The 50 Greatest Cartoons: As Selected by 1,000 Animation Professionals is a 1994 book by animation historian Jerry Beck, with a foreword written by Chuck Jones.
 | |
| Editor | Jerry Beck |
|---|---|
| Subject | Animation |
| Publisher | Turner Publishing |
Publication date | October 1, 1994 |
| Pages | 192 |
| ISBN | 187868549X |
| OCLC | 467065913 |
| 791.43 | |
| LC Class | NC1766.U5 F54 1994 |
The book features the fifty greatest cartoons of all time, selected by a group of 1000 cartoon historians, animation professionals and film critics. The votes were culled from ballots sent to members of the Society for Animation Studies, the International Animated Film Association, one hundred animation studios, and film critics from more than one hundred periodicals.
The cartoons selected include work from Disney Cartoons, Warner Bros. Cartoons, Fleischer Studios, MGM Cartoons, United Productions of America, Walter Lantz, National Film Board of Canada, Winsor McCay, Otto Messmer, Sally Cruikshank, Marv Newland, Frederic Back and various independent animators. Each selection has a plot summary, production history, and a critical analysis that examines why they were selected. The book also features commentary from Leonard Maltin, John Canemaker, Joe Adamson, Steve Schneider, Charles Solomon, and Leslie Cabarga.
Criteria
editIt consists of articles about 50 highly regarded animated short films made in North America and other notable cartoons, which are ranked according to a poll of 1,000 people working in the animation industry and film critics.[1][2]
Each cartoon is under 30 minutes long and cel animated (with the exception of Gertie the Dinosaur). Seventeen of the selected films were produced for Warner Bros.'s Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies series, ten of which were directed by Chuck Jones, including the #1 cartoon on the list, What's Opera, Doc? and the overall #2 pick Duck Amuck. Beck said Jones was one of "the most intellectual of the Warner crowd", and that he was one of the "first cartoon directors to experiment with stylized backgrounds and animation techniques, and his cartoons are noted for their highly artistic look and comic timing."[3]
Forty-five of the selected cartoons were created and released before 1960; the exceptions are The Big Snit (1985; No. 25),[4] The Cat Came Back (1988; No. 32), Bambi Meets Godzilla (1969; No. 38), The Man Who Planted Trees (1987; No. 44) and Quasi at the Quackadero (1975; No. 46).[5]
The book's front and rear cover art shows a variety of famous cartoon stars seated in a nightclub.[6] In the appendix, a list of other cartoons with substantial votes are featured.[7]
Reception and legacy
editMaryanne Dell wrote in The Orange County Register that the book "is a breeze, a visual delight that brings back childhood afternoons in front of the tube." She also mentioned how the book chronicled the "history of the genre with enough details about how these things work to satisfy anyone with a modicum of interest in the subject." Overall, she stated that the book is "worth the price of admission for the visuals, and a gem of a show."[8]
Sandra Crockett of The Baltimore Sun called the book an "animated feast". She was impressed with the illustrations in the book, complimenting the "animation cels whose colors practically leap off the page". She lauded "Ted Turner and his minions" for their appreciation and preservation of the films.[9]
In his autobiography Chuck Amuck, Jones singled out What's Opera, Doc? "for sheer production quality, magnificent music and wonderful animation, this is probably our (unit's) most elaborate and satisfying production."[10]
A mixture of the book's selections and its runner-ups were featured on Cartoon Network on March 14, 1998, as part of "The 50 Greatest Cartoons of All Time" marathon.[11] The reason for this is because the network only aired cartoons owned by Warner Bros., public domain cartoons like Gertie the Dinosaur, and those licensed to the network at the time (such as The Big Snit and Bambi Meets Godzilla). The marathon also included interviews with animators such as Chuck Jones and Joe Barbera, as well as historian Leonard Maltin and voice actors Charlie Adler and June Foray.[12][13] A similar marathon aired the following year.[14]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ The 50 greatest cartoons: as selected by 1,000 animation professionals (Book, 1994)-WorldCat.org
- ^ Ventrella, Michael A. (August 19, 2012). "Interview with Jerry Beck".
- ^ Seiler, Andy (March 25, 1996). "What's up? Jones getting an Oscar". USA Today. p. 4D. ProQuest 306785010.
- ^ Cavalier, Stephen (October 2014). "100 Greatest Animated Shorts / The Big Snit / Richard Condie". Skwigly.
- ^ Cavalier, Stephen (June 2015). "100 Greatest Animated Shorts / Quasi at the Quackadero / Sally Cruikshank". Skwigly.
- ^ "The 50 Greatest Cartoons: As Selected by 1, 000 Animation Professionals". Book Depository. Archived from the original on June 12, 2018.
- ^ The 50 Greatest Cartoons: As Selected by 1,000 Animation Professionals (pg.186)
- ^ Dell, Maryanne (November 16, 1994). "New Book Celebrates Animation". Panama City News Herald. The Orange County Register. p. 25.
- ^ Crockett, Sandra (December 11, 1994). "When you give a good book, you present volumes of pleasure". The Baltimore Sun. p. 1J. ProQuest 406899399.
- ^ Neal, David J. (January 4, 1995). "Meep Meep Master is Big Screen Star". The Salt Lake Tribune. Knight-Ridder Newspapers. p. Z2. ProQuest 288650489.
- ^ Fanitazia, Joan (March 12, 1998). "Cartoon Network to Offer the Best in Cels-Manship". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on October 24, 2021. Retrieved October 24, 2021.
- ^ "The 50 [Almost] Greatest Cartoons". Animation World News. April 1998. Retrieved October 24, 2021.
- ^ Ulie, Chuck (February 26, 1998). "Cartoon Network To Present 50 Greatest Cartoons". Chicago Tribune.
- ^ Amidi, Amid (March 22, 1999). "Cartoon Network's Greatest Cartoon Countdown". Animation World Network. Retrieved October 24, 2021.
External links
edit- Beck, Jerry, ed. (1994). The 50 Greatest Cartoons: As Selected By 1,000 Animation Professionals (1st ed.). Atlanta: Turner Publishing. ISBN 1-878685-49-X.
- 10 of the Greatest Cartoons of All Time on Flavorwire