MarketWatch Guides is MarketWatch’s research and commerce newsroom. We employ dedicated researchers distinct from our newsroom coverage. We may earn a commission from links. Learn More

Contact Us

How Does a Home Warranty Work?

Last Updated: Oct 25, 2024
A home warranty, also known as a residential service contract, covers the cost of repairing or replacing home appliances and systems that break down from normal wear and tear. Many providers even help policyholders schedule maintenance. Keep reading to learn how home warranties work, what comprehensive policies cover and what the best home warranty companies are.

Rebekah Young
Managing Editor Rebekah Young Managing Editor Rebekah Young Contributor

Rebekah Young is an editor with a decade of experience in educational content and editing. She has also guided content strategy and edited in the insurance, venture capital, financial and healthcare fields.

Jesus Sanchez Garcia
Principal Researcher Jesus Sanchez Garcia Principal Researcher Jesus Sanchez Garcia Writer

Jesus Sanchez Garcia is a writer specializing in home services content to give consumers the information they need during their buying process. His work has appeared in Architectural Digest and This Old House.

Jesus Sanchez Garcia
Principal Researcher Jesus Sanchez Garcia Principal Researcher Jesus Sanchez Garcia Writer

Jesus Sanchez Garcia is a writer specializing in home services content to give consumers the information they need during their buying process. His work has appeared in Architectural Digest and This Old House.


Our Research Process

Here’s a breakdown of how we reviewed and rated the best home warranty companies

Learn more about MarketWatch Guides
20 Companies Reviewed
Our team reviewed almost 20 home warranty providers, collecting and comparing data on monthly costs, service fees, coverages and more.
350 Quotes Collected
We've collected more than 350 sample quotes from home warranty companies to give readers an accurate view of pricing and how competitors stack up in terms of rates. We update our pages regularly to reflect accurate cost information.
22 Rating Factors
Our comprehensive rating system scores providers based on 22 data points in seven key rating factors: plan options, coverage details, pricing, trustworthiness, customer service, additional benefits and state availability.
2,000 Homeowners Surveyed
We've conducted multiple homeowner surveys to collect data on what real home warranty customers care about, such as policy features, company transparency and month premium cost.

What Is a Home Warranty?

A home warranty is typically a one-year contract between a homeowner and provider that covers the expensive, out-of-pocket costs of repairing or replacing items around your home. Policies generally exclude breakdowns caused by neglect, misuse or natural disasters.

How Is a Home Warranty Different From Homeowners Insurance?

While home warranty and home insurance policies sound similar, they’re two different plans. A home warranty covers the cost of repairing or replacing major appliances and systems that no longer work after years of regular use. On the other hand, homeowners insurance covers structural damage to your home when a natural disaster or covered peril occurs.

For example, a typical homeowners insurance plan would cover the following scenarios:

  • Damaged appliances from a lightning surge
  • Burned belongings from a fire
  • Stolen items from a home invasion

What Does a Home Warranty Cover?

Most home warranty providers offer plans that cover appliances, systems or a combination of the two. Many even allow you to supplement your coverage with optional add-ons, which protect your pool, spa, well pump, guest unit and other unique items. 

Here’s a list of common appliances covered under most home warranty contracts:

  • Built-in microwave
  • Dishwasher
  • Dryer
  • Freestanding ice maker
  • Garage door opener
  • Oven
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Stove
  • Washing machine

When it comes to systems, most home warranty providers cover the following:

  • Air conditioning
  • Ductwork
  • Garbage disposal
  • Heating
  • Plumbing
  • Water heater

What Does a Home Warranty Not Cover?

Although home warranty plans are comprehensive, it’s important to understand that coverage isn’t all-encompassing. To learn more about the details of your interested provider’s coverage, ask a representative for a sample contract. There, you can look at specific coverage caps and other plan limitations. Below are some of the most common exclusions you might find:

  • Cosmetic damage to home systems and appliances
  • Damage incurred through improper installation or maintenance
  • Systems and appliances with preexisting conditions

How Does a Home Warranty Work?

If you find a home warranty company you’re interested in and decide to purchase one of its plans, your coverage typically won’t begin for 30 days (the waiting period will be specified in your contract). This lapse in coverage is known as the waiting period. After your waiting period, you can use your new home warranty plan by following these simple steps:

  1. When a covered item breaks down from normal wear and tear, you can typically file a claim online or over the phone.
  2. Your service provider will take up to 48 hours to process your claim. Afterward, it will dispatch a technician to your home.
  3. When the technician arrives, you will owe them a small deductible, known as a service call fee. They will then diagnose the problem and recommend either a repair or replacement.
  4. Your provider will cover the repair or replacement costs up to your plan’s coverage caps. 
  5. Most providers will honor the technician’s work with a workmanship guarantee, which pays for additional repairs on that item if it breaks down again within a given time period.

How Long Does a Home Warranty Last?

Most home warranty policies are structured as one-year contracts, with the option for renewal at the end of the year. However, some providers let customers enroll in multi-year contracts. Signing up for a multi-year plan usually results in a discounted monthly or annual premium.


Are Home Warranties Tax Deductible?

Home warranties are not tax deductible for the average homeowner. However, if you are a property manager, the cost of a home warranty may qualify as a business operating expense, in which case it would be a write off. 


What Does a Home Warranty Cost?

You can break the cost of a home warranty into two categories: the monthly premium and the service call fee. Your plan’s premium is the amount you owe every month for the length of your contract. The monthly cost of a home warranty is typically between $38.73 and $63.16. Some providers help you save money on your premium by allowing you to pay for the entire year up-front.

The service call fee typically ranges from $75 to $125. Some providers allow you to select your own deductible, with a lower fee increasing your monthly payment and a higher fee decreasing it.

Home Warranty Annual Cost Calculator

The MarketWatch Guides Team developed a calculator that analyzes the anticipated yearly expenses associated with owning a home warranty. To determine your projected annual home warranty cost, simply input your monthly premium, service call fee and estimated number of claims. We recommend getting quotes from our top providers directly, as prices vary by plan, location and home size.

Home Warranty Cost Calculator

Type of Home Warranty Plan

Comprehensive plans cover both appliances and systems.

Claims Per Year

According to our survey, 1 of every 3 policyholders file at least one claim per year.

What Service Fee Are You Comfortable With?

Service fees typically range from $75-$150. Choosing a lower service fee will result in higher monthly costs.

Your Annual Cost Estimate

The results are estimates based on the information you provide and may not reflect the actual pricing of your quote.

To determine home warranty costs, MarketWatch Guides mystery shopped quotes for each plan type from 28 different home warranty providers. The results are estimates based on the information you provide and may not reflect the actual pricing of your quote.


Advertisement

The listings that appear are from companies from which this website may receive compensation, which may impact how, where and in what order products appear. Not all companies, products or offers were reviewed in connection with this listing.

Best for add-ons
EXPLORE PLANS
$200 Off + 2 Months Free + Roof Leak Protection
Our Top Pick
Best for comprehensive coverage
EXPLORE PLANS
$150 off any plan
Best for budget shoppers
EXPLORE PLANS
Cyber Monday: 40% Off Home Warranty Plans
Best for appliance coverage
EXPLORE PLANS
$100 Off with Code PROTECT

Frequently Asked Questions About Home Warranties

A home warranty may not be worth it for every homeowner. If you have a large emergency fund or new systems and appliances with manufacturer warranties, you likely don’t need a home warranty. However, many homeowners find that a home warranty can bring peace of mind by ensuring their aging items stay in working condition.

Most home warranty providers allow plan transfers from one homeowner to the next. This is especially helpful for home sellers who want to purchase home warranty coverage to entice potential home buyers. Once transferred after a home sale, you can submit claims for any covered appliance or system breakdowns. 

Methodology: Our System for Rating Home Warranty Companies

We at the MarketWatch Guides team have developed a comprehensive rating system to evaluate home warranty providers based on objective criteria. Our researchers assess each company by directly communicating with representatives, reviewing sample contracts and analyzing consumer feedback. Additionally, we have conducted surveys and focus groups to gather valuable homeowner insights.

We assign scores to each provider based on the data collected, focusing on key factors such as pricing, coverage, trustworthiness, and customer experience. Below is the breakdown of how we score home warranty companies.

  • Pricing (30%): We analyze home warranty pricing in relation to overall value by considering monthly plan costs, average service fees, upcharges for after-hour and weekend repairs, and how companies handle depreciation. We also consider customer responses to our latest home warranty survey about pricing and general satisfaction.
  • Coverage (30%): Companies that offer transferable plans, have high coverage limits and have shorter waiting periods score highly in this category. We also take into account each provider’s individual coverage limits, repair requirements and coverage exemptions for major systems and appliances.
  • Trustworthiness (20%): We consider factors such as years in business, company size, Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot ratings, and service guarantees in this rating category. We also analyze whether or not a company has any active or past lawsuits against it.
  • Customer Experience (20%): The more streamlined a provider’s customer experience is, the higher it scores in this category. We look at the availability of online sample contracts, available plan information, online quote tools, claims response times, cancellation policies and more. We also consider responses centered around general and claims satisfaction in our latest survey.
Our review methodology for home warranty companies is intended to provide a thorough overview of the best providers nationwide. To learn more, you can read our full home warranty methodology.  


If you have feedback or questions about this article, please email the MarketWatch Guides team at editors@marketwatchguides.com.

Meet the Team

Rebekah Young is an editor with a decade of experience in educational content and editing. She has also guided content strategy and edited in the insurance, venture capital, financial and healthcare fields.

Learn more about Rebekah Young

Jesus Sanchez Garcia is a writer specializing in home services content to give consumers the information they need during their buying process. His work has appeared in Architectural Digest and This Old House.

Learn more about Jesus Sanchez Garcia