When Should Replace Your Gutters? At Least Every 20 Years

If you’re worried about leaks, it’s definitely time to do a gut-check on your gutters

An exterior view of a beautiful house
Photo: Grecosvet / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
An exterior view of a beautiful house
Photo: Grecosvet / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
Amber Guetebier
Written by Amber Guetebier
Contributing Writer
Eric Gonzalez
Reviewed by Eric Gonzalez
President, Crews for Roofs
Updated July 10, 2023
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.

Whether you’ve been living in your home for years or you just moved in, the gutter system is an important area of your home to pay attention to. While most gutter systems, such as vinyl, steel, or aluminum gutters, will last an average of 20 years, others, including copper, can last closer to 50. If you’re wondering how often you should replace your gutters, this guide will help you determine the answer.

Signs You May Need Gutter Replacement

The following are signs you need new gutters:

  • Water pooling around your gutter downspout

  • Cracks

  • Peeling paints

  • Holes

  • Rust

  • Sagging gutters

  • Fallen nails or fasteners

  • Leaking water in basement or foundation

Look for all of these signs especially during or just after a rainstorm to gauge how well your gutter system is really working. Some of these problems, like clogged gutters, can be fixed with a simple cleaning or trip to a hardware store. But if you find the issue persists even after you’ve repaired it, you may need to completely remove your gutters and install replacements. 

How Often Should You Replace Gutters?

With regular maintenance for most gutter systems, you wouldn’t need to consider replacing your gutters until 20 or more years. Some systems can last even longer than that. 

However, if you’ve moved into a home where the gutters have not been cleaned and maintained, that life span can shorten dramatically. Lots of leaks and sagging, even on a newer system, may need replacement. We recommend you check your gutters after a recent storm as hail and wind can cause damages that affect their performance.

Should You Repair or Replace Your Gutter System?

Worker installing the gutter system
Photo: MyrKu / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

It is possible to replace only the sections of your gutter that have damage. For example, there may be issues with the downspout—these can sometimes be bumped by cars, run into while playing, or dislodged by enthusiastic canines. That’s a simple replacement most homeowners can do on their own. 

One of the challenges with replacing worn or damaged sections is making sure the gutter actually matches. Since many gutter systems last more than 20 years, the exact make, material, and color may not exist anymore. You will also need access to a very tall ladder or a way to access the roofline safely.

Regular Maintenance for Gutters

Close up of house gutter clogged with leaves
Photo: JJ Gouin / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

Now that you know how often you should replace your gutters, it’s time to think about maintenance (and prevention).

Even if you don’t think you need a gutter replacement yet, be sure to watch for warning signs of gutter damage when you perform regular cleanings. You should clean your gutters at least twice a year (in the spring and fall) or more often if you live in an area with heavy rainfall.

While unclogging gutters and removing debris, keep an eye out for cracks, loose fasteners, leaks, and sagging. Watch your siding for mold or excess dampness. If you hire a local gutter cleaner, ask them to keep an eye out for any damage so you can be proactive in repairs.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
Learn more about our contributors
Amber Guetebier
Written by Amber Guetebier
Contributing Writer
Amber Guetebier As a California native living in a Minnesota world, Amber has learned the hard way what plants will actually survive the winter. She is an editor and writer with publications such as Red Tricycle, The Bold Italic, and her own blog about strange plants, Rotten Botany.
Amber Guetebier As a California native living in a Minnesota world, Amber has learned the hard way what plants will actually survive the winter. She is an editor and writer with publications such as Red Tricycle, The Bold Italic, and her own blog about strange plants, Rotten Botany.
Eric Gonzalez
Reviewed by Eric Gonzalez
President, Crews for Roofs
Expert Reviewer
Expert Reviewer
The homeowners guide to Gutters
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.