ABOVE IMAGE: Stakeholders discuss challenges and opportunities facing the creative community. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
We often underestimate the value of something until it’s gone. What if the world lacked the thing you’re most passionate about?
Ask a biologist what they would do in a world without animals, and you might get a big reaction. Trying to imagine Salem without all its creative workers, artists and makers — from mural painters to dance instructors to community organizers — seems almost impossible.
On an evening in early May, PEM and the Creative Collective brought together more than 50 community stakeholders from across the region. After a bit of mixing and mingling and introductory remarks from PEM’s Chief Operating Officer, Kurt Steinberg, and the Creative Collective Founder and President, John Andrews, participants at the Creative Ecosystem Roundtable event got down to the business of problem-solving.
![Salem City Councilor-at-Large Alice Merkl; PEM board member Ana Colmenero; Salem State professor and poet January Gill O'Neil; Carolyn Cole of the Mass Cultural Council; and John Andrews of Creative Collective. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/Blog_CreativeEcosystem_1600_2.jpg)
Salem City Councilor-at-Large Alice Merkl; PEM board member Ana Colmenero; Salem State professor and poet January Gill O'Neil; Carolyn Cole of the Mass Cultural Council; and John Andrews of Creative Collective. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
As many participants noted, it’s not every day that you see poets, photographers and politicians come together for honest and open dialogue about how to nurture, sustain and promote creative communities.
Salem City Councilor-at-Large Alice Merkl; PEM board member Ana Colmenero; Salem State professor and poet January Gill O'Neil; Carolyn Cole of the Mass Cultural Council; and John Andrews of Creative Collective. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
Practicing artists and creatives, governmental officials and community leaders were seated at five tables and encouraged to step out of their traditional silos and think collaboratively. Discussions circled around several key themes: Living a Creative Life, Sustainability in the Creative Community, Partnerships and Opportunities, Tourism and Festivals and Advocacy and Governmental Affairs. Roundtable discussions were vibrant and infused with the spirit of active listening, open-mindedness and mutual respect.
PEM and Creative Collective were honored to have Carolyn Cole from Mass Cultural Council, Pedro Soto from Mass Development, Emily Ruddock from Mass Creative and Massachusetts State Senataor, Joan Lovely, as active participants lending their perspective of the broader activities happening in the Commonwealth. Locally, the event benefitted tremendously by having Salem Mayor Dominick Pangallo serve as an engaged and highly effective moderator for the Advocacy and Government Affairs discussion.
Those at the Partnerships and Opportunities table started off with an icebreaker. David Snider, PEM’s Director of Learning and Community Engagement, invited each participant to write a one-word answer for the question, “what is most needed for a successful partnership?” Heads down, pens and post-it notes out, the responses came in: intent, transparency, communication, humility and trustworthiness.
The groups also discussed art as an essential economic driver that institutions and community members have a responsibility to support. According to a 2024 study by the United States Bureau of Economic Analysis and the National Endowment for the Arts, the arts and culture sectors, both for-profit and nonprofit, contribute 4.31% to the nation's GDP. These sectors support more than 5.2 million jobs and represent a $1.02 trillion industry — more than either the construction or the transportation sectors.
![Audiences take in some music on PEM’s campus during the PEM Prize Festival in 2022. Photo by Tatiana O'Hanlon/PEM](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/images/Blog_Creative-Ecosystem_1600_3.jpg)
The questions stakeholders were asked to wrestle with were anything but simple. The arts community loves to fashion compelling places that people love. Whether it’s Lynn’s open studios, Beverly’s Montserrat College of Art or Salem’s robust schedule of festivals, the North Shore is fueled by creatives. Yet, those same people often struggle to afford the cost of living in the communities they help build. So, how do we set a better expectation and pay creatives enough to be able to stay and participate in the local economy? For starters, with collective advocacy.
This cross-disciplinary roundtable format was experimental but impactful. The room buzzed with energy as new connections were forged and fresh ideas circulated. A recurring theme was how rare and valuable it is to bring together such a wide range of creative stakeholders to tackle old challenges from a fresh perspective. Caroline Watson-Felt simultaneously represented Salem’s City Council and its theater community. In a moment of animated problem-solving, she exclaimed, “We’ve been talking about that problem for 20 years. Now is the time, let’s get it done!”
Curiosity, art and creativity — like food, water and air — are essential ingredients for quality of life. But why is creativity so difficult to pursue? At one table, a PEM board member and a Salem City Councilor listened to a group discuss the challenges they face living a creative life. Self-advocacy can be exhausting, the group agreed. Pricing your services, paintings or workshops can be challenging when everyone is dealing with this area’s high cost of living. One idea that emerged is to change how people view what is offered by the creative community, which includes how the community talks about itself.
![Maia Mattson working on her display for Bats! at 179 Essex Street, Salem. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/Blog_CreativeEcosystem_1600_4.jpg)
Maia Mattson working on her display for Bats! at 179 Essex Street, Salem. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
“We have to change the way people think about us, talk about us and interact with us,” said John Andrews. “If we continue to have conversations like tonight and bring in people who don’t get to listen to our conversations and what we need, that is when we may start to see change.”
Maia Mattson working on her display for Bats! at 179 Essex Street, Salem. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
A wide range of topics came up over the course of the evening. The group discussed how organizations and government entities don’t always know what it takes to be an artist — and that artists don’t always understand the processes of organizations and government entities. Representatives from smaller arts organizations expressed their frustrations with competing with larger, more established organizations in the grant funding reimbursement process when they couldn’t readily front a large amount of money.
Artists advocated for each other, offering advice for how to establish relationships and advocate for yourself, how to foster accountability with a contract and how to get away from a scarcity mindset and ask for resources. Supporting young artists in a changing world and creating a central place to share community partnerships and resources were also hot topics across the room.
The event also touched on the complex matrix of challenges facing the North Shore’s many immigrant communities: breaking down language, transportation and financial barriers is also key to helping all community members access art. From there, the group discussed how to address the needs of specific BIPOC communities to create more opportunities in art and culture.
Participants shared optimism that the upcoming 400th anniversary of Salem and “Salem 400” series of events could center around efforts to be a better community, building out programs that support residents.
At times, problems were solved right at the table, simply by sharing information about opportunities, such as within the City of Salem or the Salem State University community. An identified need for Spanish-to-English translation turned into the Superintendent of Salem Schools offering to help. “This is the greatest bridge right here,” said Michelle “La Poetica” Richardson, a spoken word artist who works in community engagement at Raw Art Works in Lynn.
![Hannah Varden, Public Programs and Community Engagement Assistant at PEM, and Ashley Ganem, Senior Communications and Events Manager at North Shore Community Development Cooperation. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/images/Blog_CreativeEcosystem_1600_5.jpg)
The Creative Ecosystem Roundtable was a follow-up to last November’s Networking Breakfast and Leadership Forum, also held at PEM and organized in partnership with Creative Collective, that also offered another platform to delve into the opportunities and challenges that face our creative community. These events are part of a series that will continue in the fall of 2024.
![Lindsey Cline from Siren of the Circle Burlesque; Jessica Valatka, artist and Youth Climate Leadership Club Member; and Alice Merkl, Salem City Councilor-at-Large. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/Blog_CreativeEcosystem_1600_6.jpg)
Lindsey Cline from Siren of the Circle Burlesque; Jessica Valatka, artist and Youth Climate Leadership Club Member; and Alice Merkl, Salem City Councilor-at-Large. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
Meanwhile, notes from PEM’s staff members are being compiled to identify broad themes, trends and action items for prioritizing, nurturing and sustaining creative communities.
Lindsey Cline from Siren of the Circle Burlesque; Jessica Valatka, artist and Youth Climate Leadership Club Member; and Alice Merkl, Salem City Councilor-at-Large. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.
![Kurt Steinberg, PEM’s Chief Operating Officer. Photo by Kathy Tarantola/PEM.](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/images/Blog_CreativeEcosystem_1600_7.jpg)
“We are committed to these conversations and this kind of dialogue,” said Kurt Steinberg in his closing remarks, acknowledging that PEM hasn’t always been perceived as an engaged community collaborator. Now and going forward, Steinberg said, the museum will become more of a resource for artists and cultural workers. “We are not looking to take a position, but to be a bridge. We have the seeds and the ability to get things done.”
PEM Content Producer Dinah Cardin contributed to this blog post. More on the Creative Roundtable can be found in this letter to the editor in The Salem News.
Keep exploring
Blog
“Our Time on Earth” and Rare look at collective power to drive climate action
5 Min read
![](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/_width998/Exhibition_OTOE_Share_1700px.jpg)
Blog
Keeping culture with Zainab Sumu
5 Min read
![](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/_width998/Blog_KeepingCultureZainabSumu_1800_Share.jpg)
PEMcast
PEMcast 28: Drawn to Place
37 min listen
![](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/images/_width998/Blog_PEMcast28_Share_1800px.jpg)
Blog
Salem community leaders share a few of their favorite things
18 Min read
![](https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pem-org/general/_width998/blogCommunityLeadersfavorites_1700.jpg)