Unlocking Transparency and Sustainable Finance: Navigating the FCA's New Labels for Asset Managers and Beyond

The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has significantly raised the bar for transparency and accountability in sustainable finance with its recent release of new Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR). Applicable to all FCA-authorized financial services firms, the requirements define labels that categorize investment funds’ sustainability goals. These requirements will play a crucial role in combatting greenwashing, helping consumer investors by ensuring that financial products’ sustainability claims meet a robust, evidence-based standard. 

The requirements include four distinct labels available to UK asset managers based on their financial products' specific sustainability objectives. To qualify for any of these labels, a product must meet both general and specific criteria relating to that label on an ongoing basis.

1. Sustainability Impact: Financial products labeled as Sustainability Impact are solution-oriented and follow an investment strategy that seeks to achieve pre-defined positive, measurable impacts in relation to an environmental and/or social objective such as creating renewable energy infrastructure or generating capacity. By selecting and promoting these products, asset managers showcase their commitment to delivering meaningful impact for the environment and/or society through their investment portfolios. For investors, the Sustainability Impact label helps identify initiatives that drive tangible environmental and social improvements.

2. Sustainability Focus: Products labeled as Sustainability Focus concentrate on advancing environmental and social objectives such as supporting renewable energy production, promoting resilient real estate, or providing climate insurance, among others. These objectives reflect an asset manager's dedication to supporting positive change through their investment strategies. By categorizing their products with the Sustainability Focused label, asset managers show their commitment to prioritizing sustainability considerations in their investment decision-making and fostering alignment with the broader sustainability agenda.

3. Sustainability Improvers: The Sustainability Improver label identifies products whose assets show the potential to improve environmental and/or social sustainability over time, such as companies on a credible long-term path to net zero or alignment with global social standards. This category addresses the potentially controversial approach of investing in assets that may not meet sustainability standards but have the potential to improve their environmental or social footprint. By focusing their investments on enterprises dedicated to positive change, asset managers can play a role in building a more sustainable and responsible business ecosystem in which sustainability improvement is incentivized.

4. Sustainability Mixed Goals: The Sustainability Mixed Goals label denotes financial products that encompass a mix of investments that align variously with the sustainability objectives of the Sustainability Impact, Focus, and Improver labels. This label allows an individual fund to adopt multiple ESG approaches for its portfolio. Firms choosing to identify with this label must disclose the proportion of assets invested across those labels and meet their individual requirements.

As asset managers navigate the evolving landscape of sustainable finance, the FCA's new labeling requirements present an opportunity to elevate their role in driving positive sustainability outcomes, even if they are not directly under FCA jurisdiction.

First and foremost, adhering to the FCA's labeling requirements enables asset managers to bolster transparency and authenticity in their sustainability offerings. Asset managers can ensure that investors have a clear understanding of the sustainability attributes and objectives of their investment offerings by categorizing and communicating their financial products with precision, fostering increased confidence and trust. Effective communication and alignment with these labels amplify the impact of sustainable investment strategies, empowering asset managers to deliver meaningful sustainability outcomes through their portfolios. Furthermore, embracing FCA labeling allows asset managers to proactively combat greenwashing, contributing to a more accountable and impactful sustainable finance ecosystem. 

This action by the FCA represents the next step in the evolution of ESG regulation. To date, the broadest regulation for European asset managers has been the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR). One challenge for managers has been the adoption of SFDR Articles 6, 8, and 9 as de facto labels for different types of “light green” to “dark green” funds. The SFDR was not intended to be a labeling regime, leading to a disconnect between the market’s interpretation of elements of the SFDR with their actual regulatory meaning. As a non-EU country, the UK has the ability to build its own regulatory framework and has explicitly chosen to adopt a new labeling regime. While this comes with its own challenges as asset managers determine which (if any) of the FCA labels best apply to their existing funds, it has the benefit of greater clarity and alignment between regulatory meaning and investors’ likely interpretation. It also comes with teeth, as the FCA has explicitly flagged the potential for enforcement actions (not to mention reputational harm) if companies misuse its labels or otherwise fail to meet requirements.

FCA labels will be available for use beginning July 31, 2024.

FCA and Beyond

At Integrity 2 ESG, we have created an anti-greenwashing, sustainable financing framework with the assistance of ESG savants, including Shiva Rajgopal, Todd Cort, Joseph Naayem, and Melanie Steiner, J.D., LL.M. Our assessments and certification provide investors with the confidence that asset managers are aligned with existing ESG obligations, including the FCA's four labeling requirements and the EU SFDR. Our framework is also forward-looking and aligned with the proposed requirements set forth by the SEC in May of 2022 in preparation for final rulemaking in the near future. Our certification process involves independent evaluation of an asset manager's sustainable investment practices, ensuring alignment with the regulatory regulations and criteria and the broader standards of transparency and integrity in sustainable finance. 

For asset managers, obtaining anti-greenwashing or ESG regulatory certification shows a commitment to genuine sustainable finance practices—showcasing their willingness to undergo independent evaluation and scrutiny and providing clarity and reassurance to investors regarding the authenticity of their sustainable investment offerings. 

For investors, an anti-greenwashing assessment or ESG certification acts as a clear benchmark for evaluating asset managers' adherence to regulatory requirements and validates that their words are backed up by real action. With this validation in place, investors can be confident that an asset manager's sustainable investment offerings have undergone thorough scrutiny and validation, reducing their risk of falling victim to misleading or exaggerated sustainability claims. 

In the broader context of the sustainable finance landscape, the introduction of anti-greenwashing assessments or ESG certifications aligns with the industry's collective efforts to combat greenwashing and enhance transparency. By setting a clear standard for sustainable investment practices and imposing accountability measures, our certifications contribute to building a more resilient and trustworthy sustainable finance ecosystem. Ultimately, the convergence of regulatory requirements and the implementation of anti-greenwashing assessments or ESG certifications offers investors an additional layer of assurance, ensuring that asset managers' sustainable investment products are aligned with genuine sustainability objectives and delivering on the promises of positive environmental and social impacts. 

We would be happy to help develop your ESG program, perform anti-greenwashing assessments, or obtain an ESG certification. Please contact Alan Swersky, CPA, Peter Golden, or me with any questions. 

#ESG #SFDR #FCA #EU #AssetManagement #InvestmentFunds #SustainableFinance