GoreMade Pizza

Outstanding pizzas that are fairly lesser known throughout town. I love this place - truly well made (or should I say "gore-made") pizzas with a personalized flare. Everytime I go here, I leave with a smile - I wish I also left with leftovers, but the pizzas are just too good. Great service, fun decor, everything is just so fun.

One has to know what they're getting in to when they go here.

It's a small pizza shop with a handful of seats at the bar, a few high tops and some other tables around the outside of the main space. It's quaint. The patio is very nice for dining on a pretty night. Don't expect a ton of service because they just aren't staffed for it (drink refills). Order and pay at the counter before finding a seat kind of place. If you're thirsty, you're going to get your steps in if you're sitting outside. The guys are great/helpful, but they're elbows deep in slinging pies and answering the phone.

The salads are basically a box of lettuce with some shaved parm. There aren't but a few choices of "out of the box" offerings of pizza; however, they do have enough good toppings for a "choose your own adventure". The size is a manageable serving size to share- we got two of the off the menu, and shared them. Both pizzas were good, but both were missing something as part of the flavor progression that would make it a place to return to often rather than occasionally with Columbus' good pizza scene.

Always great. Server team was on it tonight. There was a Crew game tonight so it was very busy. We arrived at 530 and got a good table.

The balsamic on the salad is really great. So is The Old Fashion. The water is cold!

A Top 10 pizza in the area.

Didn't know this place existed until recently, and it's right down the street from my place. The cheesy garlic bread is amazing - a must try! The pizzas come in a round 12" or you can get the pizza boat, which is half sized. I really enjoy thin-crust pizza and I think this place is my favorite in Columbus so far. They definitely have some unique toppings to choose from. I went with a basic pizza, but will have to try their pesto next time I'm there. There is an outdoor area available with decent amount of seating, which I did not know at first!

It's Super Bowl Sunday and I was craving pizza. I had tried this place a few years ago for a Yelp event so I thought I'd order of couple of pies. I've also been searching for the best pizza in Columbus. I haven't found it yet.

I ordered their pepperoni and a mushroom pizza.

I love that this place uses an authentic wood fire oven. You can taste some of the smokiness in the crust. I think it adds a little interest to the pizza.

The pepperoni pizza was my favorite. I did add some Mike's hot honey to it and that made it so much better.

The mushroom pizza was ok but I found it super salty. So I had a couple of pieces but found myself going back to the pepperoni.

This place is a little limited on their options but I'm not sure, I'd order this again.

The crust is tasty but it is really thin without much form to it so it takes some skill in not allowing the toppings to fall off.

Overall it was ok, but my search for the best pizza in Columbus goes on.

The pizza is awesome
Service spectacular
The ambiance is perfect for a pizza shop.
The only complaint is parking. You will have to find parking and it can be difficult and you may have a long walk. With that said I take a star away. 4 stars

Excellent, excellent pizza! My daughter has been raving about this place, and I was skeptical. But geez. This was so delicious! We got a Clintonvillain subbing the mushrooms for olives, and a Chef 's Choice Pizza -- also delicious!! Great crust, amazing toppings!

A small pizza joint with a small bar and 6 or so tables. I'm sure they do a robust carry-out business but we sat at a table by the window. Helpful employees, who are clearly proud of their product.

Street parking. We'll be back!

Great wood fired pizza. Took it to go and they got cold fast. Next time will eat there to get them piping hot out of the oven. Tried the mushroom white pizza and the pepperoni, sausage and bacon, really good flavors on both with just the right amount of char on the crust.

Food gets a 4 read on for the 3.5

First thought...be prepared to find parking and you'll pay for parking. It's on a fairly busy street so be patient and park as you find a spot, even if you have to walk a bit.

We came on a Friday afternoon and found parking fast but then had to figure out the parking app.

No wings here but salad or cheesey bread for appetizers. The only dressing they have is balsamic and housemade ranch. We opted out of either simply because of the lack of choices on dressing, no biggie for us but remember that coming in.

They also only have locally brewed and canned beers but a pretty big variety. Unfortunately no frosted glasses and sitting on the patio the beer got to room temperature pretty quickly.

We ordered the 12" pork...something or other pizza and added roasted mushrooms. Delicious!! And enough for us to share. The wood fired pizza is great and the crust is especially thin... yummy!

Pizza and two beers was $30 but we left the tab open for more beers Then seen to be short staffed so we had to go get our own beers, not an issue but would have been nice to be told that instead of having our beer sit on the counter.

Great little place for delicious pizza and if you can, sit out on the patio.

I hate giving out my haunts though I will make an exception this time...Nicholas G and Goremade one of the best Neo Italian style pizzas I have had in Columbus outside of Rome, Italy! The $19 Clintonvillan is packed with shrooms, garlic, and white sauce/cheese to temper a hungry vegetarian! There are options galore to choose from under $20 and I suggest you get good service and watch you pizza being made- that is the true charm of the place. The interaction with the pizza oven and the chefs! Don't be lame and ask for a different size- they are all 12" or half as a boat...or ask for a different type of pizza...like the guy after us trying to impress his date!?!! Square all around when the pizza is round. Check out the menu before coming to get your barrings and grab a brew or glass of wine while you are at it. One of the only places where $55 dollars can get you a nice date dinner!