The house didn't sell in the timeline I wanted without dropping the price below the number we set as the floor so we listed them back up to rent.
After that experience, I was gun shy on raising the rents to what I thought was closer to current market rates. Listed and both sides rented within a week, with a double digit interest waitlist. I generally prefer to leave a bit on the table in hope for stable and long term tenants. Also housing is expensive and I dislike the maximalist approach to all transactions. That said, I still wish I would have stuck to my original thinking on the rent as that is a $5k per year difference. I usually don't raise the rent much or even at all on renewals, but I may push for a bit more over the next few cycles. More in this case being 4-5%. We'll see what remote management overhead adds as well both in costs and in general headaches.
After that experience, I was gun shy on raising the rents to what I thought was closer to current market rates. Listed and both sides rented within a week, with a double digit interest waitlist. I generally prefer to leave a bit on the table in hope for stable and long term tenants. Also housing is expensive and I dislike the maximalist approach to all transactions. That said, I still wish I would have stuck to my original thinking on the rent as that is a $5k per year difference. I usually don't raise the rent much or even at all on renewals, but I may push for a bit more over the next few cycles. More in this case being 4-5%. We'll see what remote management overhead adds as well both in costs and in general headaches.