CARE ETHICS RESEARCH CONSORTIUM
Inaugural Conference
CARE ETHICS
+
PRECARITY
Portland State University
September 27th + 28th, 2018
Create your own conference title
What is care to you?
What is precarity to you?
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
CARE ETHICS RESEARCH CONSORTIUM
Inaugural Conference
Portland State University
September 27th + 28th, 2018
SPONSORS
Care Ethics Research Consortium (CERC)
Portland State University
University Studies
The Provost’s Office
The School of Business Administration
College of Urban and Public Affairs
Department of Philosophy
Women, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
University of Humanistic Studies, the Netherlands
WELCOME!
On behalf of the members of the Care Ethics Research
Consortium (CERC) and Portland State University, welcome
to the inaugural CERC conference. We hope you will find
the two days of presentations stimulating and inspiring.
The conference theme, is appropriately, “Care Ethics and
Precarity.” The precarious world needs the work of care
ethicists more than ever. To effectively engage in the work
of care, we must be fortified with strong relationships
among researchers and practitioners all over the world.
We hope you will make an extra effort over the course of
this conference to make connections with other scholars
who are interested in expanding the circle of compassion,
empathy, and attentiveness in a time when unnecessary
perilousness has been wrought. Because this is the first
CERC conference, no blueprint existed for its creation.
Many people must be thanked for helping to create this
event, and some of their names are listed in this program.
We all hope you have a wonderful experience.
Best,
Maurice Hamington
Executive Director, University Studies
Professor of Philosophy
Affiliate Faculty, Women, Gender and Sexuality Studies,
Portland State University
CERC Steering Committee
ORGANIZERS
CERC FOLKS
Antoinette de Fouw
Inge van Nistelrooij
Care—Ethics.org Website Support
Planning Committee
Carlo Leget
Merel Visse
Preliminary Planning Committee
Planning Committee
Elena Pulcini
Sophie Bourgault
Preliminary Planning Committee
Presentation Schedule Coordinator
Flavia Biroli
Preliminary Planning Committee
PSU FOLKS
Elea Davison
Monica Mueller
Graphic Designer
Panel Chair Coordinator
Emma Colburn
Neera Malhotra
Family Project Space Coordinator
Local Conference Team
Krys Roth
Rachel Cunliffe
Executive Director Assistant
Local Conference Team
Maurice Hamington
Veronica Hotton
Conference Executive Director
Conference Manager
Michael Flower
Vicki Reitenauer
Local Conference Team
Welcoming and Belonging Coordinator
Michelle Swinehart
Aesthetics Coordinator
WAYFINDING
Food Carts
portlandfoodcarts.com/maps
Extensive + Convenient Public Transit
trimet.org
SCHEDULE
AT—A—GLANCE
WEDNESDAY // SEPTEMBER 26th
3:30—5:30 PM Pre—Conference Registration
Lobby of University Place Hotel & Conference Center
THURSDAY // SEPTEMBER 27th
8:00—8:30 AM
Registration
Prefunction near Wahkeena Falls Room
8:30—9:00 AM
Welcoming & Acknowledgements
9:00—10:00 AM
Opening Plenary: Maurice Hamington & Carlo Leget
Wahkeena Falls Room
10:00—10:30 AM //BREAK//
//BOTH DAYS //
8:00 AM—6:30 PM Family Project Space
9:00 AM—6:00 PM PreCarity Lab
10:30—12:00 PM Session A Panel Presentations
Four concurrent sessions
12:00—1:30 PM
//LUNCH//
12:30—1:20 PM
Contemplation + Reflection
1:30—3:00 PM
Session B Panel Presentations
Four concurrent sessions
3:00—3:30 PM
//BREAK//
3:30—5:00 PM
Session C Panel Presentations
Four concurrent sessions
5:00—5:15 PM
//BREAK//
5:15—6:15 PM
KEYNOTE ADDRESS: Eva Feder Kittay
Wahkeena Falls Room
6:30—7:30 PM
//RECEPTION//
FRIDAY // SEPTEMBER 28th
8:00—8:30 AM
Registration
Prefunction near Wahkeena Falls Room
8:30—10:00 AM
Session D Panel Presentations
Three concurrent sessions
10:00—10:30 AM
//BREAK//
10:30—12:00 PM Session E Panel Presentations
Three concurrent sessions
//BOTH DAYS //
8:00 AM—6:30 PM Family Project Space
9:00 AM—6:00 PM PreCarity Lab
10:30—12:00 PM Story Exchange
12:00—1:30 PM
//LUNCH//
12:30—1:20 PM
Contemplation + Reflection
1:30—3:30 PM
Plenary: Deborah Smith Arthur & Lori Gruen
Wahkeena Falls Room
3:30—4:00 PM
//BREAK//
4:00—5:30 PM
KEYNOTE ADDRESS: Fiona Robinson
Wahkeena Falls Room
5:30—5:45 PM
//BREAK//
5:45—6:30 PM
CLOSING REMARKS: Maurice Hamington & Joan Tronto
Wahkeena Falls Room
6:30—7:30 PM
//RECEPTION//
Wahkeena Falls Room
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SCHEDULE
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
KEYNOTE
Eva Feder Kittay
Can Care Ethics Really Be ‘Globalized’?
Thursday, September 27th // 5:15—6:15 PM
Wahkeena Falls Room
Eva Feder Kittay, Ph.D., recently retired as Distinguished
Professor of Philosophy at Stony Brook University.
She is the recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, an NEH
Fellowship, and the APA and Phi Beta Kappa Lebowitz Prize.
She has also been recognized for her work in Feminist
Philosophy, being named Woman Philosopher of the Year
(2003—2004) by the Society for Women in Philosophy and
having chaired the Committee on the Status of Women
(1997—2001). Her latest book is, Learning from My Daughter:
Disabled Minds and Rethinking Things that Matter.
Notes//
Fiona Robinsion
Globalizing Care Ethics:
Resisting Hierarchies and
Embracing Precarity
Friday, September 28th // 4:00—5:30 PM
Wahkeena Falls Room
Fiona Robinson, Ph.D., is Professor of
Political Science specializing in International
Relations and Political Theory at Carleton University
(Ottawa, Canada). She is the author of The Ethics
of Care: A Feminist Approach to Human Security,
which won the University of Southern California’s
J. Ann Tickner Book Prize in 2014 and was
short—listed for the Canadian Political Science
Association’s International Relations Book Prize in
2012. Fiona Robinson was the recipient of the 2012
Faculty of Public Affairs Research Achievement
Award and a 2014 Carleton University Research
Achievement Award.
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
KEYNOTE
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
Notes//
PLENARY
Deborah Smith Arthur + Lori Gruen
Magnitude and Bond:
Mass Incarceration in the
United States and the Promise of Care
Friday, September 28th // 4:00—5:30 PM
Wahkeena Falls Room
The United States incarcerates more of its citizens than
any other country in the world; roughly 2.2 million people,
including young people, are locked up. This session will
explore the potential for examining mass incarceration
through the lens of care ethics. Using a variety of formats
including discussion, personal narratives and poetry, this
session will explore how together, through shared harvest
of the best in each of us, we can recognize our common
bond and examine the resulting policy implications.
Deborah Smith Arthur, J.D., is an Associate Professor in
University Studies at Portland State University (Oregon).
Lori Gruen, Ph.D., is a William Griffin Professor of
Philosophy at Wesleyan University (Connecticut).
Contributors
David Haywood
Matt Abraham
Noah Schultz
Stephan Fowler
Notes//
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
PLENARY
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
PRECARITY LAB
The PreCarity Lab invites a group of artists to
document and interpret the conference. Artists select
a panel of their choice and document their experience
using diverse mediums including drawing, painting,
writing, photography and video. The Trillium Lake Room
will serve as a project space where artists can
complete their creative documentation. Work will be
exhibited throughout the conference in hopes of
cultivating unexpected conversations about precarity
and the conference experience itself. The project is
grounded in the vital role of artists to see and
communicate insights, especially when it comes to
encountering alternative ways of approaching topics
related to precarity.
All conference attendees are welcome to participate.
Please stop by the Trillium Lake Room to make your own
creative interpretation of the conference.
Thursday + Friday // 9:00 AM—6:00 PM
Coordinators: Michelle Swinehart & Merel Visse
Trillium Lake Room
FAMILY PROJECT SPACE
Thursday + Friday // 8:00 AM — 6:30 PM
Newport Room
This learning space, open throughout the
conference, offers guided activities for children
(ages 6 months and older) of parents/guardians
attending workshops. Activities will respond to the
site of the conference, offering a younger
generation the chance to engage in conference
themes. Parents and guardians may participate
with their child(ren).
Before attending the Family Project Space, please
register children in the prefunction area near the
Wahkeena Falls Room on the second floor.
Coordinators
Emma Colburn (
[email protected])
Justine Larson
Melissa McGhie
CONTEMPLATION + REFLECTION
Thursday + Friday // 12:30—1:20 PM
Coordinators: Neera Malhotra & Vicki Reitenauer
Pyramid Lake Room
Facilitated Creative Engagement Practices
12:30—12:55 PM
Thursday // Choose image/object as prompt for
writing and/or art—making inspired by the conference.
Friday // Experiment with embodied practices based
on Theatre of the Oppressed techniques to reflect
collaboratively and silently on our conference experiences.
Facilitated Mindfulness Practice
1:00—1:20 PM
Thursday and Friday // Engage in guided meditation,
breathing techniques, and intentional movements.
All persons of all abilities are welcome to participate
in the Contemplation + Reflection practices.
STORY EXCHANGE
Friday // 10:30 AM—12:00 PM
Pyramid Lake Room
Making Connections through Lived Experience
This session is devoted to sharing personal stories
about precarity. Participants are invited to make
connections with precarity, share first—hand
experiences, and deeply listen to their colleagues.
This session will culminate with exchanging personal
narratives in small groups. We hope to facilitate a
conference experience where empathy and compassion
foster another way of knowing and understanding precarity.
Coordinators
David Peterson del Mar
Michelle Swinehart
Merel Visse
PROMPTS
What personal experiences shaped your understanding or definition of precarity?
Who taught you about precarity?
How does dependency shape your life?
Talk about a time when you received care that changed your life…
How has your work with care affected your life?
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
STORY EXCHANGE
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
SESSION A
10:30 AM—12:00 PM
Thursday // September 27th
Care Ethics, Power, and Institutions
Panel A1
Wahkeena Falls Room
The Heuristic and Creative Aspect of Precarity:
A Challenge to Care Ethics?
Carlo Leget (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
The Precariousness of Subjectivity: Bodies in Relations of Power
Sacha Ghandeharian (Carleton University, ON Canada)
Governing Precarity through Caring Institutions
Petr Urban (The Czech Academy of Sciences, Czech Republic)
Care and Injustice in Advanced Capitalist Societies
Panel A2
Elowah Falls Room
Care as Class Struggle: A Social Reproduction
Theory Perspective on Precarity and Care Ethics
Mary McLevey (University of Oregon)
The Faces of Care Injustice: A Case of South Korea
Hee—Kang Kim (Korea University)
Fostering Response—ability in Precarious Worlds: Toward a
New Feminist Materialist Ethics of Care in Feminist Ethics
Emilie Dionne (McGill University, QC Canada)
Learning and Teaching in Conditions of Precarity
Panel A3
Multnomah Falls Room
Cyberbullying, Female Professors, and Precarity:
Can Care Ethics Impact University Culture?
Wanda Cassidy (Simon Fraser University, BC Canada)
Care in the ‘Contact Zone’: The Precarity of International Learning
Kumari Beck (Simon Fraser University, BC Canada)
The Primacy of Care Ethics for Precarious Times
Heesoon Bai (Simon Fraser University, BC Canada)
Self—Care, Precarity and Aging
Panel A4
Astoria Room
The Precarious Position of Old People:
A Driver of the Wish to Control the Time and Manner of Death
Els van Wijngaarden (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
To Cultivate Emotional Self—Understanding for
Reducing the Sense of Precarity
Marco Ubbiali (University of Verona, Italy)
Federica Valbusa (University of Verona, Italy)
A Right to Care of the Self in the Face of Precarity?
Traci Levy (Adelphi University, New York)
Deborah Little (Adelphi University, New York)
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SESSION A
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
Family, Health and Social Policy
Panel B1
Wahkeena Falls Room
Apology as Care:
Exploring the Impact of Apology Legislation in Health Care
Fiona MacDonald (University of the Fraser Valley, BC Canada)
Feminism, Families and Childcare:
Care Ethics and Canada’s Social Policy Architecture
Rachel Langford (Ryerson University, ON Canada)
Kate Bezanson (Brock University, ON Canada)
Childcare, Gender and Class Inequalities in Argentina:
A Situated Approach to Care Ethics
Eleanor Faur (University of San Martín, Brazil)
Ania Tizziani (National University of General Sarmiento & CONICET
(National Scientific and Technical Research Council), Argentina)
Care, Sustainability and Vulnerability:
Global Considerations
SESSION B
Panel B2
Elowah Falls Room
A Global Vulnerability: Why Care for the Living World?
Elena Pulcini (University of Florence, Italy)
Dialogue Across Difference:
Care Ethics and Precarious Political Ontologies
Maggie FitzGerald Murphy (Carleton University, ON Canada)
Hestia’s Broken Hearth
Kimberley Parzuchowski (University of Oregon)
1:30—3:00 PM
Thursday // September 27th
Fragility, Empathy and the Insights of the Cared—For
Panel B3
Multnomah Falls Room
Precarity and Recursive Care
Caterina Botti (Sapienza University of Rome, Italy)
Vulnerability, Precarity and the Ambivalent Interventions of Care
Vrinda Dalmiya (University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa)
One Bad Apple… or the Perils of Commodification
Monique Lanoix (St. Paul University, ON Canada)
Precarious Students
Panel B4
Elowah Falls Room
‘A Rough Time, A Rough Transition’: Precarious Care Work
within College Students of Color Peer Mentoring Programs
Denise Goerisch (Grand Valley State University, Michigan)
Educational Emancipation:
The Practice of Care at Portland’s Democratic School
Noppawan Lerttharakul (Portland State University, Oregon)
Responding to Student Precarity and Persistence with an Ethic of Care
Robin Isserles (CUNY, Borough Manhattan Community College
of the City University of New York)
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SESSION B
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
SESSION C
3:30—5:00 PM
Thursday // September 27th
Mediated Care: Technologies, Care, and Precarity
Panel C1
Wahkeena Falls Room
Caring Silos as Protection from Precarity: How Mothers in
Online Communities Use Science and Nature to Reduce Insecurity
Darryn Wellstead (University of Ottawa, ON Canada)
Phyllis Rippey (University of Ottawa, ON Canada)
Precarious Maternity: A Care Ethical Perspective
Inge van Nistelrooij (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
Technologies of Care, Technologies of Precarity
Shelley Park (University of Central Florida)
Needs, Striking Workers,
and the Electoral Politics of Caring
Panel C2
Elowah Falls Room
A Precarity of Need Interpretation for Dependency Workers in Japan:
Considered through Nancy Fraser and Eva Feder Kittay
Kari Tsushima (Doshisha University, Japan)
Care Workers on Strike
Hailey Huget (Georgetown University, Washington DC)
Caring Concerns and Political Agenda
Carmen Domínguez—Alcón (University of Barcelona, Spain)
Precarity, Class and Family
Panel C3
Elowah Falls Room
Young Men, Social Disadvantage
and the Development of Caring Masculinities
Martin Robb (The Open University, United Kingdom)
Data from the Field: The Role of Family of
Origin Relationship Quality on Leadership in Business Ethics
Jeanne Enders (Portland State University, Oregon)
Care Workers and Precarity
Panel C4
Astoria Room
The Implications of Client Death for Home Care Workers:
Intersections of Emotional and Financial Precarity
Emily Franzosa
(CUNY, Borough Manhattan Community College of the
City University of New York)
Privileged Irresponsibility and Precarity:
On Epistemic Ignorance and the Outsourcing of Domestic Work
Riikka Prattes (Independent Researcher)
Precarity and Paid Care Around the Globe:
An Empirical Approach to Care Ethics
Amy Armenia (Rollins College, Florida)
Mignon Duffy (University of Massachusetts Lowell)
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SESSION C
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
Relational Perspectives
Panel D1
Wahkeena Falls Room
A Conception of Respect Suitable for Precarious Lives
Cara O’Connor (CUNY, Borough Manhattan Community College of the
City University of New York)
Social Robotics and the Limits of Relational Dignity
Mercer Gary (Pennsylvania State University)
What Precarity Requires of Care
Sarah Clark Miller (Pennsylvania State University)
Empathy, Abandonment and Fragility
Panel D2
Elowah Falls Room
The Fragility and Vulnerability of the Precarious Life
SESSION D
Luigina Mortari (University of Verona, Italy)
On Precarity and Abandonment: A Care Ethical, Artistic Study
Merel Visse (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
Desirable Conversations
Neera Malhotra (Portland State University, Oregon)
8:30—10:00 AM
Friday // September 28th
Empirically Grounded Ethics of Care and Precarity
Panel D3
Multnomah Falls Room
Precarity for all: From Labour Related Uncertainty
to Positional Insecurity and Beyond
Frans Vosman (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
Redoing Care: Return to Decent Life Beyond Bed, Bath and Bread:
The Case of Dutch Sans Papiers
Guus Timmerman (Presence Foundation, Netherlands)
Social Redundancy and Precariousness
Andries Baart (Presence Foundation, Netherlands)
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SESSION D
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
SESSION E
10:30AM—12:00
AM — 12:00
10:30
PMPM
Friday////September
September28th
28
Friday
Care, Neoliberal Labor Markets and Populist Politics
Panel E1
Wahkeena Falls Room
Care Ethics as a Response to the “Neo—Populist” Narrative
of Protectionist Care
Joan Tronto (University of Minnesota)
Thinking through Precarious Japan: Will Politically Heightened
Precarity and Undoing Care Make a Strong Nation?
Yayo Okano (Doshisha University, Japan)
Caring in Careless Times
Brunella Casalini (University of Florence, Italy)
Theorizing Inclusive and Diverse Classrooms
Panel E2
Elowah Falls Room
Toward Radical Inclusion: Employing Care Ethics
in Intellectually Diverse Classrooms
Lydia Fisher (Portland State University, Oregon)
Vicki Reitenauer (Portland State University, Oregon)
Using Queer Praxis to Defend Against the Precarity
of Care Ethics in Classrooms in an Age of Trump
Marilyn Preston (Grand Valley University, Michigan)
Countering Precarity: Working with/in the Human
Dimension in Educational Environments
Avraham Cohen (Adler University, BC Canada)
Jade Ho Yi Chien (Simon Fraser University, BC Canada)
Health and Precarious Communities
Panel E3
Multnomah Falls Room
Care Ethics and Precarious Situations in Hospitals and Nursing Homes
Helen Kohlen (Philosophical—Theological University of Vallendar, Germany)
Balancing between Precarity and Dignity in Public Health:
Fostering New Normative Expressions of Dignity
in the Care for People with Multiple Problems
Alistair Niemeijer (University of Humanistic Studies, Netherlands)
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
SESSION E
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018
What is one moment
or interaction that
you’d like to remember?
What is a snapshot of the
conference that seems
worth writing down?
CARE ETHICS +
PRECARITY
FINAL THOUGHTS
CERC Conference
September 27th + 28th, 2018