Lisa of Troy's Reviews > The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
by
by
If you loved The Good Sister, this book is for you!
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time is a UK story about a 15 year-old boy named Christopher Boone. Christopher is a brilliant person who is extremely analytical and starts to investigate the death of his neighbor's dog, a poodle named Wellington. Who killed Wellington and why? Christopher will be pushed well beyond his comfort zone while unabashedly telling the truth and going on an impossible journey. How comfortable are we to change and adventure?
This book was delightfully funny as Christopher tries to solve the murder of Wellington. Christopher uses his skills of analysis to matter-of-factly investigate this horrible crime, and he vividly describes how he goes about the world, the level of detail that he observes. It was a wonderful reminder to take time to look around at the world around us. He also spoke about Stranger Danger and how uncomfortable he is when speaking to other people. For many people, conversations do not flow naturally and being bombarded by chaos and overwhelmed by stimulus is quite challenging.
The characters in this book were well developed - these are my favorite types of characters because they are imperfect but try their best especially for Christopher. This book truly is British, not an American author pretending to be British. How can I tell? Well, in my last job, my entire team was based out of London so not a day would go by that I wasn't on the phone with someone from the UK. Also, I have actually been to London so I would consider myself to be a bit more than average on UK terminology. One of the things that I found simply delightful with this book was the British approach. This is very difficult to put into words, but I shall do my best. The British usually respond less hysterical and with less overaction than Americans. For example, when I was in London, there was a protestor who had glued himself to the street. The police were freeing him and taking him down to the station. A large group of people (myself included) gathered around to watch. The protestor was sitting quite calmly while the police gently put goggles over his eyes and started the process. When they freed him, the protestor calmly accepted his fate and allowed the police to do their job. A man next to me explained in a matter of fact tone that they usually just take you down to the station for half a day and release you. He had a rather good plate of eggs when he was last detained by the police.
In America, the police would be making the onlookers disband, and the protestors aren't really that committed to actually glue themselves to anything. If someone does encounter the police, usually they are thrashing about and making the whole process as difficult as possible.
As an American reading this book, I found it so interesting how the various people interacted with Christopher because I can assure you that Americans would have reacted so very differently, and I found it rather refreshing that the adults weren't hyper-protective and allowed Christopher to fully experience his journey (to some degree). There really should be a slightly Americanized version of this book though because although I do know that The Underground is called The Tube and boot is actually the trunk of a car, there were a few times when I was a bit confused. For example, Christopher was talking about how he didn't like metaphors. One of them was "I've had a pig of a day." This phrase is not used in the The States so Christopher wasn't the only one confused.
Overall, I thought that this was a delightful read. One of my family members (a bit younger than Christopher) has a genius IQ. He is extremely talented in math and can easily build almost anything. Bring something home from IKEA, blink, and he can put it together. But he can't spell to save his life. This book was a refreshing reminder that not every person fits the traditional mold and not to judge a person based on one skillset. It's a short read - pick this one up!
This was one of the 100 Books to Read Before You Die According to the BBC: https://www.listchallenges.com/bbcs-t...
2025 Reading Schedule
Jan A Town Like Alice
Feb Birdsong
Mar Captain Corelli's Mandolin - Louis De Berniere
Apr War and Peace
May The Woman in White
Jun Atonement
Jul The Shadow of the Wind
Aug Jude the Obscure
Sep Ulysses
Oct Vanity Fair
Nov A Fine Balance
Dec Germinal
Connect With Me!
Blog Twitter BookTube Insta My Bookstore at Pango
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time is a UK story about a 15 year-old boy named Christopher Boone. Christopher is a brilliant person who is extremely analytical and starts to investigate the death of his neighbor's dog, a poodle named Wellington. Who killed Wellington and why? Christopher will be pushed well beyond his comfort zone while unabashedly telling the truth and going on an impossible journey. How comfortable are we to change and adventure?
This book was delightfully funny as Christopher tries to solve the murder of Wellington. Christopher uses his skills of analysis to matter-of-factly investigate this horrible crime, and he vividly describes how he goes about the world, the level of detail that he observes. It was a wonderful reminder to take time to look around at the world around us. He also spoke about Stranger Danger and how uncomfortable he is when speaking to other people. For many people, conversations do not flow naturally and being bombarded by chaos and overwhelmed by stimulus is quite challenging.
The characters in this book were well developed - these are my favorite types of characters because they are imperfect but try their best especially for Christopher. This book truly is British, not an American author pretending to be British. How can I tell? Well, in my last job, my entire team was based out of London so not a day would go by that I wasn't on the phone with someone from the UK. Also, I have actually been to London so I would consider myself to be a bit more than average on UK terminology. One of the things that I found simply delightful with this book was the British approach. This is very difficult to put into words, but I shall do my best. The British usually respond less hysterical and with less overaction than Americans. For example, when I was in London, there was a protestor who had glued himself to the street. The police were freeing him and taking him down to the station. A large group of people (myself included) gathered around to watch. The protestor was sitting quite calmly while the police gently put goggles over his eyes and started the process. When they freed him, the protestor calmly accepted his fate and allowed the police to do their job. A man next to me explained in a matter of fact tone that they usually just take you down to the station for half a day and release you. He had a rather good plate of eggs when he was last detained by the police.
In America, the police would be making the onlookers disband, and the protestors aren't really that committed to actually glue themselves to anything. If someone does encounter the police, usually they are thrashing about and making the whole process as difficult as possible.
As an American reading this book, I found it so interesting how the various people interacted with Christopher because I can assure you that Americans would have reacted so very differently, and I found it rather refreshing that the adults weren't hyper-protective and allowed Christopher to fully experience his journey (to some degree). There really should be a slightly Americanized version of this book though because although I do know that The Underground is called The Tube and boot is actually the trunk of a car, there were a few times when I was a bit confused. For example, Christopher was talking about how he didn't like metaphors. One of them was "I've had a pig of a day." This phrase is not used in the The States so Christopher wasn't the only one confused.
Overall, I thought that this was a delightful read. One of my family members (a bit younger than Christopher) has a genius IQ. He is extremely talented in math and can easily build almost anything. Bring something home from IKEA, blink, and he can put it together. But he can't spell to save his life. This book was a refreshing reminder that not every person fits the traditional mold and not to judge a person based on one skillset. It's a short read - pick this one up!
This was one of the 100 Books to Read Before You Die According to the BBC: https://www.listchallenges.com/bbcs-t...
2025 Reading Schedule
Jan A Town Like Alice
Feb Birdsong
Mar Captain Corelli's Mandolin - Louis De Berniere
Apr War and Peace
May The Woman in White
Jun Atonement
Jul The Shadow of the Wind
Aug Jude the Obscure
Sep Ulysses
Oct Vanity Fair
Nov A Fine Balance
Dec Germinal
Connect With Me!
Blog Twitter BookTube Insta My Bookstore at Pango
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 5, 2020
– Shelved
April 23, 2021
–
Started Reading
April 23, 2021
–
54.87%
"This book is very funny! I also don't disagree with most of Christopher's behavior problems - I don't like my food touching either!"
page
124
April 24, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Kat (Books are Comfort Food)
(new)
Apr 24, 2021 09:23PM
Sounds like a nice book, Lisa. I really like your review.
reply
|
flag
Great review, Lisa! I went to England to research my latest book and had such a fun time. Ended up closing a pub singing horribly off-key with some newly found “mates” who then took me to an underground pub—we had such a blast!
Mark wrote: "Great review, Lisa! I went to England to research my latest book and had such a fun time. Ended up closing a pub singing horribly off-key with some newly found “mates” who then took me to an underg..."
Thanks, Mark! Sounds like it was a great time! When is your new book to be released?
Thanks, Mark! Sounds like it was a great time! When is your new book to be released?
What a well remember comparison of the US and UK. Historically I feel something went really wrong with American policing they seem so confrontational and aggressive, whilst in the UK most police actions begin with ways to pacify and reduce aggression. ..also the book is such a wonderful Brit read, thank you Lisa :)
Lisa of Troy wrote: "Mark wrote: "Great review, Lisa! I went to England to research my latest book and had such a fun time. Ended up closing a pub singing horribly off-key with some newly found “mates” who then took me..."
I’m trying to release one book per every holiday season (so by this November/December). In the meantime, having a blast in your Lord of the Flies class!
I’m trying to release one book per every holiday season (so by this November/December). In the meantime, having a blast in your Lord of the Flies class!
Excellent review Lisa, I read this many years ago (before I even wrote reviews), and recall enjoying it very much. I love your closing comments….so true!
What a fabulous review Lisa - you really nailed it, and us British! Maybe a glossary of British terms would help?! This is one of my favourite books, I love out of the ordinary characters, especially when a book helps others understand these characters. Brilliantly done.
Very nice review, Lisa! Your comments on the cultural and language differences made me smile. I'm often more attracted to British English and I have no problem understanding it - mainly because the UK is my favorite holiday destination - but I have problems sometimes with American English. My solution: a thesaurus ;-).
Lovely review and sentiment. I've had this on my shelves for yrs just haven't gotten to it. You've piqued my interest.
You probably looked that up already, but if you didn't, "I've had a pig of a day" means you've had a very bad day. :)
The book sounds interesting, thank you for sharing your thoughts!
The book sounds interesting, thank you for sharing your thoughts!
babes how have you gone into a whole tangent about how british it is?? first of all the way you can tell is that he says cunt. but also, how did you write 439 words about its britishness and not a single one about how shit its depiction of autism was?? or how poorly educated the author was?? do some research honestly
Baba wrote: "What a well remember comparison of the US and UK. Historically I feel something went really wrong with American policing they seem so confrontational and aggressive, whilst in the UK most police ac..."
I think you should google ‘met police sexually assault women’ and then come back and reevaluate this bc it’s really just hidden better in the uk
I think you should google ‘met police sexually assault women’ and then come back and reevaluate this bc it’s really just hidden better in the uk
pennyg wrote: "Lovely review and sentiment. I've had this on my shelves for yrs just haven't gotten to it. You've piqued my interest."
don’t bother
don’t bother
Thanks for the great review! This might be outdated question but at the beginning of the review, you said "If you loved The Good Sister, this book is for you!"
May I know the author of The Good Sister? There are so many books with the same title and I want to make sure I find the correct one. Thank you
May I know the author of The Good Sister? There are so many books with the same title and I want to make sure I find the correct one. Thank you
It is unfortunate that in US police work starts with an assumption that the one being confronted is armed and dangerous. Even when you can clearly see it is not the case. Common sense or humanity is totally missing.
Great review, Lisa... As always.
Great review, Lisa... As always.
Good review from Lisa of Troy. The only thing that surprised me about her review is that, perhaps just by oversight, it does not mention that the boy narrator and central character of the novel is autistic, which affects the way he sees things.
I know little about the condition, but I spoke to one man whose son is autistic who found that the way the condition is portrayed in this novel is nothing like how his son is. However, I understand that the preferred medical term is now 'on the autistic spectrum', which possibly implies that autism is not one thing but a group of related things, so individual experiences of it will differ.
As for British colloquialisms, 'I've had a pig of a day' is not a common expression, but 'pig' as a general derogatory term, most often of a person but also of a thing, is quite common. I assumed (with all respect to pigs) that that was so around the World, so I had assumed everyone would realise that 'a pig of a day' just meant 'a very bad day', but I suppose that if it looks like an idiom or a proverb people may wonder if it has a more specific meaning.
Even reading a lot of things written by Americans, having watched quite a lot of American films, having relatives in New York City and Chicago etc. I still come across unexpected differences in the use of language.
Only recently I noticed that 'song' seems to have a different meaning. Hence I have come across Americans who say things like 'Pachelbel's Canon is my favourite song', whereas most people in Britain would say that it cannot be a 'song' as it is a purely instrumental piece, and to us a song is not a song unless it has words.
I don't know if to Americans 'song' just means any piece of music, with or without words, that lasts a few minutes? But presumably the related verb to sing does still imply use of vocal chords to form words? Please politely correct me if I have misunderstood!
I know little about the condition, but I spoke to one man whose son is autistic who found that the way the condition is portrayed in this novel is nothing like how his son is. However, I understand that the preferred medical term is now 'on the autistic spectrum', which possibly implies that autism is not one thing but a group of related things, so individual experiences of it will differ.
As for British colloquialisms, 'I've had a pig of a day' is not a common expression, but 'pig' as a general derogatory term, most often of a person but also of a thing, is quite common. I assumed (with all respect to pigs) that that was so around the World, so I had assumed everyone would realise that 'a pig of a day' just meant 'a very bad day', but I suppose that if it looks like an idiom or a proverb people may wonder if it has a more specific meaning.
Even reading a lot of things written by Americans, having watched quite a lot of American films, having relatives in New York City and Chicago etc. I still come across unexpected differences in the use of language.
Only recently I noticed that 'song' seems to have a different meaning. Hence I have come across Americans who say things like 'Pachelbel's Canon is my favourite song', whereas most people in Britain would say that it cannot be a 'song' as it is a purely instrumental piece, and to us a song is not a song unless it has words.
I don't know if to Americans 'song' just means any piece of music, with or without words, that lasts a few minutes? But presumably the related verb to sing does still imply use of vocal chords to form words? Please politely correct me if I have misunderstood!
I regret that one person here has posted a few separate comments that seem unnecessarily rude. Perhaps we can all, where we wish to criticize something, at least do so politely.
I forgot to mention in my previous comment, for anyone who does not already know that the title 'The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time' is a quotation from one of Conan Doyle's short stories about Sherlock Holmes, 'The Adventure of Silver Blaze', about the theft of a race horse of that name, in the course of which someone is killed.
Holmes advises a policeman who is investigating the case to look into 'the curious incident of the dog in the night time.' 'The dog did nothing in the night time'. 'That was the curious incident'.
This is also sometimes referred to as 'the dog who didn't bark.' The clue being that we would expect the dog to bark at an intruder in the night, and the question is why he did not.
Holmes advises a policeman who is investigating the case to look into 'the curious incident of the dog in the night time.' 'The dog did nothing in the night time'. 'That was the curious incident'.
This is also sometimes referred to as 'the dog who didn't bark.' The clue being that we would expect the dog to bark at an intruder in the night, and the question is why he did not.
Great review. Yeah, had to search one phrase myself..."losing my rag". Granted, my google search results didn't really give a definitive answer.
Christopher wasn't 'confused' about someone 'having a pig of a day'. It is is illogical, and irrational.
Besides, someone who is married to a cat would be confused by erudite language.
And no, praise God, may there not be an American version of this excellently written story. There is enough literary 'trailer trash' on the planet now!
Not to mention the Asperger 'nut jobs' are the only sensible people on the planet!
Besides, someone who is married to a cat would be confused by erudite language.
And no, praise God, may there not be an American version of this excellently written story. There is enough literary 'trailer trash' on the planet now!
Not to mention the Asperger 'nut jobs' are the only sensible people on the planet!