What’s the Difference between Home Insurance and Home Warranty?

Many homeowners ask the question: home insurance or home warranty? Frankly, it’s not a debate of one or the other but of whether you need both. Home insurance and home warranties protect your home from emergencies and your bank account from spontaneous, wallet-breaking expenses. But should you pay for home insurance, home warranty, or both? Keep reading as we break down the differences between home insurance and home warranties so you know how to best protect your home.

What are the Differences Between Home Insurance and Home Warranties?

Home insurance covers your home, specifically, your home’s structure, while a home warranty covers your home’s systems and appliances. Both offer protection to your home and belongings, but as a whole, they’re different in their cost coverage, level of protection, requirement, and cost. 

Homeowners Insurance vs. Home Warranty: Coverage Differences

Photo: Nikola Stojadinovic / E+ / Getty Images

Homeowners insurance and home warranties are distinct in the type of coverage they offer homeowners. Insurance covers the structure of your home, your personal belongings, and injuries or property damage. It may even cover living expenses at a four-star hotel if an emergency forces you out of your home. On the other hand, home warranties cover your major systems and appliances. This ranges from your HVAC and plumbing systems to your everyday household appliances like ovens, refrigerators, and washer/dryer units.

Cost Coverage Differences

When you get home insurance or a home warranty, what does it pay for? Home insurance pays for everything that’s covered in the policy. If you need to repair or replace your belongings, the cost is covered. Did your tree fall and damage your neighbor’s fence? It’s covered. Home insurance pays for injuries or damages caused by you, your property, or your family members, and that includes pets. All you’d need to do is file a homeowners insurance claim, and your insurer would send you a check for the amount covered. Depending on the policy, they may cover the total cost or they may cover the cost up to a maximum amount.

A home warranty doesn’t pay for everything, but it certainly helps. It helps you pay for repairing or replacing any applicable appliances or systems that are covered by your policy.

Protection Differences

Homeowners insurance and home warranties give you peace of mind. You know your house and belongings are protected, but what are they protected from?

A home warranty is fairly limited in what it protects your appliances from. It covers your systems and appliances from age or regular wear and tear. For example, if your refrigerator or dishwasher starts leaking because it’s old or outdated, your warranty will help you pay to repair or replace your appliances. Now, if a falling object were to damage your dishwasher or someone stole your refrigerator, a home warranty wouldn’t help you, but homeowners insurance would.

The level of protection you get from your homeowners' insurance depends on the policy. The most common type of homeowners insurance is the HO-3 policy, and it’s considered the standard. It covers your home structure against open perils and liabilities. An open-perils policy protects your home against any and all disasters unless your policy lists it as an exception. Your personal property, however, is covered on a named-perils basis. They’re only covered from a list of specific perils that are named in your policy. 

HO-3 policies usually offer broad coverage against 16 named perils. They are:

• Fire or lightning

• Windstorm or hail

• Explosion

• Riot or civil commotion

• Damage caused by aircraft

• Damage caused by vehicles

• Smoke

• Vandalism

• Theft

• Volcanic eruption

• Falling object

• Weight of ice, snow, or sleet

• Accidental water overflow or steam discharge

• Sudden and accidental tearing apart, cracking, burning, or bulging of certain household systems

• Freezing of systems or appliances

• Sudden and accidental damage from electrical current

While your insurance policy may cover most of what you feel you need, some exclusions are typical of homeowners insurance. It won’t cover wear and tear, neglect, mold, pet or animal damage, or—much to the displeasure of many homeowners—floods. Homeowners insurance covers water damage that is “sudden and unexpected,” like that from a leaking pipe. So you’ll need to add special flood coverage if that’s a concern for you. If not, have your local water damage restoration professional on speed dial and hope you don’t have a flood.

Differences in Requirement

Having homeowners insurance isn’t a law, but depending on how you buy your home, you may be required to get it. If you apply for a loan to pay off your mortgage, your lender will likely require that you pay for a policy. This usually ends once you pay off the loan. Alternatively, a home warranty is completely optional.

Payment Differences

Deductibles and service fees are often used interchangeably, but they work differently in home insurance and warranties. Your home insurance policy will require that you pay a deductible—an out-of-pocket cost for each claim you file. The lower the deductible, the higher your monthly or annual premium, but deductibles tend to range between $500 to $2,000 or more.

The payment for home warranty claims can also be called deductibles, but they are more reminiscent of service fees. Each service call you make for one of your appliances or systems will typically include a service fee that will cost you around $75 to $125 per call.

Cost Differences

Because their coverage is different, you can expect differences in the cost of home insurance vs home warranties. On average, the cost of homeowners insurance is $1,500 a year, but this varies based on factors like where you live and the value of your home. Homeowners are paying slightly less for home warranties. On average, a home warranty costs $1,049 a year, but again, this can depend on your location and whether your plan covers your appliances, systems, or both.