Wikipedia:Peer review/William Spaniel/archive1
This is an article I wrote, and while I think it's good, I hope for the article to continue to be able to expand, as well as further incorporating its 3rd party sources. The ultimate goal of this article is to get featured. Anything to help will be appreciated, thanks.stealthymatt 00:41, 22 May 2007 (UTC)
- I don't mean to be a splash of cold water, but as noted on the talk page, your efforts are good at satisfying verifiability, but still not necessarily showing notability. If you consider that, say, Starcitygames and TCGplayer.com themselves don't have WP articles, it seems hard to justify a writer for one of them who hasn't done something else really incredibly notable (like become a major Wizards designer or win a World Championship). It'd be a shame to waste all the work, but perhaps one of the Magic wikis would be a better place for the article? SnowFire 03:44, 24 May 2007 (UTC)