Wikipedia:Picture peer review: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Mystery fish: try the tree of life |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{redirects|WP:PPR|Requests for page protection|Wikipedia:Requests for page protection|the portal reviews page|WP:Portal peer review}} |
|||
{| style="clear:both; background:none;" |
|||
{{historical}} |
|||
{| |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
| width="60%" style="padding:1em; border:1px solid #dfdfdf; background-color:#E7EBF5; vertical-align: top;"| |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
<small>''[{{SERVER}}{{localurl:Wikipedia:Picture Peer review|action=purge}} Purge server cache]''</small> |
|||
<!-- PICTURE PEER REVIEW IS INACTIVE --> |
|||
==Picture Peer Review Archives== |
|||
This page is a staging area for [[Wikipedia:Featured pictures|Feature Picture]] standard pictures before full nomination on [[Wikipedia:Featured picture candidates]] as well as a working area to request help with useful pictures that need editing help, or help with finding the best article that they illustrate. |
|||
<!-- Place reviewed nominees, pending archiving, below this line--> |
|||
'''Note:''' [[Peer review]] is the process of review by peers and usually implies a group of authoritative reviewers who are equally familiar and expert in the subject. The process represented by this page is not formal peer review in that sense and articles that undergo this process cannot be assumed to have greater authority than any other, merely that they have been scrutinised by other editors who are interested in the issues with illustrating Wikipedia articles. |
|||
[[Wikipedia:Picture_peer_review/Archives|'''Picture Peer Review Archives Mainpage''']]<br> |
|||
| style="padding:1em; border:1px solid #dfdfdf; background-color:#E7EBF5; vertical-align: top;" | |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
{{Shortcut|[[WP:PPR]]}} |
|||
{{Fpipages}} |
|||
|- |
|||
| colspan=2 style="padding:1em; border:1px solid #dfdfdf; background-color:#E7EBF5; vertical-align: top;"| |
|||
===Instructions=== |
|||
To ask for help with a picture fill out an FPC template, then add it to an appropriate section below. |
|||
#'''Review [[Wikipedia:What is a featured picture?]] to make sure the image is up to standards.''' |
|||
## If you think your picture may not meet standards add it to [[Wikipedia:Picture peer review]] for review. |
|||
#Create a new subpage named <tt> [[/ExampleName|Wikipedia:Picture peer review/'''ExampleName''']] </tt> |
|||
# Copy the following content into the new blank subpage: |
|||
#:'''Do not change this portion of text at all''': <tt>'''<nowiki>{{subst:PAGENAME}}</nowiki>'''</tt> |
|||
#:<pre><nowiki> |
|||
===[[Wikipedia:{{subst:PAGENAME}}| ExampleName ]]=== |
|||
[[ Image: Example.jpg |thumb| Caption goes here ]] |
|||
Add your reasons for nominating it here; |
|||
say what article it appears in, and who created the image. |
|||
*Nominate and '''support'''. - ~~~~ |
|||
* |
|||
'''Comments:''' |
|||
* |
|||
'''Seconder:''' |
|||
* |
|||
<!-- additional comments go above this line --> |
|||
<br style="clear:both;" /> |
|||
</nowiki></pre> |
|||
# Add '''<tt><nowiki>{{</nowiki>Wikipedia:Picture peer review/ExampleName<nowiki>}}</nowiki></tt>''' to the top of the appropriate section below. |
|||
|} |
|||
__TOC__ |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Place suggestions and self nominations for [[WP:FPC]] below. Anyone can then comment on a suggestion and recommend improvements. If the suggestion meets FPC guidelines and no significant objections remain, another editor can second the suggestion and move the candidate to [[WP:FPC]] for voting. If a suggestion doesn't find a seconder within one week, it can be removed to make way for new suggestions. |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
{{Wikipedia:Picture peer review/ExampleName}} |
|||
{{Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Wavecut platform}} |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
{{Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Scottish Parliament Committee Room Ceiling}} |
|||
{{Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Sidi_Saiyyad_Ni_Jaali}} |
|||
{{/HeidelbergTun}} |
|||
{{Wikipedia:Featured_picture_candidates/HermitCrab}} |
|||
{{Wikipedia:Featured picture candidates/Salt Lake 2002 Olympic Cauldron Park}} |
|||
{{Wikipedia:Featured picture candidates/Great Gallery}} |
|||
===[[Dubrovnik|Dubrovnik, Croatia]]=== |
|||
[[Image:Dubrovnik (near), Croatia.jpg|thumb|200px|A view of '''Dubrovnik''' from the south]] |
|||
[[Image:Dubrovnik edit.jpg|thumb|200px|Original image retouched by [[user:Alexander VII|Alexander VII]].]] |
|||
I thought that this image, with minor touch-ups, could be a potential candidate for featured picture. The exposure and compostition look to be very good as it is, in my opinion; |
|||
Picture can be found in the [[Dubrovnik]] article. Image was uploaded by [[user:Neoneo13|Neoneo13]]. |
|||
*Nominate and '''support'''. - [[User:Alexander VII|Alexander VII]] 22:00, 3 May 2006 (UTC) |
|||
* |
|||
'''Comments:''' |
|||
* |
|||
'''Seconder:''' |
|||
* |
|||
<!-- additional comments go above this line --> |
|||
<br style="clear:both;" /> |
|||
==Pictures that need placing on an appropriate article== |
==Pictures that need placing on an appropriate article== |
||
If you have an excellent picture, but can't think where to put it, add it to the section below. Similarly if you need help in writing a new article on the subject of a photo, request it below. |
If you have an excellent picture, but can't think where to put it, add it to the section below. Similarly if you need help in writing a new article on the subject of a photo, request it below. If you are unsure of what plant or animal is in a picture please ask at [[Wikipedia:Reference desk/Science]]. |
||
{{clear}} |
|||
===Les Arcs=== |
|||
[[image:LesArcs.JPG|400px]] |
|||
{{-}} taken by [[user:Stevage|Stevage]]. It was taken in the French ski resort Les Arcs, but I don't think it shows much of the actual ski resort. Ideas? :) [[User Talk:Stevage|Stevage]] 09:58, 21 April 2006 (UTC) |
|||
:[[Les Arcs]] wouldn't work? --[[User:Dante Alighieri|Dante Alighieri]] | [[User talk:Dante Alighieri|Talk]] 21:39, 21 April 2006 (UTC) |
|||
::I am dum. Thanks. :) [[User Talk:Stevage|Stevage]] 22:09, 21 April 2006 (UTC) |
|||
===Mystery fish=== |
|||
[[image:P1010238_crop1.jpg|400px]] |
|||
{{-}} taken by [[user:Yummifruitbat|Yummifruitbat]]. |
|||
I spotted this little character on a visit to Vancouver Aquarium, B.C. but omitted to check the display to find out what species (s)he is. If anyone can identify him (even vaguely) I could set about finding appropriate articles for him to illustrate. Thanks! :) [[User:Yummifruitbat|Yummifruitbat]] 02:10, 3 May 2006 (UTC) |
|||
:Looks like a [[goby]] to me. There are many, many species, and I don't know which one this is. --[[User:Ginkgo100|Ginkgo100]] 16:34, 3 May 2006 (UTC) |
|||
::The [[WP:TOL|Tree of Life]] Wikiproject is a good place to ask questions on identifying animals. [[User Talk:Stevage|Stevage]] 22:13, 6 May 2006 (UTC) |
|||
==Pictures that need moving from other Wikipedias== |
==Pictures that need moving from other Wikipedias== |
||
If you have found a good picture on another language Wikipedia that would benefit the English Wikipedia, suggest it below. The image may need confirmation on its identification and assistance with translating the caption and moving to Commons before placing on the equivalent English language article. |
If you have found a good picture on another language Wikipedia that would benefit the English Wikipedia, suggest it below. The image may need confirmation on its identification and assistance with translating the caption and moving to Commons before placing on the equivalent English language article. |
||
[[Category:Non-talk pages with subpages that are automatically signed]] |
|||
[[de:Wikipedia:Bilderwerkstatt]] |
|||
[[Category:Wikipedia peer review]] |
|||
[[fr:atelier graphique]] |
|||
Latest revision as of 21:32, 29 June 2022
 | This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
|
Picture peer review was a staging area for potential Featured Picture Candidates (FPCs). This review was a useful "spot check" before making a formal FPC nomination – a working area where you can get some creative feedback, request help with useful pictures that might need minor editing, or advice with finding the best article that they illustrate – giving that nomination its best possible chance of promotion. Note: "peer review" usually implies a group of authoritative reviewers who are equally familiar with and expert in the subject. The process represented by this page is not a formal academic peer review in that sense. Images that undergo this process cannot be assumed to have greater authority than any other. For general advice on editing pictures prior to uploading, see Wikipedia:How to improve image quality. For the specific criteria against which FPCs are judged, see Wikipedia:What is a featured picture?
|
Featured picture tools: |
Picture Peer Review Archives
[edit]Picture Peer Review Archives Mainpage
|
Please cut and paste nominations to be archived from the Picture peer review mainpage to the top of the appropriate archive page, creating a new archive (by nomination date) when necessary.
|
Pictures that need placing on an appropriate article
[edit]If you have an excellent picture, but can't think where to put it, add it to the section below. Similarly if you need help in writing a new article on the subject of a photo, request it below. If you are unsure of what plant or animal is in a picture please ask at Wikipedia:Reference desk/Science.
Pictures that need moving from other Wikipedias
[edit]If you have found a good picture on another language Wikipedia that would benefit the English Wikipedia, suggest it below. The image may need confirmation on its identification and assistance with translating the caption and moving to Commons before placing on the equivalent English language article.