyssey a score of three out of four stars, complimenting the show for its engaging blend of humor and drama, and likening it to Grey's Anatomy set on a cruise ship. He found the series to have a silly yet enjoyable tone, attributing this to the chemistry between the characters and the light-hearted storytelling. Mathieson said Jackson brings a charming presence to the role, showcasing both authority and a laid-back attitude. He also praised the creative team behind the show, noting that their collaboration results in a unique mix of influences, from comedic medical situations to a nostalgic nod to The Love Boat . [30]
Joel Keller of Decider said that Doctor Odyssey aims to extend the formula of Murphy's 9-1-1 franchise to a medical drama set on the high seas. He praised the show's entertainment value, likening it to The Love Boat with its mix of guest stars, outrageous medical cases, and romantic tension among the characters. Keller praised the performances, particularly those of Jackson and Soo, noting their strong chemistry and Soo's confident portrayal of her character. However, he found some moments in the first episode, such as a lengthy monologue about COVID and a dramatic rescue scene, to be over-the-top. [31] Joly Herman of Common Sense Media rated Doctor Odyssey three out of five stars, describing it as a soapy yet entertaining medical drama. She praised the series for its positive messages, pointing out the importance of integrity, teamwork, and understanding others' perspectives. Herman highlighted the strong characters who advocate for their principles and responsibilities. Despite its light-hearted approach, she found that the show effectively focuses on serious values, encouraging viewers to enjoy life while striving to be good people. [32] Columnist Maurice Tougas dismissed the series as being "so ludicrous that it's almost watchable," finding the plots repetitive. [33]
