Who Do You Hire for a Fireplace Remodeling Project?

Get in touch with a fireplace contractor for the fireplace of your fantasies

Woman sitting by the fireplace reading a book
Photo: AleksandarNakic / E+ / Getty Images
Woman sitting by the fireplace reading a book
Photo: AleksandarNakic / E+ / Getty Images
Kate Fann
Written by Kate Fann
Contributing Writer
Updated November 10, 2023
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.

Selecting the right professional for your fireplace remodeling project is crucial for achieving a visually appealing and functional fireplace. When researching who to hire for a fireplace remodel, you have a few options to choose from. Each option comes with benefits to consider, as you prepare to tackle this project to ultimately see your vision for the perfect fireplace come to life.

Benefits of Hiring a Fireplace Contractor to Remodel a Fireplace

Do your research before diving into a remodeling project. Reach out to as many different types of people as you can, from contractors to remodeling companies, to be as informed as possible on all the modern remodeling options available to you.

- Traci Snyder, Vice President of Marketing, People and Technology, Improveit Home Remodeling

The cost to remodel a fireplace is between $400 and $2,000, with an average fireplace remodel cost of $1,200. The overall project cost will largely depend on the work completed, whether you're interested in fixing a few imperfections or require a full remodel.

Here are some of the advantages of hiring a fireplace contractor for such a project:

  • Expertise and experience With their wealth of knowledge and experience, fireplace contractors are well-equipped to tackle all aspects of a fireplace remodel. From designing to installing, they are well-versed in local building codes, safety requirements, and design principles to guarantee a secure and compliant remodel.

  • Quality workmanship: With their advanced training and expertise, professional contractors are equipped to produce top-tier results. Their focus on even the smallest details and masterful craftsmanship can yield a stunning fireplace remodel that operates flawlessly and looks remarkable.

  • Warranty and guarantee:: Established fireplace contractors often provide warranties or guarantees for both their craftsmanship and the installations they execute, which can provide peace of mind should any concerns arise post-renovation.

  • Time and cost savings: Investing in a professional may come with an initial expense, but ultimately, it can prove to be a wise choice that saves you both time and money. Undertaking a DIY fireplace remodeling project can be a daunting and pricey endeavor, especially if mistakes are made. However, hiring an experienced contractor with the necessary skills and equipment can streamline the process and deliver an efficient outcome.

  • Customization and design guidance:: A skilled fireplace contractor can provide invaluable assistance in designing a fireplace that will match your home's aesthetic. They can guide the materials, finishes, and layout options that are best suited to your vision, and will customize the remodel to meet your unique requirements. With their help, you can choose from a range of design elements, including mantels, hearths, and surround materials, to create a truly one-of-a-kind fireplace that perfectly reflects your individual style.

Who Can Remodel a Fireplace?

A fireplace contractor is the best choice for fireplace remodeling. However, you may also be able to hire a masonry contractor since they’re familiar with the tools and supplies used in the project. A select few handypeople may have enough experience to remodel your fireplace, but you should call a fireplace contractor first and a masonry contractor second before getting in touch with a general handyperson. Always ask specific questions about what you’re envisioning for your project before hiring a professional.

  • Fireplace contractor

  • Masonry contractor

  • Handyperson

Should I DIY a Fireplace Remodel?

Undertaking a fireplace remodel on your own is possible, provided you possess the essential skills and expertise, and have an understanding of the local building codes and safety protocols.

Before you decide to embark on a DIY fireplace remodel, there are important factors to consider:

  • Skills and experience: Undertaking a fireplace remodeling project is a complex and labor-intensive project that demands a deep understanding of masonry, carpentry, and construction techniques. Inexperienced individuals who attempt such a project risk making costly errors that could compromise both the safety and aesthetics of their fireplace.

  • Safety: Ensuring safety is paramount when dealing with fireplaces. Inadequate installation or modifications can cause severe fire hazards, smoke-related problems, or even structural damage. Entrusting the task to an experienced contractor is a wise choice, as they are well-versed in safety protocols, and will make sure that the remodel adheres to safety regulations.

  • Building codes: To guarantee that your fireplace is both safe and legal, it is essential to adhere to local building codes and regulations when installing or making modifications. If you decide to go the DIY route, you must be vigilant about understanding these regulations in your area.

  • Tools and equipment: Remodeling a fireplace often demands specialized equipment and tools. Acquiring these tools could entail significant costs if you do not already own or have access to them.

  • Cost: Although undertaking a DIY project may seem like a budget-friendly option at first glance, it may eventually lead to greater expenses due to potential mistakes that need to be fixed, or the need to buy tools and materials that you don't already have.

Should I Hire a Masonry Contractor to Remodel a Fireplace?

Contractor remodeling wood fireplace
Photo: Blend Images / John Fedele / Tetra images / Getty Images

A fireplace can indeed be remodeled by hiring a masonry contractor. These skilled professionals possess a specialized knowledge of working with a variety of masonry materials for different types of fireplaces including concrete, brick, and stone, which makes them highly qualified for handling fireplace remodeling projects.

Here are some benefits of hiring a masonry contractor for a fireplace remodel:

  • Masonry expertise: Contractors who specialize in masonry possess a wealth of knowledge and practical experience in working with materials used for constructing fireplaces. They guarantee that the renovation is not only structurally secure but also visually captivating. They are adept at developing customized patterns and designs using various stones or bricks to elevate the fireplace's overall aesthetic appeal.

  • Material versatility: With the help of skilled masonry contractors, selecting the perfect material to create the fireplace of your dreams is made simple. Choose from options including brick, natural stone, cultured stone veneer, and concrete to achieve your desired aesthetic.

Should I Hire a Handyperson for a Fireplace Remodel?

Depending on the extent of the remodel, you can hire a handyperson to renovate a fireplace.  A handyperson often has a range of skills and can be capable of performing various home improvement projects, including fireplace remodels. However, you will want to ensure you hire a professional with this skill set.

Here are some potential benefits of hiring a handyperson for a fireplace remodel:

  • Cost-effective: Opting for a handyperson to remodel your fireplace could prove to be a wise financial decision if your project doesn't entail significant structural modifications or intricate masonry work. A handyperson may charge relatively lower rates compared to a specialized contractor, making them an economical option for smaller projects and less complex fireplace remodels. 

  • Versatility: A handyperson with a diverse skill set can provide significant advantages for fireplace remodeling projects that require multiple tasks. Their expertise in trades such as masonry, carpentry, painting, and other relevant areas enables them to tackle various aspects of the project with ease.

  • Smaller-scale projects: For a relatively minor fireplace remodel that involves updating the mantel, replacing tiles, or refreshing the hearth, a handyperson would be a fitting option. They possess the necessary equipment and expertise to efficiently undertake smaller-scale projects while maintaining meticulous attention to detail.

How Do Fireplace Contractors Remodel a Fireplace?

To remodel fireplaces, contractors follow a systematic process that begins with an initial consultation with homeowners. During this meeting, they discuss the homeowners' preferences, design ideas, and goals, while assessing the condition of the existing fireplace and any safety concerns. Contractors then collaborate with the homeowners to create a tailored design plan, which includes selecting materials, finishes, and any necessary structural changes.

Once the plan is approved, contractors obtain any required permits and approvals from local authorities. The actual remodeling work involves either removing or preparing the existing fireplace structure. Depending on the design, contractors may update the hearth, surround, or insert a new firebox, while ensuring compliance with safety regulations and building codes.

Masonry work may be necessary, which involves laying bricks or stones and applying mortar to create the desired aesthetic. Skilled carpenters handle mantel and shelving installations, while electricians or gas experts set up fireplaces with the appropriate heating elements or gas lines. The final stages involve finishing touches such as painting, sealing, and installing any additional features like mantels, screens, or glass doors.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
Learn more about our contributor
Kate Fann
Written by Kate Fann
Contributing Writer
Kate Fann is a content writer with ten years of online writing experience, taking a specialized focus on strategic SEO.
Kate Fann is a content writer with ten years of online writing experience, taking a specialized focus on strategic SEO.
The homeowners guide to Fireplaces
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.