Belonging and high performance are both topics that are close to my heart.
I am excited to be announcing the publication of the research paper ‘The Dynamics of Belonging: A Quadrant-Based Analysis of Team Cohesion and Performance’ by Dirk Coetzee and myself, with valuable insights from Dee Hoch, M.A., ACC (link in the comments)
This research grew out of one of the excellent rounds of reflection and discussion that we had earlier this year at a PhD seminar about leadership that I conducted for United International Business School, where Dirk was a participant, pursuing a doctorate after a successful career in management consulting.
The general tendency in today’s discourse is to affirm that belonging supports performance. Indeed it would be great if there was a simple positive correlation between these two desirable states. We think it is not so simple!
In order to examine this we have created a four quadrant model, where organizations are positioned in one of the quadrants depending on their level of performance orientation and the importance they place on belonging:
👉 Disengagement Quadrant: Low performance orientation, low importance of belonging – low motivation and minimal community, leading to underperformance and disconnection
👉 Comfort Zone Quadrant: Low performance orientation, high importance of belonging – strong interpersonal connections and harmonious work environment, often lacking a sense of urgency and ambition
👉 Transactional Excellence Quadrant: High performance orientation, low importance of belonging – focusing on high performance through individual accountability; often sacrificing team cohesion and long term sustainability
👉 Synergistic Thrive Quadrant: High performance orientation, high importance of belonging – team members are committed to both performance goals and to each other, fostering a sustainable high performance culture
The quadrant model allows organizations to reflect on their actual and desired positioning. We believe that for many, including ourselves, the Synergistic Thrive Quadrant is the ideal position, however some may also choose the Comfort Zone Quadrant or the Transactional Excellence Quadrant as their objective.
Which Quadrant is your organization’s current and & or desired position? What are your thoughts on the model?
#highperformance #belonging #leadership #humanresources