Operation Tun Tun, also known as Operation Knock Knock,[1] is the name coined by pro-government deputy Diosdado Cabello during the 2017 Venezuelan protests that describes a crackdown on dissent from the Venezuelan opposition using state security forces.
After the 2024 Venezuelan presidential election, Operation Tun Tun was activated to arrest large numbers of protesters and people opposed to the government of Nicolás Maduro and, according to human rights activists, to instill fear in opponents of the government and quell the 2024 Venezuelan protests.[2][3][4][5]
Term
editIn the second hearing of the Organization of American States to analyze possible crimes against humanity in Venezuela, Major General Hebert García Plaza described Operation Tun Tun as an operation normally carried out at night, where a Bolivarian Intelligence Service commission visits the person and takes them away, possibly without an arrest warrant or issued by a Public Ministry prosecutor.[6]
When asked by the Argentine jurist Luis Moreno Ocampo about the origin of the name, García Plaza answered that although he did not know its origin and that "one would have to ask Diosdado Cabello", he supposed that it came from the sound emitted by the door when it is knocked by the security forces.[6]
Application
edit2017: Venezuelan protests
editOn 17 May 2017, Diosdado Cabello assured during his television program Con el mazo dando that he would activate an operation called "Tun Tun" that night for people who imported implements for "terrorists", noting that the opposition "is going to get harder than a cat burglar" and describing Voluntad Popular deputy Freddy Guevara as a "drug addict".[7] On 24 June, during a ceremony commemorating the Battle of Carabobo and Army Day, President Nicolás Maduro declared that all those detained in Operation Tun Tun were under military justice.[8]
Cabello also threatened the shipping companies in the country, stating that "they contribute with the transfer of supplies that are used by members of these violent groups to generate acts of vandalism and terrorism in Venezuela" and declaring that the situation "will be taken to the competent authorities to investigate these actions", saying that shipping companies DHL, Liberty Express, Aduanera Las Dos L, Aduana Isacar and Economía Aduanera 2000 could be charged under the Anti-Terrorism Law.[9]
A report by Human Rights Watch and Foro Penal documented at least six instances in which Venezuelan security forces raided residential areas and apartments in Caracas and in four different states. In some of the raids, which tended to occur near barricades built by protesters, security forces entered homes without search warrants, stealing personal belongings and food, and beating and arresting residents.[10] The deputy of the Legislative Council of the Bolívar state, Cesar Ramírez, witnessed the raid in the urbanizations of Villa Latina, Los Olivos and Los Mangos in Puerto Ordaz, where officers of the National Guard, military counter-intelligence and the Bolivarian Intelligence Service were present with sledgehammers, demolition equipment, and firearms, breaking glass and main access doors and raiding residences. Ramirez described the actions of the officers as "very far from what is a police operation" stating that "it looked like a criminal operation with people in National Guard uniforms, hooded and with firearms causing destruction and running over a civilian population inside their homes, violating human rights". Ramírez requested the Attorney General's Office order a criminal investigation against governor Francisco Rangel Gómez, officials of the General Directorate of Military Counterintelligence and the Bolivarian National Guard for causing destruction to private property, raid of apartments without a court order and detaining a minor without an arrest warrant.[11]
2017–2018: Supreme Court in exile
editOn 19 July 2024, Diosdado Cabello threatened, again in his program Con el mazo dando, the candidates to be appointed by the National Assembly as judges of the Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela in exile, after the judges appointed in 2015 with vices and irregularities by the outgoing ruling party majority of the National Assembly, saying: "Let's see who will appoint you, who will defend you, to see if Julio Borges will defend you when the operation tuntun comes for you, let's see if they will defend you."[9]
On the morning of 30 April 2018, officers of the Bolivarian National Intelligence Service (SEBIN) raided the Maturín house of relatives of the Supreme Court magistrate in exile, Elenis Rodríguez, where her mother, who had Alzheimer's disease, and a sister of the justice live, who was taken as a witness to testify but was released after several hours. SEBIN personnel took computer equipment from the home.[12]
In the rest of the country, similar procedures were carried out against properties of at least four other magistrates, including Miguel Ángel Martín , who served as president of the Supreme Tribunal, and magistrates Cioly Zambrano, Tony Marval, and Pedro Troconis.[12]
2019: Present Future youth leadership program
editOn July 11, 2019, Diosdado threatened to apply Operation Tun Tun against Reinaldo Diaz Ohep and others who supported Present Future, a program promoting development of youth leaders.[13]
2020: COVID-19 pandemic
editIn 2020, the Academy of Physical, Mathematical and Natural Sciences of Venezuela published a report on the COVID-19 pandemic where it warned that the peak of the outbreak in the country could reach 4,000 cases per day in June. Cabello responded to the report by threatening the academy, saying "This is an invitation for security agencies to visit these people. It is an invitation to a tun tun". The academy rejected the threats.[14]
2024: Venezuelan presidential election
editFollowing the 2024 Venezuelan presidential election and protests, Maduro accused the opposition of promoting a coup.[15]
Crackdown on protesters
editIn a crackdown by Maduro security forces following the elections,[16][17][18] Operation Tun Tun (Operation Knock Knock) is the strategy Maduro mentioned; BBC News stated that "rights groups say it consists of the authorities going door-to-door to detain those with links to the protests or the opposition".[15] Rafael Uzcategui of Laboratorio de Paz "suggested the operation was intended to terrify Venezuelans into submission", adding that "what we are seeing is simply an effort to sew [sic] a climate of terror", according to The Guardian.[19]
Venezuela's counterintelligence agency, DGCIM used its social media accounts to warn that Operation Tun-Tun was just beginning, and set up a telephone line to gather reports about protesters, who Maduro officials refer to as traitors.[20]
The Maduro adminstraton reported at least 2,000 people had been arrested as of 7 August; Clara del Campo of Amnesty International said that number included over 100 teens.[15] Human rights groups and relatives of the detained said that they are typically charged with terrorism, are not allowed a private defense, and the whereabouts of many are unknown.[15][21] Maduro ordered two prisons to be rehabilitated to contain the detained.[22][23]
A campaign worker for the opposition told The Washington Post that "security forces and the Maduro-supporting bikers known as colectivos appear to be targeting low-income areas that have previously been strongholds of government support".[16] According to the Miami Herald, a "retired Venezuelan Army major, who asked not to be named because he is being sought by the regime, said most of the violence seen in past days in Venezuela came from armed paramilitary groups that are being paid well to generate fear among their countrymen", adding that they are being offered US$1–2,000 to participate in the repression.[24]
Maduro personally encouraged individuals to report those protesting the CNE election result through an internet application, VenApp.[16] According to The Washington Post, "human rights advocates warned that [the app] could be repurposed" when it was created to report medical emergencies.[16] Maduro stated: "We're opening a new page in the app for all the Venezuelan population, so they can confidentially give me all the information about the delinquents who have threatened the people—attacked the people—so we can go after them and bring them to prompt justice."[16] Following a flood of complaints, the app is no longer found on Google and Apple stores because of the harassment potential. Another internet page created by the government allows users to post media of protesters where they can be identified by other users.[16] As of 1 August, another 1,000 individuals were being sought for arrest.[25]
A complaint from a neighbor may start the process, in which arrests are being conducted outside of the law.[26]
Extortion from police and security forces, judges and prosecutors has been reported, with victims being asked to pay between US$500 and $15,000, depending on the charge, to be released.[26]
Arrests of politicians and journalists
editFreddy Superlano, a former candidate, was detained by masked men two days after the election.[27][17][28] Shortly before, Cabello had announced that the arrest of ten opposition leaders was planned.[29] Cabello confirmed Superlano's arrest 30 hours later but did not reveal his whereabouts.[29][30] A week later, attorney Joel García confirmed that Superlano and journalist Roland Carreño (who also worked for the Popular Will party[15]) were held in El Helicoide on unknown charges, calling their arrests "kidnapping with a judicial appearance".[31] Representatives of Superlano's party said they were told by chavista informants that Superlano would be tortured to "make him confess to the false plan set up by regime spokesmen such as Tarek William Saab".[30][32]
The same day that Superlano was detained, Ricardo Estévez, an advisor with Vente Venezuela for the González campaign, was taken from his residence by armed men from two unmarked cars, presumed to be from the Bolivarian Intelligence Service.[33][15] Rafael Sivira, the youth coordinator for opposition party Radical Cause, and another unidentified person were also detained.[34]
Vente Venezuela politician María Oropeza livestreamed as security forces broke into her residence without a search warrant and arrested her two hours after she described the ongoing detentions as a "witch hunt".[19][35][18] According to Infobae, the DGCIM added music by Freddy Krueger (a character from A Nightmare on Elm Street) and published their edited version of the video.[36] As of 9 August, her whereabouts were unknown.[18]
BBC News says it has been told that journalists and activists have been targeted in Operation Tun-Tun.[15] The Venezuelan SNTP (Syndicate of National Press Workers ) denounced that reporter Yousner Alvarado and cameraman Paúl León were arrested shortly after the election, and photographer Deysi Penna was detained on 2 August. That same day, Chilean National Television said its journalist Iván Núñez and his cameraman José Luis Tapia were arrested; they were later released safely in Colombia.[37]
Opposition targeted
editOpposition leaders said that citizens who witnessed the vote tally sheets in the electoral process (poll watchers) were persecuted and detained.[16] The CNE had their contact data; Maduro accused them of being guerillas, according to NTN 24.[38] Many poll watchers reportedly have "fled their homes in fear".[16]
On 2 August, Vente Venezuela said its offices in Caracas were attacked by six armed individuals who ransacked the premises.[39]
Cuban participation
editAccording to the Miami Herald, "activists have denounced that a number of the agents taking part in repressing opposition figures and protesters have Cuban accents", as "at least four passenger flights" have arrived from Cuba, according to local media.[24] José Colina, a former lieutenant in the Venezuelan National Guard, told the Miami Herald that his military sources still in Venezuela say that some of the Operation Tun Tun searches and arrests are conducted by Cubans.[24]
Reception
editPolitical scientist and editor of Aporrea Nicmer Evans described the operation as "fascist", denouncing that they knocked on his door to ask him about deputy Germán Ferrer, husband of the attorney general dismissed by the National Constituent Assembly, Luisa Ortega Díaz.[40] In 2020, constitutionalist Joel Rodríguez Ramos declared that Operation Tun Tun "presaged barbarism".[41]
See also
edit- Great Purge in the Soviet Union
- Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries, Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward in China
- Cambodian Genocide
- Enforced disappearances in Venezuela
References
edit- ^ Romero, Tibisay; Guanipa, Mircely; Sequera, Vivian (5 August 2024). "Maduro security forces round up Venezuelans involved in protests in 'operation knock-knock'". CTV News. Toronto: CTV. Archived from the original on 6 August 2024. Retrieved 12 August 2024.
- ^ Hernández, Alicia (6 August 2024). "Qué es la 'Operación Tun Tun' con la que los cuerpos de seguridad de Venezuela arrestan masivamente a manifestantes y opositores" [What is 'Operation Tun Tun' with which Venezuelan security forces massively arrest protesters and opponents?] (in Spanish). BBC News. Retrieved 10 August 2024.
- ^ Robles, Frances (10 August 2024). "'Operación Tun Tun': el gobierno de Venezuela detiene a quienes cuestionan la victoria de Maduro" ['Operation Tun Tun': Venezuelan government arrests those who question Maduro's victory]. The New York Times (in Spanish). Retrieved 10 August 2024.
- ^ Singer, Florantonia (5 August 2024). "Venezuela's political crisis enters uncharted territory". El Pais. Retrieved 10 August 2024.
- ^ Zegarra, Gonzalo (7 August 2024). "El chavismo convierte un villancico venezolano en sinónimo de represión. ¿En qué consiste la 'operación Tun, tun?" [Chavismo turns a Venezuelan Christmas carol into a synonym for repression. What is 'Operation Tun, tun'?] (in Spanish). CNN en Español. Retrieved 10 August 2024.
- ^ a b OAS Videos - Events (15 September 2017). "Audiences to analyze possible crimes against humanity in Venezuela. September 15th, 2017". YouTube. 2:17:21. Retrieved 30 July 2017.
- ^ "Diosdado Cabello: Comenzó la operación "Tun tun" contra los terroristas". El Nacional. 17 May 2017. Retrieved 20 July 2023.
- ^ Núñez, Ayatola (25 June 2017). ""Todos los detenidos en la operación tun-tun están bajo justicia militar"". El Nacional. Retrieved 29 July 2017.
- ^ a b López, Odell (17 May 2017). "Cabello amenaza con allanamientos a través de la "Operación tun tun"". Efecto Cocuyo. Retrieved 29 July 2018.
- ^ Foro Penal (2017). "5". Crackdown on Dissent. Brutality, Torture, and Political Persecution in Venezuela (PDF). Human Rights Watch. p. 61. ISBN 978-1-6231-3549-2.
- ^ "El diputado César Ramírez condenó la violación de derechos humanos durante "operación Tun Tun" en Puerto Ordaz". El Correo del Orinoco. 29 May 2017. Retrieved 29 July 2017.
- ^ a b Rodríguez Rosas, Ronny. "Allanan inmuebles vinculados con al menos cinco magistrados del TSJ en el exilio". Efecto Cocuyo. Retrieved 30 April 2018.
- ^ "Diosdado amenaza con aplicar "operación tún tún" contra el diplomático Reinaldo Díaz Ohep (VIDEO)". La Patilla. 11 July 2019. Retrieved 13 July 2019.
- ^ "Academia de Ciencias rechaza amenazas de Diosdado Cabello". Runrun (in Spanish). 14 May 2020. Retrieved 17 May 2020.
- ^ a b c d e f g Wells, Ione (8 August 2024). "Venezuela security forces swoop on activists as repression worsens". BBC News. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Herrero, Ana Vanessa; Paul, Maria Luisa; Schmidt, Samantha (31 July 2024). "Maduro urges Venezuelans to report protesters who question his reelection". The Washington Post. Retrieved 1 August 2024.
- ^ a b Itriago Acosta, Andreina (30 July 2024). "Venezuela Detains Opposition Figure Amid Post-Election Crackdown". Bloomberg. Retrieved 30 July 2024.
- ^ a b c Schmidt, Samantha (8 August 2024). "Maduro boasts 2,200 arrests since election; rights groups say 23 dead". Washington Post. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ a b Taylor, Luke (8 August 2024). "'A climate of terror: Maduro cracks down on Venezuelans protesting contested election win". The Guardian. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ Rojas, Esteban (7 August 2024). "'Let's Get Them!' Maduro's Campaign To Flush Out 'Traitors'". Barron's. Agence France-Presse. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ "El régimen de Venezuela prohibió la defensa privada y acusa de terrorismo a los detenidos en las protestas contra el fraude de Maduro" [Venezuela's regime has banned private defense and accuses those arrested in protests against Maduro's fraud of terrorism]. Infobae (in Spanish). 2 August 2024. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ "Thousands of arrests and terrorism charges: Nicolás Maduro intensifies persecution of opponents in Venezuela". El Pais. 9 August 2024. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ Barreto Jové, Andreína (1 August 2024). "Maduro ordenó adecuar cárceles de Tocuyito y Tocorón para encerrar a los detenidos en las protestas" [Maduro ordered the adaptation of Tocuyito and Tocorón prisons to hold those arrested during the protests]. El Diario (in Spanish). Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ a b c Delgado, Antonio Maria (5 August 2024). "This man holds the Venezuelan regime together. Here's why Maduro doesn't trust him". Miami Herald. Retrieved 6 August 2024.
Maduro ... has turned to Cuban intelligence agents to keep an eye on members of the military ... And few are being watched as closely as Maduro's own defense minister, Vladimir Padrino López, amid Maduro's growing distrust in the country's armed forces … arrival in Venezuela of at least four passenger flights from Cuba, while activists have denounced that a number of the agents taking part in repressing oppositions figures and protesters have Cuban accents ... A retired Venezuelan Army major ... said most of the violence seen in past days in Venezuela came from armed paramilitary groups that are being paid well to generate fear among their countrymen.
Also available from Leader-Telegram - ^ Paraguassu, Lisandra; Fernandez, Leonardo; Buitrago, Deisy (1 August 2024). "Brazil, Mexico and Colombia call for Venezuela to release full vote tallies". Reuters. Retrieved 2 August 2024.
- ^ a b Méndez, Maryorin (21 August 2024). "'Operación tun-tun', el nuevo negocio de extorsión oficial en Venezuela: ¿Qué hacer?" ['Operation tun-tun', the new official extortion business in Venezuela: What to do?]. NTN24 (in Spanish). Retrieved 27 August 2024.
- ^ Vyas, Kejal; Dubé, Ryan (30 July 2024). "Venezuela's Opposition Releases Election Database; Claims Big Victory Over Strongman Maduro". The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on 30 July 2024. Retrieved 30 July 2024. Also available from MSN Archived 30 July 2024 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ "Venezuela opposition leader Freddy Superlano has been detained, party says". Reuters. 30 July 2024. Retrieved 30 July 2024.
- ^ a b "Diosdado Cabello confirmó el secuestro de Freddy Superlano y se burló de los rumores sobre torturas: 'Está hablando muy bien'" [Diosdado Cabello confirmed the kidnapping of Freddy Superlano and mocked the rumors about torture: 'He is speaking very well']. Infobae (in Spanish). 1 August 2024. Retrieved 1 August 2024.
- ^ a b "Resultados de las elecciones en Venezuela 2024, en vivo / Jorge Rodríguez, presidente de la Asamblea: 'María Corina Machado y Edmundo González deben ir presos'" [Venezuela 2024 election results, live / Jorge Rodríguez, president of the Assembly: 'María Corina Machado and Edmundo González must go to jail']. El Pais (in Spanish). 30 July 2024. Retrieved 31 July 2024.
- ^ Aure, Yanuacelis (6 August 2024). "Confirmaron que Freddy Superlano y Roland Carreño se encuentran recluidos en El Helicoide" [Confirmed that Freddy Superlano and Roland Carreño are being held in El Helicoide]. El Diario (in Spanish). Retrieved 7 August 2024.
- ^ "La oposición denunció que el chavismo torturó a Freddy Superlano" [The opposition denounced that Chavismo tortured Freddy Superlano]. infobae (in Spanish). 31 July 2024.
- ^ "Detienen en Caracas a dirigente de Vente Venezuela Ricardo Estévez" [Vente Venezuela leader Ricardo Estévez is arrested in Caracas]. Efecto Cocuyo (in Spanish). 30 July 2024. Retrieved 31 July 2024.
- ^ "Hombres armados arrestan a Freddy Superlano y otros dos políticos opositores" [Armed men arrest Freddy Superlano and two other political opposers]. NTN24 (in Spanish). 30 July 2024. Retrieved 31 July 2024.
- ^ La opositora María Oropeza transmite en vivo cómo la detienen. El Pais. 8 August 2024. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ "El escalofriante video con el que el régimen de Maduro atemoriza a los venezolanos y se burla de la dirigente María Oropeza y de la oposición" [The chilling video with which the Maduro regime frightens Venezuelans and mocks the leader María Oropeza and the opposition]. Infobae (in Spanish). 8 August 2024. Retrieved 9 August 2024.
- ^ "The Wall Street Journal se suma a los sitios web bloqueados en Venezuela, donde se registran detenciones de comunicadores" [The Wall Street Journal joins the list of websites blocked in Venezuela, where journalists have been arrested]. Voice of America (in Spanish). 2 August 2024. Retrieved 7 August 2024.
- ^ Méndez, Maryorin (31 July 2024). "'Operación tun-tun': La macabra cacería del régimen venezolano contra testigos electorales se intensifica con las horas" ['Operation tun-tun': The Venezuelan regime's macabre hunt against electoral witnesses intensifies by the hour]. NTN24 (in Spanish). Retrieved 31 July 2024.
- ^ "Venezuelan opposition says office ransacked as post-election tensions grow". Al Jazeera. 2 August 2024. Retrieved 2 August 2024.
- ^ "Nicmer Evans: Operación tun tun tocó mi puerta para preguntarme por Ferrer". El Nacional. 16 August 2017. Retrieved 29 July 2018.
- ^ Sánchez, Pacífico (31 March 2020). "Constitucionalista Joel Rodríguez Ramos: Operación "tun tun" presagia barbarie". El Impulso. Retrieved 3 April 2020.