ROMANIAN JOURNAL
OF
INTERNAL MEDICINE
Volume 47
No. 3, 2009
CONTENTS
REVIEWS
CORINA LICHIARDOPOL, MARIA MOŢA, The thyroid and autoimmunity .........................................................................
OLGA ORĂŞAN, ANGELA COZMA, N. REDNIC, D. SÂMPELEAN, ANDRADA PÂRVU, L. PETROV, Anemia –
a complication of antiviral treatment in chronic viral hepatitis C .....................................................................................
207
217
ORIGINAL ARTICLES
D. ZDRENGHEA, DANA POP, OANA PENCIU, M. ZDRENGHEA, Drug treatment of heart failure patients in a general
Romanian hospital ............................................................................................................................................................
TOMINA POPESCU, MARIA MOŢA, Dyslipidemia and hypertension in patients with type 2 diabetes and retinopathy ........
D.L. DUMITRAŞCU, TEODORA SURDEA-BLAGA, LILIANA DAVID, Esophageal achalasia – manometric patterns ......
DUMITRA BĂLAN, P.A. BABEŞ, Incidence and type of stroke in patients with diabetes. Comparison between diabetics and
nondiabetics ......................................................................................................................................................................
MARIOARA DANIELA BRAICU, CRISTINA PRIŢULESCU, D. ALEXANDRU, MARIA MOŢA, The assessment of
subclinic atherosclerosis objected through IMT in normal and dyslipidemic patients with various degrees of glucose
tolerance ...........................................................................................................................................................................
INIMIOARA MIHAELA COJOCARU, M. COJOCARU, ADINA NICOLETA POPESCU, L. POPESCU, R. TĂNĂSESCU,
Study of antiphospholipid antibodies in type 2 diabetes mellitus with and without diabetic retinopathy .........................
RUXANDRA MOROTI CONSTANTINESCU, MĂDĂLINA GEORGESCU, A. PASCU, ADRIANA HRISTEA,
VICTORIA ARAMĂ, C. BĂICUŞ, RUXANDRA OANA CĂLIN, EUGENIA KOVACS, Otoacoustic emissions
analysers for monitoring aminoglycosides ototoxicity .....................................................................................................
BOGDANA VÎRGOLICI, IRINA STOIAN, CORINA MUSCUREL, MAGDA MĂRĂCINE, LAURA POPESCU,
C. MORARU, VERONICA DINU, Systemic redox modifications in senile cataract ......................................................
MARILENA GÎLCĂ, IRINA STOIAN, DANIELA LIXANDRU, LAURA GĂMAN, BOGDANA VÎRGOLICI,
V. ATANASIU, Protection of erythrocyte membrane against oxidative damage by Geriforte in healthy human subjects
227
235
243
249
257
267
273
279
289
CASE REPORTS
C. JURCUŢ, CRINA FILIŞAN, CLAUDIA POPOVICI, LIANA TOMA, B. PANAITE, O. NICODIN, I. COPACI, Young
woman with polyserositis, ovarian cystic mass and increased level of CA-125. Case report of peritoneal and pleural
tuberculosis ......................................................................................................................................................................
DIANA ZANFIR, SABINA ZURAC, FLORICA STĂNICEANU, B. ANDREESCU, A. REBOŞAPCĂ, Incidental findings
during ENT routine examination for head and neck trauma ............................................................................................
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 205–306
297
301
206
REVIEWS
The Thyroid and Autoimmunity
CORINA LICHIARDOPOL1, MARIA MO Aβ
1
β
Department of Endocrinology,
Department of Diabetes, University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Craiova, Romania
Autoimmune thyroid diseases (Hashimoto thyroiditis, Graves’ disease, postpartum thyroiditis,
atrophic thyroiditis and drug induced thyroiditis) are prevalent disorders worldwide, especially in
women (related to the millieu of sex steroids and X chromosome effects on the thyroid and the
immune system).
Disruption of thyroid self tolerance, usually induced by an infection, generates abnormal
thyroid – immune interactions, implicating an array of cytokines and their receptors. Thyrocytes
achieve antigen presenting cell properties which stimulate effector immune cells (Th1, Thβ, Th17), in
the context of defective immunomodulatory T regulatory cells, resulting in thyroid lymphocytic
infiltration and activation of B cells, with production of antibodies against thyroid antigens, thyroid
destruction or stimulation, depending on the Th1-Thβ balance.
During pregnancy there is a Thβ predominance sustained by the increased glucocorticoid,
estrogen and progesteron levels, which allows tolerance versus the histoincompatible fetoplacental unit.
In the postpartum period, the return shift Thβ to Th1 favors the occurrence of postpartum thyroiditis.
Altered thyroid hormone levels can influence the immune system, and, on the other side, some
immune cells secrete TSH, which exerts endocrine and paracrine, cytokine-like effects.
Understanding the complex pathogenesis of autoimmune thyroid disorders is crucial for
prevention and management.
Key words: thyroid autoimmunity, Th cells, interleukins, chemokines.
THYROID AUTOIMMUNITY: PREVALENCE
AND CLINICAL SPECTRUM
Autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD), which
affect approximately 5% of the population (with a
larger incidence in women), result from disruption
of self tolerance induced by environmental factors
in genetically susceptible individuals [1], and are
characterized by lymphocytic infiltration of the
thyroid, antibodies against thyroid antigens and
thyroid dysfunction.
The true prevalence of AITD may be higher,
at least in certain areas, since studies showed a
variable percentage of antithyroid antibodies positivity
in disease free populations: 18% in the United
States – NHANES III cohort; [β], 1β.4% in Australia –
The Busselton Thyroid Study [γ], 18.8% in Denmark
[4], 7% in Germany [5].
In the Wickham Survey autoimmune thyroiditis
was identified in 10% of subjects with a 4.γ% annual
rate progression to overt hypothyroidism [6].
The clinical spectrum of autoimmune diseases
encompasses Hashimoto thyroiditis (the most frequent
form), Graves’ disease, postpartum thyroiditis, drugROM. J. INTERN. MED., β009, 47, 3, β07–β15
induced thyroiditis, thyroiditis within polyglandular
autoimmune syndromes and atrophic thyroiditis [7].
Phenotypic expression of thyroid autoimmunity
depends on the pattern of immune response that
predominates at a given time. Abnormal interactions
between thyrocytes and immunocompetent cells
(macrophages, dendritic cells, T cells) as well as
between immune cells generate autoimmunity.
Hashimoto thyroiditis is a typical T-cell-mediated
autoimmune disease, characterized by formation of
tertiary lymphoid follicles within the thyroid
(containing T cells, mainly Th1, and B cells), with
destruction of thyroid follicular cells generating
hypofunction, and the presence of antiTPO and/or
antiTg antibodies in the serum.
Graves’ disease is a Thβ mediated disease
with mild lymphocytic infiltration of the thyroid and
production of antibodies that stimulate TSHR, thus
generating hyperthyroidism. Postpartum thyroiditis
occurs in 5–9% of women due to Thβ to Th1
immune response return shift. Atrophic thyroiditis is
caused by antibodies blocking TSH receptor
(TSHR) [1].
β08
Corina Lichiardopol and Maria Mo a
INITIATION OF THYROID AUTOIMMUNITY
Probably the trigger of thyroid autoimmunity
is represented by infection, the most important
environmental factor. Epstein Barr virus infection
has been associated with many chronic autoimmune
diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus,
rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, Sjögren
syndrome, autoimmune thyroiditis, autoimmune hepatitis,
Kawasaki disease and polymyositis. Infectious
agents reported to trigger AITD include: Yersinia
enterocolitica, Borrelia burgdorferi, Helicobacter
pylori, Escherichia coli, foamy virus, rubella virus,
retroviruses, human T cell leukemia virus 1, hepatitis
B and C viruses, enteroviruses.
There are six mechanisms by which infection
generates autoimmunity:
1. molecular mimicry: the infecting agent contains
an epitope similar to that of a self antigen;
β. epitope spreading; overprocessing and overpresentation of antigens by presenting cells
causes activation of large numbers of T cells with
broad specificities;
γ. polyclonal activation; infection of B cells with B
cell proliferation, enhanced antibody production
and generation of circulating immune complexes
which may damage self tissues;
β
4. bystander activation; enhanced cytokine production
with expansion of autoreactive T cells;
5. binding of infectious superantigens to the
variable domain of the T cell receptor beta
chain and major histocompatibility complex
class β molecules allows binding to a wide
variety of T cells, irrespective of their
specificity and, thus, induces autoimmunity [8].
6. Viruses can induce expression of genes
necessary for antigen presentation in thyroid
cells (Fig. 1); thyrocytes of patients with
Hashimoto thyroiditis express costimulatory
molecules (ICAM, B7-1), increased MHC class I
molecules, CXCL-10 (a chemokine ligand that
exerts chemotactic activity on lymphoid cells),
Fas which interacts with Fas ligand on other
thyrocytes surface inducing apoptosis, and toll
like receptor γ (surface receptor usually present
on dendritic cells, critical for the development of
antigen specific adaptive immunity, both
hormonal and cell mediated) which activates
NF-k and interferon regulatory factor γ (IRF-γ)
pathways and production of TNFα and
interferon , respectively. ARN viruses activate
IRF-γ causing, also, aberrant expression of
MHC class II on thyrocytes along with other
molecules implicated in antigen presentation [9].
Fig. 1. – Initiation of thyroid autoimmunity.
γ
β09
The thyroid and autoimmunity
The lack of infections has also detrimental
effects by diluting the capacity of the immune
system to avoid autoimmune responses [10].
Production of thyroid autoantibodies precedes
the development of clinical AITD and is also an
epiphenomenon secondary to the release of thyroid
antigens by thyrocytes undergoing either stimulation
or apoptosis [11].
CD40 is a member of the TNF-R receptor
family expressed mainly on B cells and antigen
presenting cells, implicated in B cell proliferation
and antibody secretion.Fig. 1.
Enhanced CD40 expression in thyroid follicular
cells induces antigen presenting properties by
overexpression of IL-6 and expression of MHC class
II molecules [1β].
Thyroid autoantigens are represented by TSH
receptor, thyroid peroxidase (TPO), thyroglobulin,
sodium/iodide symporter and pendrin. TPO and
pendrin are expressed at the apical pole of the
thyrocyte and are not accessible to circulating immune
cells (cryptic antigens). It is generally accepted that a
cryptic antigen, once exposed, activates immune cells
better than dominant antigens [1γ].
Anti Tg antibodies do not fix complement but
ATPO antibodies (especially IgG1 subclass) damage
thyroid cells, once follicular structure has been
disrupted, by antibody dependent cell cytotoxicity
(ADCC) and complement mediated cytotoxicity.
Moreover, ATPO can damage the thyroid by
ADCC when associated with monocytes, the
process being triggered by FC RI (CDγβ) and
FC RII (CD64) expressed on monocytes [14].
IMMUNE CELLS
Initiation of thyroid autoimmunity is poorly
understood. An early event is represented by an
increased appearance of intrathyroidal antigen
presenting cells (APC) which take up and present
thyroid autoantigens along with MHC class II
molecules and costimulatory molecules to T helper
cells [15].
Dendritic cells secrete IL-1β, IL-βγ, IL-6 and
TGF 1. There is a polarization of macrophages: a
M1 polarization when stimulated by IFN , LPS and
GM-GSF, increasing antibacterial proinflammatory
and antiangiogenic functions, and a Mβ polarization
under the influence of IL-10, IL-4, IL-1γ (proangiogenic). M1 macrophages produce IL-1β, IL-βγ,
IL-6, TNFα and low levels of IL-10 while Mβ
macrophages produce IL-10 and low levels of IL-6
and TNFα [16].
Effector Th cells evolve from naive CD4+ T
cells (CD4 is a cell surface glycoprotein that acts as
a coreceptor for the T cell receptor) stimulated by
APC with a distinct TCR engagement (CD80/86
proteins on APC surface bind CDβ8 on T cell
surface) (Fig. β).
Fig. β. – Interactions between immune cells; differentiation of effector T cells.
β10
Corina Lichiardopol and Maria Mo a
Th cells polarization dictates the type of
immune response:
1. Th1 cells develop under the influence of IL-1β
and secrete IL-β, TNF and IFN providing
immunity against intracellular pathogens by
macrophage activation, cell mediated immunity
and phagocyte-dependent protective responses.
Th1 responses induce B cells to produce IgG1
and IgGγ (IgG1 are complement fixing and
opsonizing Ab).
β. Thβ cells develop under the influence of IL-4,
secrete IL-4, IL-5, IL-1γ assuring immunity against
extracellular pathogens by antibody production
(mainly IgE and IgG4), eosinophil activation,
inhibition of several macrophage functions
(phagocyte independent protective response).
Th1 and Thβ cells do not represent distinct cell
lineages, but extreme polarized forms; Th1
response, when it becomes dangerous, can be
shifted to a less polarized profile – Th0 or even
Thβ – process called immune deviation.
γ. Th17 cells appear as a result of TGF action in
the presence of IL-6 (IL-βγ promoting their
maintenance) and assure host defense against
bacteria and fungi. Th17 cells produce IL-17
with proinflammatory effects by induction of
proinflammatory cytokines (IL-6, TNFα) and
chemokines (KC, MCP-1 and MCP-β) and
also, proliferation, maturation and chemotaxis
of neutrophils, that mediate tissue infiltration
and destruction. Autoreactive Th17 cells have
an important role in autoimmunity.
4. Tregs are a heterogeneous family of T cells
which inhibit autoimmunity and protect against
tissue injury. Self tolerance is maintained
through clonal deletion, clonal anergy, normal
level of lymphogenesis and activation induced
cell death [17].
The primary mechanism leading to self
tolerance is recessive tolerance induced by thymic
deletion of autoreactive cells, but, even in healthy
individuals, some of them escape, and intervention
of another mechanism – peripheral dominant tolerance,
mediated by iTregs, is required [18].
Tregs are classified in naturally occurring
Tregs, CD4+ CDβ5+ FOXPγ+ cells (nTregs),
which mature early within the thymus and act
cytokine – independently by cell to cell contact and
induced or adaptive Tregs (iTregs), which are
generated in the periphery from mature T cells in
4
response to particular antigenic stimulation,
concomitant with dominant CTLA-4 engagement
and a certain cytokine milieu. Adaptive Tregs are
more efficient than nTregs in suppressing antigen
specific effector cell responses; although hyporesponsive in term of proliferation, they are activated
upon specific suboptimal antigen stimulation to
produce IL-10 and TGF , which suppress effector
T cell function. There are several subsets of iTregs
[19]:TR1, Thγ cells, CD8+ cells, NK Tcells, δ
Tcells, CD4-CD8-Tcells.
In the case of a microbial infection nTregs
class convert to Th17 cells [β0], when stimulated
with IL-6, with subsequent neutrophil mobilization
and proinflammatory effects; later appearing TGF
induced Tregs terminate antigen specific response
and prevent the emergence of nonspecifically
stimulated or cross reactive self reactive Tcells.
Tregs decrease CD80/86 expression on dendritic
cells, inhibit dendritic cell accumulation and
maturation in the spleen and lymph nodes, and
suppress Th1 immune response [19].
Also, Tregs suppress immune response by
preferential consumption of IL-β (which stimulates
proliferation of T cells), induction of effector T cell
apoptosis via CDγ0/CDγ0L interactions or perforin/
granzyme B, production of immuno-suppressive
cytokines such as IL-10 and TGF and production
of immunosuppressive metabolites as a result of
upregulation of indoleamine-β, γ-dioxygenase (IDO)
in dendritic cells [β1].
In patients with autoimmune thyroid disease
different Tregs subsets are detected in the
peripheral blood and in the thyroid; in peripheral
blood there is an increased number of CD4+
lymphocytes expressing GITR (glucocorticoid inducible
TNF receptor), FOXPγ, IL-10, TGF and CD69
while the thyroid infiltrate contains an increased
number of CD69+, CDβ5+, GITR+ cells with
moderate FOXPγ expression.
However, the suppressive function of these
Tregs seems to be defective and they are not able to
modify the clinical course of inflammation; GITR
ligand from the inflamed thyroid binds GITR on
Tregs and acts as a costimulatory molecule,
favoring their proliferation but inhibits their
regulatory activity. On the other side, effector
T cells may be resistant to Tregs, a phenomenon
that could be related to defects in intracellular
signaling [ββ][βγ].
5
β11
The thyroid and autoimmunity
PROGRESSION OF AUTOIMMUNE PROCESS
Once the tolerance to thyroid antigens is
broken, endothelial cells of regional postcapillary
venulae are activated, allowing the extravasation of
blood leucocytes attracted by chemokines. The
recruitment and arrest of lymphocytes in the thyroid
is only partially understood. Immune cells adhere to
the endothelium, then migrate across it, then through
the interstitium and move toward thyroid follicular
cells, sometimes organizing into germinal centers,
resembling lymph node germinal centers. In autoimmune
thyroid diseases there is an enhanced expression of
adhesion molecules (selectins and integrins) on
lymphocytes and endothelial cells (lymphocyte
function associated antigen 1-LFA1, interstitial cell
adhesion molecule 1-ICAM 1, very late antigen 4-VLA4)
as well as selectin ligands.
CXC chemokines are secreted by thyrocytes
stimulated by TNFα, IFN and IL1β; CXCL10,
CXCL9 are responsible for recruitment of activated
lymphocytes in the thyroid. CXCL10 promotes
differentiation of Th0 cells into Th1 cells, while
CCLβ- the differentiation of Th0 cells into Thβ
cells. CXCL10 binding to CXCRγA generates an
angiostatic effect, while binding to CXCRγB exerts
chemotactic and immune effects. CXCRγ is
expressed on immune cells (T cells, especially Th1,
B cells, NK cells), vascular pericytes, microvascular
endothelial cells. Immune cells expressing CXCRγ
are attracted in the inflamed thyroid.
Th1 cells secrete IFN , which stimulates
production of chemokines by thyroid follicular
cells, thus maintaining and expanding the autoimmune process [β4].
Predominance of Th1 a immune response
promotes thyrocytes apoptosis [β5] mediated by Fas
and TRAIL (TNF – related apoptosis inducing ligand),
leading to Hashimoto thyroiditis. Predominance of a
Thβ immune response induces antigen-specific B cells
to produce antithyroid antibodies; stimulatory antiTSH
receptor antibodies are responsible for Graves’
disease and blocking antiTSH receptor antibodies
are responsible for atrophic thyroiditis. Thus, the
clinical expression of thyroid autoimmunity depends
on the Th1-Thβ balance [15].
In Hashimoto thyroiditis hypothyroidism is
not only the result of thyrocytes destruction, but
also of the thyroid function impairment induced by
Th1 cytokines.
IL-1 and IFN down regulate the expression
of TG, TPO, Na/I symporter and HβOβ generating
enzymes (DUOX), effects partially mediated by
nitric oxide and antagonized by increased TSH
concentrations. IL-4, a Thβ cytokine, blocks Th1
induced alterations in DUOX, TPO and Tg
secretion. Thγ cytokines-TGF and IL-10-repress
thyrocytes function but their effects can also be
overturned by Thβ cytokines [βγ].
PREGNANCY AND THYROIDITIS
During pregnancy there is a physiologic shift
of Th1 to Thβ immune responses aimed to avoid
rejection of the histoincompatible fetoplacental unit
by a maternal cell-mediated immune attack. The
increase of glucocorticoids, estrogen and progesterone
levels suppresses cell mediated immunity and
enhances humoral immunity, explaining the
remission of Th1 mediated diseases (rheumatoid
arthritis, multiple sclerosis, type 1 diabetes and
autoimmune thyroiditis) and aggravation of Thβ
mediated diseases (systemic lupus erythematosus).
During the postpartum period, abrupt decrease of
glucocorticoids, estrogens and progesterone to
subnormal levels allows the “return shift” of Thβ to
Th1 immune response favoring the occurrence of
Th1 mediated diseases such as postpartum
thyroiditis [15].
INTERFERON INDUCED THYROIDITIS
Autoimmune thyroid diseases appear in 15%
of interferon α treated patients (75–80% Hashimoto
thyroiditis and β0–β5% Graves’ disease). Interferon α
induces a transient increase in Th1 response but,
also, an increased production of Thβ cytokines. Thβ
activation is higher in patients with interferon induced
thyroiditis who remain euthyroid, whereas in
patients with thyroid dysfunction there is a
decreased Thβ response and an increased Th1
response. The innate response is crucial in
determining whether an autoimmune reaction will
occur; a type 1 bias of NK and NKT cells was
demonstrated in experimental models of autoimmune
diabetes and encephalomyelitis.
In interferon treated patients both type 1 and
type β activation of peripheral NK and NKT CD56cells was found, type 1 occurring in patients with
or without thyroid dysfunction and type β in
patients who remained euthyroid. Type 1 activation
of CD56+ cells was earlier than that observed in
CD4+ cells, but it is not capable alone to induce
β1β
Corina Lichiardopol and Maria Mo a
destruction of the thyroid; by contrast, the type 1
activation of CD4+ and CD8+ cells is critical [β7].
Type I interferons (α and ) activate interferon
regulatory factors and upregulate TLRγ in nonimmune
cells in an autocrine/ paracrine manner [9].
IMMUNE REGULATION OF THE THYROID AXIS
TSH is produced by splenic dendritic cells,
bone marrow CD11b+ monocytes/ macrophages
and granulocyte precursors, intestinal epithelial
cells from subvillus crypt regions, T cells, B cells.
This extrapituitary TSH may act on immune
cells either directly, as a cytokine like regulatory
molecule or indirectly, by secretion of thyroid
hormones.
TSH has been shown to stimulate antibody
production, lymphocytes proliferation, NK cells
activity, phagocytic stimuli, secretion of TNFα by
CD11b- bone marrow cells. Thyroid hormones
influence the functional or developmental activity of
cells in bone marrow and secondary lymphoid tissues.
In euthyroid sick syndrome (a basic host
mechanism aimed to conserve energy during
fasting, sepsis, trauma, acute severe diseases, bone
marrow transplantation) a failure in T4 to Tγ
conversion occurs. Proinflammatory cytokines
IL-1, IL-6 and TNFα decrease TSH level. An
increased conversion of T4 to Tγ within the
tanicytes of the third ventricle generates a localized
Tγ feedback mechanism that suppresses TRH and
TSH. In the recovery phase, the immune system is
responsible for increasing thyroid hormone output;
bone marrow CD11b+ cells, which secrete TSH,
migrate into the thyroid and operate in a paracrine
manner [β8]. Whether this TSH-producing immune
cells with potential to traffick into the thyroid play
a role in thyroid autoimmunity is not known.
THYROID DYSFUNCTION AND THE IMMUNE
SYSTEM
Thyroid hormones are not essential for the
development of the immune system but are involved
in the maintenance of immune homeostasis.
Hypothyroidism decreases thymic activity,
causes spleen and lymph nodes involution and thus,
represses both cell mediated and humoral immune
responses. In hyperthyroidism both stimulatory and
suppressing effects on the immune system have
been described.
6
It was demonstrated that thyroid hormones
modulate lymphocytic activity through protein
kinase C signaling pathway [1].
GENDER AND AUTOIMMUNE THYROID
DISEASES
It is well known that autoimmune thyroid
diseases are more prevalent in females and this
phenomenon was initially ascribed to hormonal
differences, since autoimmune thyroid disease are
rare prepubertally; estrogens exacerbate and
androgens inhibit immune responses.
Gonadotropin-releasing hormone and sex
steroids are strongly implicated in the development
and function of the immune system.
GnRH and its type I receptor are both
expressed in primary lymphoid organs and
peripheral immune cells and exacerbate autoimmune
diseases, independent of gonadal steroids, by
increasing the number of Th cells, the level of
interferon gamma, the number of IL-β receptors
with proliferation and activation of T and B cells.
Receptors for estrogens and androgens are
expressed in primary lymphoid organs and are
implicated in immune cell development in the
thymus (negative regulators of different immune
cells subsets), and bone marrow. There is a gender
difference in immune responsiveness.
Peripheral T and B cells possess only
estrogen receptors which are responsible for the
increased number of Th cells and autoantibody
production. Although androgen receptors were not
documented in peripheral T and B cells, androgens
have suppressor effects by increasing the number
of suppressor T cells and decreasing the number of
B cells [β9].
Autoimmune thyroid disease appearance after
menopause suggests that X chromosome may be more
important than estrogens [β0]. A potential mechanism
is skewed X-chromosome inactivation, a pattern where
80% or more of the cells inactivate the same X-chromosome. Thus, self antigens on one X-chromosome are
insufficiently expressed in the thymus and in peripheral
sites involved in tolerance induction, but may yet be
highly expressed in peripheral tissues and blood cells.
Recently it was demonstrated that skewed XCI is
associated with an increased risk of developing AITD
with an odds ratio of 9 (1.64–49.4) [γ1].
Another mechanism important for the pathogenesis
of AITD may be represented by haplo-insufficiency
7
β1γ
The thyroid and autoimmunity
of X linked genes consequent to chromosome
instability, generating a high rate of monosomy X in
the peripheral white blood cells [γ0].
The increased prevalence of AITD in patients
with Turner syndrome (hypoestrogenic state) stands
also for haploinsufficiency of X chromosome genes
implicated in thyroid function (TBG-codes for
thyroglobulin, MCT8-codes for a thyroid hormone
transporter into cells, MNG2-related to susceptibility
to multinodular goiter, GRDX-related to susceptibility
to Graves’ disease) or in the immune response
(FOXP3-essential for the development of self
tolerance, genes coding for many interleukin
receptors, factors that stimulate lymphocytes
proliferation and production of immunoglobulins,
CD40 ligand – a glycoprotein expressed on T
cells and epithelial cells which stimulates B
cell proliferation, adhesion and differentiation)
(www.pubmed.gov/OMIM).
CHRONIC THYROIDITIS AND HEPATITIS C
VIRUS INFECTION
According to WHO data, the highest prevalence
of HCV hepatitis in Europe is registered in
Romania (4.56%), so a special attention should be
paid to the association between HCV infection and
chronic thyroiditis.
AITD (ORţ1.6) and hypothyroidism (ORţβ.9)
are more prevalent in HCV positive patients than in
HBV infected patients or healthy controls. Also
epidemiologic studies showed an association
between HCV infection and thyroid cancer that
needs to be confirmed [γβ].
The high prevalence of AITD in HCV
infection is independent of alpha-interferon
therapy, which suggests the role of HCV in
breakdown of immune tolerance and emphasizes
the necessity of screening all AITD patients for
HCV and, also, monitoring all HCV infected
patients for AITD [γγ].
It was recently shown that HCV envelope
glycoprotein Eβ can bind to thyroid CD81
receptors leading to IL-8 release without inducing
thyrocytes apoptosis, thus triggering thyroiditis in
genetically susceptible individuals by a bystander
activation mechanism [γ4].
CONCLUSIONS
Thyroid autoimmunity results from an
imbalance in Th1-Thβ immune responses, usually
triggered by infections in genetically susceptible
individuals.
Predominance of the Th1 phenotype induces
cell-mediated thyrocytes’ apoptosis with subsequent
Hashimoto thyroiditis or postpartum thyroiditis.
On the contrary, predominance of the Thβ
phenotype induces production of antibodies against
the TSH receptor either stimulatory causing
Graves’ disease or inhibitory, causing atrophic
thyroiditis.
Autoimmune thyroid diseases may also be
drug induced (interferon induced thyroiditis).
This spectrum of thyroid autoimmunity
reflects the complexity of immune-thyroid
interactions, and clarifying their pathogenic roles
will allow a better clinical management of thyroid
autoimmune diseases.
Bolile tiroidiene autoimune (tiroidita Hashimoto, boala Graves, tiroidita
postpartum, atrofică şi medicamentoasă) sunt frecvent întâlnite, în special la femei
(legat de efectele steroizilor sexuali şi a cromozomului X asupra tiroidei şi
sistemului imun). Pierderea toleranţei faţă de antigenele tiroidiene, de obicei
indusă de o infecţie, generează interacţiuni anormale cu sistemul imun, ce implică
numeroase citokine şi receptorii lor. Tirocitele dobândesc proprietăţi de
prezentare a antigenului, stimulează celulele imune efectoare (Th1, Th2, Th17) în
contextul deficienţei celulelor T reglatoare, determinând infiltrare limfocitară
tiroidiană, activarea celulelor B cu producere de anticorpi antitiroidieni,
distrugere sau stimulare tiroidiană, în funcţie de balanţa Th1-Th2. În timpul
sarcinii, datorită creşterii glucocorticoizilor, estrogenilor şi progesteronului,
predomină răspunsul imun Th2, asigurând toleranţa faţă de unitatea
fetoplacentară. După naştere, restabilirea Th1 favorizează apariţia tiroiditei
postpartum. Nivelul hormonilor tiroidieni influenţează activitatea sistemului imun,
β14
Corina Lichiardopol and Maria Mo a
8
iar pe de altă parte, unele celule imune secretă TSH, ce acţionează endocrin,
paracrin şi asemănător citokinelor. Descifrarea patogeniei complexe a bolilor
autoimune tiroidiene este deosebit de importantă pentru profilaxia şi managementul
acestora.
Corresponding author: Corina Lichiardopol, MD
Department of Endocrinology, University of Medicine and Pharmacy,
4, Petru Rares, Craiova, Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
1.
β.
γ.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
1β.
1γ.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
β0.
β1.
KLECHA, A.J., BARREIRO ARCOS, M.L., FRICK, L., GENARO, A.M., CREMASCHI, G., Immune-endocrine interactions
in autoimmune thyroid diseases. Neuroimmunomodulation, β008, 15, 68–75.
HOLLOWELL, J.G., STAEHLING, N.W., FLANDERS, W.D., HANNON, W.H., GUNTER et al., Serum TSH, T(4), and
thyroid antibodies in the United States population (1988 to 1994): National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey
(NHANES III). J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β00β, 87, 489–499.
O'LEARY, P.C., FEDDEMA, P.H., MICHELANGELI, V.P., LEEDMAN, P.J., CHEW, G.T. et al., Investigations of thyroid
hormones and antibodies based on a community health survey: the Busselton thyroid study. Clin. Endocrinol. (Oxf), β006, 64,
97–104.
PEDERSEN, I.B., KNUDSEN, N., JORGENSEN, T., PERRILD, H., OVESEN, L., LAURBERG, P., Thyroid peroxidase and
thyroglobulin autoantibodies in a large survey of populations with mild and moderate iodine deficiency. Clin. Endocrinol.
(Oxf), β00γ, 58, γ6–4β.
VOLZKE, H., LUDEMANN, J., ROBINSON, D.M., SPIEKER, K.W., SCHWAHN, C. et al., The prevalence of undiagnosed
thyroid disorders in a previously iodine-deficient area. Thyroid, β00γ, 13, 80γ–810.
VANDERPUMP, M.P., TUNBRIDGE, W.M., FRENCH, J.M., APPLETON, D., BATES, D. et al., The incidence of thyroid
disorders in the community: a twenty-year follow-up of the Whickham Survey. Clin. Endocrinol. (Oxf), 1995, 43, 55–68.
DUNTAS, L.H., Environmental factors and autoimmune thyroiditis. Nat. Clin. Pract. Endocrinol. Metab., β008, 4, 454–460.
SHOENFELD, Y., ZANDMAN-GODDARD, G., STOJANOVICH, L., CUTOLO, M., AMITAL, H. et al., The mosaic of
autoimmunity: hormonal and environmental factors involved in autoimmune diseases – 2008. Isr. Med. Assoc. J., β008, 10, 8–1β.
HARII, N., LEWIS, C.J., VASKO, V., MCCALL, K., AVIDES-PERALTA, U. et al., Thyrocytes express a functional toll-like
receptor 3: overexpression can be induced by viral infection and reversed by phenylmethimazole and is associated with
Hashimoto's autoimmune thyroiditis. Mol. Endocrinol., β005, 19, 1βγ1–1β50.
DAVIES, T.F., Infection and autoimmune thyroid disease. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β008, 93, 674–676.
BAN, Y., GREENBERG, D.A., DAVIES, T.F., JACOBSON, E., CONCEPCION, E., TOMER, Y., Linkage analysis of thyroid
antibody production: evidence for shared susceptibility to clinical autoimmune thyroid disease. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab.,
β008, 93, γ589–γ596.
TOMER, Y., CONCEPCION, E., GREENBERG, D.A., A C/T single-nucleotide polymorphism in the region of the CD40 gene
is associated with Graves’ disease. Thyroid., β00β, 12, 11β9–11γ5.
YOSHIDA, A., HISATOME, I., TANIGUCHI, S., SHIRAYOSHI, Y., YAMAMOTO, Y. et al., Pendrin is a novel autoantigen
recognized by patients with autoimmune thyroid diseases. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β009, 94, 44β–448.
REBUFFAT, S.A., NGUYEN, B., ROBERT, B., CASTEX, F., PERALDI-ROUX, S., Antithyroperoxidase antibody-dependent
cytotoxicity in autoimmune thyroid disease. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β008, 93, 9β9–9γ4.
TSATSOULIS, A., The role of stress in the clinical expression of thyroid autoimmunity. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., β006, 1088,
γ8β–γ95.
DACE, D.S., KHAN, A.A., KELLY, J., APTE, R.S., Interleukin-10 promotes pathological angiogenesis by regulating
macrophage response to hypoxia during development. PLoS. ONE., β008, 3, eγγ81.
LIU, Y., ZHENG, P., FoxPγ, A Life beyond Regulatory T Cells. Int. J. Clin. Exp. Pathol., β009, 2, β05–β10.
DEJACO, C., DUFTNER, C., GRUBECK-LOEBENSTEIN, B., SCHIRMER, M., Imbalance of regulatory T cells in human
autoimmune diseases. Immunology, β006, 117, β89–γ00.
ZHENG, S.G., The Critical Role of TGF-beta1 in the Development of Induced Foxp3+ Regulatory T Cells. Int. J. Clin. Exp.
Med., β008, 1, 19β–β0β.
KORN, T., MITSDOERFFER, M., CROXFORD, A.L., AWASTHI, A., DARDALHON, V.A. et al., IL-6 controls Th17
immunity in vivo by inhibiting the conversion of conventional T cells into Foxp3+ regulatory T cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.
A., β008, 105, 18460–18465.
VAN DER VLIET H.J.J., NIEUWENHUIS, E.E., IPEX as a result of mutations in FOXP3. Clin. Dev. Immunol., β007, 2007,
89017.
9
The thyroid and autoimmunity
β15
ββ. MARAZUELA, M., GARCIA-LOPEZ, M.A., FIGUEROA-VEGA, N., DE LA, F.H., VARADO-SANCHEZ, B. et al.,
Regulatory T cells in human autoimmune thyroid disease. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β006, 91, γ6γ9–γ646.
βγ. MCLACHLAN, S.M., NAGAYAMA, Y., PICHURIN, P.N., MIZUTORI, Y., CHEN, C.R. et al., The link between Graves’
disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis: a role for regulatory T cells. Endocrinology, β007, 148, 57β4–57γγ.
β4. ROTONDI, M., CHIOVATO, L., ROMAGNANI, S., SERIO, M., ROMAGNANI, P., Role of chemokines in endocrine
autoimmune diseases. Endocr. Rev., β007, 28, 49β–5β0.
β5. CORONA, G., BIAGINI, C., ROTONDI, M., BONAMANO, A., CREMONINI, N. et al., Correlation between, clinical,
biochemical, color Doppler ultrasound thyroid parameters, and CXCL-10 in autoimmune thyroid diseases. Endocr. J., β008, 55,
γ45–γ50.
β6. PONCIN, S., LENGELE, B., COLIN, I.M., GERARD, A.C., Differential interactions between Th1/Th2, Th1/Th3, and Th2/Th3
cytokines in the regulation of thyroperoxidase and dual oxidase expression, and of thyroglobulin secretion in thyrocytes in vitro.
Endocrinology, β008, 149, 15γ4–154β.
β7. MAZZIOTTI, G., SORVILLO, F., PISCOPO, M., MORISCO, F., CIOFFI, M. et al., Innate and acquired immune system in
patients developing interferon-alpha-related autoimmune thyroiditis: a prospective study. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β005, 90,
41γ8–4144.
β8. KLEIN, J.R., The immune system as a regulator of thyroid hormone activity. Exp. Biol. Med. (Maywood.), β006, 231, ββ9–βγ6.
β9. TANRIVERDI, F., SILVEIRA, L.F., MACCOLL, G.S., BOULOUX, P.M., The hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis: immune
function and autoimmunity. J. Endocrinol., β00γ, 176, β9γ–γ04.
γ0. GUARNERI, F., BENVENGA, S., Environmental factors and genetic background that interact to cause autoimmune thyroid
disease. Curr. Opin. Endocrinol. Diabetes Obes., β007, 14, γ98–409.
γ1. BRIX, T.H., KNUDSEN, G.P., KRISTIANSEN, M., KYVIK, K.O. et al., High frequency of skewed X-chromosome
inactivation in females with autoimmune thyroid disease: a possible explanation for the female predisposition to thyroid
autoimmunity. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., β005, 90, 5949–595γ.
γβ. ANTONELLI A., FERRY C., FALLAHI P., FERRARI S.M., GHINOI A. et al., Thyroid disorders in chronic hepatitis C virus
infection. Thyroid, β006, 16(6), 56γ–7β.
γγ. TESTA A., CASTALDI P., FANT V., FIORE G.F., GRIECO V. et al., Prevalence of HCV antibodies in autoimmune thyroid
disease. Eur. Rev. Med. Pharmacol. Sci., β006, 10(4), 18γ–6.
γ4. AKENO N., BLACKARD J.T., TOMER Y., HCV E2 protein binds directly to thyroid cells and induces IL-8 production: a new
mechanism for HCV induced thyroid autoimmunity. J. Autoimmun., β008, 31(4), γγ9–44.
Received May 10, β009
β16
Corina Lichiardopol and Maria Mo a
10
Anemia – A Complication of Antiviral Treatment in Chronic Viral Hepatitis C
OLGAăăOR ŞAN1,ăăANGELAăăCOZMA1,ăăN.ăREDNIC1,ăăD.ăSÂMPELEAN1,ăăANDRADAăăPÂRVU2,ăăL.ăPETROV2ă
1ă
4thăMedicalăClinic,ăUniversityăofăMedicineăandăPharmacy,ăCluj-Napoca,ăRomaniaă
HematologyăClinic,ăUniversityăofăMedicineăandăPharmacy,ăCluj-Napoca,ăRomaniaă
2ă
Anemiaă isă ană importantă andă frequentă secondaryă effectă ofă theă treatmentă withă pegylatedă
interferonă andă ribavirină ină patientsă withă chronică virală Că hepatitis.ă Ribavirină producesă moreă oftenă
hemolytică anemia,ă whileă pegylatedă interferonă mayă determineă medullaryă suppression.ă Theă levelă ofă
hemoglobină beneathă 10ă g/dLăisă consideredă byă mostă authorsă asă beingă theă referenceă levelă foră anemiaă
secondaryătoătheăantiviralătreatment.ăBeneathăthisăhemoglobinăvalueăităisărecommendedătoăreduceăorătoă
stopă theă treatmentă withă ribavirin,ă toă administeră recombinantă humană erythropoietină oră bloodă
transfusion,ăbasedăonătheăseverityăofătheăanemia.ăă
Theăgrowthărateăofătheăserumăerythropoietinăinătheăfirstăfewăweeksăofătreatmentăisăcorrelatedăwithă
theănecessityăofădecreasingătheădosesăorăevenătoăstopătheătreatmentăwithăribavirin.ăTheăSVRă(sustainedă
viralăresponse)ărateăofătheăpatientsăisăreducedăwhenătheăribavirinădosesăareăreducedădueătoăanemia.ă
Key words: hepatitis,ăCăvirusăinfection,ăanemia.
HepatitisăCăvirusă(HCV)ăinfectionăisăaămajoră
causeăofăchronicăhepaticădiseaseăaffectingă170ămillionă
peopleăthroughoutătheăworld.ăChronicăHCVăinfectionă
causesăprogressiveăhepaticăfibrosisăandăcirrhosisăină
20%ăofăpatients,ăandă10–20%ăofăpatientsăwithăcirrhosisă
developăhepatocarcinomaăwithină5ăyearsă[1–4].ă
Theăgoldăstandardăinătheătreatmentăofăchronică
virală hepatitisă Că isă pegylatedă interferonă alphaă 2aă
(Pegasysă–ăHoffmannălaăRoche)ăorăpegylatedăinterferonă
alphaă2bă(Pegintronă–ăScheringăPlough)ăandăribavirină
(Copegusă–ăHoffmannălaăRoche,ăRebetolă–ăScheringă
Plough,ă respectively).ă Combinedă treatmentă increasesă
theă efficacyă ofă therapy,ă i.e.ă ită increasesă theă rateă ofă
sustainedăviralăresponseă(SVR)ăcomparedătoăpegylatedă
interferonă monotherapy.ă Theă combinedă pegylatedă
interferonă andă ribavirină antivirală treatmentă isă
superioră toă standardă interferonă treatmentă oră standardă
interferonă andă ribavirină treatment,ă SVRă beingă
obtainedăină54–56%ăofăpatientsă[1–6].ă
Antivirală treatmentă hasă numerousă adverseă
effects;ăităcausesăanemia,ăneutropenia,ăandăthrombocytopeniaăinăparticular.ăAnemiaăisăassociatedăwithăaă
decreaseăinătheăqualityăofălife,ăwithătheăneedăforătheă
reductionăofăribavirinădosesăorăevenătheăcessationăofă
treatment,ăwhichămostăfrequentlyăresultsăinăaăweakeră
responseătoăantiviralătreatmentă[1].ă
Anemiaă isă veryă commonă ină patientsă withă
chronică virală hepatitisă Că underă antivirală treatment.ă
Aăretrospectiveăstudyăonă677ăpatientsăshowsăthatăină
ROM.ăJ.ăINTERN.ăMED.,ă2009,ă47,ă3,ă217–225ă
56%ă ofă patients,ă Hbă decreasedă byă 3ă g/dL,ă ină 10%ă
Hbăhavingăvaluesăofălessăthană10ăg/dLă[7].ă
Anemiaă ină patientsă withă virală hepatitisă Că
treatedăwithăpegylatedăinterferon/ribavirinăhasăseverală
causes:ăhemolyticăanemia,ăperniciousăanemia,ăaplastică
anemiaă secondaryă toă ribavirină treatment;ă pegylatedă
interferon-inducedă boneă marrowă suppressionă andă
chronică posthemorrhagică anemia,ă secondaryă toă
nutritională deficits,ă areă presentă ină variableă degreesă
inăallăchronicădiseasesă[8].ă
Hemoglobină (Hb)ă concentrationsă decreasedă
toălessăthană12ăg/dLă(meanădecreaseă=ă3.7ăg/dL)ăină
52%ăofăpatientsăwhoăreceivedăcombinedăpegylatedă
interferonăalphaă2aăandăribavirinătherapy,ăandădoseă
reductionăwasărequiredăină22%ăofăpatientsă[8][9].ă
DEFINITION OF ANEMIA IN PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC VIRAL HEPATITIS C TREATED WITH
PEGYLATED INTERFERON AND RIBAVIRIN
Ină1968,ătheăWorldăHealthăOrganizationă(WHO)ă
setă theă loweră limită ofă theă normală hemoglobină (Hb)ă
valueăată12ăg/dLăforăwomenăandă13ăg/dLăforămen.ăTheă
NationalăCancerăInstituteă(NCI)ăandăCommonăToxicityă
Criteriaă foră Adverseă Eventsă (CTCAE)ă defineă anemiaă
ofăfirstădegreeăofăseverityăasăHbălevelsăbetweenă10ăg/dLă
andă theă loweră limită foră menă andă womenă [8][10].ă
ThisăHbăvalueăwasăconsideredăasătheăreferenceăforă
theăestablishmentăofăclinicallyăsignificantăanemiaăină
clinicalătrialsăusingăribavirină[8][11].ă
218ă
ă
OlgaăOr şanăet al.ă
PATHOGENIC MECHANISMS INVOLVED IN
ANEMIA IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC VIRAL
HEPATITIS C TREATED WITH PEGYLATED
INTERFERON AND RIBAVIRIN
ANEMIAăăINăăPATIENTSăăWITHăăCHRONICăăVIRALăă
HEPATITISăăCă
Anemiaăsecondaryătoăchronicădiseasesăisăalsoă
foundă ină patientsă withă chronică virală hepatitisă C.ă
Thisă hasă aă complexă etiologyă includingă deficientă
ironăuse,ăaăreducedădegreeăofăhemolysis,ăaădecreasedă
lifeă durationă ofă erythrocytes,ă lowă erythropoietină
secretion,ă alongă withă aă reducedă tissueă responseă toă
erythropoietin.ă Theseă mechanismsă areă consideredă toă
beădueătoătheăinflammatoryăactionăofăcytokines,ăwhichă
amongă otheră effectsă increaseă hepcidină productionă
[12].ă Hepcidină preventsă ironă fromă leavingă theă cellsă
andă tendsă toă increaseă intracellulară ironă levels,ă whichă
inhibitsă erythropoietină productionă [13].ă Ină addition,ă
ironă boundă toă hepcidină isă moreă difficultă toă useă forăă
Hbăsynthesisă[8].ă
Aplasticăanemiaăisărarelyăfoundă(approximatelyă
2%)ăinăchronicăhepatitisăCăvirusăinfection.ăOnlyă0.3–
0.5%ă ofă aplastică anemiaă casesă occură followingă virală
hepatitis,ăusuallyăaăhepatitisăCăvirusăinfection.ăSeverală
peculiaritiesă areă described:ă mostă ofă theă patientsă areă
youngămen;ătheăsignsăofăboneămarrowăaplasiaăappeară
aboută 2ă monthsă afterătheă acuteă episode;ăprognosisăisă
generallyă unfavorable.ă 25%ă ofă patientsă withă aplastică
anemiaăhaveăfunctionalăhepaticăalterationsăatătheătimeă
ofă diagnosisă (subclinicală infections).ă Theă alterationsă
ofă theă hepatică functionă referă toă aă decreaseă ină theă
numberăofăTălymphocytes,ăanăincreaseăinătheănumberă
ofă Tă suppressoră lymphocytesă resultingă ină gammainterferonăproductionăwhichădepressesăhematopoiesis.ă
ANEMIAăăSECONDARYăăTOăăRIBAVIRINăăTREATMENTăă
INăăPATIENTSăăWITHăăCHRONICăăVIRALăăHEPATITISăăCă
Hemolytică anemiaă inducedă byă ribavirină
treatmentă isă knownă toă beă theă mostă importantă
adverseăeffectăofăantiviralătreatmentăinăpatientsăwithă
chronicăviralăhepatitisăCă[15–18].ă
Ribavirină entersă theă erythrocytesă withă theă helpă
ofă aă nucleosideă transporteră andă isă initiallyă convertedă
toăribavirinămonophosphate,ăsubsequentlyătoăribavirină
diphosphateă andă triphosphate.ă Theă accumulationăă
ofă ribavirină phosphatesă alongă withă theă relativeă
adenosineă triphosphateă deficiencyă increasesă theă
susceptibilityă toă oxidativeă processes,ă causingă ană
increaseă ină cellulară toxicityă andă subsequentlyă
extravascularăhemolysisă[8][16].ă
ă
2ă
Theăincreaseăinăironă(Fe)ădepositsăinătheăliveră
isăknownăinăhemolysis.ăHemolysisădueătoăribavirină
treatmentăisăaccompaniedăbyăFeăstorageăinătheăliver,ă
approximatelyă 1500ă µg/year.ă Theă ironă storedă afteră
6–12ă monthsă ofă ribavirină treatmentă mayă causeă theă
developmentă ofă hepatică fibrosis.ă Ferritină levelsă doă
notăsignificantlyăchangeăinătheseăpatientsă[19].ă
Someă patientsă developă symptomsă ofă anemia,ă
includingă fatigue,ă superficială breathing,ă palpitations,ă
cephalea.ă Theă suddenă decreaseă ină hemoglobină cană
precipitateă anginaă pectorisă ină susceptibleă patients.ă
Deathsăfromăacuteămyocardialăinfarctionăandăcerebrovascularăaccidentsăhaveăbeenăreportedăinăpatientsăwithă
chronică hepatitisă Că receivingă combinedă therapy.ă
Ribavirinăshouldănotăbeăadministeredătoăpatientsăwithă
preexistingă anemiaă andă coronaryă diseasesă oră
cerebrovascularădiseases.ăRibavirinăisăeliminatedăfromă
theă organismă byă theă kidneys.ă Patientsă withă renală
diseasesă cană developă severeă life-threateningă
hemolysis.ăPatientsăwithăcreatinineălevelsăhigherăthană
2ăm/dLă(whichărevealsărenalădysfunction)ăshouldănotă
beătreatedăwithăribavirin.ăInătheăcaseăofătheseăpatientsă
withăhepatitisăCăwhoăneedătreatment,ămonotherapyăisă
recommendedă[8].ă
Ribavirină causesă hemolysisă dependingă onă theă
administeredă dosesă [16][20].ă Theă decreaseă ină Hbă
startsă betweenă theă firstă andă theă fourthă weeksă ofă
therapyă andă mayă beă sudden.ă Hemolytică anemiaă isă
reversibleăapproximatelyă4–8ăweeksăafterătheăcessationă
ofă treatmentă [7].ă Ită improvesă withă theă reductionă ofă
dosesă (10–15%ă ofă patients)/cessationă ofă treatment/ă
discontinuousătreatment.ăErythropoietinăalphaăisăusefulă
inăpatientsăwithăprogressiveăanemia,ătheămajorăbenefită
beingătheămaintenanceăofăribavirinădosesă[21–23].ă
Tsubotaăandăco-workersăreportedăanăincreaseăină
plasmaă ribavirină levelsă betweenă weeksă 4ă andă 14ă ofă
treatmentă [24].ă Theă SVRă rateă wasă higheră inăpatientsă
withă aă higheră serumă ribavirină concentration.ă Dueăă
toă theă factă thată theă determinationă ofă ribavirină
concentrationsă isă expensive,ă ită isă notă cost-effectiveă
forăallăpatients.ăInăcontrast,ăHbădeterminationăisăeasyă
toăperform,ărapidăandăinexpensive;ăso,ătheăuseăofăthisă
parameterăasăaăprognosticăfactorăforătheădevelopmentă
ofăanemiaăbyăitsărepeatedădeterminationăeveryă2ăweeksă
becomesăextremelyăimportantă[27].ăă
Inăaăstudyăofă2001ăonă244ăpatientsăchronicallyă
infectedă withă hepatitisă Că virusă (Devineă EBă et al.),ă
threeă factorsă thată significantlyă influenceă ribavirininducedă hemolysisă areă described:ă theă pretreatmentă
thrombocyteăcountă(P–0.01),ătheăadministeredăinterferonă
alphaădoseă(P–0.001)ăandătheăhaptoglobinăphenotypeă
(P–0.01).ăPatientsăwhoăhaveăstartedătreatmentăwithăaă
3ă
lowerăthrombocyteăcountăhaveăaămoreămarkedădecreaseă
ofă Hbă levels.ă Interferonă alpha,ă whichă isă myelosuppressiveă ină highă doses,ă alsoă contributesă toă theă
developmentăofăanemia.ăTheăthirdăfactorăisăhaptoglobin,ă
whichă hasă threeă phenotypes.ă Haptoglobină bindsă toă
erythrocytes,ăandăthereăareădifferencesăbetweenătheă
threeă phenotypesă regardingă theiră bindingă properties.ă
Theă presentedă studyă suggestsă thată ribavirină uptakeă
differsădependingăonătheăhaptoglobinăphenotypeă[25].ă
Ină2004,ăNomuraăH.ăandăco-workersăconsideredă
femaleă sex,ă ageă >ă 60ă years,ă aă ribavirină dose/bodyă
weightă>ă12ămg/kg,ătheăpretreatmentăHbăvalue,ăaăHbă
decreaseă ată 2ă weeksă ofă treatmentă byă >ă 2ă g/dLă asă
predictiveăfactorsăforătheădevelopmentăofăanemiaă[27].ă
AdvancedăageăandătheăpretreatmentăHbăvalueă
areă independentă factorsă associatedă withă theă
importantă decreaseă ină Hbă levelsă duringă theă courseă
ofătreatmentă[25–27].ă
Recently,ă ribavirină clearanceă (Tableă I)ă hasă
beenă usedă asă aă predictiveă factoră foră ribavirininducedăhemolyticăanemiaă[28–30].ă
Table I
Definitionăofăribavirinăclearance [17]ă
ă
CL/F (L/h) = 32.3×G ×(1 – 0.0094×age)×(1 – 0.42×sex)/ Scr
Gă–ăweightă(kg)ă
Scră–ăserumăcreatinineă
ă
Naokiă Hiramitsuă andă co-workersă establishedă
CL/Fă<ă15ăasăaăreferenceălevelăforătheăcessationăofă
ribavirină treatment,ă becauseă ită wasă foundă thată ată
thisăvalue,ă6%ăofăpatientsăhadăHbălevelsălowerăthană
8.5ă g/dL,ă aă valueă ată whichă treatmentă shouldă beă
stopped.ă Noă patientă withă CL/Fă >ă 15ă presentedă Hbă
valuesălowerăthană8.5ăg/dL.ăTheămeanăHbădecreaseă
isă moreă sensitiveă ină theă evaluationă ofă theă riskă ofă
discontinuousătreatmentăthanăCL/F.ăTheăassessmentă
ofă anemiaă everyă 2ă weeksă ină patientsă withă CL/Fă <ă
15ăisătheămostăsensitiveămodalityăforătheăevaluationă
ofătheăprogressionăofăanemiaă[20].ă
ANEMIAăăSECONDARYăăTOăăINTERFERONăă
TREATMENTăăINăăPATIENTSăăWITHăăCHRONICăăVIRALăă
HEPATITISăăCă
Theăliteratureădescribesărareăcasesăofăperniciousă
anemiaă secondaryă toă longă durationă interferonă
therapyă [31],ă bută interferonă causesă boneă marrowă
suppressionă withă theă decreaseă ofă Hbă concentrations,ă
neutropeniaă andă thrombocytopeniaă [6][10][32].ă
ă
219
AnemiaăandăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCă
Deficientă erythropoietină productionă alsoă contributesă
toătheăpathophysiologyăofăanemiaă[33],ăFig.ă1.ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
Fig.ă1.ă–ăSideăeffectsăofăinterferonăduringătheăfirstă12ăweeksăofă
treatmentă(upătoădatedă2004).ă
SERUM ERYTHROPOIETIN AND ANEMIA IN
PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC VIRAL HEPATITIS C
TREATED WITH PEGYLATED INTERFERON AND
RIBAVIRIN
Erythropoietină isă ană endogenousă hormoneă
thatăcausesăanăincreaseăinătheănumberăofăprogenitoră
cellsăofătheăerythrocyticăseriesăinătheăblood-formingă
marrowă[34].ă
TheădiminutionăofătheăHbălevelăisăphysiologicallyă
accompaniedă byă ană increaseă ină theă serumă erythropoietinălevel,ăwhichăsubsequentlyănormalizesătheăHbă
levelă[35].ăTheăHbă–ăserumăerythropoietinărelationshipă
isă lessă obviousă ină patientsă withă chronică disordersă
(suchă asă neoplasiasă [36],ă humană immunodeficiencyă
virusă (HIV)ă infectionă [37])ă thană ină patientsă withă
chronicăVHCăunderăcombinedăantiviralătreatment.ă
Ină theă studyă ofă Balană V.ă andă co-workers,ă
serumă erythropoietină levelsă increasedă duringă theă
firstă 8ă weeksă ofă treatmentă ină allă theă monitoredă
groupsă ofă patients:ă patientsă whoă completedă theă
studyă withoută requiringă ribavirină doseă reduction,ă
patientsă whoă hadă ribavirină doseă reductionă duringă
theă8ăweeksăofăstudy,ăandăpatientsăwhoăinterruptedă
treatmentă beforeă theă completionă ofă theă study.ă Theă
greatestă increaseă wasă foundă ină patientsă whoă
receivedă treatmentă foră 8ă weeksă andă whoă neededă
ribavirinădoseăreductionă[33],ăFig.ă2.ă
Inăpatientsăwhoăcompletedă8ăweeksăofăcombinedă
antivirală treatmentă requiringă theă adjustmentă ofă
ribavirină doses,ă theă meană ribavirină doseă reductionă
wasă225ămg/dayăatătheăendăofătheăstudy.ăTheămeană
220ă
ă
OlgaăOr şanăet al.ă
4ă
Fig.ă 2.ă –ă Meană serumă erythropoietină studiedă
weeklyă duringă theă firstă 8ă weeksă ofă treatmentă
withă pegylatedă interferonă andă ribavirin.ă SEMă
ăăăăăăăăăăăăstandardăerrorăofătheămeană[33].ă
ribavirină doseă remainedă relativelyă constantă duringă
theă firstă threeă weeksă ină patientsă whoă interruptedă
treatmentăatăanăearlyăstageă[33].ă
Aă tendencyă ofă meană Hbă toă decreaseă andă ofă
meană serumă erythropoietină toă increaseă isă notedă
untilă weeksă 5–6ă ofă treatment,ă afteră whichă theiră
levelsăbecomeărelativelyăconstant.
Theă erythropoietică responseă ină patientsă withă
HCVăinfectionăseemsălowăcomparedătoăpatientsăwithă
ironă deficiencyă anemiaă andă cancer,ă ironă deficiencyă
anemiaă andă HIVă infection,ă respectivelyă [36][37].ă
Foră theă sameă Hbă decrease,ă theă increaseă ină serumă
erythropoietină wasă lessă markedă ină patientsă withă
HCVătreatedăwithăpegylatedăinterferonăandăribavirină
comparedătoăpatientsăwithăironădeficiencyăanemia.ă
Theă resultsă ofă recentă clinicală trialsă showă thată
anemiaă ină HCVă infectedă patientsă respondsă toă
recombinantă humană erythropoietină (erythropoietină
alpha)ă treatmentă [21][23].ă Itsă earlyă administrationă
preventsă theă reductionă ofă ribavirină doses,ă maintainsă
highăHbălevelsăandăimprovesătheăqualityăofălifeă[33].ă
EFFECT OF ANEMIA AND OF THE REDUCTION
OF PEGYLATED INTERFERON/RIBAVIRIN DOSES
ON VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE IN PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC VIRAL HEPATITIS C
Theă HCVă genotypeă andă viremiaă areă
importantă predictorsă foră theă sustainedă virologicală
responseăalongăwithăotherăfactorsăsuchăasăage,ăsex,ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
race,ăhepaticăhistologicalăchangesăandătransaminaseă
levelsă[38–42].ă
Recentă studiesă suggestă thată highă serumă
ribavirină levelsă causeă ană increaseă ină theă SVRă rate.ă
However,ă theă increaseă ofă ribavirină dosesă shouldă
alsoă takeă intoă accountă theă adverseă effectsă ofă
therapy.ă Theă lowă Hbă levelă ată theă onsetă ofă therapyă
andătheăhighăserumăribavirinălevelăareăpredictorsăofă
anemiaă ină patientsă treatedă withă ribavirină [38][43–
45].ă22%ăofătheăpatientsărequiredătheăadjustmentăofă
ribavirinădosesădueătoăanemiaă[6].ă
Theăprobabilityăofăanemiaăincreasesădependingă
onătheăribavirinădoseăusedă(particularlyăinătheăcaseăofă
dosesă higheră thană 15ă mg/kg)ă ină patientsă treatedă
withă pegylatedă interferonă alphaă 2aă andă ribavirin,ă
whileă theă obtainingă ofă theă SVRă dependingă onă theă
ribavirină doseă usedă isă influencedă byă theă HCVă
genotype.ă Lowă ribavirină dosesă (800ă mg/day)ă areă
sufficientă toă obtaină SVRă ină patientsă withă HCVă
genotypesă2ăandă3.ăHCVăgenotypeă1ărequiresătheăuseăofă
theă standardă ribavirină doseă (1000ă oră 1200ă mg/day)ă
withă ană increasedă riskă foră theă developmentă ofă
anemiaă[38],ăFig.ă3.ă
Viremiaă ată theă onsetă ofă treatment,ă age,ă
baselineă ALATă levels,ă theă ribavirină dose/kgă bodyă
weight,ă cirrhotică statusă andă ribavirină clearanceă
influenceă theă sustainedă virologicală response,ă whileă
theă probabilityă ofă appearanceă ofă anemiaă isă
influencedă byă sex,ă theă ribavirină dose/kgă bodyă
weight,ă baselineă hemoglobină levels,ă age,ă baselineă
ALATălevelsăandăcirrhoticăstatusă[38],ăFig.ă4. ă
5ă
AnemiaăandăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCă
221
Fig.ă3.ă–ăMeanăprobabilityăofăobtainingăSVRăinăpatientsăwithăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCăgenotypeă1ătreatedăforă48ăweeksădependingăonă
theăprognosticăfactorsăofăSVRă(confidenceăintervală95%)ă[38].ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
Fig.ă4.ă–ăMeanăprobabilityăofăanemiaăinăpatientsăwithăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCăgenotypeă1ătreatedăforă48ăweeksădependingăonătheă
prognosticăfactorsăofăanemiaă(confidenceăintervală95%)ă[38].ă
ă
222ă
ă
OlgaăOr şanăet al.ă
TREATMENT OF ANEMIA IN PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC VIRAL HEPATITIS C TREATED WITH
PEGYLATED INTERFERON AND RIBAVIRIN
Theă treatmentă ofă anemiaă ină patientsă withă
chronică hepatitisă Că virusă infectionă treatedă withă
combinedă antivirală therapyă consistsă ofă ribavirină
doseă reduction/cessationă ofă ribavirină treatment,ă
administrationă ofă recombinantă humană erythropoietină
orătransfusion.ă
A.ăREDUCTION/CESSATIONăăOFăăRIBAVIRINăă
TREATMENTă
Theă specifică recommendationsă ină theă caseă ofă
anemiaă occurringă afteră treatmentă areă asă follows:ă theă
ribavirinădoseăshouldăbeădiminishedătoă600ămilligramsă
peră dayă (200ă milligramsă ină theă morningă andăă
400ă milligramsă ină theă evening),ă ină anyă ofă theă
followingă cases:ă 1)ă patientă withoută aă significantă
cardiovasculară disease,ă showingă aă decreaseă ină
hemoglobinăvaluesăofăupătoă<ă10ăg/dLăandă>ă8.5ăg/dLă
oră 2)ă patientă withă aă stableă cardiovasculară disorder,ă
showingă duringă anyă 4ă weekă periodă ofă treatmentă aă
decreaseă ină hemoglobină valuesă >ă 2ă g/dL.ă Ină theseă
cases,ă theă readministrationă ofă theă initială doseă isă notă
recommended.ă
Theă administrationă ofă ribavirină shouldă beă
interruptedăinăanyăofătheăfollowingăcases:ă1)ăpatientă
withoutăaăsignificantăcardiovascularădiseaseăpresentingă
aă confirmedă decreaseă ină hemoglobină valuesă toăă
<ă 8.5ă g/dL;ă2)ă patientă withă aă stableă cardiovasculară
disease,ăwithăhemoglobinăvaluesă<ă12ăg/dL,ăinăspiteă
ofădoseăreductionăforă4ăweeks.ă
Ifăanemiaăremits,ătheăadministrationăofăribavirină
canăbeăreinitiatedăinăaădoseăofă600ămilligramsăperăday,ă
whichăcanăbeăsubsequentlyăincreasedătoă800ămilligramsă
perăday,ădependingăonătheătherapist’sădecision.ăInătheseă
cases,ă theă readministrationă ofă theă initială doseă isă notă
recommendedă[46–48].ă
B.ăRECOMBINANTăăHUMANăăERYTHROPOIETINă
Erythropoietinăalphaăisăaărecombinantăhumană
erythropoietică growthă factor.ă Itsă administrationă
stimulatesă erythrocyteă productionă andă increasesă
hemoglobinăconcentration.ăAăsignificantăincreaseăină
hemoglobină isă foundă afteră 2ă weeks,ă sometimesă upă
toă6ăweeksăofătreatment,ăbecauseătheămaturationăofă
erythroidă progenitorsă andă theiră releaseă intoă
circulationătakesătimeă[8][50].ă
Antivirală treatmentă ină patientsă withă chronică
hepatitisăCăvirusăinfectionăsignificantlyăchangesătheă
ă
6ă
qualityă ofă lifeă [51][52].ă Theă useă ofă erythropoietină
alphaăincreasesătreatmentăcomplianceăandăimprovesă
theăqualityăofălifeă[8][49].ă
Erythropoietină alphaă isă indicatedă ină patientsă
withă aă significantă decreaseă ină hemoglobină levelsă
duringă theă firstă weeksă ofă ribavirină treatment.ă Ină thisă
case,ătwoăstrategiesăcanăbeăused:ăeitherăaăconservativeă
approachă oră aă prophylactică one.ă Ină theă conservativeă
approach,ă patientsă areă carefullyă monitoredă andă
erythropoietină treatmentă isă indicatedă whenă hemoglobină
levelsădecreaseătoălessăthană10ăg/dL.ăErythropoietină
isă administeredă prophylacticallyă toă patientsă withă aă
significantăcardiovascularăriskă[8].ăă
C.ăINDICATIONSăăOFăăTRANSFUSIONă
Transfusionă isă rarelyă necessaryă ină patientsă
withă chronică virală hepatitisă Că underă antivirală
treatment.ăForă aă longătimeă transfusionă wasă indicatedă
ată aă Hbă valueă ofă 10ă g/dLă (Hematocrită –ă Htă 30%).ă
However,ă dueă toă theă risksă ofă transfusionă ină theseă
patientsă (transmissionă ofă infectionsă –ă e.g.ă HIV;ă
adverseă immuneă reactionsă toă transfusion)ă alongă
withă theă risk/benefită ratio,ă transfusionă isă
recommendedă ată Hbă valuesă rangingă betweenă 7ă andăă
10ăg/dL:ă7ăg/dLăinăpatientsăwithoutăotherăcomorbiditiesă
(myocardială oră cerebrală ischemia,ă hemorrhage)ă [54].ă
Accordingă toă NCIă andă CTCAE,ă transfusionă isă
indicatedăatăHbăvaluesălowerăthană8ăg/dLă[53].
CONCLUSIONS
Anemiaăisăaăfrequentăandăredoubtableăadverseă
reactionă ofă pegylatedă interferonă andă ribavirină
treatmentă ină patientsă withă chronică virală hepatitisă C.ă
Ribavirinăcausesăhemolyticăanemiaăinăparticular,ăandă
pegylatedăinterferonăinducesăboneămarrowăsuppression.ă
Aă Hbă valueă loweră thană 10ă g/dLă isă consideredă byă
mostăauthorsăasătheăreferenceăforăanemiaăsecondaryă
toăantiviralătreatment.ăBelowăthisăhemoglobinăvalue,ă
theăreductionăorăcessationăofăribavirinătreatment,ătheă
administrationăofărecombinantăhumanăerythropoietină
oră transfusionă areă recommendedă dependingă onă theă
severityăofăanemia.ă
Theă rateă ofă increaseă ofă serumă erythropoietină
duringă theă firstă weeksă ofă treatmentă isă correlatedă
withătheăneedăforăribavirinădoseăreduction/cessationă
ofă ribavirină treatment.ă Theă SVRă rateă isă loweră ină
patientsă who,ă dueă toă anemia,ă receiveă reducedă
ribavirinădoses.ă
7ă
AnemiaăandăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCă
223
Anemia este o reacţie adversă redutabilă şi frecventă a tratamentului cu
pegilatinterferon şi ribavirină la pacienţii cu hepatită cronică virală C. Ribavirina
produce îndeosebi anemie hemolitică iar pegilatinterferonul induce supresie
medulară. Valoarea hemoglobinei sub 10 g/dL este considerată de cei mai mulţi
autori ca fiind de referinţă pentru anemia secundară tratamentului antiviral. Sub
această valoare a hemoglobinei se recomandă reducerea sau întreruperea
tratamentului cu ribavirină, administrarea eritropoetinei umane recombinate sau
tranfuzia în funcţie de gravitatea anemiei.
Rata creşterii eritropoetinei serice în primele săptămâni de tratament se corelează
cu necesitatea scăderii dozelor/ întreruperii tratamentului cu ribavirină. Rata RVS
(răspuns viral susţinut) este mai mică la pacienţii la care datorită anemiei se reduc
dozele de ribavirină.
ă
ă
ă
Corresponding author: OlgaăOr şană
4thăMedicalăClinic,ăă
18,ăRepubliciiăStr.,ăCluj-Napoca,ăRomâniaă
E-mail:
[email protected]ă
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
ă
CHAO-HUNGăH.,ăCHUAN-MOăL.,ăSHENG-NANăL.ăet al.,ăAnemia associated with antiviral therapy in chronic hepatitis C:
incidence, risk factors, and impact on treatment response.ăLiverăInternational,ă2006,ă26,ă1079–1086.ă
SEEFă L.B.,ă BUSKELL-BALESă Z.,ă WRIGHTă E.C.ă et al.,ă Longterm mortality after transfusion-associated non-A,non-B
hepatitis.ăTheăNatl.ăHeart,ăLung,ăBloodăInst.ăStudyăGroup,ăN.ăEngl.ăJ.ăMed.,ă1992, 327,ă1906–11.ă
NIEDERAUăC.,ăLANGEăS.,ăHEINGTESăT.ăet al.,ăPrognosis of chronic hepatitis C: results of a large, prospective cohort study.ă
Hepatology,ă1998,ă28,ă1687–95.ă
CHIARAMONTEă M.,ă STROFFOLOINIă T.,ă VIANă A.ă et al.,ă Rate of incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with
compensated viral cirrhosis.ăCancer,ă1999,ă85,ă2132–7.ă
MANNSăM.P.,ăMcHUTCHINSONăJ.G.,ăGORDONăS.C.ăet al.,ăPeginterferon alfa-2b plus ribavirin compared with interferon
alfa- 2b plus ribavirin for initial treatment of chronic hepatitis C: a randomised trial.ăLancet,ă2001,ă358,ă958–65.ă
FRIEDă M.W.,ă SHIFFMANă M.L.,ă REDDYă K.R.ă et al.,ă Peginterferon alfa- 2a plus ribavirin for chronic hepatitis C virus
infection.ăN.ăEngl.ăJ.ăMed.,ă2002,ă347,ă975–82.ă
SULKOWSKIăM.S.,ăWASSERMANăR.,ăBROOKSăL.,ăBALLăL.,ăGISHăR.,ăChanges in haemoglobin during interferon alpha2b plus ribavirin combination therapy for chronic hepatitis C virus infection.ăJ,ăViralăHepat.,ă2004,ă11:243–50.ă
McHUTCHINSONă J.G.,ă MANNSă M.P.,ă andă LONGOă D.L.,ă Definition and management of anemia in patients infected with
hepatitis C virus.ăLiverăInternational,ă2006,ă26,ă389–398.ă
Pegasysă(peginterferonalfa-2a)ă[packageinsert].ăNutley,ăN.J.ăHoffmann-LaăRocheăInc.,ă2004.ă
NATIONALă INSTITUTEă OFă HEALTHă CONSENSUSă DEVELOPMENTă CONFERENCEă STATEMENT.ă Management of
hepatitis C,ă2002–Juneă10–12,ă2002,ăHepatology,ă2002,ă36(Suppl.1),ăS3–20.ă
Rebetolă(ribavirinăUSP)ăcapsulesăandăoralăsolutionă[packageinsert].ăKenilworth,ăN.J.ăScheringăCorporation,ă2004.ă
GANZăT.,ăHepcidin in iron metabolism.ăCurr.ăOpin.ăHematol.,ă2004,ă11,ă251–4.ă
SPIVAKăJ.L., Iron and the anemia of chronic disease.ăOncologyă(Huntingt),ă2002, 16,ă25–33.ă
GRIGORIUăG.,ăTratat de Medicină Internă, Hematologie, parteaăI,ă1997.
BODENHEIMERă H.C.J.,ă LINDSAYă K.L.,ă DAVISă G.L.ă et al.,ă Tolerance and efficacy of oral ribavirin treatment of chronic
hepatitis C: a multicenter trial.ăHepatology,ă1997,ă26,ă473–7.ă
DeFRANESCHIă L.,ă FATTOVICHă G.,ă TURRINIă F.ă et al.,ă Hemolytic anemia induced by ribavirin therapy in patients with
chronic hepatitis C virus infection: role of membrane oxidative damage.ăHepatology,ă2000,ă31,ă997–1004.ă
VanVLIERBERGHăH.,ăDELANGHEăJ.R.,ăDeVOSăM.,ăLEROUX-ROELăG.,ăFactors influencing ribavirin-induced hemolysis.ă
J.ăHepatol.,ă2001,ă34,ă911–16.ă
TAPPEROăG.,ăBALLAREăM.,ăFARINAăM.,ăNEGROăF.,ăSevere anemia following combined alpha-interferon/ribavirin therapy
of chronic hepatitis C.ăJ.ăHepatol.,ă1998,ă29,ă1033–4,ă14–171.
BISCEGLIEă A.M.,ă BACONă B.R.,ă KLEINERă D.E.,ă HOOFNAGLEă J.H.,ă Increase in hepatic iron stores following prolonged
therapy with ribavirin in patients with chronic hepatitis C.ăJ.ăHepatol.,ă1994ăDec.,ă21(6),ă1109–12.ă
HIRAMITSUăN.,ăKURASHIGEăN.,ăOZEăT.ăet al.,ăEarly decline of hemoglobin can predict progression of hemolytic anemia
during pegylated interferon and ribavirin combination therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis C.ăHepatologyăResearch,ă2008,ă
38,ă52–59.ă
224ă
ă
OlgaăOr şanăet al.ă
8ă
21. AFDHALă N.H.,ă DIETRICHă D.T.,ă POCKROSă P.J.ă et al.,ă Epoetin alfa maintains ribavirin dose in HCV-infected patients: a
prospective, double-blind, randomized controlled study.ăGastroenterology,ă2004,ă126,ă1302–11.ă
22. POCKROSăP.J.,ăSHIFFMANăM.L.,ăSCHIFFăE.R.ăet al.,ăEpoetinalfa improves quality of life in anemic HCV-infected patients
receiving combination therapy.ăHepatology,ă2004,ă40,ă1450–8.ă
23. DIETRICHăD.T.,ăWASSERMANăR.,ăBRAUăN.ăet al.,ăOnce-weekly epoetin alfa improves anemia and facilitates maintenance
of ribavirin dosing in hepatitis C virus-infected patients receiving ribavirin plus interferon alfa. Am.ăJ.ăGastroenterol.,ă2003,ă98,ă
2491–9.ăă
24. TSUBOTAă A.,ă AKUTAă N.,ă SUZUKIă F.ă et al.,ă Viral dynamics and pharmacokinetics in combined interferon alfa-2b and
ribavirin therapy for patients infected with hepatitis C virus of genotype 1b and high pretreatment viral load.ă Intervirology,ă
2002,ă45,ă33–42.ă
25. DEVINEă E.B., KOWDLEYă K.V.,ă VEENSTRAă D.L.ă et al., Interferon alfa-induced pernicious anemia in chronic hepatitis C
infection. J.ăViralăHepat., 2001,ă8,ă287–292.
26. TAKAKIă S.,ă TSUBOTAă A.,ă HOSAKAă T.ă et al.,ă Factors contributing to ribavirin dose reduction due to anemia during
interferon alfa 2b and ribavirin combination therapy for chronic hepatitis C.ăJ.ăGastroenterol.,ă2004,ă39,ă668–73.ă
27. NOMURAă H.,ă TANIMOTOă H.,ă KAJIWARAă E.ă et al.,ă Factors contributing to ribavirin induced anemia.ă J.ă Gastroenterol.ă
Hepatol.,ă2004,ă19,ă1312–7.ă
28. JENă J.F.,ă GLUEă P.,ă GUPTAă S.,ă ZAMBASă D.,ă HAJIANă G.,ă Population pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic analysis of
ribavirin in patients with chronic hepatitis C.ăTher.ăDrugăMonit.,ă2000,ă22,ă555–65.ă
29. KAMARăN.,ăCHATELUTăE.,ăMANOLISăE.,ăLAFONTăT.,ăIZOPETăJ.,ăROSTAINGăL.,ăRibavirin pharmacokinetics in renal
and liver transplant patients: evidence that it depends on renal function.ăAm.ăJ.ăKidneyăDis.,ă2004,ă43,ă140–6.ă
30. KARINOăY.,ăKATOăT.,ăARAKAWAăT.ăet al.,ăTotal clearance (CL/F) of ribavirin is the factor most influencing the incidence
of hemolytic anemia during IFN plus ribavirin therapy.ăHepatology,ă2004,ă40ă(Suppl1),ă358.
31. BORGAă G.,ă REYNAUDă L.,ă GENTILEă I.,ă BORELLIă F.,ă CERINIă R.,ă CIAMPIă R.ă et al.,ă Journal of Interferon & Cytokine
Research. Januaryă1,ă2003,ă23(1),ă11–12.ăă
32. FRIEDăM.W.ăSide effects of therapy of hepatitis C and their management.ăHepatology,ă2002,ă36(Suppl.1),ăS237–44.ă
33. BALANă V.,ă SCHWARZă D.,ă WUă G.Y.ă et al.,ă Erythropoietic response to anemia in chronic hepatitis C patients receiving
combination pegylated interferon/ribavirin.ă Am.ă J.ă Gastroenterol.,ă 2005,ă 100,ă 299–307.SPIVAKă J.L.,ă The blood in systemic
disorders.ăLancet, 2000,ă355,ă1707–12.ă
35. BAROSIăG.,ăInadequate erythropoietin response to anemia. Definition and clinical relevance.ăAnn.ăHematol.,ă1994,ă68,ă215–23.ă
36. MILLERăC.B.,ăJONESăR.J.,ăPIANTADOSIăS.ăet al.,ăDecreased erythropoietin response in patients with the anemia of cancer.ă
N.ăEngl.ăJ.ăMed.,ă1990,ă322,ă1689–92.ă
37. SPIVAKăJ.L.,ăBARNESăD.C.,ăFUCHSăE.ăet al.,ăSerum immunoreactive erythropoietin in HIV-infected patients.ăJAMA,ă1989,ă
261,ă3104–7.ă
38. ERICă S.,ă JANETă R.W.,ă FRANKă D. et al., Predicting sustained virological response and anaemia in chronic hepatitis C
patients treated with peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) plus ribavirin.ăBritishăJournalăofăClinicalăPharmacology,ăVolumeă62,ăIssueă6,ă
p.ă699–709.ă
39. BERGăT.,ăSARRAZINăC.,ăHERMANNăE.,ăHINRICHSENăH.,ăGERLACHăT.ăet al.,ăPrediction of treatment outcome in patients
with chronic hepatitis C: significance of baseline parameters and viral dynamics during therapy. Hepatology,ă2003ăMar.,ă37(3),ă
600–9.ă
40. LEEăS.S.,ăReview article: indicators and predictors of response to anti-viral therapy in chronic hepatitis C.ăAlimentăPharmacol.ă
Ther.,ă2003,ă17,ă611–21.ăă
41. ZEUZEMă S., Heterogeneous virologic response rates to interferon-based therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis C: who
responds less well?ăAnn.ăIntern.ăMed.,ă2004,ă140,ă370–81.ăă
42. FOSTERăG.R.,ăFRIEDăM.W.,ăHADZIYANNISăS.J.,ăCHANNEACăM.,Treatment of chronic hepatitis C with peginterferon alfa2a (40KD) (PEGASYS (R) and ribavirin (COPEGUS (R): patient age has a marked influence on the individual estimated
probability of achieving a sustained virological response.ăHepatology,ă2003,ă38ă(Suppl.ă1),ă246A.ăă
43. JENăJ.,ăLAUGHLINăM.,ăCHUNGăC.,ăHEFTăS.,ăAFFRIMEăM.B.,ăGUPTAăS.K.,ăGLUEăP.,ăHAJJANăG.,ă Ribavirin dosing in
chronic hepatitis C: application of population pharmacokinetic–pharmacodynamic models.ă Clin.ă Pharmacol.ă Ther.,ă 2002,ă 72,ă
349–61.ăă
44. LINDALHăK.,ăSCHWARCZăR.,ăBRUCKHFELDăA.,ăSTAHLEăL.,ă Evidence that plasma concentration rather than dose per
kilogram body weight predicts ribavirin-induced anaemia.ăJ.ăViral.ăHepatol.,ă2004,ă11,ă84–7.ăă
45. LINDALHă K.,ă STAHLERă L.,ă BRUCHFELDă A.,ă SCHWARCZă R.,ă High-dose ribavirin in combination with standard dose
peginterferon for treatment of patients with chronic hepatitis C.ă Hepatology,ă 2005,ă 41,ă 275–9.Rebetol®ă (ribavirină USP)ă
capsulesăandăoralăsolutionă[packageăinsert].ăKenilworth,ăN.J.,ăScheringăCorporation,ă2004.ă
47. PegasysăH-C-395.ăEuropeanăPublicăAssessmentăReport.ăRevisionă13ă–ăPublishedă02/12/08.ăă
48. PegIntronăH-C-28ăEuropeanăPublicăAssessmentăReport.ăRevisionă16ă–ăPublishedă02/12/08.ăă
49. SULKOWSKIăM.S.,ăAnemia in the treatment of hepatitis C virus infection.ăClin.ăInfect.ăDis.,ă2003,ă37ă(Suppl.ă4),ăS315–22.ăă
50. Epogenă(Epoetinăalfa)ăforăinjectionă[packageăinsert].ăThousandăOaks,ăC.A.ăAmgen.ăInc.,ă2004.ă
ă
9ă
AnemiaăandăchronicăviralăhepatitisăCă
225
51. SPIEGELăB.M.,ăYOUNOSSIăZ.M.,ăHAYSăR.D.,ăREYICKIăD.,ăROBBINSăS.,ăKANWALLăF.,ăImpact of hepatitis C on health
related quality of life: a systematic review and quantitative assessment.ăHepatology,ă2005,ă41,ă790–800.ăă
52. SCHEAFFERăM.,ăSCHMIDTăF.,ăFOLWACZNYăC.ăet al.,ăAdherence and mental side effects during hepatitis C treatment with
interferon alfa and ribavirin in psychiatric risk groups.ăHepatology,ă2003,ă37,ă443–51.ă
53. Natională Canceră Institute.ă Commonă Terminologyă Criteriaă foră Adverseă Eventsă v3.0ă (CTCAE).ă Updated:ă Decemberă 12,ă 2003.ă
Availableăat:ăhttp://ctep.cancer.gov/reporting/ctc.html.ăAccessed:ăFebruaryă23,ă2005.ă
54. NIGGă L.,ă SCHANZă U.,ă AMBUHLă P.M.,ă FEHRă J.,ă BACHLIă E.B.,ă Prolonged course of pure red cell aplasia after
erythropoietin therapy.ăEur.ăJ.ăHaematol.,ă2004,ă73,ă376–9.ă
ReceivedăFebruaryă9,ă2009ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
226ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
OlgaăOr şanăet al.ă
10ă
ORIGINAL ARTICLES
Drug Treatment of Heart Failure Patients in a General Romanian Hospital
D. ZDRENGHEA1, DANA POP1, OANA PENCIU1, M. ZDRENGHEA2
1
University of Medicine and Pharmacy “Iuliu Haţieganu”, Cluj-Napoca, Romania,
Rehabilitation Hospital–Cardiology Department
2
University of Medicine and Pharmacy “Iuliu Haţieganu”, Cluj-Napoca,
“Ion Chiricuţă” Oncology Institute, Hematology Department
Objective. It is very well known that in clinical practice, according to the published
guidelines, the heart failure patients are undertreated. There are striking differences in applying the
guidelines in various countries and, up to the present, there are no consistent data for Romania.
Material and Methods. There were studied 459 heart failure patients admitted in the
Cardiology Department of a general hospital in Cluj-Napoca, Romania. They were evaluated from the
point of view of the drugs used during hospitalization and recommended to be taken after discharge.
Results. The patients, 393 males and 66 females, aged 61±9 years (lower in comparison with
other countries) were included in NYHA III and IV class, except 3%, in NYHA II class. The ischemic
etiology was registered in 56% of the patients. Drug treatment was as follows: diuretics–86.98%,
ACEI–77.77%, beta blockers–55.95, ARB’s–7%, digoxin–51.63%, aldosterone antagonists–49%,
nitrates–61.28%, statins–24%, antithrombotic therapy–60% (antiplatelet–45.75%, anticoagulants–
28.5%), antiarrythmics–27.91% (mainly amiodarone). In comparison with other European countries,
the use of RAAS antagonists is similar, there are more beta blockers and nitrates used, but there is
less use of antithrombotic therapy (especially anticoagulation) and of statins.
Conclusion. Even though Romania still belongs to the group of developing countries, the drug
treatment of heart failure patients does not much differ from the treatment applied in developed countries.
Key words: heart failure, drug treatment, guidelines.
The drug treatment of chronic heart failure
patients is now very well established and available
guidelines offer very concrete data about the
usefulness of some medications [1–5].
The control of congestive syndrome is usually
assured by diuretics and RAAS antagonists together
with rate control in patients with rapid rate atrial
fibrillation-digoxin, beta blockers [1–4].
In turn, the evolution, quality of life and
survival are significantly improved by RAAS
antagonists and beta blockers, but also by aldosterone
antagonists [3–7].
The relief of pulmonary congestion, leading to
a rapid resolution of breathlessness, can be easier
obtained by using intravenous diuretics and nitrates
[2][4]. Arrhythmias are controlled by amiodarone
(supraventricular and ventricular arrhythmias), and
digitalis and beta blockers are used for rate control
of atrial flutter and fibrillation [4–6][8–11].
Long term anticoagulation is indicated in
patients with atrial fibrillation, previous thrombembolic
events, or much enlarged cardiac chambers [11][12].
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 227–233
Statins are recommended in ischemic heart
failure patients, but also in nonischaemic ones, to
improve the endothelial function, even if the recent
CORONA trial reported benefits for hospitalization,
but not for survival [13][14].
Unfortunately, there is a significant gap
between guidelines recommendations and their
implementation in clinical practice, generally all
categories of drugs being underused, or their doses
being lower than those recommended and demonstrated
as being efficient [18].
This is true mainly for the general practice,
but also for the internal medicine or even cardiology units [19–21].
There are some explanations of the phenomenon.
First, during clinical practice, the heart failure
patients are somewhat different from those studied
during clinical trials which represent, even in case
of very accurate randomization, a selected
population [22]. Second, in daily practice many
heart failure patients have preserved LVEF and
consequently drug treatment is not necessary to be
D. Zdrenghea et al.
228
as aggressive as for systolic heart failure patients.
On the other hand, during daily clinical practice it
is often difficult to reach the recommended doses
for RAAS antagonists and beta blockers because of
the severe adverse effects, and consequently, the
excellent results reported by the very large trials
are much less [23][24].
Also, many doctors do not know the optimal
treatment recommended by guidelines or the patients
are not compliant with long term treatment [25–27].
Thus, it is necessary to optimize the
implementation of guidelines for all the countries,
including the developing ones. This is once more
important for former communist countries because
of the lower economic status [18–25].
In Romania, the aspects of guidelines
implementation were less studied, this being the
reason of the present clinical study.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
There were studied 459 consequently admitted
patients in the Cardiology Department of a General
Hospital (Rehabilitation Hospital), in Cluj-Napoca
Romania, between January 2006 and December
2006, being discharged with the diagnosis of chronic
heart failure. The patients were evaluated using the
hospital files, from the point of view of the drugs
used during hospitalization, and recommended to be
taken at discharge. The study included both patients
with systolic heart failure (LVEF< 40%) and with
preserved LVEF (> 40%). 393 patients were males
and 66 females, aged 61±9 years.
The ischemic etiology was registered in 56%
of the patients, idiopathic in 12%, toxic in 10% and
others in 22%.
We also registered the cardiovascular risk
factors known to intervene as underlying and/or
precipitating factors of the heart failure: hypertension,
diabetes mellitus, arrhythmias, etc.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
The data were analyzed using SPSS 8.0 for
Windows. We calculated mean and standard
deviation for normal distributed quantitative
variables. Differences between quantitative variables
were examined using Student test (independentsample T test), and for qualitative variables we used
χ2 test. A p value less than 0.05 was considered
significant from the statistical point of view.
2
RESULTS
The great majority of the patients were
included in III and IV NYHA class (97%) and only
3% in II NYHA class.
Hypertension was registered in 33% of the
patients, valvulopathies (primary or secondary to LV
systolic dysfunction) in 45.5%, diabetes mellitus in
14.38%, and arrhythmias in 76.47%. Atrial fibrillation
was registered in 47.37% of the patients, and severe
ventricular arrhythmias in 15.38%.
Drug treatment during hospitalization and/or
recommended at discharge was as follows: diuretics
86.98%, RAAS antagonists 84.77% (77.77% ACEI, 7%
ARB’s), beta blockers 55.95%, nitrates 61.28%, statins
24%, antithrombotic therapy 60% (antiplatelet drugs
44.75% anticoagulants 28.5%), antiarrhythmics 27.91%
(amiodarone 25%), calcium channel blockers 8%.
Very interesting results were obtained from the
analysis of readmissions, registered in 52% of the
patients. If we considered the drugs excluded or
introduced in the treatment schedule during readmission,
beta blockers and antiarrhythmics were less excluded
and most introduced (in more than 40% of the cases),
followed by nitrates, probably in relationship with
associated angina pectoris. In turn, ACEI and digoxin
were excluded and introduced in low, and almost
equal proportions (Fig. 1).
After treatment adjustment the evolution was
good in 62%, stable in 15% and worse in 23% of
the patients.
DISCUSSION
The mean age of our patients (61±9 years)
was about ten years less than that registered in the
developed countries, where the mean age of heart
failure patients is about 74 years [4]. This is in
relationship with the increased percent and the
early onset of cardiovascular diseases in our
population, the primary preventive measures still
lacking for the great majority of the population.
In comparison with the results of Euro Heart
Failure Survey [28], published in 2003, but
analyzing 2000–2001 treated patients, our data are
similar or even better (Fig. 2). Thus, ACEI are used
in 77.77% vs. 61.8%; ARBs in 7% vs. 4.5%, beta
blockers in 55.95% vs. 36.95, diuretics in 86.58 vs.
89.95, aldosterone antagonists in 49% vs. 20%,
aspirin 45.75% vs. 21.1%. Antithrombotic therapy
was less used (60% vs. 77.6%), but digoxin (51.65%
vs. 35.7%) and nitrates (61.25% vs. 32.1%) were
3
Drug treatment of heart failure
229
Fig. 1. – Drugs excluded or introduced in the treatment schedule during readmission for decompensated heart failure.
Fig. 2. – Comparison between drugs used in heart failure patients in Cluj-Napoca Study and Euro Heart Failure Survey.
used significantly more. There are no comparative
data about antiarrhythmic therapy, but calcium
channel blockers were less used (8%) than in Euro
Heart Failure Survey (21.2%).
Also, our data are much closer to the
published guidelines [2][4–6] than those recently
reported about heart failure treatment in Scotland:
the use of diuretics was similar – 89%, ARBs were
230
D. Zdrenghea et al.
more used – 9% but ACEI, beta blockers and
spironolactone were used in only 63%, 34% and
15% of the patients [29]..
The results suggest that even in developing
countries, to which Romania belongs, the drug
treatment of heart failure patients is now similar to
that applied in developed countries.
The explanation could be the availability of
information (internet, medical meetings, etc.), but
also the availability of modern cardiovascular
drugs, even if not always the last generation.
Unfortunately, because the number of the
studied patients was not very large, we could not
analyze each component of every category of
drugs. Probably this is not so important because
even “old drugs” were demonstrated, by large and
very well-known clinical trials, to significantly
improve the clinical picture, evolution and survival
in heart failure patients [1–6].
Considering the medication used, 40% of the
patients received the recommended triple association:
diuretics, ACEI, beta blockers, the percent being
more than double with respect to that reported in the
Euro Heart Failure Survey [28]. The high use of
ACEI can be explained not only throughout a correct
applying of the guidelines, but also throughout the high
percent (33%) of the hypertensive patients [2][4] [5].
It is also important that 97% of the patients were
included in III or IV NYHA class, the ACEI being
imposed by the severe clinical picture, a situation
somehow different from that noted in general
medical practice.
The high percent of diuretics is explained by
the congestive syndrome, almost all our patients
being on III or IV NYHA class [2].
The higher use of beta blockers in comparison
with other countries (Euro Heart Failure Survey) is
explained not only by the dominant ischemic etiology
of the heart failure (56%) and associated hypertension
(33%), but it reflects a good knowledge of the
guidelines [4–7], [28][30]. Unfortunately, the general
use of beta blockers remained less than recommended
by guidelines. This cannot be explained only by the
severe clinical picture, 23% of the patients being
included in IV NYHA class, and with severe
congestive syndrome, which can be initially worsened
by the administration of beta blockers [30].
Spironolactone was also used in a very high
percent, the dose being usually 50–100mg/day,
higher than that generally reported. The explanation
4
is that of the severe congestive syndrome which
imposed high dose spironolactone to preserve and
increase the diuretic effect of furosemide [2][4][5].
The higher use of digoxin can be explained,
not only by a traditional approach to the heart
failure treatment, but also by the high percent of
atrial fibrillation patients (48%), digoxin being
recommended as an AV blocker to obtain an
appropriate heart rate control [3–5].
Calcium channel blockers are surprisingly less
used, even if almost 60% of the patients were
ischemic, but this is according to the current
guidelines, which recommended calcium antagonists
to be used only in uncontrolled or vasospastic angina,
or associated hypertension [4][5][31].
Antithrombotics, and especially anticoagulant
therapy, were much less used than recommended or
than registered in other studies [11][12]. We do not
have a clear explanation for the less than recommended
use of aspirin (50%). For anticoagulants, the very low
percent could be explained by a traditional approach,
even in patients with atrial fibrillation, but also by
the difficulties to follow up the coagulation for a large
part of the heart failure patients.
A final “minus” is represented by the low use
of antiarrhythmic therapy, even if the implantable
cardioverter defibrillators (ICD) are very rarely available
and used in Romania [2][32]. The arrhythmogenic risk
in heart failure patients is continuously increasing
and it is necessary, together with cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) and ICD implantation,
to promote the antiarrhythmic therapy as a
practically temporary solution [33], [34], [35].
CRT with or without ICD seems to improve
survival and morbidity in selected patients with
chronic heart failure who are optimally treated with
pharmacologic agents according to current guidelines
[2][4][33][34].
LIMITS OF THE STUDY
The data used in this analysis were collected
from hospital files, from the point of view of the
drugs used during hospitalization, and recommended
to be taken at discharge (but not sure to be taken at
home). We did not always investigate the reason
for not taking the proper drugs (side effects,
absolute or relative contraindication). Study was
performed mainly on an urban sample (university
hospital) and, probably, in a rural sample the
situation is even worse (lower percentage of
patients taking proper medication).
5
Drug treatment of heart failure
CONCLUSION
Even though Romania still belongs to the
group of the developing countries, the drug
treatment of the heart failure patients does
not much differ, or is even better than the treatment
231
applied in developed countries. At the same time,
almost all the category of drugs are underused
in relationship with the guidelines recommendations,
being necessary to improve their use in current
clinical practice.
Obiective. Inhibiţia farmacologică a sistemelor neurohormonale cu IECA,
sartani, antagonişti aldosteronici sau betablocante a demonstrat o reducere
semnificativă a mortalităţii şi a numărului internărilor la bolnavii cu insuficienţă
cardiacă. Ghidurile de diagnostic şi tratament oferă o sinteză a acestor rezultate,
însă recomandările acestora nu sunt aplicate la toţi bolnavii în practica clinică,
rezultatele obţinute fiind inferioare celor raportate de marile trialuri. Până la ora
actuală nu există date în ceea ce priveşte această situaţie în România.
Material şi metodă. Am luat în studiu 459 de pacienţi care au fost internaţi
în secţia de Cardiologie a Spitalului Clinic de Recuperare – Cluj-Napoca cu
diagnosticul de insuficienţă cardiacă, şi la care s-a urmărit tratamentul
recomandat, atât în timpul internării cât şi la externare.
Rezultate. Pacienţii, 393 bărbaţi şi 66 femei, cu o vârstă medie de 61±9 ani
(mai scăzută comparativ cu alte ţări europene) au fost incluşi în clasele funcţionale
NYHA III şi IV cu excepţia a 3%, în clasa NYHA II. Etiologia ischemică a fost
înregistrată la 56% dintre pacienţi. În ceea ce priveşte tratamentul medicamentos
administrat, rezultatele au fost după cum urmează: diuretice–86.98%, IECA–77.77%,
beta blocante–55.95%, sartani–7%, digoxin–51.63%, antagonişti aldosteronici–49%,
nitraţi–61.28%, statine–24%, medicaţie antitrombotică–60% (antiagregante plachetare–
45.75%, anticoagulante–28.5%), antiaritmice–27.91% (in special amiodaronă). Comparativ
cu alte ţări europene, utilizarea antagoniştilor sistemului renină–angiotensinăaldosteron este similară, betablocantele şi nitraţii sunt utilizate mai frecvent, însă
terapia antitrombotică (în special anticoagulantele) şi statinele sunt mai rar
recomandate.
Concluzie. Cu toate că România face parte din grupul ţărilor în curs de
dezvoltare, tratamentul medicamentos recomandat pacienţilor cu insuficienţă
cardiacă nu diferă semnificativ faţă de cel aplicat în ţările europene dezvoltate.
Corresponding author: D. Zdrenghea. University of Medicine and Pharmacy,
Rehabilitation Hospital, Cardiology Department,
46–50 Viilor Str., Cluj-Napoca, Romania.
Tel +040264438940; fax: +040264207035
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
1.
2.
MIELNICZUK L., STEVENSON L.W., Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors and angiotensin II type I receptor blockers
in the management of congestive heart failure patients: what have we learned from recent clinical trials? Curr. Opin. Cardiol.,
2005, J., 20(4):250–5.
ESC Committee for Practice Guideline (CPG). The Task Force on Acute Heart Failure of the European Society of Cardiology
Executive summary of the guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of acute heart failure. Eur. Heart J., 2005; 26(4):384–416.
Digoxin Therapy Does Not Improve Outcomes in Patients With Advanced Heart Failure on Contemporary Medical Therapy.
Circulation: Heart Failure, 2009; 2:90–97.
232
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
D. Zdrenghea et al.
6
.GEORGIOPOULOU V.V., KALOGEROPOULOS A.P., GIAMOUZIS G. The Task Force for the Diagnosis and Treatment of
Acute and Chronic Heart Failure 2008. ESC Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Acute and Chronic Heart Failure
2008. Eur. Heart J., 2008, 29: 2388–2442.
ESC Committee for Practice Guideline (CPG). Task force for the diagnosis and treatment of chronic heart failure of the
European Society of Cardiology: Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of chronic heart failure: executive summary
(update 2005. Eur. Heart J., 2005; 26(11):1115–40.
A Report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines (Writing
Committee to Update the 2001 Guidelines for the Evaluation and Management of Heart Failure): Developed in Collaboration
With the American College of Chest Physicians and the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation: Endorsed by
the Heart Rhythm Society. ACC/AHA 2005 Guideline Update for the Diagnosis and Management of Chronic Heart Failure in
the Adult. Circulation, 2005; 112:e154–e235.
FAUCHIER L., PIERRE B., DE LABRIOLLE A., BABUTY D., Comparison of the beneficial effect of beta blockers on
mortality in patients with ischaemic or non-ischaemic systolic heart failure: A meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.
Eur. J. Heart Failure, 2007; 9:1136–39.
MICHAL TENDERA., Epidemiology, treatment, and guidelines for the treatment of heart failure in Europe. European Heart
Journal Supplements, 2005; 7 (Supplement J.), J5–J9.
HAMAD E., MATHER P.J., SRINIVASAN S., RUBIN S., WHELLAN D.J., FELDMAN A.M., Pharmacologic therapy of
chronic heart failure. Am. J. Cardiovasc. Drugs, 2007; 7(4):235–48.
VOORS A.A., VAN VELDHUISEN D.J., Pharmacological treatment of chronic heart failure according to the 2005 guidelines
of the European Society of Cardiology. Minerva Cardioangiol., 2005; 53(4):233–9.
ANTER E., JESSUP M., CALLANS D.J., Atrial Fibrillation and Heart Failure Treatment Considerations for a Dual Epidemic.
Circulation, 2009; 119:2516–2525.
ECHEMANN M., ALLA F., BRIANÇON S. et al., Antithrombotic therapy is associated with better survival in patients with
severe heart failure and left ventricular systolic dysfunction (EPICAL study). Eur. J. Heart Fail, 2002; 4(5):647–54.
CLELAND J.G.F., COLETTA A.P., ABDELLAH A.T. et al., Clinical trials update from the American Heart Association 2007:
CORONA, RethinQ, MASCOT, AF-CHF, HART, MASTER, POISE and stem cell therapy. Eur. J. of Heart Failure, 2008; 10: 102–108.
FONAROW G.C., Randomized Clinical Outcome Trials of Statins in Heart Failure. Heart Failure Clinics, 2008; 4(2): 225–229.
ZALIADUONYTE-PEKSIENE D., MIKUCKAITE L., KAVOLIŪNIENE A., The main aspects of symptomatic therapy of
chronic heart failure. Medicina (Kaunas), 2006; 42(11):949–55.
MCMURRAY J., COHEN-SOLAL ALAIN, DIETZ R. et al., Practical recommendations for the use of ACE inhibitors, beta
blockers, aldosterone antagonists and angiotensin receptor blockers in heart failure: Putting guidelines into practice.
Eur. J. Heart Failure, 2005; 7: 710–21.
COLETTA A.P., CLELAND J.G., CULLINGTON D., CLARK A.L., Clinical trials update from Heart Rhythm 2008 and Heart
Failure 2008: ATHENA, URGENT, INH study, HEART and CK-1827452. Eur. J. Heart Fail, 2008; 10(9):917–20.
DE GROOTE P., ISNARD R., ASSYAG P. et al., Is the gap between guidelines and clinical practice in heart failure treatment
being filled? Insights from the IMPACT RECO survey. Eur. J. Heart Fail, 2007; 9(12):1205–11.
CLELAND J.G., COHEN-SOLAL A., COSIN AGUILAR J. et al., Management of heart failure in primary care (the
IMPROVEMENT of Heart Failure Programme): an international survey. Lancet, 2002; 360:1631–9.
STAWICKI S., ROIK M., JASIK M. et al., Differences between cardiologists and internists in the management of heart failure.
Medical guidelines compared with every-day practice. Kardiol. Pol., 2004; 61(11):431–9.
FABBRI G., GORINI M., MAGGIONI A.P., DI LENARDA A., Temporal trends in pharmacological therapy in the IN-CHF
registry from 1995 to 2005. , 2007; 8(2):102–6.
LENZEN M.J., BOERSMA E., REIMER W.J. et al., Under-utilization of evidence-based drug treatment in patients with heart
failure is only partially explained by dissimilarity to patients enrolled in landmark trials: a report from the Euro Heart Survey
on Heart Failure. Eur. Heart J., 2005; 26(24):2706–13.
KOMAJDA M., LAPUERTA P., HERMANS N. et al., Adherence to guidelines is a predictor of outcome in chronic heart
failure: the MAHLER survey. Eur. Heart J., 2005; 26(16):1653–9.
HAUPTMAN P.J., SWINDLE J., HUSSAIN Z., BIENER L., BURROUGHS T.E., Physician attitudes toward end-stage heart
failure: a national survey. Am. J. Med., 2008; 121(2):127–35.
CHRISTOPHER M. O’CONNOR, The new heart failure guidelines: Strategies for implementation. Am. Heart J., 2007;
153:S22S5.
MARIELL JESSUP, M.D., SUSAN C. BROZENA, M.D., Guidelines for the Management of Heart Failure: Differences in
Guideline Perspectives. Cardiol. Clin., 2007; 5:497–506.
LAINSCAKA MITJA, KEBERB IRENA, Patients’ knowledge and beta blocker treatment improve prognosis of patients from a
heart failure clinic. Eur. J. Heart Fail, 2006; 8(2):187–90.
The Study Group of Diagnosis of the Working Group on Heart Failure of the European Society of Cardiology. The EuroHeart
Failure Survey Programme a survey on the quality of care among patients with heart failure in Europe. Part 2: treatment. Eur.
Heart J., 2003; 24: 464–474.
STURM H.B., HAAIJER-RUSKAMP F.M., VEEGER N.J., BALJÉ-VOLKERS C.P., SWEDBERG K., VAN GILST W.H.,
The relevance of comorbidities for heart failure treatment in primary care: A European survey. Eur. J. Heart Failure, 2006;
8: 31–7.
7
Drug treatment of heart failure
233
29. MURPHY N.F., SIMPSON C.R., MCALISTER F.A. et al., National survey of the prevalence, incidence, primary care burden,
and treatment of heart failure in Scotland. Heart, 2004; 90:1129–1136.
30. The COMET investigators. Should beta-blocker therapy be reduced or withdrawn after an episode of decompensated heart
failure? Results from COMET. Eur. J. Heart Failure, 2007; 9:901 9.
31. IO K., MINATOGUCHI S., NISHIGAKI K. et al., Effects of benidipine and some other calcium channel blockers on the
prognosis of patients with vasospastic angina. Cohort study with evaluation of the ergonovine coronary spasm induction test.
Arzneimittelforschung., 2007; 57(9):573–81.
32. ITURRALDE TORRES P., Primary prevention of sudden cardiac death implanted cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) versus
antiarrhythmic drugs. Arch. Cardiol. Mex., 2007 Oct.–Dec., 77 Suppl 4:S4–129–32.
33. SWEDBERG K., CLELAND J., COWIE M.R. et al., Successful treatment of heart failure with devices requires collaboration.
Eur. J. Heart Fail, 2008; 10(12):1229–35.
34. GASPARINI M., Indications to implantable cardioverter defibrillator in heart failure patients: a comment on the recently
released ESC Guidelines on treatment and diagnosis of heart failure. Eur. Heart J., 2005; 26(22):2472–2473.
Received May 25, 2009
Dyslipidemia and Hypertension in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes
and Retinopathy
TOMINA POPESCU1, MARIA MO A2
2
1
Clinical Hospital CF Craiova
Clinic of Diabetes, Nutrition and Metabolic Diseases, University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Craiova
Aim. Type 2 diabetes is associated with dyslipidemia and higher cardiovascular risk and also
generates multiple microvascular complications. Diabetic retinal changes, diabetic maculopathy and
proliferative retinopathy are major causes of vision loss among the people of working age worldwide.
We searched the association between diabetic retinopathy (as one of the most important long time
microvascular complications in diabetes), lipids disorder and blood pressure in subjects with T2DM
without known cardiovascular diseases.
Material and methods. We examined 100 patients with type 2 diabetes, without clinical
evidence of coronary, cerebrovascular or peripheral artery disease; 48 (48%) were women (mean age
61.23±8.49) and 52 (52%) were men (mean age 60.75±8.43). Diabetic retinopathy was graded from
retinal photograph according to Early Treatment for Diabetic Retinopathy Study severity scale. In
each patient we measured total cholesterol, HDL, LDL, triglycerides. Statistical analysis was
performed using Mann-Whitney U-test, Kruskal-Wallis and Oneway Anova tests.
Results. Diabetic retinopathy was found in 59.5% men and 40.5% women. The patients who
presented diabetic retinopathy had significantly higher values of total cholesterol (223.05±42.39 mg/dL
vs 199.84±45.73 mg/dL) and LDL-C (152.29±42.46 mg/dL vs 117.33±45.35 mg/dL) and smaller HDLC (38.95±12.46 mg/dL vs 48.64±14.70 mg/dL) as compared to the patients without retinopathy.
Although values of triglycerides were higher in the group with retinopathy than in the control one
(179.71±112.60 mg/dL vs 172.53±104.53 mg/dL) there were no statistically significant differences.
Conclusions. We found a statistically significant correlation between retinopathy and
dyslipidemia, which suggested that the use of systemic lipid lowering therapy in type 2 diabetes is of
benefit in patients with retinal changes, in order to prevent visual loss.
Key words: diabetic retinopathy, type 2 diabetes, dyslipidemia, blood pressure.
Diabetic retinopathy is a major microvascular
complication of diabetes, and is the commonest
cause of blindness in people of working age in the
Western world. It can be defined as a damage of
retina’s microvascular system due the prolonged
hyperglycaemia [1]. The appearance of retinopathy
is directly related to the time of evolution of the
disease and metabolic control. It is estimated that
diabetes mellitus affects 4 per cent of the world’s
population, almost half of whom have some degree
of diabetic retinopathy at any given time [2].
Diabetic retinopathy occurs both in type 1 and type 2
diabetes mellitus and has been shown that nearly
all type 1 and 75 per cent of type 2 diabetes will
develop DR after 15 years duration of diabetes as
shown in earlier epidemiological studies [3].
The individual risk can be significantly
reduced by early blood glucose control and
treatment of vascular risk factors [4]. It was found,
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 235–241
in some studies [5][6], that the risk for diabetic
retinopathy is directly correlated with serum
lipidis, but it was not found an association between
the lowering lipids therapy and retinopathy.
Early intensive intervention to control cardiovascular
risk factors is essential in clinical management.
Atherogenic dyslipidemia characterized by elevated
triglycerides, a low level of high-density lipoprotein
cholesterol (HDL-C), and an increase in the preponderance
of small, dense low-density lipoprotein (LDL) particles,
is a key modifiable risk factor for macrovascular
diabetic complications [7], but it is still unclear to
what extent it can influence the appearance and
evolution of diabetic retinopathy.
The potential for systemic lipid modulation to
prevent visual loss still remains unclear. Recently,
in the Fenofibrate Intervention in Event Lowering
in Diabetes (FIELD) study fenofibrate treatment
demonstrated a significant 30% reduction in the
236
Tomina Popescu and Maria Mo a
need for laser therapy in patients with and without
known diabetic retinopathy, and more particularly,
in the first course of laser treatment for both
macular edema and proliferative retinopathy [8].
Regarding hypertension, epidemiologic studies
have not found blood pressure to be a consistent risk
factor for diabetic retinopathy incidence and progression
[9][10]. However, other trials indicate that tight
control of blood pressure is a major modifiable factor
for the incidence and progression of diabetic
retinopathy. The beneficial effects of tight controlling
blood pressure still remain unclear. Two large
Randomized Controlled Trials are currently ongoing.
The Action in Diabetes and Vascular Disease
(ADVANCE) study will evaluate the effect of a
perindopril-indapamide combination on the incidence
of DR [11], while the Diabetic Retinopathy
Candesartan Trial (DIRECT) will evaluate the angiotensin II receptor blocker candesartan [12].
In this article we examined the relation between
serum lipids, blood pressure and retinopathy in a
group of patients with type 2 diabetes.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
We used the data of 100 patients with type 2
diabetes recorded at Clinical Hospital C.F. Craiova.
Exclusion criteria – clinical evidence of macrovascular complication (peripheral arterial disease,
previous stroke or myocardial infarction, abnormal
EKG), active liver disease.
Diabetic retinopathy was graded from retinal
photograph according to Early Treatment for
Diabetic Retinopathy Study severity scale. In each
patient we measured total cholesterol, HDL-C,
triglycerides and calculated LDL-C using Fiedwald
formula LDL-Cţtotal cholesterol-(HDL-C+TG/5)
mg/dL, when TG were under 400 mg/dL. We also
questioned about diabetes duration, smoking and
measured blood pressure, BMI and abdominal
circumference. Blood pressure was recorded as the
mean of three consecutive measurements in the
sitting position taken 5 min apart. Hypertension
was defined according to the current guidelines
[13] as BP levels ≥ 140/90 mmHg or the use of
anti-hypertensive drugs.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Statistical analysis was performed using
programs available in the SPSS 17.0 statistical
2
package. All variables were tested for normal
distribution of the data. Data are presented as means ±
standard deviation or percentages. Differences
between the studied groups examined used t-test or
the Mann-Whitney U-test for parametric and nonparametric data, respectively, while a chi-square test
was used for categorical data. P-values Ţ 0.05 were
considered statistically significant.
RESULTS
General characteristics:
Total number of subjects 100
Men 52 (52%) mean age at examination
60.75±8.43
Women 48 (48%) mean age at examination
61.23±8.49
Classification of the groups – we found diabetic
retinopathy in 42 (42%) subjects. Among these, 25
(59.5%) were men and 17 (40.5%) were women. The
control group (patients without retinopathy) has
58 subjects, with 27 (46.6%) men and 31 (53.4%)
women. Clinical and laboratory characteristics of the
groups are shown in the table below (Table I).
In patients with diabetic retinopathy we found,
as we expected, a higher diabetes duration (13.86
years in proliferative retinopathy and 8.31 years in
nonproliferative retinopathy vs 6.53 years in patients
without retinopathy), with pţ0.020 (Fig. 1). Bars
show means and error bars show means –/+ 1.0 SE.
We did not find correlations between the presence
of retinopathy and sex, although the percentage of
nonproliferative retinopathy had slightly increased in
men versus women (36.54% vs 33.33%) and increased
net in proliferative retinopathy (11.54% vs 2.08%),
but without statistical significance (Fig. 2).
Smoking was strongly correlated with retinopathy,
31.35% of non-smokers presented retinopathy
compared to 63.6% of smokers (pţ0.003) (Fig. 3).
Systolic blood pressure correlates significantly
with the presence of retinopathy, with pţ0.031, but
does not correlate with the severity of retinopathy;
diastolic blood pressure correlates with both
presence (pţ0.003) and severity of retinopathy
(pţ0.004) (Fig. 4).
Dyslipidemia correlates well with the presence
and severity of retinopathy, especially HDL-C and
LDL-C. Although triglycerides were higher in
patients with retinopathy, we did not find statistical
significance (Table II). The graphics represent mean
values of lipidis with standard deviation (Fig. 5).
3
Dyslipidemia and hypertension
237
Table I
Clinic and laboratory characteristics of the groups
Variable
Without retinopathy
With retinopathy
p (2 tailed)
27 (46.6%)/31(53.4%)
25 (59.5%)/17(40.5%)
0,228
60.69±8.79
61.38±7.99
0.690
6.00 (3.00-9.00)
10.00 (4.00-12.25)
0.020
Smoker (%)
12 (20.7%)
21 (50.0%)
0.003
Hypertension (%)
40 (69.0%)
41 (97.6%)
0.000
Total cholesterol (mg/dL)
199.84±45.73
223.05±42.39
0.011
Triglycerides (mg/dL)
172.53±104,53
179.71±112,60
0.574
HDL-C (mg/dL)
48.64±14.70
38.95±12.46
0.001
LDL-C (mg/dL)
117.33±45.35
152.29±42.46
0.000
138.33±16.74
145.76±16.74
0.031
83.64±9.13
89.12±8.70
0.003
30.33±4.48
29.20±3.65
0.183
100.17±10.79
98.19±12.69
0.402
Male/female (%)
Mean age
Diabetes duration (years)
Systolic blood pressure
(mm Hg)
Diastolic blood pressure
(mm Hg)
Body mass index
(kg/m2)
Abdominal circumference
(cm)
Fig. 1. – Relation between diabetic retinopathy and diabetes duration.
Fig. 2. – Relation between diabetic retinopathy
and sex.
Fig. 3. – Relation between smoking habit and
retinopathy.
Fig. 4. – Blood pressure and retinopathy.
5
Dyslipidemia and hypertension
239
Table II
Lipids and diabetic retinopathy
Variable
Diabetic retinopathy
triglycerides
(mg/dL)One-Way
ANOVA
HDL-C (mg/dL)
LDL-C (mg/dL)
p (2 tailed)
test
221.89±42.39
228.86±45.26
0.038
188.14±111.66
0.855
Kruskal-Wallis
Absent
Nonproliferative
Proliferative
Total cholesterol
(mg/dL)
199.84±45.73
172.53±104.53
178.03±114.33
48.64±14.70
38.14±12.54
43.00±12.08
0.001
Kruskal-Wallis
117.33±45.35
153.44±41.64
146.71±49.40
0.001
One-Way
ANOVA
Fig. 5. – Lipids and diabetic retinopathy.
CONCLUSION
1. In our data, diabetic retinopathy is correlated
with diabetes duration, hypertension (especially
diastolic value) and smoking and it is sustained
that blood pressure control can reduce the
incidence of diabetic retinopathy and it must be
obtained as early as possible.
2. Dyslipidemia was significantly correlated with
the presence of diabetic retinopathy, but this
significance decreases with the severity of
retinopathy. We suggest that lipid lowering
therapy must be initiated as soon as possible
in order to prevent the development of diabetic
retinopathy. We did not find correlations
between triglycerides and retinopathy, but most
of the patients with retinopathy in our study
were on fibrates therapy.
3. We could not find associations between diabetic
retinopathy and BMI or waist circumference,
probably because patients with poor glycaemic
control and smokers have a better BMI but not a
“protection” for microvascular complications.
Diabetul zaharat de tip 2 este asociat cu dislipidemie şi cu risc cardiovascular
crescut şi generează, de asemenea, multiple complicaţii microvasculare. Modificările
240
Tomina Popescu and Maria Mo a
6
retinei în diabet, maculopatia diabetică şi retinopatia proliferativă reprezintă
principalele cauze de orbire la populaţia adultă la nivel mondial. Am studiat asocierea
între retinopatia diabetică (una dintre cele mai importante complicaţii microvasculare
pe termen lung în diabet), dislipidemie şi valorile tensiunii arteriale la un grup de
subiecţi cu diabet zaharat tip 2 fără boli cardiovasculare manifeste.
Material şi metodă. Am examinat 100 de pacienţi cu diabet tip 2 fără boli
cardiovasculare clinic manifeste. 48 (48%) au fost femei (vârsta medie la
examinare 61.23±8.49 ani) şi 52 (52%) au fost bărbaţi (vârsta medie 60.75±8.43).
Retinopatia diabetică a fost diagnosticată conform protocolului oferit de Early
Treatment for Diabetic Retinopathy Study. Fiecărui pacient i-au fost măsurate
colesterolul total, trigliceridele, HDL-C, LDL-C. Analiza statistică a fost efectuată
utilizând testele Mann-Whitney U-test, Kruskal-Wallis şi Oneway Anova.
Rezultate. Retinopatia diabetică a fost diagnosticată la 59.5% dintre bărbaţi
şi la 40.5% dintre femei. Pacienţii cu retinopatie au prezentat valori semnificativ
crescute ale colesterolului total (223,05±42,39 mg/dL vs 199,84±45,73 mg/dL) şi
ale LDL-C (152,29±42,46 mg/dL vs 117,33±45,35 mg/dL) precum şi valori mai
mici ale HDL-C (38,95±12,46 mg/dL vs 48,64±14,70 mg/dL) comparativ cu cei
fără retinopatie. Deşi valorile trigliceridelor au fost mai mari în grupul cu retinopatie
decât în cel de control (179,71±112,60 mg/dL vs 172,53±104,53 mg/dL), acest fapt nu
a prezentat semnificaţie statistică.
Concluzii. Am constatat o corelaţie semnificativă statistic între retinopatie şi
dislipidemie, ceea ce sugerează că utilizarea tratamentului hipolipemiant la
pacientul cu diabet tip 2 şi complicaţii retiniene este benefică pentru prevenirea
pierderii vederii.
Corresponding author: Tomina Popescu, MD
Clinical Hospital C.F.
6, Ştirbei Vodă, Craiova, Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
OSHITARI T., ROY S., Common therapeutic strategies for diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma. Curr. Drug Ther., 2007; 2:224–32.
AIELLO L.P., GARDNER T.W., KING G.L., BLANKENSHIP G., CAVALLERANO J.D., FERRIS F.L. 3rd et al., Diabetic
retinopathy. Diabetes Care, 1998; 21: 143–56.
3. KLEIN R., KLEIN B.E.K., MOSS S.E., DAVIS M.D., DEMETS D.L., The Wisconsin epidemiologic study of diabetic
retinopathy III. Prevalence and risk of diabetic retinopathy when age at diagnosis is 30 or more years. Arch. Ophthalmol.,
1984; 102: 527–32.
4. REMA M., PRADEEPA R., Diabetic Retinopathy: An Indian perspective. Indian J. Med. Res., 125, March 2007, pp. 297–310.
5. VAN LEIDEN H.A., DEKKER J.M., MOLL A.C. et al., Blood pressure, lipids, and obesity are associated with retinopathy:
the hoorn study. Diabetes Care, 2002; 25(8):1320–1325.
6. KLEIN R., SHARRETT A.R., KLEIN B.E. et al., ARIC Group. The association of atherosclerosis, vascular risk factors, and
retinopathy in adults with diabetes: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Ophthalmology, 2002; 109(7):1225–1234.
7. Steinmetz A., Lipid-lowering therapy in patients with type 2 diabetes: the case for early intervention. Diabetes Metab. Res.
Rev., 2008 May–Jun.; 24(4):286–93.
8. ANSQUER J.C., FOUCHER C., AUBONNET P., LE MALICOT K., Fibrates and microvascular complications in diabetes –
insight from the FIELD study. Curr. Pharm. Des., 2009; 15(5):537–52.
9. KLEIN B.E., KLEIN R., MOSS S.E., PALTA M., A cohort study of the relationship of diabetic retinopathy to blood pressure.
Arch. Ophthalmol., 1995; 113(5): 601–6061.
10. KLEIN R., SHARRETT A.R., KLEIN B.E. et al., ARIC Group. The association of atherosclerosis, vascular risk factors, and
retinopathy in adults with diabetes: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Ophthalmology. 2002; 109(7):1225–1234.
1.
2.
7
Dyslipidemia and hypertension
241
11. ADVANCE Collaborative Group. ADVANCE – Action in Diabetes and Vascular Disease: patient recruitment and characteristics of
the study population at baseline. Diabet. Med., 2005; 22(7):882–888.
12. SJØLIE A.K., PORTA M., PARVING H.H., BILOUS R., KLEIN R., DIRECT Programme Study Group. The DIabetic
REtinopathy Candesartan Trials (DIRECT) Programme: baseline characteristics. J. Renin Angiotensin Aldosterone Syst.,
2005; 6(1):25–32.
13. CHOBANIAN A.V., BAKRIS G.L., BLACK H.R., CUSHMAN W.C., GREEN L.A., IZZO J.L., Jr. et al., Joint National
Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure. National Heart, Lung, and Blood
Institute; National High Blood Pressure Education Program Coordinating Committee: Seventh report of the Joint National
Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure. Hypertension, 2003; 42:1206–1252.
doi: 10.1161/01.HYP.0000107251.49515.c2.
Received May 30, 2009
242
Tomina Popescu and Maria Mo a
8
Esophageal Achalasia – Manometric Patterns
D.L. DUMITRAŞCU, TEODORA SURDEA-BLAGA, LILIANA DAVID
“Iuliu Haţieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy,
2nd Department of Internal Medicine, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
Achalasia is a primary esophageal motility disorder involving the body of the esophagus and
lower esophageal sphincter. Esophageal manometry is the gold standard to diagnose achalasia. Two
cardinal features are encountered in achalasia: incomplete LES relaxation and absent peristalsis in the
lower esophagus. In a group of 94 patients with dysphagia we looked for the manometric changes, trying
to identify clinical and manometric particularities of the cases with achalasia. 35 cases had manometric
changes compatible with the diagnostic of achalasia. A number of 41 patients had other esophageal
motility disorders and 8 patients had normal esophageal manometry. The majority of patients (80%) had
an increase basal pressure in the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) and the rest of them had a normal
pressure of the LES. Absence of the lower esophageal sphincter relaxation or incomplete relaxation was
observed in all cases. Aperistalsis was found in 33 patients (94.3 %) and 2 patients (5.7%) presented
hyperperistaltism of the tubular esophagus. We followed the manometric changes pre and post treatment
in 10 cases, all having similar manometric modifications, before and after treatment; only the basal
pressure of the lower esophageal sphincter was modified after treatment.
Key words: lower esophageal sphincter, achalasia, manometry.
Achalasia is a primary esophageal motility
disorder involving the body of the esophagus and
lower esophageal sphincter, affecting equally both
genders and all ages [1]. The disease seems to be
caused by denervation of the esophagus resulting
from loss of nitric oxide-producing inhibitory
neurons in the myenteric plexus [2][3].
In terms of diagnosis, esophageal manometry
is the gold standard to diagnose achalasia [1].
Achalasia is characterised manometrically by two
cardinal features: incomplete LES relaxation and
absent peristalsis in the lower esophagus.
Additional features that are often encountered but
that are not in themselves diagnostic are an
increased basal intraesophageal pressure that is
higher than intragastric pressure, and an increased
basal LES pressure [4].
Laparoscopic myotomy and pneumatic balloon
dilatations of the lower esophageal sphincter are
considered definitive treatments for achalasia. The
role of manometry in post-treatment surveillance
remains controversial [1].
In our study we looked for the manometric
changes in patients with achalasia, trying to
identify clinical and manometric particularities of
these cases. In a small group of patients we also
assessed the manometric changes in esophagus
before and after surgical or dilation treatment.
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 243–247
MATERIAL AND METHODS
A total of 94 patients with dysphagia were
enrolled in the study. The patients were admitted in
our hospital in a period of 3 years – between
January 2005 and December 2007; the majority of
them were referred to manometry department after
endoscopic and radiologic evaluation by other
clinicians. All patients signed the informed consent
form. Clinical symptoms and signs, endoscopic
changes and radiologic findings were also recorded
for all the patients. Patients with no signs of
organic esophageal stenosis were submitted to
manometric studies.
Esophageal motility was measured using a
perfused manometric system (Medtronic) with
8 channels (8 recording points). The patients were
evaluated in the lateral recumbent position. We
recorded the following manometric parameters: the
pressure in the upper esophageal sphincter, the
peristalsis of the esophagus (the amplitude, shape,
duration and progression velocity of contractions),
basal lower esophageal sphincter pressure and residual
LES pressure after swallowing. For the assessment of
LES we used the pull-through technique. Peristalsis
and LES relaxation were assessed in response to 5 ml
of water swallows, using the pull-through technique;
a minimum of 10 swallows (spaced at least
15 seconds apart) were tested.
D.L. Dumitraşcu et al.
244
RESULTS
From the 94 patients, 35 cases proved to have
manometric changes compatible with the diagnostic
of achalasia. A number of 41 patients had other
esophageal motility disorders (diffuse esophageal
spasm, hyperperistaltic esophagus, nonspecific
motility disorders) and 8 patients had normal
esophageal manometry (Table I).
Table I
2
We followed the manometric changes pre and
post treatment in 10 cases. 8 patients were treated
through balloon dilation and 2 patients underwent
surgical treatment (myotomy through laparoscopy).
All these cases had similar manometric modifications,
before and after treatment (as listed in Table III); as
expected, only basal pressure of the lower esophageal
sphincter was modified after treatment. The severity
of the symptoms decreased in all cases, all patients
reporting the amelioration of dysphagia.
Manometric diagnostic for the patients with dysphagia
Disorder
Achalasia
94 patients
35 (37.3 %)
Diffuse esophageal spasm
10 (10.6%)
Hyperperistaltic esophagus
9 (9.6%)
Nonspecific motility disorders
32 (34.0%)
8 (8.5%)
Normal manometry
The majority of patients (80%) had an
increased basal pressure in the lower esophageal
sphincter (LES) and the rest of them had a normal
pressure of the LES. None of these patients had
complete LES relaxation during deglutition. Absence
of the lower esophageal sphincter relaxation or
incomplete relaxation were observed in all cases.
Regarding the peristalsis of the esophageal
body, aperistalsis was found in 33 patients and
2 patients presented hyperperistalsis of the tubular
esophagus. So, from 35 cases of achalasia, 94.3%
had a typical form, while 5.7% corresponded to
vigorous, atypical achalasia (Table II).
Table II
Manometric changes in patients with achalasia
MANOMETRIC CHANGES
N (%)
LES pressure
LES hypertonia
28 (80%)
LES normotonia
7 (20%)
LES relaxation during deglutition time
Lack of LES relaxation
35 (100%)
LES relaxation
0
Peristalsis of the tubular esophagus
Normal peristalsis of tubular esophagus
0
Aperistalsis of tubular esophagus
33 (94.28%)
Hyperperistalsis of tubular esophagus
2 (5.71%)
We also evaluated the pressure in the upper
esophageal sphincter (UES). We identified 18 patients
with UES hypertonia (51.42%) and 17 patients
(48.58%) with normal pressure in the UES.
Table III
Manometric changes before and after treatment
Manometric
modifications
Pre-treatment
Post-treatment
LES hypertonia
present
reduced
LES relaxation
absent
absent
Tubular peristalsis
absent
absent
UES hypertonia
present
present
DISCUSSION
Achalasia, a primary esophageal motor disorder,
is characterized by the absence of esophageal
peristalsis especially in the distal two-thirds (smooth
muscle) and impaired lower esophageal sphincter
(LES) relaxation due to damage to the myenteric
plexus. It is a rare disease affecting both genders
with a prevalence of < 1/10.000 and an incidence of
1/100 000 [5]. In addition to the typical symptom of
dysphagia for both liquids and solids, patients may
initially present with chest pain and regurgitation.
Diagnosis is typically delayed 2–3 years from the
beginning of symptoms [1].
Esophageal manometry is indicated in patients
whose symptoms and other investigations, for
example, endoscopy or radiologic studies, suggest a
motor disorder. Manometric studies are usually
second- or third-line investigations following initial
assessment by radiology and endoscopy [4]. Until
now, esophageal manometry remains the gold
standard in diagnosing achalasia [1].
Motor function can be assessed by a variety of
recording techniques including radiology, scintigraphy
manometry, and most recently intraluminal electrical
impedance monitoring. Some of these are complementary.
Manometric measurement of esophageal pressure is
the most direct method for assessment of motor
function. Only manometry can give information on
the strength of contractions. However, when the
diagnosis requires information about intraluminal
3
Esophageal achalasia
flow, this can be obtained by complementary
measurement of transit by radiology, scintigraphy,
or intraluminal impedance monitoring [4].
The typical manometric features in achalasia
are as follows:
1. Incomplete lower esophageal sphincteric relaxation
with swallowing. Whereas the normal sphincter
relaxes by over 90%, relaxation with most
swallows in patients with achalasia is less than
50% [4][6][7].
2. Complete absence of peristalsis; swallowing
results in simultaneous waves that are usually
of low amplitude.
Additional features that are often encountered
but that are not in themselves diagnostic are an
increased basal intraesophageal pressure that is
higher than intragastric pressure, and an increased
basal LES pressure (in about 50% of patients) [4].
In cases of achalasia that are established by all
available clinical criteria, the defining manometric
features (aperistalsis and incomplete LES relaxation)
are present in >90% of patients. Other manometric
features (increased intraesophageal baseline pressure
or isobaric waveforms) provide supportive evidence
to improve the suspicion rate [8].
Variations in the manometric features occur
between patients, which makes manometric diagnosis
difficult, and manometric findings should always
be considered in the context of the clinical
radiologic and endoscopic findings.
Impaired LES relaxation is frequently observed.
It may be difficult to pass the manometric assembly
through the esophagogastric junction. The nadir
pressure threshold that defines incomplete
relaxation depends on the method of analysis of
LES pressure, and whether end-expiration, midexpiration, or average LES pressure is used.
Typically there is partial relaxation [4]. Normal
LES relaxation is commonly believed to be
“complete”. However, it is usual for there to be a
small nadir pressure of up to 7 mmHg even
at maximal relaxation [6][7][9]. With a sleeve
sensor, the duration of LES relaxation is usually
<8 seconds [9]. Our results are similar with data
from literature; in our study all patients with
achalasia had impaired lower esophageal sphincter
relaxation. Complete relaxation was not observed
in any of the cases.
In achalasia, occasionally relaxation may
appear to be complete [10][11]. However, in such
instances careful inspection of the LES recording
usually reveals subtle abnormalities such as a
245
delayed onset and shortened duration of relaxation,
and relaxation appears to be functionally
inadequate [12][13].
Aperistalsis is the other cardinal feature of
achalasia; it is considered a “sine qua non” condition
in order to diagnose achalasia. Classically, the
esophageal body is characterized by only lowamplitude (<30 mmHg) simultaneous isobaric
pressure waves [1]. In our study more than 94% of
patients with achalasia showed no peristalsis in
tubular esophagus and they were diagnosed with a
typical form of achalasia.
A few patients have wave amplitudes within
or above the normal range. When the average
contraction amplitude is above 37 mmHg, the term
“vigorous” achalasia is used [14][15]. Reported
frequencies about vigorous achalasia in literature
varies from 1.5% (in studies using high resolution
manometry) [16] to 31% [17]. From our 35 patients
with achalasia, only 2 patients (less than 6%) had
atypical, vigorous form of achalasia. The relevance
of this sub classification remains unclear as the
prognostic and therapeutic value of this separation
are controversial [17].
Occasionally, the pattern of esophageal
motility may mimic a diffuse spasm, and overlap
between achalasia and diffuse spasm has been
reported [18]. The aperistaltic segment usually
involves the entire esophageal body. However,
partial preservation of peristalsis may be present in
the proximal esophagus [4].
A hypertensive LES (i.e. basal LES pressure
>45 mmHg) may be present and occasionally
increased intraesophageal basal pressure above the
intraabdominal pressure is observed [8][19]. This is
a consequence of esophageal retention and it often
disappears if the patient regurgitates retained
esophageal contents or excess fluid is aspirated
from the esophagus during the manometry. Up to
40% of the patients with achalasia have normal LES
pressure (10–40 mm Hg); however, low pressure LES
is not seen in untreated achalasia patients [20].
The majority of our patients with achalasia (80%) had
an increased basal LES pressure, while 7 out of
35 patients had a normal basal LES pressure. Our
results regarding LES resting pressure are similar
with data from literature.
Differential diagnosis of manometrical changes
in achalasia includes pseudoachalasia. Manometrically
the features are the same and the diagnosis depends
on clinical, radiologic, and endoscopic features.
Severe peristaltic failure and complete aperistalsis
246
D.L. Dumitraşcu et al.
may also be seen in patients with connective tissue
diseases such as scleroderma, amyloidosis, and
diabetes mellitus, and in reflux disease. However, in
such patients, basal LES pressure is typically very
low, LES relaxation is complete, and there is no
increase in basal intraesophageal pressure [21][22].
Laparoscopic myotomy of and pneumatic
balloon dilatations of the lower esophageal
sphincter are considered definitive treatments for
achalasia. Both treatment options offer sustained
clinical responses, but are in fact palliative
treatments. Botulinum toxin injection in the lower
esophageal sphincter is considered an acceptable
alternative in patients who are not candidates for
surgery or balloon dilatation. Pharmacologic therapies
for achalasia offer mild, transient improvement at best
[1]. After treatment, patients should be followed up
regularly (yearly) in order to identify disease
progression early and avoid the development of the
end-stage disease when esophagectomy may become
the only treatment option.
In order to monitor the success of the
therapeutic intervention and to detect disease
recurrence prior to the development of symptoms,
Vaezi et al. proposed the “timed barium swallow”.
It consists of the ingestion of 50-100 ml of barium
with plain thoracic radiographs taken at 1, 2 and 5
minutes. Measuring the height of the barium
column at these time intervals allows quantifying
the degree of esophageal bolus retention [23].
4
The role of manometry in post-treatment
surveillance remains controversial. Curing achalasia
would mean restoring esophageal peristalsis and
restoring the neurons of the myenteric plexus [1].
We repeated manometry in 10 patients one month
after treatment and we did not find significant
manometric changes compared to pre-treatment
manometric studies. Only the basal LES pressure
decreased, secondary to the rupture of muscle
fibers. We did not evaluate these patients a year
after treatment.
The patients included in our study were
referred to manometry department so they were
previously selected (using endoscopic and radiologic
studies). All of the patients had dysphagia, so the high
number of patients diagnosed with achalasia and
other esophageal motility disorders in this study
cannot be used to determine the prevalence and
incidence of these diseases in our region.
In conclusion our results showed that in achalasia
the majority of patients have incomplete or no
relaxation of LES; the peristalsis in esophageal
body is usually absent; only in rare cases the
amplitude of waves in esophagus are increased
(vigorous achalasia); the basal LES pressure is
higher than normal. It seems that therapy does not
modify the pattern of esophageal motility at the
level of the esophageal body.
Achalasia este o tulburare de motilitate esofagiană primară implicând corpul
şi sfincterul esofagian inferior (SEI). Manometria esofagiană este standardul de
aur în diagnosticul achalasiei. Două caracteristici cardinale apar în achalasie:
relaxare incompletă a SEI şi absenţa peristaltismului în corpul esofagian. Într-un
grup de 94 pacienţi cu disfagie s-au urmărit modificările manometrice pentru
identificarea particularităţilor clinice şi manometrice ale achalasiei. 35 de cazuri
au prezentat modificări manometrice compatibile cu achalasia. Alţi 41 pacienţi au
prezentat alte tulburări de motilitate esofagiană şi 8 au prezentat manometrie
esofagiană normală. Majoritatea pacienţilor (80%) au prezentat creşterea
presiunii bazale a SEI, restul au avut presiunea SEI normală. Absenţa relaxării
SEI sau relaxarea incompletă s-a observat în toate cazurile. Aperistaltismul a fost
identificat la 33 pacienţi (94,3%) şi 2 (5,7%) au prezentat hiperperistaltism al
esofagului tubular. În 10 cazuri s-a efectuat manometrie postterapeutic: presiunea
bazală a SEI a fost modificată de tratament, motilitatea pe esofagul tubular nu a
fost modificată.
Corresponding author: D.L. Dumitraşcu, Professor
2nd Department of Internal Medicine
2–4, Clinicilor Str., 4000 Cluj-Napoca, Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
5
Esophageal achalasia
247
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
POHL D., TUTUIAN R., Achalasia: an overview of diagnosis and treatment. J. Gastrointestin. Liver Dis., 2007; 16(3):297–303.
DUNTEMANN T.J., DRESNER D.M., Achalasia-like syndrome presenting after highly selective vagotomy. Dig. Dis. Sci.,
1995; 40(9):2081–3.
CASSELLA R.R., BROWN A.L., SAYRE G.P., ELLIS F.H., Achalasia of the esophagus: pathologic and etiologic
considerations. Ann. Surg., 1964 Sep., 160:474–87.
HOLLOWAY R.H., Esophageal manometry. Review. GI Motility online [serial online] 2006 [cited September 2008] Available
from: URL: http://www.nature.com/gimo/contents/pt1/full/gimo30.html
MAYBERRY J.F.. Epidemiology and demographics of achalasia. Gastrointest. Endosc. Clin. N. Am., 2001; 11:235–248.
PANDOLFINO J.E., KAHRILAS P.J.; American Gastroenterological Association. AGA technical review on the clinical use of
esophageal manometry. Gastroenterology, 2005; 128(1):209–24.
CASTELL J., Esophageal Manometry. In: Schuster Atlas of Gastrointestinal Motility, 2002, 69–86.
McCORD G.S., STAIANO A., CLOUSE R.E., Achalasia, diffuse esophageal spasm and non-specific motor disorders.
Baillieres Clin. Gastroenterol., 1991; 5(2):307–35.
HOLLOWAY R.H., PENAGINI R., IRELAND A.C., Criteria for objective definition of transient lower esophageal sphincter
relaxation. Am. J. Physiol., 1995(1 Pt 1); 268:G128–33.
HIRANO I., TATUM R.P., SHI G., SANG Q., JOEHL R.J., KAHRILAS P.J., Manometric heterogeneity in patients with
idiopathic achalasia. Gastroenterology, 2001; 120(4):789–98.
KATZ P.O., RICHTER J.E., COWAN R., CASTELL D.O., Apparent complete lower esophageal sphincter relaxation in
achalasia. Gastroenterology, 1986; 90(4):978–83.
STAIANO A., CLOUSE R.E., Detection of incomplete lower esophageal sphincter relaxation with conventional point-pressure
sensors. Am. J. Gastroenterol., 2001; 96(12):3258–67.
MEARIN F., MALAGELADA J.R., Complete lower esophageal sphincter relaxation observed in some achalasia patients is
functionally inadequate. Am. J. Physiol., 2000; 278(3):G376–83
TODORCZUK J.R., ALIPERTI G., STAIANO A., CLOUSE R.E., Reevaluation of manometric criteria for vigorous achalasia.
Is this a distinct clinical disorder? Dig. Dis. Sci., 1991; 36(3):274–8.
GOLDENBERG S.P., BURRELL M., FETTE G.G., VOS C., TRAUBE M., Classic and vigorous achalasia: a comparison of
manometric, radiographic, and clinical findings. Gastroenterology, 1991; 101(3):743–8.
KAHRILAS P.J., GHOSH S.K., PANDOLFINO J.E., Esophageal motility disorders in terms of pressure topography: the
Chicago Classification. J. Clin. Gastroenterol., 2008; 42(5):627–35.
CAMACHO-LOBATO L., KATZ P.O., EVELAND J., VELA M., CASTELL D.O., Vigorous achalasia: Original description
requires minor change. J. Clin. Gastroenterol., 2001; 33(5):375–7.
VANTRAPPEN G., JANSSENS J., HELLEMANS J., COREMANS G., Achalasia, diffuse spasm and related motility
disorders. Gastroenterology, 1979; 76(3):450–7.
HIRANO I., TATUM R.P., SHI G., SANG Q., JOEHL R.J., KAHRILAS P.J., Manometric heterogeneity in patients with
idiopathic achalasia. Gastroenterology, 2001; 120(4):789–98.
VANTRAPPEN G., VANGOIDSENHOVEN G.E., VERBEKE S., VANDENBERGHE G., VANDERBROUCKE J.,
Manometric studies in achalasia of the cardia, before and after pneumatic dilations. Gastroenterology, 1963 Sep., 45:317–25.
KAHRILAS P.J., KISHK S.M., HELM J.F., DODDS W.J., HARIG J.M., HOGAN W.J., Comparison of pseudoachalasia and
achalasia. Am. J. Med., 1987; 82(3):439–46.
TRACEY J.P., TRAUBE M., Difficulties in the diagnosis of pseudoachalasia. Am. J. Gastroenterol., 1994; 89(11):2014–18.
VAEZI M.F., BAKER M.E., ACHKAR E., RICHTER J.E., Timed barium oesophagram: better predictor of long term success
after pneumatic dilation in achalasia than symptom assessment. Gut, 2002; 50(6):765–70.
Received June 12, 2009
248
D.L. Dumitraşcu et al.
6
Incidence and Type of Stroke in Patients with Diabetes.
Comparison Between Diabetics and Nondiabetics
DUMITRAăăB LAN¹,ăăP.A.ăBABE޲ă
1
ăEmergencyăCountyăHospital,ăVâlcea,ăRomaniaă
ăFacultyăofăMedicine,ăOradeaăUniversity,ăRomaniaă
2
Background. Strokeă isă theă thirdă causeă ofă death,ă afteră heartă diseaseă andă cancer.ă Diabetesă
mellitusăisăoneăofătheăriskăfactorsăforăstrokeăandăitsăincidenceăisăincreasing,ăleadingătoăanăaccentuationă
ofătheăriskăofăstroke.ăWeăexploredătheărelationshipăbetweenădiabetesăandătypesăofăstroke,ăriskăfactorsă
forătheălatterăone,ăbothăinăsubjectsăwithădiabetesăandăinăthoseăwithoutădiabetes.ă
Methods.ă Theă studyă wasă conductedă onă twoă groupsă thată includedă 228ă subjects;ă groupă 1–136ă
diabetică patientsă andă strokeă recentlyă installed;ă groupă 2–92ă patientsă withoută diabetesă bută strokeă
recentlyă installed,ă hospitalizedă ină theă Neurologică Departmentă ofă theă Countyă Emergencyă Hospital,ă
Vâlceaăduringă2006–2008.ă
Onăeveryăbatchăweăhaveămadeăbiochemicalămeasurements:ăglycemică profile,ălipidăprofile,ăweă
haveăestablishedănormalăvaluesăforăeveryăgroupă(nondiabeticsăandădiabeticăsubjects),ăweădeterminedă
theătypeăandălocationăofăstrokeăasătheăresultăofăCT.ă
Statisticală analysisă wasă performedă usingă SPSSă 15ă foră Windowsă application,ă adaptedă toă
processingă medicală statistics.ă Theyă calculatedă theă averageă ofă theă parameters,ă standardă deviation,ă
standardădeviationăofătheăaverage,ăfrequencyăranges,ătablesăfrequencyătestsăofăstatisticalăsignificanceă
byăStudentămethodă(tătest),ăandăcalculationăofăHi2ăscore.ăWeăcalculatedăPearsonăcorrelationăcoefficientsăthată
weăhaveăinterpretedăusingătheărulesăofăColton.ă
Results.ă Ină bothă groupsă ischaemică strokeă predominatedă –ă 116ă (85%)ă casesă ină diabeticsă andăă
68ă (74%)ă casesă ină nondiabetics;ă haemorrhagică strokeă wasă approximatelyă equală ină diabeticsă andă
nondiabeticsă20ă(15%)ăcasesăvs.ă24ă(26%)ăcases.ăTheăaverageăageăwasăsignificantlyăhigherăinăgroupă2ă
versusăgroupă1ă(pă=ă0.026*).ăMostăofătheă2ndăgroupăsubjectsăareăfromăruralăareas,ăwhileăină1stăgroupă
theyă areă fromă theă urbană areas.ă Hypertensionă wasă mostlyă aă pre-existingă riskă factoră ină bothă groups.ă
Serumă lipidă wasă overă theă valuesă recommendedă ină bothă groups.ă Theă indexă ofă insulinoresistance,ă
materializedăbyăHOMA-IR,ăwasăpresentăină80%ăofăsubjectsăofă1stăgroupăandăină52%ăofăsubjectsăofătheă
2ndă group.ă Theă incidenceă rateă ofă strokeă wasă muchă higheră ină diabetică populationă thană ină theă
nondiabeticsăbetweenă2006ăandă2008.ăă
Conclusions.ăStrokeăisăinstalledăatăaăyoungerăageăinădiabeticăsubjectsăthanăinănondiabeticăonesă
andăităisămoreăfrequentăinănondiabeticămales;ăinsulinoresistanceăisăaăriskăfactorăpresentăinăbothăgroups,ă
butăweăfoundăaăstatisticalăsignificanceăonlyăinăgroupă2.ă
Key words:ădiabetes,ăischaemicăstroke,ăhaemorrhagicăstroke,ăriskăfactor.ă
Diabetesă mellitusă isă associatedă withă ană
increasedă riskă ofă atherosclerotică vasculară diseases,ă
includingă cerebrovasculară disease.ă Thisă increaseă isă
probablyătheărelationshipăbetweenătheăsideăeffectsăofă
hyperglycaemiaă ină associationă withă otheră riskă
factors,ăsuchăas:ăhypertension,ădyslipidaemia,ăobesity,ă
etc.ăMorbidityăandămortalityăinăatheroscleroticădiseaseă
appearătoăbeăhigherăinădiabeticăpatientsăasăcomparedă
toă nondiabetics.ă WHOă estimatesă thată 16.6ă millionă
peopleăworldwideădieăofăcardiovascularădiseaseăeveryă
year,ăwhichăisătheăthirdăcauseăofădeath.ăă
Otheră 15ă millionă persons/yeară haveă aă minoră
strokeăandă600ămillionăpeopleăwithăhypertensionăhaveă
ROM.ăJ.ăINTERN.ăMED.,ă2009,ă47,ă3,ă249–255ă
ă
aăriskăforăheartăfailureăorăstroke.ăCardiovascularădiseasesă
areă responsibleă foră 76%ă ofă mortalityă ină diabetes,ă
55%ă ofă themă areă dueă toă ischaemică heartă disease,ă
andă12%ătoăstrokeăandăcerebrovascularădisease.ă
OBJECTIVESă
Startingă fromă theseă facts,ă weă establishedă theă
followingăobjectives:ă
• toă studyă theă incidenceă andă typeă ofă strokeă ină
patientsăwithădiabetesăasăcomparedătoănondiabetică
subjects,ă fromă theă sameă geographicală areaă –ă aă
comparativeăstudyăinăpatientsăwithădiabetesăandă
250ă
ă
•
DumitraăB lanăandăP.A.ăBabeşă
strokeă recentlyă installedă (groupă 1)ă andă patientsă
withoutădiabetesăbutăwhoăhaveărecentlyăinstalledă
strokeă(groupă2);ă
toă compareă theă incidenceă rateă ofă theă stroke,ă
duringă3ăyearsă(2006–2008)ăinădiabeticăpopulationă
andăgeneralăpopulation.ăă
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Theăstudyăwasăconductedăonătwoăgroupsăthată
includedă228ăsubjects:ăgroupă1–136ădiabeticăpatientsă
andăstrokeărecentlyăinstalledăandăgroupă2–92ăpatientsă
withoută diabetes,ă bută havingă recentlyă installedă
stroke,ă hospitalizedă ină theă Neurologică Departmentă
ofă theă Countyă Emergencyă Hospitală Vâlcea,ă ină theă
periodă2006–2008.ă
Theă diagnosisă ofă strokeă wasă madeă basedă onă
clinicală data,ă andă cerebrală CT.ă Groupă 1ă includedă
136ă patientsă withă diabetesă andă strokeă recentlyă
installed;ă thereă wereă notă includedă ină theă studyă
patientsăwithăhistoryăofătransitoryăischaemicăattackă
oră recurrentă stroke.ă Theă dataă wereă collectedă fromă
theăclinicalădataăsheet:ăCT,ălipidăprofile,ăglycaemică
profile,ăHbA1c,ăinsulinemia,ăCăpeptide.ă
Groupă 2ă includedă 92ă nondiabetică patients,ă
admittedă ină theă sameă periodă ină theă Departmentă ofă
Neurologyă –ă Countyă Emergencyă Hospitală Vâlcea.ă
Groupă 2ă wasă formedă afteră groupă 1,ă bută wasă notă
orderedăbyăage,ăsexăandăhomeăenvironment,ăasăweă
consideredă necessaryă toă determineă theă impactă ofă
diabetesămellitusăasăriskăfactorăinădiabeticăpopulationă
thană ină nondiabeticsă andă theă presenceă ofă otheră riskă
factorsă ină nondiabetică population.ă Patientsă withă IFGă
orăIGTăhistory,ăhistoryăofăischaemicătransitoryăstrokeă
orărecurrentăstroke,ăwereănotăincludedăinătheăstudy.ăInă
theăstudyăprotocol,ăpatientsăhaveăreportedădataărelatedă
to:ă age,ă gender,ă homeă environment,ă BMI,ă personală
historyă ofă pathologyă (hypertension,ă heartă disease),ă
regulară submissionă toă theă specialistă (periodică visits),ă
theătypeăofădiabetesăandăantidiabeticătherapyăused,ătheă
systolică andă diastolică bloodă pressure.ă Computerizedă
tomographyă (CT)ă wasă performedă withină theă firstă
36–48ă hoursă afteră admission.ă Onlyă seriousă cases,ă
whichă usuallyă haveă haemorrhagică stroke,ă wereă
examinedă withină 24ă hours.ă Weă determinedă theă
followingăbiochemicalăparameters:ăfastingăandăpostprandială glycaemia,ă totală cholesterol,ă LDL-chol.,ă
HDL-chol.,ă Col/ă HDLă ratio,ă triglycerides.ă Weă
determinedă HbA1c,ă theă fastingă plasmaă insulin,ă weă
calculatedăHOMA-IRăindex.ăWeămadeăaăcomparisonă
betweenă typesă ofă strokeă ină theă twoă groupsă andă
ă
2ă
calculatedă theă riskă factorsă foră eachă typeă ofă stroke.ă
Theă statisticsă testsă wereă calculatedă usingă statisticală
softwareăSPSSă15ăforăWindows.ăForăsomeăcasesăweă
usedă Epiinfoă 2000,ă epidemiologicală software.ă
Confidenceă intervalsă associatedă toă theă variablesă ină
theă studyă wereă calculatedă foră aă thresholdă ofă
significanceă ofă 5%ă basedă onă aă methodă usingă
bionominalădistribution.ă
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Inătheăischemicăstrokeăweăfoundăaăstatisticallyă
significantă differenceă ă betweenă theă ageă ofă subjectsă
fromă groupsă 1ă andă 2ă (pă <0.05*)(Tableă I),ă ină theă
diabeticăgroupăofăsubjectsăităwasăfoundătheăaverageă
ageă ofă 67.53 ± 8.1ă years,ă andă ină nondiabetică
subjectsă 70.50 ± 9.45ă yearsă (Tableă II).ă Theă sameă
statisticallyăsignificantădifferenceă(pă<0.05)(TableăIII)ă
wasă foundă ină theă caseă ofă haemorrhagică stroke,ă theă
averageăageăofădiabeticăsubjectsăwasă63ă±ă7.2ăyears,ă
andăthatăofănondiabeticsă69.5ă±ă10.8ăyearsă(TableăIV).ă
Inătheădiabeticăpopulation,ăstrokeăwasăinstalledăearlier,ă
andă asă thisă isă well-known,ă diabetesă acceleratesă theă
atherosclerosis.ăComparingătheăvaluesăofăfastingăandă
postprandială glycaemiaă ofă theă twoă groups,ă foră bothă
typesă ofă stroke,ă weă foundă statisticallyă significantă
differencesă(pă<0.05)ă(TablesăIăandăIII).ă
Ină theă firstă group,ă glycosylatedă haemoglobină
hadăapproximatelyătheăsameăvalue,ăinăsubjectsăwithă
ischemicăandăhaemorrhagicăstrokeă(8.6%ă±ă1.3ăvs.ă8,ă
5ă±ă1.5%);ăinătheăsecondăgroup,ăallătheăsubjectsăhadă
normală valuesă ofă theă HbA1c.ă Statisticală analysisă
showedă aă statisticallyă significantă differenceă betweenă
groups,ă ină bothă ischemică andă haemorrhagică strokeăă
(pă<0.05*)ă(TablesăIăandăIII).ăFastingăinsulinemiaăhadă
approximatelyătheăsameăvaluesăinăsubjectsăwithăstrokeă
inăbothăgroups,ălackingăinăanyăstatisticalăsignificance.ă
Inăsubjectsăwithăhaemorrhagicăstroke,ăinsulinemiaă
wasăhigherăinătheăgroupă1ăasăcomparedăwithăgroupă2ă
(19.37ă ±ă 16.21ă µUI/mLă vs.ă 10.43ă ±ă 4.06ă µUI/mL)ă
(Tableă IV),ă aă statisticallyă significantă differenceă
(p=0.013*)ă(TableăIII).ăTheăaverageăplasmaăcholesterolă
wasă significantlyă increasedă ină subjectsă withă diabetesă
andă ischaemică strokeă asă comparedă withă nondiabeticsă
(233.28ă ±ă 47.81ă mg/dLă vs.ă 215.74ă ±ă 36.79ă mg/dL,ă
p=0.01*)ă (Tablesă Iă andă II).ă Aă statisticallyă significantă
differenceă wasă foundă ină subjectsă withă haemorrhagică
stroke,ă comparingă theă twoă groups,ă bută hereă theă
averageă plasmaă cholesterolă wasă higheră ină groupă 2ă
(214.83ă±ă33.01ămg/dLăvs.ă180.40ă±ă66.91ămg/dL,ă
p=0.046*)(Tableă III).ă Hypertriglyceridemia,ă theă dys-
3ă
251
Strokeăandădiabetesă
lipidemiaăcommonăofădiabetesămellitus,ăwasăfoundăină
diabetică subjectsă withă ischemică strokeă (199.07ă ±ă
124.03ă mg/dL),ă bută notă ină nondiabetică subjectsă withă
ischemicăstrokeă(129.21ă±ă64.07ămg/dL);ăbetweenătheă
twoă groupsă thereă wasă aă statisticallyă significantă
differenceă(pă<0.05)ă(TablesăIăandăII).ă
Table I
TheăStudentătestă(comparisonăbetweenăgroupsăwithăischemicăstroke)ă
Data
Ageă
FastingăGlucoseă
PostprandialăGlucoseă
HbA1că
Insulinemiaă
Totalăcholesterolă
Triglyceridesă
LDL-cholesterolă
HDL-cholesterolă
Systolicăbloodăpressureă
Diastolicăbloodăpressureă
BMIă
p value
Confidence interval 95%
0.026*ă
<<0.05*ă
<<0.05*ă
<<0.05*ă
0.25ă
0.01*ă
<<0.05*ă
0.026*ă
372ă
731ă
0.925ă
0.557ă
[–5.56;ă–0.36]ă
[85.47;115.67]ă
[123.30;156.87]ă
[318.49;382.31]ă
[–[110.33;420.52]ă
[4.32;ă30.75]ă
[37.86;ă101.86]ă
[1.26;ă19.80]ă
[–3.2;ă1.20]ă
[–6.06;ă8.62]ă
[–3.98;ă3.61]ă
[–0.83;ă1.54]ă
ăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăăp<0.05*ă
Table II
ăComparisonăbetweenăgroupă1ăandăgroupă2ăwithăischemicăstrokeă
Group Statisticsă
Age
Fasting Glucose
Postprandial Glycaemia
HbA1c
Insulinemia
Cholesterolemia
Triglycerides
LDL-chol
HDL-chol
Systolic BP
Diastolic BP
BMI
Group
N
Mean
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
116ă
68ă
67.53ă
70.50ă
193.98ă
93.41ă
245.62ă
105.53ă
8.5776ă
5.0735ă
13.7833ă
12.2324ă
233.28ă
215.74ă
199.07ă
129.21ă
131.91ă
121.38ă
40.21ă
41.21ă
159.22ă
157.94ă
87.76ă
87.94ă
28.41ă
28.06ă
Std. Deviation Std. Error Mean
8.100ă
9.455ă
80.889ă
11.017ă
89.606ă
13.477ă
1.52453ă
.64336ă
10.83365ă
7.36347ă
47.481ă
36.790ă
124.300ă
64.078ă
35.240ă
20.941ă
8.723ă
6.324ă
26.732ă
19.666ă
11.765ă
13.936ă
4.261ă
3.341ă
.752ă
1.147ă
7.510ă
1.336ă
8.320ă
1.634ă
.14155ă
.07802ă
1.00588ă
.89295ă
4.408ă
4.461ă
11.541ă
7.771ă
3.272ă
2.539ă
.810ă
.767ă
2.482ă
2.385ă
1.092ă
1.690ă
.396ă
.405ă
Standardădeviationă=ă±ă2SDă
ă
252ă
ă
DumitraăB lanăandăP.A.ăBabeşă
4ă
Table III
TheăStudentătestă(comparisonăbetweenăgroupsăwithăhaemorrhagicăstroke)ă
Data
Ageă
FastingăGlucoseă
PostprandialăGlucoseă
HbA1că
Insulinemiaă
Totalăcholesterolă
p value
0.026*ă
<<0.05*ă
<<0.05*ă
<<0.05*ă
0.25ă
0.01*ă
Confidence interval 95%
[–5,56;ă–0,36]ă
[85,47;115,67]ă
[123,30;156,87]ă
[318,49;382,31]ă
[–[110,33;420,52]ă
[4,32;ă30,75]ă
Triglyceridesă
LDL-cholesterolă
HDL-cholesterolă
Systolicăbloodăpressureă
Diastolicăbloodăpressureă
BMIă
<<0.05*ă
0.026*ă
0.372ă
0.731ă
0.925ă
0.557ă
[37,86;ă101,86]ă
[1,26;ă19,80]ă
[–3,2;ă1,20]ă
[–6,06;ă8,62]ă
[–3,98;ă3,61]ă
[–0,83;ă1,54]ă
p<0.05*ă
Ină subjectsă withă haemorrhagică stroke,ă theă
triglycerideă values,ă ină theă comparisonă ofă twoă
groups,ă didă notă reveală anyă statisticallyă significantă
difference.ă Plasmaă triglycerideă valuesă wereă higheră
ină subjectsă withă ischaemică strokeă thană ină subjectsă
withăhaemorrhagicăstroke.ă
TheăaverageăvaluesăofăLDL-chol.ăwereăincreasedă
ină subjectsă withă diabetesă andă ischemică strokeă vs.ă
nondiabeticsă (131.91ă ±ă 35.24ă mg/dLă vs.ă 121.38ă ±ă
20.94ămg/dL)ăwithăaăstatisticallyăsignificantădifferenceă
(pă =ă 0.026*)ă (Tableă I).ă Weă foundă aă statisticallyă
significantădifferenceă(pă=ă0.026*)ăwhenăweăcomparedă
subjectsă withă haemorrhagică strokeă fromă theă twoă
groups,ă bută LDL-chol.ă wasă increasedă ină nondiabeticsă subjectsă (119.50ă ±ă 19.37ă mg/dLă vs.ă
104.20ă±ă23.61ămg/dL)ă(TableăIV).ăă
Systolicăbloodăpressureăvaluesăwereăapproximatelyă
equalăinăsubjectsăwithăischemicăstrokeăinăbothăgroups,ă
bută muchă loweră asă comparedă toă subjectsă withă
hemorrhagică stroke.ă Thus,ă ină theă diabetică subjectsăă
andăischaemicăstroke,ăaverageăsystolicăbloodăpressureă
wasă159.22ă±ă26.73ămmHg,ăandăinădiabeticăsubjectsă
withă haemorrhagică stroke,ă theă averageă wasă 200ă ±ăă
29.73ă mmHg;ă ină nondiabetică subjectsă weă foundă theă
sameă difference:ă 157.94ă ±ă 19.66ă mmHgă ină patientsă
withă ischemică strokeă andă 195.83ă ±ă 27.80ă mmHgă ină
patientsă withă hemorrhagică stroke.ă Thereă wereă noă
statisticallyă significantă differencesă betweenă subjectsă
withăischaemicăorăhaemorrhagicăstrokeăinăbothăgroups.ă
Diastolicăbloodăpressureăvaluesăwereăapproximatelyă
equală ină bothă groupsă ofă subjects.ă Weă haveă notă foundă
significantădifferencesăbetweenăgroupsăbyătypeăofăstroke,ă
asă regardsă theă distributionă ofă BMI;ă subjectsă withă
diabetesă andă ischemică strokeă hadă aă meană ofă BMIă –ă
28.41ă±ă4.26ăkg/m2,ăandănondiabeticăsubjectsă–ă28.06ă
±ă3.34ăkg/m2ă(TableăII).ă
ă
Thereăwereănoăstatisticallyăsignificantădifferencesă
ină subjectsă ofă theă twoă groupsă withă haemorrhagică
stroke,ă bută diabetică subjectsă hadă aă meană ofă BMIă
greateră (31.9ă ±ă 4.75ă kgă /ă m2)ă thană nondiabeticsă
subjectsă(30.25ă±ă3.33ăkg/m2).ă
Theă riskă factorsă foră ischaemică strokeă ină theă
diabeticăgroupăăwere:ătheăruralăareaă(RRă=ă1.160,ăORă=ă
2.87,ă pă =ă 0.038),ă plasmaă totală cholesterolă (RRă =ă
1.561,ăORă=ă7.28,ăp<0.05*),ăplasmaătriglyceridesă(RRă=ă
1.193,ăORă=ă3.08ăpă=ă0.02*);ăchol.total/HDL-chol.ratioă
(RRă =ă 3.653,ă ORă =ă 24.43,ă p<0.05*);ă systolică bloodă
pressureă(RRă=ă1.631,ăORă=ă7.67,ăpă<ă0.05*);ădiastolică
bloodă pressureă (RRă =ă 1.253,ă ORă =ă 3.56,ă pă <0.05*);ă
postprandială glycaemiaă (RRă =ă 1.098,ă ORă =ă 2.59,ăă
p <<0.05*).ăForăhaemorrhagicăstrokeănoăriskăfactoră
withăstatisticalăsignificanceăwasăfound.ă
Riskă factorsă foră hemorrhagică strokeă ină nondiabeticăsubjectsăwere:ăfemaleă(RRă=ă3.412,ăORă=ă
5.556,ăp <<0.05*)ăandădiastolicăbloodăpressureă(RRă=ă
2.250,ăORă=ă3.375,ăpă=ă0.018*)ăandăischemicăstroke:ă
maleă(RRă=ă1.63,ăORă=ă5.56,ă pă<0.05*)ăandăinsulină
resistanceă determinedă byă HOMA-IRă indexă (RRă =ă
1.310,ă ORă =ă 2.86, pă =ă 0.032*).ă Weă calculatedă theă
incidenceărateăofăstrokeăinătheădiabeticăpopulationăandă
ină generală populationă onă theă overallă studyă periodă
(2006–2008)ă(Fig.ă1).ă
In conclusion ină bothă groups,ă theă ischemică
strokeă hasă predominated,ă bută riskă factorsă wereă notă
common,ă exceptingă foră diastolică bloodă pressure.ă Ină
group 1,ă theă riskă factorsă foră theă ischaemică strokeă
were:ăpostprandialăglycaemia,ăserumătotalăcholesterol,ă
LDL-cholesterol,ătotalăchol./HDL-chol.ăratio,ăsystolică
andădiastolicăbloodăpressureă andătriglycerides;ăinătheă
group 2, theă riskă factorsă foră theă ischaemică strokeă
were:ămaleăandăinsulinoresistanceă(byăHOMA-IR).ăă
5ă
253
Strokeăandădiabetesă
Table IV
Comparisonăbetweenăgroupă1ăandăgroupă2ăwithăhaemorrhagicăstrokeă
ă
Group Statisticsăă
group
N
Mean
1ă
20ă
2ă
24ă
1ă
Ageă
Fastingăglycaemiaă
Postprandialăglycaemiaă
HbA1că
Insulinemiaă
PeptideăCă
Cholesterolă
Triglyceridesă
LDL-Chol.ă
HDL-Chol.ă
SystolicăBPă
DiastolicăBPă
BMIă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
Fig.ă1.ă–ăComparisonăofăătwoăgroups.ă
ă
Std. Deviation
Std. Error Mean
63.00ă
7.226ă
1.616ă
69.50ă
10.863ă
2.217ă
20ă
200.80ă
61.704ă
13.797ă
2ă
24ă
92.50ă
10.571ă
2.158ă
1ă
20ă
253.60ă
88.040ă
19.686ă
2ă
24ă
118.75ă
26.742ă
5.459ă
1ă
20ă
8.6400ă
1.36667ă
.30560ă
2ă
24ă
5.4917ă
.76039ă
.15521ă
1ă
20ă
19.3700ă
16.21624ă
3.62606ă
2ă
24ă
10.4333ă
4.06733ă
.83024ă
1ă
20ă
3.5800ă
2.01667ă
.45094ă
2ă
24ă
3.1833ă
.39746ă
.08113ă
1ă
20ă
180.40ă
66.917ă
14.963ă
2ă
24ă
214.83ă
33.011ă
6.738ă
1ă
20ă
139.00ă
70.990ă
15.874ă
2ă
24ă
113.83ă
37.657ă
7.687ă
1ă
20ă
104.20ă
23.610ă
5.279ă
2ă
24ă
119.50ă
19.371ă
3.954ă
1ă
20ă
44.50ă
12.433ă
2.780ă
2ă
24ă
39.25ă
8.456ă
1.726ă
1ă
20ă
200.00ă
29.736ă
6.649ă
2ă
24ă
195.83ă
27.806ă
5.676ă
1ă
20ă
111.00ă
15.355ă
3.434ă
2ă
24ă
103.33ă
17.362ă
3.544ă
1ă
20ă
31.90ă
4.756ă
1.064ă
2ă
24ă
30.25ă
3.339ă
.682ă
254ă
ă
DumitraăB lanăandăP.A.ăBabeşă
Haemorrhagicăstrokeăwasămoreăfrequentăinăgroupă2,ăină
personsăoveră70ăyearsăandăriskăfactorsăwereăfemaleăandă
diastolică bloodă pressure.ă Subjectsă withă haemorrhagică
strokeă hadă aă greateră BMI,ă thană thoseă withă ischaemică
stroke.ăAverageăageăofănondiabeticăsubjectsăwithăstrokeă
wasăsignificantlyăhigherăthanăofădiabeticăsubjects.ăTheă
incidenceă rateă ofă stroke,ă calculatedă ină theă diabetică
populationăină2006–2008,ăwasămuchăhigherăthanăinătheă
generală populationă duringă theă sameă periodă (2006ă –ă
18.81‰ăvs.ă5.21‰;ă2007ă–ă27.15‰ăvs.ă6.9‰;ă2008ă–ă
16.64‰ăvs.ă6.85‰).ă
ă
Accidentul vascular cerebral este a treia cauză de deces, după bolile
cardiace şi cancer. Diabetul zaharat este unul dintre factorii de risc pentru
accidentul vascular cerebral şi incidenţa lui este în continuă creştere, ceea ce duce
la o accentuare a riscului de accident vascular cerebral. Studiul de faţă şi-a
propus să exploreze relaţia dintre diabetul zaharat, frecvenţa şi tipul de accident
vascular cerebral; factorii de risc pentru acesta, atât la subiecţii cu diabet zaharat,
cât şi la cei fără diabet.
Material şi metode. Studiul a fost efectuat pe două loturi, care au inclus 228
subiecţi; lotul 1–136 pacienţi cu diabet şi accident vascular cerebral recent
instalat şi lotul 2–92 pacienţi fără diabet zaharat şi accident vascular cerebral
recent instalat, internaţi în Secţia de Neurologie a Spitalului Judeţean de Urgenţă
Vâlcea în perioada 2006–2008. La fiecare lot am efectuat determinări biochimice
pentru a obiectiva profilul glicemic, profilul lipidic, insulinorezistenţa; am stabilit
valorile normale pentru lotul subiecţilor diabetici şi nediabetici, am stabilit tipul şi
localizarea accidentului vascular cerebral după rezultatul tomografiei computerizate.
Analiza statistică s-a efectuat cu ajutorul aplicaţiei SPSS 15 for Windows,
adaptată prelucrărilor statisticii medicale. S-au calculat medii ale parametrilor,
deviaţii standard, abaterea standard a mediei, intervale de frecvenţă, tabele de
frecvenţă, teste de semnificaţie statistică prin metoda Student (testul t), şi
calcularea scorului Hi pătrat. S-au calculat coeficienţi de corelaţie Pearson, care
s-au interpretat folosind regulile lui Colton.
Rezultate. În ambele loturi a predominat accidental vascular ischemic – 116
(85%) cazuri la subiecţii diabetici şi 68 (74%) cazuri la nediabetici, faţă de cel
hemoragic – 20 (15%) cazuri în lotul 1 şi 24 (26%) cazuri în lotul 2. Sexul masculin
a fost majoritar în lotul 2, în lotul 1 distribuţia fiind aproximativ egală. Vârsta medie
a fost semnificativ mai mare în lotul 2 faţă de lotul 1(p=0,026*). În lotul 2 au
predominat subiecţii din mediul rural, iar în lotul 1 cei din mediul urban. HTA a fost
majoritară ca factor de risc preexistent în ambele loturi. Valorile lipidelor
plasmatice au fost peste cele recomandate în ambele loturi. Insulinorezistenţa
obiectivată prin indicele HOMA-IR a fost prezentă la 80% dintre subiecţii lotului 1 şi
la 52% din subiecţii lotului 2.
Incidenţa accidentului vascular cerebral a fost mult mai mare în populaţia
diabetică decât în cea nediabetică în perioada 2006–2008.
Concluzii. Accidentul vascular cerebral se instalează la vârste mai tinere la
pacienţii cu diabet comparativ cu cei fără diabet, este mai frecvent la sexul
masculin la nediabetici, insulinorezistenţa este un factor de risc prezent în ambele
loturi, dar cu semnificaţie statistică doar în lotul 2.
ă
ă
ă
Corresponding author: DumitraăB lan,ăMDă
EmergencyăCountyăHospitalăVâlceaă
E-mail:ă
[email protected]ă
6ă
7ă
Strokeăandădiabetesă
255
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
WOLFă P.A.,ă D’AGOSTINOă R.B.,ă BELANGERă A.J.ă et al.,ă Probability of stroke: a risk profile from the Framingham study.ă
Stroke,ă1991; 22:313–318.ă
DEăFRONZOăR.A.,ăFERANNINIăE.,ăKEENăH.,ăZIMMETăP.,ăInternational Text Book of Diabetes Mellitus, thirdăed.ă2004,ăTHEă
WORLDăHEALTHăREPORTă–ă2002.ă
ABBOTă R.D.,ă DONAHUEă R.P.,ă MACMAHONă S.W.ă et al.,ă Diabetes and the risk of stroke: The Honolulu Heart Program.
Jama,ă1987;ă257:ă949–952.ă
FOLSOMăA.R,ăRASMUSSENăM.L.,ăCHAMBLESSăL.E.ăet al.,ăProspective associations of fasting insulin, body fat distribution
and diabetes with risk of ischemic stroke.ăDiabetesăCare,ă1999; 22:ă1077–1083.ă
DANESHăJ.,ăCOLLINSăR.,ăPETOăR., Chronic infection and coronary heart disease is there a link ?ăLancet,ă1997;ă350: 430–436.ă
ADACHIăH.,ăHIRAIăY.,ăTSURUTOăM.ăet al.,ăIs insulin resistance or diabetes mellitus associated with stroke?ăDiabetesăRes.ă
Clin.ăPract.,ă2001;ă51:ă215–223.ă
MACKNESSă M.I.,ă DURRINGTONă P.H.,ă MACKNESSă B.,ă How high density lipoprotein against the effect of lipid
peroxidation.ăCurr.ăOpin.ăLipidol.,ă2000; 11:ă383–388ă
CAPESăS.E.,ăHUNTăD.,ăMALMBERGăK.,ăPATHAKăP.,ăGERNSTEINăH.C.,ăStress hyperglycaemia and prognostic of stroke in
nondiabetic and diabetic patients. A systematic overview.ăStroke,ă2001;ă32:ă2426–2432.ă
PUSSINENăJ.P.,ăMETSOăJ.,ăMALLEăE.ăet al.,ăThe role of plasma phospholipid transfer protein (PLTP) in HDL remodelling in
acute-phase patients.ăBiochim.ăBiophys.ăActa, 2002;ă1533:ă153–163.ă
JAMROZIKăK.,ăBROADHURSTăR.J.,ăFORBESăS.ăet al.,ăPredictors of death and vascular events in the elderly.ăStroke,ă2000;ă
31:ă863–868.ă
KUUSISTOăJ.,ăMYKKANENăL.,ăPYORALAăK.,ăLAAKSOM.,ăNon-insulin-dependent diabetes and its metabolic control are
important predictors of stroke in elderly subjects.ăStroke, 1994;ă25:ă1157–1164.ă
HUăF.B.,ăSTAMPFERăM.J.,ăSOLOMONăC.G.ăet al.,ăThe impact of diabetes mellitus on mortality from all causes and coronary
heart disease in women.ăArch.ăIntern.ăMed.,ă2001;ă161:ă1717–1723.ă
ASIAăPACIFICăCOHORTăSTUDIES,ăCollaboration. Serum Triglycerides as a Risk Factor for Cardiovascular Disease in the
Asia-Pacific Region. Circulation,ă2004;ă110(17):ă2678–2686.ă
BOWMANă T.,ă SESSOă H.,ă MAă JING,ă KURTă T.,ă KOSEă C.,ă STAMPFERă M.,ă GAZIANOă J.M.,ă Cholesterol and the Risk of
Ischemic Stroke.ăStroke, 2003;ă34(12):ă2930–2934.ă
LAKKAăH.-M.,ăLAKKAăT.A.,ăTUOMILEHTONăJ.,ăSIVENIUSăJ.,ă SALLONENă J.T.,ă Hyperinsulinemia and the risk of
cardiovascular death and acute coronary and cerebrovascular events in men. The Kuopio Ischaemic Heart Disease Risk Factor
Study.ăArch.ăIntern.ăMed.,ă2007;ă160:ă1160–1168.ă
ISOăH.,ăREXRODEăC.,ăHENNEKENSăC.H.ăet al.,ăApplication of computer tomography – oriented criteria for stroke subtype
classification in a prospective study. Ann.ăEpidemiol.,ă2005;ă10:ă81–87.ă
INTERNATIONALăDIABETESăFEDERATION,ăGuideline for the management of post-meal glucose.ă2007.ă
ReceivedăJuneă1,ă2009ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
256ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
DumitraăB lanăandăP.A.ăBabeşă
8ă
The Assessment of Subclinic Atherosclerosis Objected through IMT in Normal
and Dyslipidemic Patients with Various Degrees of Glucose Tolerance
MARIOARA DANIELA BRAICU1, CRISTINA PRI ULESCU2, D. ALEXANDRU3, MARIA MO A3
Clinical Emergency Hospital Craiova, Clinic of Diabetes, Nutrition & Metabolic Diseases,
1
CF Hospital, Craiova
2
University of Medicine and Pharmacy Craiova – Medical Informatics
3
University of Medicine and Pharmacy Craiova, Clinic of Diabetes, Nutrition & Metabolic Diseases
Aim. The evaluation of atherosclerosis, by the measurement of intima media thickness (IMT)
at the level of right common carotid arteries (CCA Right) and left (CCA Left), for normolipidemic
patients (NL) and dislipidemic patients (DLP) with various degrees of alteration to glucose tolerance.
Design and methods of research. We have analyzed a group of 120 NL patients and a group
of 120 DLP patients. The test of orally provoked hyperglycemia was performed to assess the
disturbance of tolerance to glucose. IMT was determined by the method of ultrasonography in model
2B at the level of right and left common carotid arteries, measured at 2 cm from the bifurcation of
common carotids.
Results. For patients with DLP the IMT medium was statistically higher than the group of NL
patients. The normoglycemic normolipidemic patients (NG_NL) presented a lower IMT value than
the normoglycemic dislipidemic patients (NG_DLP). For the group of DLP patients, IMT was
statistically higher for patients with pre-diabetes (ALT) – impaired fasting glycaemia (IFG) and the
impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) – compared to NG patients (with statistical signification).
Conclusions. The presence of sub-clinic atherosclerosis objected through IMT was higher for
DLP patients compared to NL patients demonstrating the role of dyslipidemia in the production of
atherosclerosis. For patients with diabetes (DM), of both groups, the value of IMT was higher as
compared to NG patients, demonstrating the influence of hyperglycemia in the production of
atherosclerosis.
Key words: diabetes, dyslipidemia, intima media thickness, atherosclerosis.
The cardiovascular diseases are responsible for
approximately 50–80% of the decease causes for DM
persons, while the mortality of coronary causes is two
times higher for DM males and 4–5 times higher for
DM females compared to persons without DM [1].
The atherogene mechanisms are complex,
plurifactorial and dynamic and they usually assume
the synergic action of non-lipidic and lipidic factors.
Hypercholesterolemia, hypertension, smoking
and the association of these three factors of cardiovascular risk represent approximately 75% of the
cardiovascular diseases worldwide [2].
The endothelial dysfunction plays a main role
both in the initiation as well as in the progression
of atherosclerosis, numerous studies showing its
role in the pathogeny of atherosclerosis [3][4].
The endothelial cells are sensible to modifications
of glucose molecules, fat acids, lipoproteins so that
any injuries lead to the supra-production of ROS
which determine inflammation and annul the
protective role of endothelium [5].
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 257–265
One of the main consequences of the increase
of superoxide anion production, as a response to the
action of different stimuli (hypercholesterolemia,
HTA, smoking, etc.), is the inactivation of nitric
oxide and the modification of the function of
metaloproteins, important enzymes in the process of
vascular remodeling [6][7].
Presently, it is considered that the chronic
hyperglycemia has a complex and possibly secondary
role in the accession of atherogenesis, a role also
moderated by the effects of other cardiovascular risk
factors [8]. The ways through which hyperglycemia
leads to the appearance of atherogenesis lesions are
not fully elucidated, the endothelial dysfunction
representing the starting point.
The full knowledge of the atherosclerotic
process is highly important for early interventions
in the prevention of atherosclerosis as well as in the
case in which the process of reduction of progression
rate was initiated [9].
258
Marioara Daniela Braicu et al.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
In 2008 we studied two lots of patients (a lot of
120 patients with dyslipidemia and a control lot of
120 patients with normal values of sanguine lipids)
from the registers of family doctors in Craiova,
patients who had not been diagnosed with DZ and
who did not follow a dyslipidemia treatment,
according to inclusion criteria (age between 20 and 80
and a jeun glycemia under 126 mg/dL) and to
exclusion criteria (diagnosed DM, pregnancy,
gastrointestinal resections, acute stress: recent trauma,
surgery, inflammatory processes, AVC, IMA;
treatment with glucocorticoids, thiazide diuretics,
synthesis estrogens, salicylates, thyroid hormones,
IRC, renal transplant, chronic nephropathy, neoplasia,
cirrhosis, LES, and psychical diseases).
We recorded anamnestic data and anthropometric
parameters: weight, height, waist and hip. We
2
calculated the waist/hip indexes, IMC, the indexes
of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR).
We determined the plasmatic values of
glycemia using the enzymatic method, insulinemia
through the electrochemiluminescence method on
ELECSYS 1010, total cholesterol and triglycerides
using enzymatic methods, HDL cholesterol through
precipitation method and LDL cholesterol through
Friedwald formula (when the value of triglycerides
was Ţ 400 mg/dL). We made TTOG with 75 g of
pulvis glucose, determining à jeun glycemia two
hours after the administration of glucose. Blood
pressure was also measured and EKG was made.
The IMT was determined at the level of right and
left common carotid arteries through Doppler
ultrasonography in model 2B.
Presentation of characteristics of NL groups
(Table I) and DLP group (Table II).
Table I
Characteristics of NL group
Characteristics
Age[years]
Waist [cm]
Body indexes [kg/m2]
Glycemia à Jeun [mg/dL]
Glycemia in 2 hours [mg/dL]
Total cholesterol [mg/dL]
LDL cholesterol [mg/dL]
HDL cholesterol [mg/dL]
Triglycerides [mg/dL]
Insulinemia [µU/ml]
HOMA IR
Systolic blood pressure [mmHg]
Diastolic blood pressure [mmHg]
Intima Media Thickness – ACC right [mm]
Intima Media Thickness – ACC left [mm]
Average
51.74
94.43
27.72
105.53
131.41
168.18
93.68
52.60
110.80
9.80
2.54
128.79
78.63
0.74
0.75
Standard deviation
13.84
12.89
4.94
17.18
43.77
17.54
17.43
7.77
29.56
5.04
1.37
19.78
14.39
0.09
0.09
Variation factor
26.74
13.65
17.83
16.28
33.31
10.43
18.61
14.77
26.68
51.39
54.04
15.36
18.30
11.68
11.79
Table II
Characteristics of DLP group
Characteristics
Age[years]
Waist [cm]
Body indexes [kg/m2]
Glycemia à Jeun [mg/dL]
Glycemia in 2 hours [mg/dL]
Total cholesterol [mg/dL]
LDL cholesterol [mg/dL]
HDL cholesterol [mg/dL]
Triglycerides [mg/dL]
Insulinemia [µU/ml]
HOMA IR
Systolic blood pressure [mmHg]
Diastolic blood pressure [mmHg]
Intima Media Thickness – ACC right [mm]
Intima Media Thickness – ACC left [mm]
Average
54.03
98.71
29.61
112.34
158.31
229.99
144.03
46.37
186.13
11.11
3.08
134.25
80.11
0.77
0.78
Standard deviation
10.84
10.95
4.97
18.86
67.71
48.05
49.73
13.24
74.10
4.66
1.35
17.78
12.18
0.08
0.08
Variation factor
20.06
11.09
16.79
16.78
42.77
20.89
34.53
28.54
39.81
41.97
43.71
13.25
15.21
9.90
9.91
3
259
Atherosclerosis in normal and dyslipidemic patients
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
RESULTS
For data processing there have been used the
EPI2000 software, distributed by OMS, SPSS,
specialized in scientific calculations, produced by SPSS.
The recording of data about patients using the
EXCEL program produced the initial data base
from where the significant aspects of this study
have been taken.
Analyzing IMT at the level of ACC Right
(Table III, Fig. 1), and at the level of ACC Left
(Table IV, Fig. 2) for the NL patients lot and DLP
patients lot and on the various degrees of tolerance
to glucose (NG, IFG, IGT and DM), we have
obtained the following results.
Table III
Analysis IMT to ACC Right to NL and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ
ACC R
T
T
T
Avg
Std
CV
NL
0.74
0.09
11.68
NL_NG
0.71
0.08
11.36
NL_IFG
0.76
0.08
10.85
NL_IGT
0.76
0.09
11.20
NL_DZ
0.79
0.08
10.36
DLP
0.77
0.08
9.90
DLP_NG
0.77
0.08
10.17
DLP_IFG
0.74
0.08
10.36
DLP_IGT
0.77
0.07
9.44
DLP_DZ
0.80
0.07
9.11
Comparing ACC Right average between groups
0.80
0.74
0.77
0.71
0.77
0.76
0.74
0.76
0.77
0.79 0.80
Average
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
DLP
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
NG
Lot
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig.1. – Comparing ACC Right average between groups.
Table IV
Analysis IMT to ACC Left to Nl and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ
Avg
Std
CV
NL
0.75
0.09
11.79
NL_NG
0.72
0.08
11.59
NL_IFG
0.77
0.08
10.52
NL_IGT
0.78
0.09
11.06
NL_DZ
0.80
0.08
10.10
DLP
0.78
0.08
9.91
DLP_NG
0.78
0.08
10.24
DLP_IFG
0.75
0.07
9.85
DLP_IGT
0.78
0.08
9.75
Comparing ACC Left average between groups
0.90
Average
ACC R
T
T
T
0.80
0.75
0.78
0.72
0.78
0.77
0.75
0.78
0.78
0.80 0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
0.30
DLP
0.20
0.10
0.00
Lot
NG
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig. 2. – Comparing ACC Left average between groups.
DLP_DZ
0.80
0.07
9.13
260
Marioara Daniela Braicu et al.
We have analyzed the value of IMT to the
studied lots according to sex and we have obtained
the following results:
4
1. For male IMT at the level ACC Right
(Table V, Fig. 3) at the level ACC Left (Table
VI, Fig. 4).
Table V
Analysis IMT to ACC Right to NL and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ – male
ACC R
M
M
M
Avg
Std
CV
NL
NL_NG
NL_IFG
NL_IGT
NL_DZ
DLP
DLP_NG
DLP_IFG
DLP_IGT
DLP_DZ
0.74
0.08
11.35
0.71
0.07
10.13
0.77
0.09
11.81
0.77
0.09
11.08
0.81
0.06
7.97
0.78
0.08
9.81
0.79
0.07
8.55
0.73
0.09
12.49
0.78
0.08
10.16
0.79
0.06
8.04
Comparing ACC Right average between groups, for male
0.90
Average
0.80
0.74
0.78
0.71
0.79
0.77
0.73
0.77
0.78
0.81 0.79
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
0.30
DLP
0.20
0.10
0.00
NG
Lot
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig. 3. – Comparing ACC Right average between groups, for male.
Table VI
Analysis IMT to ACC Left to NL and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ – male
M
M
M
Avg
Std
CV
NL
NL_NG
NL_IFG
NL_IGT
NL_DZ
DLP
DLP_NG
DLP_IFG
DLP_IGT
DLP_DZ
0.75
0.09
11.42
0.71
0.07
10.30
0.77
0.09
11.20
0.79
0.09
10.83
0.81
0.08
9.31
0.79
0.08
9.76
0.80
0.07
8.41
0.74
0.09
11.52
0.79
0.08
10.51
0.80
0.07
8.42
Comparing ACC Left average between groups, for male
0.90
0.80
Average
ACC R
0.75
0.79
0.71
0.80
0.77
0.74
0.79
0.79
0.81 0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
0.30
DLP
0.20
0.10
0.00
Lot
NG
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig. 4. – Comparing ACC Left average between groups, for male.
5
261
Atherosclerosis in normal and dyslipidemic patients
2. For female IMT for the level ACC Right
(Table VII, Fig. 5) for the level ACC Left
(Table VIII, Fig. 6).
Comparing the average ACC Right for
patients in NL and DLP lots using Student test, we
found pţ0.01, therefore a lower value than the limit
of 0.05 (that is 5%), which shows us that there is a
statistically significant difference between the
average of the values ACC Right for the two groups
(Table IX).
Table VII
Analysis IMT to ACC Right to NL and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ – female
ACC R
NL
NL_NG
NL_IFG
NL_IGT
NL_DZ
DLP
DLP_NG
DLP_IFG
DLP_IGT
DLP_DZ
F
F
F
0.74
0.09
12.03
0.72
0.09
12.28
0.76
0.08
10.53
0.75
0.09
11.68
0.79
0.09
11.32
0.77
0.08
10.03
0.75
0.09
11.40
0.76
0.06
7.87
0.76
0.06
8.57
0.80
0.08
10.06
Comparing ACC Right average between groups, for female
Average
0.90
0.80
0.74
0.77
0.72 0.75
0.76 0.76
0.75
0.79 0.80
0.76
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
0.30
DLP
0.20
0.10
0.00
NG
Lot
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig. 5. – Comparing ACC Right average between groups, for female.
Table VIII
Analysis IMT to ACC Left to NL and DLP groups with sub-groups NG, IFG, IGT, DZ – female
ACC R
NL
NL_NG
NL_IFG
NL_IGT
NL_DZ
DLP
DLP_NG
DLP_IFG
DLP_IGT
DLP_DZ
F
F
F
0.75
0.09
12.17
0.72
0.09
12.55
0.77
0.08
10.48
0.77
0.09
11.68
0.80
0.09
10.78
0.77
0.08
10.06
0.75
0.09
11.37
0.76
0.06
8.13
0.76
0.07
8.97
0.81
0.08
9.91
Comparing ACC Left average between groups, for female
0.90
Average
0.80
0.75 0.77
0.72 0.75
0.77
0.76
0.77
0.76
0.80 0.81
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
NL
0.30
DLP
0.20
0.10
0.00
Lot
NG
IFG
IGT
DZ
Sub-group
Fig. 6. – Comparing ACC Left average between groups, for female.
262
Marioara Daniela Braicu et al.
Comparing NL and DLP groups on various
degrees of tolerance to glucose, we find for NG
patients’ lots:
Comparing the average ACC Right for patients
in groups NL_NG and DLP_NG using Student Test,
we found p~ţ0, so a lower value than the limit of
0.05 (that is 5%), which shows that there is a
statistically significant difference between the average
of the values ACC Right for the two groups.
Analyzing ACC Right for IFG patients’ groups
with IGT and DZ it is observed that no matter the
degree of glycemia alteration, the presence or not of
DLP does not influence significantly IMT (Table X).
Table IX
Comparing IMT to NL and DLP groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
NL
ACC Right
0.74
0.01
0.09
P(TŢţt) two-tail
11.68
6
DLP
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.08
0.01
9.90
For ACC Left we found pţ0.01, showing the
existence of a statistically significant difference in
favour of DLP.
Table X
Comparing IMT to NL_NG and DLP_NG; NL_IFG and DLP_IFG; NL_IGT and DLP_IGT; NL_DZ and DLP_DZ groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard
deviation
Variation
factor
NL_NG
ACC
Right
0.71
0.01
DLP_NG
ACC
Right
0.77
0.01
NL_IFG
ACC
Right
0.76
0.01
DLP_IFG
ACC
Right
0.74
0.01
NL_IGT
ACC
Right
0.76
0.01
DLP_IGT
ACC
Right
0.77
0.01
NL_DZ
ACC
Right
0.79
0.01
DLP_DZ
ACC
Right
0.80
0.01
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.09
0.07
0.08
0.07
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
00
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
0.41
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
0.83
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
0.78
11.36
10.17
10.36
11.20
9.44
10.36
9.11
For ACC Left we found p~ţ0, showing the
existence of a statistically significant difference in
favour of DLP (for NL_NG and DLP_NG).
Analyzing ACC Left, for groups of patients
with IFG, IGT and DM, we observe that no matter
the degree of glycemia alteration, the presence or
not of DLP does not influence IMT significantly.
Studying the average value of IMT of ACC
Right for the NL group of patients and comparing the
average between the sub-groups of patients NG, IFG,
IGT and DZ using Student test, we have obtained
pţ0.02, respectively pţ0.01 and pţ0.01 lower values
than the limit of 0.05 (that is 5%), which shows a
statistically significant difference between the average
of ACC Right for the groups (Table XI).
Table XI
Comparing IMT to NL_NG and NL_ IFG; NL_NG and NL_ IGT; NL_NG and NL_ DZ groups
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.71
NL_IFG
ACC Right
0.76
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.71
NL_IGT
ACC Right
0.76
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.71
NL_DZ
ACC Right
0.79
Dispersion
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
Standard deviation
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.09
0.08
0.08
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
11.36
0.02
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
11.36
0.01
P(TŢţt)
Two-tail
11.36
0.01
Average
Variation factor
10.85
For ACC Left, the value p~ţ0 with statistical
significance in favour of IFG, IGT and DZ.
Comparing the average ACC Right for patients
in groups NL_IFG and NL_IGT, in groups NL_IFG
with NL_DM, from groups NL-IGT with NL-DM,
11.20
10.36
there were not statistically significant modifications
between the groups compared (Table XII).
Comparing the average ACC Left for patients
in groups NL_IFG with NL_IGT, from groups
NL_IFG with NL_DM, from groups NL_IGT with
7
263
Atherosclerosis in normal and dyslipidemic patients
NL_DM, there were not statistically significant
modifications between the groups compared.
Comparing the average ACC Right for patients
in groups NL_DM and NL_ALT using Student test,
we found pţ0.31, so a higher value than the limit of
0.05 (that is 5%), which shows there is not a
statistically significant difference between the average
of values ACC Right for the two groups (Table XIII).
Table XII
Comparing IMT to NL_IFG and NL_ IGT; NL_IFG and NL_ DZ; NL_IGT and NL_ DZ groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt)
two-tail
10.85
NL_IFG
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.09
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt)
two-tail
10.85
0.99
11.20
NL_IGT
ACC Right
0.79
0.01
0.08
0.38
10.36
NL_NG
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.09
P(TŢţt)
two-tail
11.20
NL_DZ
ACC Right
0.79
0.01
0.08
0.34
10.36
Table XIII
Comparing IMT to NL_ DZ and NL_ALT groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
NL_DZ
ACC Right
0.79
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.36
Comparing the average ACC Left for patients
in lots NL_DM and NL_ALT, there were not
statistically significant modifications between the
groups compared.
Studying the value IMT of ACC Right to the
group of DLP patients and comparing the average
between the sub-groups NG, with IFG, with IGT
and with DZ, we obtained the following results:
•
NL_ALT
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.08
0.31
10.95
Comparing the average ACC Right for patients
in groups DLP_NG with DLP_IFG, from
groups DLP_NG with DLP_IGT, from groups
DLP_NG with DLP_DM (Table XIV), from
groups DLP_IFG with DLP_IGT, from groups
DLP_IGT with DLP_DZ (Table XV), there
were not statistically significant modifications
between the groups compared.
Table XIV
Comparing IMT to DLP_NG and DLP_IFG; DLP_NG and DLP_IGT; DLP_NG and DLP_DZ groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
DLP_NG
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.17
DLP_IFG
ACC Right
0.74
0.01
0.08
0.20
10.36
DLP_NG
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.17
DLP_IGT
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.07
0.89
9.44
DLP_NG
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.17
Table XV
Comparing IMT to DLP_IFG and DLP_IGT; DLP_IGT and DLP_DZ groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
DLP_IFG
ACC Right
0.74
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.36
DLP_IGT
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.07
0.24
9.44
DLP_IGT
ACC Right
0.77
0.01
0.07
P(TŢţt) two-tail
9.44
DLP_DZ
ACC Right
0.80
0.01
0.07
0.11
9.11
DLP_DZ
ACC Right
0.80
0.01
0.07
0.14
9.11
264
Marioara Daniela Braicu et al.
8
groups DLP_DM with DLP_ALT (Table XVII)
through Student test, we found pţ0.01, respectively
pţ0.02, so a lower value than the limit of 0.05
(that is 5%), which shows there is a statistically
significant difference between the groups.
There were not any statistically significant
modifications even when we analyzed the average
ACC Left.
• Comparing the average ACC Right for patients in
groups DLP_IFG with DLP_DM (Table XVI) and
Table XVI
Comparing IMT to DLP_IFG and DLP_DZ groups
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
DLP_IFG
ACC Right
0.74
0.01
0.08
P(TŢţt) two-tail
10.36
DLP_DZ
ACC Right
0.80
0.01
0.07
0.01
9.11
Table XVII
Comparing IMT to DLP_DZ and DLP_ALT GROUPS
Average
Dispersion
Standard deviation
Variation factor
DLP_DZ
ACC Right
0.80
0.01
0.07
P(TŢţt) two-tail
9.11
Comparing the average ACC Left for patients
in groups DLP_IFG with DLP_DM and groups
DLP_DM with DLP_ALT we found pţ0.01,
respectively pţ0.03, with a statistically significant
difference between the groups.
CONCLUSIONS
Analyzing the average value of IMT at the
level of ACC Right and ACC Left, it has been
observed that there is a statistically significant
difference of the NL group of patients compared to
DLP group.
Studying the average of IMT based on sex, it
has been observed that at the level of both ACC the
value is higher for males than for females, which
confirms the literature data.
Comparing the average value of IMT for the
two groups of patients: NL and DLP, according to
the tolerance degree to glucose, it has been noticed
that only for NG patients there is an IMT value
statistically higher than for DLP patients, which
underlines the importance of DLP in the production
of atherogenesis; for patients with IFG, with IGT
and DM there have not been statistically significant
differences between groups.
DLP_ALT
ACC Right
0.76
0.01
0.07
0.02
9.84
Studying the average value of IMT to the NL
lot of patients on tolerance degrees on glucose, it
has been noted that there is a statistically
significant difference between the NL_NG group
compared to the patients NL-IFG, NL_IGT,
NL_DM, at the level of both ACC, this thing
demonstrating the contribution of hyperglycemia in
the development of atherosclerosis.
There has not been a statistically significant
correlation through the comparison of sub-groups
IGT_IFG, IFG_DM, IGT_DM to NL patients,
results also sustained by literature data, which
show that the lower the atherogene risk is, the
lower the glycemia values are.
For DLP group of patients, comparing the
DLP_NG patients with DLP_IFG patients, DLP_IGT,
DLP_DM, there have not been statistically significant
differences, at the level of the two carotid arteries,
between the compared groups. Comparing the subgroup of patients DLP-IFG and DLP_DM patients,
both at the level of ACC Right as well as at the level of
ACC Left, there have been statistically significant
differences. Comparing the DLP_DM group of patients
with the group of patients DLP_ALT and with the group
DLP_IFG, at the level of both carotids there have been
higher statistically significant differences, in favour of
DM, demonstrating the contribution of glycemia
alteration degree in the production of atherogenesis.
9
Atherosclerosis in normal and dyslipidemic patients
265
Obiectiv. Evaluarea prezenţei aterosclerozei, prin măsurarea grosimii intimă
medie (IMT) la nivelul arterei carotide comune dreaptă (ACC Dr) şi stângă (ACC
St), la pacienţi normolipidici (NL) şi dislipidemici (DLP) cu grade variate ale
alterării toleranţei la glucoză.
Designul şi metodele cercetării. Am analizat un lot de 120 pacienţi NL şi un
lot de 120 pacienţi cu DLP. A fost efectuat testul de hiperglicemie provocată oral
pentru evaluarea perturbărilor toleranţei la glucoză. IMT a fost determinată prin
metoda ultrasonografiei în model 2B la nivelul arterei carotide comune drepte şi
stângi, măsurat la 2 cm de bifurcaţia carotidelor comune.
Rezultate. La pacienţii DLP, media IMT a fost statistic semnificativ mai mare
comparativ cu lotul de pacienţi NL. Pacienţii normoglicemici normolipidemici
(NG_NL) au prezentat o valoare a IMT mai mică decât pacienţii normoglicemici
dislipidemici (NG_DLP). La lotul de pacienţi DLP, IMT a fost statistic semnificativ
mai mare la pacienţii ce prezentau prediabet (ALT) – alterarea glicemiei à jeun
(IFG) şi scăderea toleranţei la glucoză (IGT) – comparativ cu pacienţii NG.
Pacienţii cu diabet din lotul DLP au prezentat o IMT mai mare comparativ cu
pacienţii NG (cu semnificaţie statistică).
Concluzii. Prezenţa aterosclerozei subclinice obiectivată prin IMT a fost mai
mare la pacienţii DLP faţă de pacienţii NL, demonstrând rolul dislipidemiei în
producerea aterosclerozei. La pacienţii cu diabet (DZ), din ambele loturi, valoarea
IMT a fost mai mare comparativ cu pacienţii NG, demonstrând influenţa hiperglicemiei
în producerea aterosclerozei.
Corresponding author: Prof. Maria Mo a, MD, PhD
Clinical Centre of Diabetes, Nutrition & Metabolic Diseases
1, Tabaci Str., Craiova, Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
IDF e – Atlas, 2007, Available at http://www.eatlas.Idf.org/
American Heart Association. Statistical Fact Sheet – Populations. International Disease Statistics. Dallas, Tex: American Heart
Association; 2003. Available online at: http://www.americanheart.org/presenter.jhtml?identifierţ3001001.
LUSIS A., Atherosclerosis. Nature, 2000; 407:233–241.
WIDLANSKY M.E., GOKC N., KEANEY J.F. JR. et al., The clinical implications of endothelial dysfunction. J. Am. Col.
Cardiol., 2003; 42:1149–1160.
DEFRONZO R.A., FERRANNINI E., KEEN H., ZIMMET P., International Textbook of Diabetes Mellitus, Third Edition,
Volume Two, 2004.
JACKSON C., Matrix metalloproteinases and angiogenesis. Curr. Oprin. Nephrol. Hypertens., 2002; 11: 295–299.
WASSMANN S., NICKENIG G., Improvement of endothelial function by HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, Drug News
Perspect, 2002; 15 (2): 85–92.
PICKUP J.C., WILLIAMS G., Text book of Diabetes, third ed., 2003.
BRUNZELL J.D., MICHAEL DAVIDSON M., FURBERG C.D., GOLDBERG R.B, HOWARD B.V. et al., Lipoprotein
Management in Patients with Cardiometabolic Risk. Consensus statement from the American Diabetes Association and the
American College of Cardiology Foundation. Diabetes Care, 2008; 31: 811–822.
Received May 25, 2009
266
Marioara Daniela Braicu et al.
10
Study of Antiphospholipid Antibodies in Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
with and without Diabetic Retinopathy
INIMIOARA MIHAELA COJOCARU1, M. COJOCARU2,
ADINA NICOLETA POPESCU3, L. POPESCU4, R. TĂNĂSESCU1
1
“Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Department of Neurology, “Colentina” Clinical Hospital
2
“Titu Maiorescu” University, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Physiology
3
Department of Neurology, “Colentina” Clinical Hospital
4
Clinical Hospital of Ophthalmologic Emergencies
Antiphospholipid antibodies (aPL) are considered to be contributory factors in the
development of thrombotic events. The objective of the study was to determine if aPL are involved in
the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. IgG
anticardiolipin antibodies (IgG aCL), lupus anticoagulant (LA), and anti-IgG β2-glycoprotein I
antibodies (anti-β2-GPI) were prospectively tested in 34 patients with DR (group 1), 20 males and
14 females, range of age 52–79 years, mean age 57±4.6 years, duration of diabetes 8–15 years, as
compared to 29 type 2 diabetic patients without DR (group 2), 19 males and 10 females, range of age
54–77 years, mean age 58±4.8 years, duration of diabetes 10–13 years, and to 31 controls matched for
age and sex (group 3). IgG aCL and anti-β2-GPI were detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay (ELISA) and LA was detected by activated partial thromboplastin time, kaolin clotting time,
dilute Russell’s viper venom time, dilute prothrombin time. Comparison between patients and
controls and patients group were expressed as relative risk with its 95% confidence interval
(RR [95%/CI], where a lower limit>1.0 was considered significant. All values were determined by
Fischer’s exact test. A value of p<0.05 was considered statistically significant. The incidence of IgG
aCL positive (low 4–15 GPL U IgG aCL titers) in group 1 was 21/34 (62%) vs. 12/29 (41%) in group
2 (RR 1.460 95% CI [0.9052 to 2.382]), p=0.1330. The incidence of LA positive in group 1 was
27/34 (79%) vs. 8/29 (28%) in group 2 (RR 3.086 95% CI [1.584 to 6.010]), p<0.0001. The incidence
of anti-IgG β2-GPI positive in group 1 was 29/34 (85%) vs. 6/29 (21%) in group 2 (RR 4.640 95% CI
[2.067–10.418]), p<0.0001. The results suggest the possible participation of anti-β2-GPI and LA in
the pathogenesis of DR, shifting the hemostatic balance toward a pro-thrombotic state increasing the
risk of developing thrombosis.
Key words: Antiphospholipid antibodies (aPL), diabetic retinopathy (DR), type 2 diabetes
mellitus.
Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is a major complication
in patients with diabetes mellitus and a cause of
disability, its prevalence being related to the
duration of diabetes and the glycemic control.
Diabetic retinopathy is a multifactorial process
in which genetic, metabolic, haemostatic and growth
factors play an important role.
In the pathogenesis of diabetic microangiopathy
the immunological mechanism might play a role.
Antiphospholipid antibodies (aPL) are considered
to be contributory factors in the development of
thrombotic events [1]. APL have been linked to
vascular damage in diabetes mellitus (DM).
The objective of the study was to determine if
aPL are involved in the pathogenesis of DR in
patients with type 2 DM.
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 267–271
MATERIAL AND METHODS
IgG anti-cardiolipin antibodies (IgG aCL), lupus
anticoagulant (LA) and anti-IgG β2-glycoprotein I
antibodies (anti-β2-GPI) were prospectively tested in
34 patients with DR (group 1), 20 males and
14 females, ranges of age 52–79 years, mean age
57±4.6 years, duration of diabetes 8–23 years as
compared to 29 type 2 diabetic patients without DR
(group 2) 19 males and 10 females range of age 43–
78 years, mean age 58±4.8 years, duration of diabetes
10–13 years, and to 31 controls matched for age and sex.
The type 2 DM patients were classified
according to National Diabetes data group criteria [2].
Diabetic retinopathy was assessed by 7 field
stereo fundus photograph and was classified according
to the ETDRS-Airlie House Classification [3].
Inimioara Mihaela Cojocaru et al.
268
Exclusion criteria were: autoimmune disorders,
chronic hepatitis, poor glycemic control (HbA1c>7%),
borderline hypertension (>140/90), hypertriglyceridemia
(>1.9 mol/L) or hypercholesterolemia (>5.6 mol/L).
Both diabetics and controls were non-smokers
and had not taken drugs which could affect
haemostasis for at least 4 weeks before the study.
Informed consent was obtained from all
subjects after explanation of the nature of the study
and the investigation was approved by the bioethics
committee of the hospital.
IgG aCL and anti-IgG β2-GPI were detected
by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA).
The concentration of aCL was measured in
GPL intenational units (a unit being equivalent to
the binding activity of 1 mg of aCL/mL). Positivity
of aCL was defined as titers of IgG aCL higher
than 15 GPL units.
LA was detected by activated partial thromboplastin time, kaolin clotting time, dilute Russell’s
viper venom time, dilute prothrombin time.
The concentration of anti-IgG-β2-GPI was
measured in U/mL (normal cut off 20 U/mL).
Comparison between patients and controls
and patients group were expressed as relative risk
with its 95% confidence interval (RR [95%/CI]),
where a lower limit>1.0 was considered significant.
All values were determined by Fischer’s
exact test. A value of p<0.05 was considered
statistically significant.
RESULTS
The incidence of IgG aCL positive (low 4–15
GPL U IgG aCL titers) in group 1 was 21/34 (62%)
vs. 12/29 (41%) in group 2 (RR 1.460 95% CI
[0.9052 to 2.382]), p=0.1330.
The incidence of LA positive in group 1 was
27/34 (79%) vs. 8/29 (28%) in group 2 (RR 3.086
95% CI [1.584 to 6.010]), p<0.0001.
The incidence of anti-IgG β2-GPI positive in
group 1 was 29/34 (85%) vs. 6/29 (21%) in group 2
(RR 4.640 95% CI [2.067–10.418]), p<0.0001.
DISCUSSION
It has been hypothesized that aPL directed
against endothelial antigens could be responsible
for initiating vascular injury.
Vascular damage and disturbed endothelial
function occur early in the course of diabetic
2
microangiopathy converting the endothelium from a
thromboresistant to a thrombogenic surface [4][5].
It has been suggested that immunological
mechanisms have a role in the pathogenesis of diabetic
microangiopathy via immune complex deposition [6].
Antibodies directed against endothelial antigens
could be responsible for initiating vascular injury, but
could also be marker of endothelial dysfunction.
Potential synergism between generation of
autoantibodies, haemostatic alterations and endothelial
stress has been also suggested.
Moderate high aCL titers must be exceptional in
patients with type 2 DM, low aCL titers may occur in
patients with type 2 DM, these low titers do not seem
to be associated with complicated DM, cardiovascular
disease, nephropathy or retinopathy [7].
Some authors find low IgG aCL titers in
about one third of their patients [7].
Other study has described that low (5–
20 GPL U) IgG aCL titers were significantly more
frequent in patients with diabetes with and without
cardiovascular disease than in controls [8].
In a series of 205 patients with type 1 and
2 DM, no patient had moderate-high (>20 GPL U)
IgG aCL titers and only one had moderate high
IgM aCL titers [8].
In a series of 46 patients with type 2 DM, no case
had an IgG aCL titer higher than 20 GPL units [9].
On the contrary, in a series of 21 patients
with type 2 DM, a IgG aCL titer equal or higher
than 15 GPL U was present in 9.5% of cases [10].
The immunosenescence theory suggests that
immune dysfunction with aging is associated with
increased autoantibodies production; these autoantibodies may be “innocent bystanders” or contribute
to the pathogenesis of diseases such as atherosclerosis
[11]. The patients of authors’ series were mostly
elderly, and the frequency of low aCL titers might be
explained by the immunosenescence theory.
It has been reported a significantly higher
frequency of aPL (IgG or IgM aCL and/or LA) in
patients with type 1 and 2 diabetes with macroangiopathy than in patients with uncomplicated
diabetes or controls, the results suggesting a potential
role of PL-binding antibodies in the progression of
vascular complication in DM [10].
These authors did not find statistical differences
in the frequencies of a low IgM or IgG aCL titer in
patients with and without nephropathy or with and
without retinopathy.
Other studies describe no association between
aCL and retinopathy and nephropathy [8][9].
3
Antiphospholipid antibodies in type 2 diabetes mellitus
Vascular damage and disturbed endothelial
function occur early in the course of diabetic
microangiopathy converting the endothelium from
a thromboresistant to thrombogenic surface [4][5].
The immunological mechanism could have a
role in the pathogenesis of diabetic microangiopathy
via immune complexes deposition [6].
Antibodies directed against endothelial antigens
could be responsible for initiating vascular-injury, but
could also be a marker of endothelial dysfunction.
It has been suggested a potential synergism
between generation of autoantibodies, haemostatic
alterations and endothelial stress.
LA is though to be involved in this endothelial
alteration and is frequently associated with diabetic
vascular complications (overt nephropathy or macroangiopathy) and retinal occlusive vasculopathies [10].
The presence of LA was detected in 32.2%
diabetic patients, aCL was found in 80% of LA
positive and only in 9% of LA negative patients [12].
Clinically manifest microangiopathy (retinopathy
and/or nephropathy) was found in 60% LA positive
and in 18% LA negative diabetics [12].
A high prevalence of proliferative DR was
observed in LA positive patients (66.6%).
The clinical association between LA positivity
and thrombotic events is thought to be due to an LA
induced endothelial cell dysfunction; in DM a similar
dysfunction of the coagulopathy and anticoagulant
pathways, as a result of endothelial damage, has been
described [13–16].
Some authors had observed decreased APC
(activated protein C) concentrations and increased F1+2
(prothrombin degradation products) plasma levels in
LA positive patients, as evident expression of prothrombotic condition and endothelial dysfunction [12].
LA positivity might be considered an
additional risk factor in the pathogenesis of
microangiopathy (retinopathy and/or nephropathy)
in DM patients, representing an intersection point
between immune and haemostatic alteration [17].
269
The presence of aPL (81%) [18] appears to
be greater than the prevalence of aPL reported in
patients with other autoimmune disorders [19–22].
In addition, studies of such autoimmune
diseases have revealed that aPL are not always
directed against PL alone, for purified IgG from
certain aCL positive patients does not react with
CL unless β2-GPI or prothrombin are present
[23][24]; the β2-GPI-phospholipid complex is a
novel epitope that stimulates the immune system to
produce aPL [23–25].
The same type of novel epitopes occur for the
kininogens when they are combined with phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) [26].
Experimental evidence suggests that hyperglycemia triggers a cascade of biochemical events
that leads to vascular dysfunction and early
structural changes of vessels [27][28].
This is confirmed by increased concentrations
of von Willebrand factor [29], reduced endotheliumderived relaxing factor and prostacyclin [28],
decreased concentrations of tissue plasminogen activator
[13], increased plasma concentrations of fibrinogen
and activated factor VII [28], and down-regulation of
natural anticoagulant pathways [30][31].
The net effect of these changes is the
conversion of endothelium from a thromboresistant
to a thrombogenic surface [30][31].
Detection of aPl in patients with DR may
help recommend prophylactic treatment [32].
CONCLUSION
The results of our study suggest the possible
participation of anti-β2-GPI and LA in the pathogenesis
of DR, shifting the haemostatic balance toward a
pro-thrombotic state increasing the risk of
developing thrombosis.
Se consideră că anticorpii antifosfolipidici sunt factori care contribuie la
producerea fenomenelor trombotice. Obiectivul acestei cercetări a fost determinarea
anticorpilor antifosfolipidici posibil implicaţi în patogenia retinopatiei diabetice la
pacienţi cu diabet tip 2. Anticorpii anticardiolipinici (IgG aCL), anticoagulantul
lupic (LA) şi anti IgG-β2-glicoproteina I (anti-β2-GPI) au fost testaţi prospectiv la
34 pacienţi cu retinopatie diabetică (grupul 1), 20 bărbaţi şi 14 femei cu vârste
între 52–79 ani, vârsta medie 57±4,6 ani, durata diabetului 8–15 ani, comparativ
cu 29 pacienţi cu diabet tip 2 fără retinopatie diabetică (grupul 2), 19 bărbaţi şi 10
femei cu vârsta între 54–77 ani, vârsta medie 58±4,8 ani, durata diabetului 10–13
270
Inimioara Mihaela Cojocaru et al.
4
ani, şi cu 31 martori asemănători ca vârstă şi sex (grupul 3). IgG aCL şi anti-IgG
β2-GPI au fost determinaţi folosind tehnica ELISA, iar LA a fost determinat
folosind timpul de tromboplastină parţial activată, timpul de coagulare cu caolin,
timpul Russel cu venin de viperă diluat, timpul cu protrombină. Comparaţia între
pacienţi şi martori şi grupurile de pacienţi a fost exprimată ca risc relativ cu
intervalul de confidenţă 95% (RR[95% CI] la care o limită mai mică de >1.0 a fost
considerată semnificativă. Toate valorile au fost determinate prin testul de
exactitate Fischer. O valoare p<0.05 a fost considerată semnificativă statistic.
Incidenţa pozitivităţii IgG aCL (titruri reduse de 4–15 GPL U IgG aCL) a fost la
grupul 1 de 21/34 (62%) vs. 12/29 (41%) la grupul 2 (RR 1.460 95%/CI [0.9052–
2.382]), p=0.1330. Incidenţa pozitivităţii LA la grupul 1 a fost de 27/34 (79%) vs.
8/29 (28%) la grupul 2 (RR 3.086 95% CI [1.584–6.010]), p<0.0001. Incidenţa
pozitivităţii anti-IgG β2-GPI la grupul 1 a fost de 9/34 (85%) vs. 6/29 (21%) la
grupul 2 (RR 4.640 95% CI [2.067–10.418]), p<0.0001. În concluzie, rezultatele
indică participarea posiblă a anticorpilor anti-β2-GPI şi LA la patogenia
retinopatiei diabetice.
Corresponding author: Inimioara Mihaela Cojocaru MD, PhD, Senior lecturer
“Colentina” Clinical Hospital, Clinic of Neurology
19–21, Şos. Ştefan cel Mare
020125, Bucharest Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
BERTOLACCINI L.M., HUGES G.R., Antiphospholipid antibody testing: which are most useful for diagnosis? Rheum. Dis.
Clin. North Am., 2006; 32: 455–63.
NATIONAL DIABETES DATA GROUP, Classification of diabetes mellitus and other categories of glucose intolerance.
Diabetes, 1979; 28: 1039–57.
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY STUDY RESEARCH GROUP, Report 7. A modification of the Arilie House classification of
diabetic retinopathy. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci., 1981; 21: 210–26.
HAEFLIGER I.O., MEYER P., FLAMMER J. et al., The vascular endothelium as a regulator of the ocular circulation: a new
concept in ophthalmology? Surv. Ophthalmol., 1994; 39: 123–32.
KOHNER B.M., PATEL V., RASSMAN S.M.B., Role of blood flow and impaired autoregulation in the pathogenesis of
diabetic retinopathy. Diabetes, 1995; 44: 603–7.
AHMED E., NITYANAND S., MUSTAFA A. et al., Anti-cardiolipin antibodies and circulating immune complexes in type 1
diabetes mellitus: increased prevalence and relation to vascular complications. Clin. Exp. Immunol., 1999; 115(2): 255–9.
CALVO-ROMERO J.M., LIMA-RODRIGUEZ M.L., Anticardiolipin antibodies in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Clin.
Med. Res., 2009; Feb. 26 (published online).
HENDRA T.J., BAGULEY E., HARRIS E.N. et al., Anticardiolipin antibody levels in diabetic subjects with and without
coronary artery disease. Postgrad. Med. J., 1989; 65: 140–3.
TARKUN J., HACIHANEFIOGLU A., TARKUN P. et al., Anticardiolipin and anti-beta 2 glycoprotein I antibody
concentrations in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Res. Clin. Pract., 2005; 68: 181–7.
GALTIER-DEREURE F., BIRON C., VIES M. et al., Vascular complications of diabetes mellitus: what role for phospholipidbinding antibodies? Lupus, 1998; 7: 469–74.
LING K.L., GABRIEL S.E., Autoantibodies; innocent bystander or key player in immunosenescence and atherosclerosis.
J. Rheumatol., 2007; 34: 1203–7.
GIUSTI C., SCHIAFFINI R., BOSCO D. et al., Lupus anticoagulant positivity in insulin dependent diabetic patients: an
additional risk factor in the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy. Br. J. Ophthalmol., 2000; 84: 531–3.
WALMSLEY D., HAMPTON K.K., GRANT P.F., Contrasting fibrinolytic responses in type 1 (insulin-dependent) and type 2
(non-insulin-dependent diabetes). Diabetic Med., 1991; 8: 954–9.
BRENNER B.M., TROY J.L., BALLERMANN B.J., Endothelium-dependent vascular responses: mediator and mechanism.
J. Clin. Invest., 1989; 84: 1373–8.
GARCIA-FRADE L.J., DE LA CALLE H., TORADO M.C. et al., Hypofibrinolysis associated with vasculopathy in noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Thromb. Res., 1990; 59: 51–9.
MANSFIELD M.W., GRANT P.J., Fibrinolysis and diabetic retinopathy in NIDDM. Diabetes Care, 1995; 18: 1577–89.
5
Antiphospholipid antibodies in type 2 diabetes mellitus
271
17. CARR M.E., Diabetes mellitus: a hypercoagulate state. J. Diabetes Complications, 2001; 15: 44–54.
18. GARGIULO P., GOLDBERG J., ROMANI B. et al., Qualitative and quantitative studies of autoantibodies to phospholipids in
diabetes mellitus. Clin. Exp. Immunol., 1999; 118: 30–4.
19. FIELDS R.A., TOUBLOCH H., SCOULES R.P. et al., The prevalence of anticardiolipin antibodies in a healthy elderly
population and in association with antinuclear antibodies. J. Rheumatol., 1989; 16: 623–5.
20. LECERF V., ATHENE-GELAS M., LAUZIAN C. et al., Antiphospholipid antibodies in atherosclerosis. Am. J. Med., 1992;
92: 576.
21. PALOMO I.J., MUJICA V.E., ALARCON M.L. et al., Prevalence of antiphospholipid antibodies is not different in Chilean
diabetic patients and normal individuals. J. Diabetes Complications, 2005; 19: 133–7.
22. GIN H., VERGNOT V., DIAKOU V. et al., Antiphospholipid antibodies in diabetes mellitus. Clinical Chemistry and
Laboratory Medicine, 2002; 40: 604–8.
23. HUGHES G.R.V., Antiphospholipid syndrome: ten years on Lancet, 1993; 343: 341–4.
24. McINTYRE J.A, WOGENKNECHT D.R., SUGI T., Phospholipid binding plasma proteins required for antiphospholipid
antibody detection. An overview, Am. J. Reprod. Immunol., 1997; 37: 101–10.
25. MATSUURA E., IGARASHI I., FUJIMOTO M. et al., Heterogeneity of anticardiolipin antibodies defined by anticardiolipin
cofactor. J. Immunol., 1992; 248: 3885–91.
26. SAGI T., McINTYRE J.A., Phosphatidylethanolamine induces specific conformational changes in the kininogens recognizable
by antiphosphatidylethanolamine antibodies. Thromb. Haemost., 1996; 76: 354–60.
27. ANDREANI D., The labyrinth of diabetic vascular disease: crossroads and waysout. Diab. Nutr. Metab., 1995; 8: 54–64.
28. CERIELLO A., Coagulation activation in diabetes mellitus: the role of hyperglycemia and therapeutic prospects. Diabetologia,
1993; 36: 1119–25.
29. STEHOUER C.D.A., ZELLENRATH P., POLACK B.C.P. et al., Von Willebrand factor and early diabetic retinopathy; no
evidence for a relationship in patients with type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus and normal urinary albumin excretion.
Diabetologia, 1992; 35: 555–9.
30. GARGIULO P., SCHIAFFINI R., BOSCO D. et al., Diabetic microangiopathy: lupus anticoagulant dependent thrombotic
tendency in type 1 diabetes mellitus. Diab. Med., 1997; 14: 132–7.
31. LORENZI M., CAGLIERO E., Pathophysiology of endothelial and other vascular cells in diabetes mellitus: call for data.
Diabetes, 1991; 40: 653–9.
32. CARBONE J., SANCHEZ-RAMON S., COBO-SORIANO R. et al., Antiphospholipid antibodies: a risk factor for occlusive
retinal vascular disorders. J. Rheum., 2001; 28: 2437–41.
Received June 19, 2009
272
Inimioara Mihaela Cojocaru et al.
6
Otoacoustic Emissions Analysers for Monitoring Aminoglycosides Ototoxicity
RUXANDRA MOROTI CONSTANTINESCU1,4, MĂDĂLINA GEORGESCU2,4, A. PASCU2, ADRIANA HRISTEA1,4,
VICTORIA ARAMĂ1,4, C. BĂICUŞ3,4, RUXANDRA OANA CĂLIN1,4, EUGENIA KOVACS4
2
1
“Matei Balş” National Institute for Infectious Diseases, Bucharest, Romania
“Dorin Hociota” Phono-Audiology and ENT Functional Surgery Institute, Bucharest, Romania
3
“Colentina” Clinical Hospital, Bucharest, Romania
4
“Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest, Romania
Objectives. Aminoglycosides (AG) are widely prescribed despite their notorious toxicity.
These antibiotics cause irreversible hearing loss, starting with high frequencies and progressing
toward conversational frequencies (0.5–2 kHz), by destroying the acoustic hair cells in the inner ear.
The integrity of these cells could be analysed by recording faint sounds that they produce –
otoacoustic emissions (OAE). The aim of the present study was to monitor and to characterise the
acoustic toxicity of the AG using an OAE analyser.
Method. We performed a prospective study of 49 patients receiving gentamicin (G), during
2007–2008. We made serial OAE recordings with an ILO 92 analyser (1–8 kHz) on at least
3 occasions: at the start, during treatment and after the cessation of G therapy (1–6 months). The
recordings were performed at the patient’s bedside and did not require the active participation of the
patient. The method is fast, non-invasive, accurate and does not request an ENT specialist. We
included patients presenting OAE. Ototoxicity was defined using adapted ASHA (American Speech
Hearing Association) criteria.
Results. We studied 49 patients (24/25 female/male), mean age of 37.24 (3–70 years old), who
received G for 4–42 days: less than 10 days – 24 patients and more than 10 days –25 patients. Hearing
impairment was observed in 10 patients (20.4%) and appeared during the therapy or in the next
3 months, with a loss of one or 2 high frequencies that occurred unilaterally in 9 out of 10 cases. The
acoustic damage correlates with the length of G treatment. We did not find a statistical correlation
between the degree of impairment and the age, regimen or addition of another ototoxic drug, although
the hearing loss was slightly higher in those with concomitant exposure.
Conclusion. OAE monitoring of AG treatment is a very useful way for detecting and preventing
acoustic toxicity, because it could warn about hearing loss before damage of the conversational
frequencies. The accuracy is similar to the classical methods, but it is faster and easier to perform.
Key words: aminoglycosides, acoustic toxicity, otoacoustic emissions.
Aminoglycosides are proven ototoxic and
nephrotoxic drugs, probably because of concentration
in, and retention by sensory hair cells of the
cochleovestibular and renal proximal tubule cells.
AGs are rapidly taken up by these cells and
damaged them by initiating cellular apoptosis [1–6].
The incidence of AG’s ototoxicity in patients
varied from 2% to 41% in different studies [3][7–10].
The classical method for testing the cochlear
function is pure tone audiometry (PTA), which
presumes an active participation of the patient, so it
is not applicable to newborns, young children and
unconscious patients; besides, PTA imply a phonoisolated special room and could not be applicable at
the patient’s bedside.
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 273–278
The Corti stimulation by pressure waves of
sounds takes place tonotopically, depending on
reaching the travelling wave’s peak: the high
frequencies sounds are perceived at the base of the
cochlea and the lower frequencies sounds are
perceived closer and closer to the apex [11].
A clear perception of a sound (very good
sensitivity and frequency selectivity) depends on
the anatomical integrity and functioning of the
cochlear amplifier, represented by the outer hair
cells (OHC), parts of the Corti organ [12].
Cochlear injury starts from the basal region of
the cochlea and extends progressively to the apex, so
the first loss in hearing begins with the acute sounds
and then the low sounds, till the conversational
frequencies (0.5–2 kHz) are reached [3][13–14].
Ruxandra Moroti Constantinescu et al.
274
Patients frequently develop symptoms usually
during the ototoxic therapy, but these can appear by
a little extent in the next months, because of the
AG persistence in the cochlear organ of Corti
(animal studies have shown the presence of AG
molecules in hair cells up to 6 months after
administration) [1][15].
OHC are the most susceptible structure in the
inner ear to the ototoxic drugs and OHC damage
can be monitored by testing for otoacoustic
emissions (OAE).
Otoacoustic emissions are low intensity
sounds of cochlear origin that can be recorded by a
microphone fitted into the ear canal. They are
generated by the motion of the OHC when the
sound is processed [12][16]. 95% of normal people
present evoked OAE, but these tend to decrease in
amplitude with ageing: infants have large OAE, but
many adults with normal hearing have low-level
OAE [12].
Recording OAE represents a simple, noninvasive, sensitive and specific tool for screening
cochlear function. Distortion Product OAE (DPOAE) are the most frequency-specific indicator,
especially for higher frequencies (>4kHz) [17].
That can be used to monitor the effect of ototoxic
treatment and enables early diagnosis when
acoustic impairment occurs [12][17].
METHOD
This is a prospective study involving 49
patients that received G during 2007–2008, in
“Matei Balş” National Institute of Infectious
Diseases, Bucharest, Romania.
We used an OAE analyser ILO 92, a portable
device, able to record OAE in a range of 1–8 kHz
in DP-OAE mode. The recordings took place in a
silent room or even at the patient’s bedside, in a
non-invasive manner. The method is rapid (several
minutes) and does not require an active
participation of the patient.
The inclusion criterion was the presence of
evoked OAE.
We excluded patients with middle ear pathology
(because OAE’s recording depends on the integrity of
the way through the middle and external ear).
The patients provided an informed consent
and completed a questionnaire (which included
questions about previous exposure to ototoxic
agents, noise or pre-existing hearing impairment).
2
Any concomitant medication during G treatment
was also noted.
We made serial recordings of DP-OAE for
each patient, in at least 3 moments: prior to G
therapy, during and after the end of therapy (1–6
months). The initial recording was considered to be
the baseline DP-OAE record. We checked the
presence of the DP-OAE signal at high frequencies
(6, 8 kHz), bilaterally. The following measurements
focused on these higher frequencies which are first
implicated when the G ototoxicity emerged.
Ototoxicity was defined adapting ASHA 1994
criteria, regarding the highest patient’s frequencies:
as a 20dB or greater decrease at one frequency,
10dB or greater decrease at 2 adjacent frequencies
or loss of 3 consecutive frequencies.
RESULTS
Of the 49 patients studied, 24 were female
and 25 male; the mean age was 37.24 (3–70 years
old); the G treatment had a length between 4 and
42 days: 24 patients were treated for less than
10 days and 25 patients had longer courses.
The pathological conditions for AG therapy
were diverse: endocarditis, sepsis, nosocomial
urinary tract infections, pneumonia, listerial meningitis
and miscellaneous ENT (ear-nose-throat) acute
infections.
Hearing impairment (Fig. 1) was observed in
10 patients (20.4%) and appeared during the
therapy or in the next 3 months, with the loss of
one or two high frequencies (Fig. 2), that occurred
unilaterally in 9 out of 10 cases.
The acoustic damage tends to correlate with
the length of AG treatment (25% for long versus
16% for short courses) (Fig. 3).
We did not find a statistical correlation
between the degree of impairment and the age (one
patient out of 6 under 16 years old was affected
versus 9 out of 43 patients beyond 16 years old),
administration rhythm (among 40 patients those
received multiple daily doses regimen, 8 were
affected versus 2 out of 9 which received oncedaily G dose) or association of another ototoxic
drug (glycopeptides or loop diuretics), although the
hearing loss was slightly higher in those with
concomitant exposure: 5 out of 15 (33.3%) versus
5 out of 34 non-exposed (14.7%) (Fig. 4).
3
275
Otoacoustic emissions
Fig. 1. – The hearing impairment due to
G treatment.
10.1
16.6
12.1
10.4
15.1
–2.6
–6.5
20.6dBspl
4.4
–3.8
–11.1
–11.3
–12.9
–15.2
–18.5
5.7
20.4
23.2
21.7
28.0
12.6
12.0
12.9dBspl
11.2
19.9
13.2
12.3
10.2
–26.2
–30.0
22.0dBspl
5.4
–2.2
–11.6
–13.5
–14.5
–14.2
–17.0
5.8
22.1
24.8
25.8
24.7
–12.0
–13.0
14.2dBspl
Fig. 2. – DP-OAE at the beginning of G treatment (left), with the presence of OAE at every recorded frequency (from 1 to 8 kHz –
appearing in light grey columns) and after 3 months from the cessation of the treatment (right), with 6 and 8 kHz frequencies lost
(arrows).
Fig. 3. – The hearing impairment related to
the length of the treatment.
Ruxandra Moroti Constantinescu et al.
276
4
Fig. 4. – The hearing impairment related to
the simultaneous exposure to G and another
ototoxic agent.
DISCUSSION
Although AG’s toxicity is well recognised,
some medical conditions require this therapy. So, it
is useful to identify the patients who are at risk to
develop ototoxicity and to observe any auditory
impairment that can occur.
In our study, one fifth of patients receiving AG
develop ototoxicity, similar with those obtained with
classical methods. G-induced hearing loss was
moderate in its effect: none of the patients lost the
conversational frequencies. The acoustic impairment
slightly correlates with the length of G administration.
Simultaneous use of another ototoxic medication
also seems to enhance the harmful effect.
Because the patient usually does not
recognize a hearing loss until it has progressed to
the conversational frequencies (0.5–2 kHz), the test
of high frequencies (6–10 kHz) appears to be the
proper indicator of early toxicity. This could be
done by OAE analysers or by classical PTA
method (the last is not always applicable and
necessitates special conditions).
OAE examination is a simple, fast and noninvasive method for detecting the hearing injury,
has similar results to the classical methods, but it is
easier to perform (at the patient’s bedside and does
not require an active participation of the patient). A
screening with OAE analysers could be
implemented as a monitoring tool of any potential
ototoxic therapies.
Acknowledgements. Dr. Peter Steyger – Associate
Professor of Otolaryngology – Head & Neck Surgery, Oregon
Hearing Research Center, USA – for his help in providing
articles related to our work.
Aminoglicozidele sunt antibiotice larg prescrise, în pofida toxicităţii lor
binecunoscute. Sunt cohleotoxice ireversibile, afectând iniţial frecvenţele înalte şi
apoi progresiv frecvenţe din ce în ce mai joase, până la atingerea frecvenţelor
conversaţionale (0,5–2 kHz), prin distrugerea anatomică a celulelor ciliate acustice
din urechea internă. Funcţionalitatea acestor celule poate fi analizată prin
înregistrarea unor sunete de mică intensitate produse de acestea – otoemisiuni
acustice (OAE). Scopul studiului actual este de monitorizare şi caracterizare a
ototoxicităţii cohleare a gentamicinei (G) folosind un analizor OAE.
Metodă. Am desfăşurat în 2007–2008 un studiu prospectiv implicând
pacienţi care au primit tratament cu G, folosind un otoanalizor acustic (ILO 92),
cu baleiaj în frecvenţe de la 1–8 kHz. S-au realizat înregistrări seriate ale OAE: la
startul terapiei (considerat baseline), pe parcursul acesteia şi la 3–6 luni
postterapie. Au fost incluşi în studiu pacienţi care aveau OAE prezente la
5
Otoacoustic emissions
277
înregistrarea iniţială. Ototoxicitatea acustică a fost definită folosind criteriile
ASHA (American Speech Hearing Association) adaptate.
Rezultate. Lotul studiat a fost constituit din 49 pacienţi, 24 femei şi 25 bărbaţi,
cu media de vârstă 37,24 ani (3–70 ani), trataţi cu G între 4 şi 42 zile: sub 10 zile –
24 pacienţi şi peste 10 zile – 25 pacienţi.
Afectarea de auz s-a produs la 10 pacienţi (20,4%), a apărut în timpul
terapiei sau pe parcursul următoarelor 3 luni şi a implicat una sau două dintre
frecvenţele cele mai înalte recepţionate la baseline; pierderea a fost unilaterală în
9 din 10 cazuri. A existat o corelaţie între pierderile de auz şi durata tratamentului
aminoglicozidic. Nu am găsit corelaţii semnificative între pierderile de auz şi
vârstă, regim de administrare sau asocierea unui al doilea ototoxic în medicaţie,
deşi a existat o diferenţă în acest sens (afectare mai mare la cei dublu expuşi).
Concluzii. Monitorizarea tratamentului aminoglicozidic cu analizoare
acustice aduce date importante şi precoce despre apariţia disfuncţiei auditive pe
parcursul administrării terapiei, prin detectarea afectării iniţial a frecvenţelor
înalte, care ar putea progresa ulterior spre atingerea frecvenţeler conversaţionale.
Acurateţea metodei este similară cu a metodelor clasice însă este mai rapidă,
simplă şi universal aplicabilă.
Correspondence author: Ruxandra Moroti Constantinescu
“Matei Balş” National Institute for Infectious Diseases,
1, Grozovici str, sect 2, Bucharest, Romania,
E-mail:
[email protected],
phone: +40722550335, +40213186100/5204 fax: +40213186094
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
DAY C.F., MANGIARDI D., COTANCHE D.A., STEYGER P.S., Uptake of fluorescent gentamicin by vertebrate sensory cells
in vivo. Hear Res., 2009, 213:64–78.
NAKASHIMA T., TERANISHI M., HIBI T., KOBAYASHI M., UMEMURA M., Vestibular and cochlear toxicity of
aminoglycosides – A review. Acta Otolaryngol., 2000, 120: 904–911.
ROTSTEIN C., MANDELL L., Clinical aminoglycoside ototoxicity. In: Roland P.S. & Rutka J.A. (eds.) Ototoxicity, Hamilton,
Ontario, Decker B.C., 2004, pp. 82–92.
SONG B.B., SCHACHT J., Variable efficacy of radical scavengers and iron chelators to attenuate gentamicin ototoxicity in
guinea pigs in vivo. Hear Res., 1996, 94: 987–993.
DENAMUR S., VAN BAMBEKE F., MINGEOT-LECLERCQ M.P., TULKENS P.M. (2008), Apoptosis induced by
aminoglycosides in LLC-PK1 Cells: comparative study of neomycin, gentamicin, amikacin, and isepamicin using
electroporation. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother., Jun. 52(6):2236–8. Epub., 2008 Apr. 7.
DEHNE N., RAUEN U., DE GROOT H., LAUTERMANN J., Involvement of the mitochondrial permeability transition in
gentamycin ototoxicity. Hear Res., 2002, 169: 47–55.
SMYTH A.R., BHATT J., Once-daily versus multiple-daily dosing with intravenous aminoglycosides for cystic fibrosis.
Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews, 2006, Issue 3. Art. No.: CD002009. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002009.pub2.
SATALOFF J., WAGNER S., MENDUKE H., Kanamycin ototoxicity in healthy men. Arch. Otolaryngol., 1964; 80(4):413–417.
MOORE R.D., LERNER S.A., LEVINE D.P., Nephrotoxicity and ototoxicity of aztreonam versus aminoglycosides therapy in
seriously ill non-neutropenic patients. J. Infect. Dis., 1992, 165:683–688.
SHA S.H., SCHACHT J., QIU J.H., Aspirin to prevent gentamicin-induced hearing loss. N. Engl. J. Med., 2006, April: 1856–1857.
TUPER G., AHMAD N., SEIDMAN M., Mechamisms of ototoxicity. Perspectives on Hearing and Hearing Disorders;
Research and Diagnostics, 2005; 9: 2–10. DOI:10.1044/hhd9.1.2
PRIEVE B.A., FITZGERALD T.S., Otoacoustic Emissions. In: Katz J. (ed.) Handbook of Clinical Audiology, 5th edn.
Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, 2001, pp. 440–463.
BROCKENBROUGH J.M., RYBAK L.P., MATZ G.J., Ototoxicity. In: Bailey B.J. (ed.) Head and Neck surgeryotolaryngology, Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, pp. 1893–1898.
278
Ruxandra Moroti Constantinescu et al.
6
14. BRUMMET R.E., FOX K.E., Aminoglycosides-induced hearing loss in humans. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother., 1989, 33:
797–800.
15. DULON D., HIEL H., AUROUSSEAU C., ERRE J.P., ARAN J.M., Pharmacokinetics of Gentamicin in the sensory hair cells
of the organ of Corti: rapid uptake and long term persistence. C.R. Acad. Sci. III, 1993; 316: 682–687.
16. KEMP D.T. (2002), Otoacoustic emissions, their origin in cochlear function, and use. Br. Med. Bull., 2002, 63:223–241.
17. ILO O.A.E., Instrument User Manual Otodynamics, Ltd., 1997.
Received June 10, 2009
Systemic Redox Modifications in Senile Cataract
BOGDANA VÎRGOLICI1, IRINA STOIAN1, CORINA MUSCUREL1,
MAGDA MĂRĂCINE1, LAURA POPESCU1, C. MORARU2, VERONICA DINU1
1
“Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest, Romania
2
Ophthalmic Surgery Department of “Oculus” Clinic, Bucharest
Recent studies on cataract formation focus on a primary role of systemic oxidative stress,
generated outside the lens. Plasma inflammatory markers are associated with senile cataract.
Objective. The aim of this study was to find correlations between blood oxidative stress
markers and some inflammatory plasma markers in cataractous patients.
Design and Methods. The blood samples were collected from 38 patients (aged 50 to 80).
Patients were subdivided according to two criteria. Considering age criteria, presenile and senile
cataract groups were formed. According to the absence or presence of other ocular comorbidities
(age–related macular degeneration, glaucoma), pure cataract and nonpure cataract groups were
constituted. Fifteen age and sex matched healthy subjects were selected for the control group.
Results. In our study, for all groups of patients, the measured markers of oxidative stress were
modified vs. control values. Plasma antioxidant capacity, plasma antioxidant “gap”, cholesterol and
albumin/globulin levels were significantly decreased while RBC SOD activity, RBC catalase activity
and plasma ceruloplasmin were significantly increased. Inflammatory markers, ceruloplasmin and
albumin/globulins were correlated with different parameters of oxidative stress.
Conclusion. The blood redox values and the level of some inflammatory markers demonstrate
that senile cataract is a systemic disease with an inflammatory component.
Key words: senile cataract, oxidative stress, inflammation, systemic disease.
Cataract is one of the major causes of blindness
throughout the world [1]. Understanding the
mechanisms of cataractogenesis will lead to a better
therapy. It is estimated that the need for cataract
extractions would be diminished by half if onset of
cataract would be delayed by only ten years [2].
Oxidative stress continues to be the leading
mechanism of cataractogenesis. The lens exists in
an environment that is rich in endogenous sources
of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which are
produced by the high local oxygen concentration,
the chronic exposure to light, and the pathogenic
activities of lens epithelial cells.
Although multiple physiologic defenses exist
to protect the lens from the toxic effects of light
and oxidative damage, mounting evidence suggests
that chronic exposure to oxidative stress over the
long-term may damage the lens and predispose it to
cataract development [3].
J.J. Harding proposes a variety of factors
implicated in maturity onset cataractogenesis: a low
antioxidant defense capacity, a high lipid peroxidation,
augmented nonenzymic glycosylation, a reduced
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 279–287
chaperone function of alpha-crystallins and an
increased permeability of lens membrane. There are a
few arguments for these statements: low levels of
reduced glutathione and reduced activity of antioxidant
enzymes, high content of sugar phosphates in lens
which are reactive glycating molecules, altered
structure of alpha-crystallins with diminished
chaperone function, membranes lesions with loss
of gap junctions and an increased flux through
nonspecific cation channels [4].
Some theories of oxidative stress in senile
cataract are based on the generation of reactive
oxygen species and reactive molecules within the
nucleus itself. Truscott considers that the lens barrier,
which becomes apparent in middle age, acts to
impede the flow of small molecules between the
cortex and the nucleus. The barrier may contribute to
the lowered concentration of reduced glutathione
(GSH) in the lens nucleus after middle age. By
extending the residence time within the lens centre,
the barrier also facilitates the decomposition of
intrinsically unstable metabolites and may exacerbate
the formation of H(2)O(2) in the nucleus [5].
280
Bogdana Vîrgolici et al.
However, many studies on cataract formation
focus on a primary role of systemic oxidative
stress, generated outside the lens. We mention
some of their conclusions:
–
–
–
subjects with early cataract are under increased
systemic oxidative stress, which can be identified
by a sensitive biomarker of lipid peroxidation,
such as isomers of total hydroxyoctadecadienoic
acid (HODE) [6].
patients with cataract have lower values of
serum investigated parameters of antioxidative
defense system (ascrobate, dehydroascorbate,
vitamin E, glutathione, peroxidase and catalase
activity) and higher level of plasma lipid
peroxidation product [7].
cataractous patients had significantly lower
whole blood GSH values, erythrocyte superoxide
dismutase (SOD) activity and higher plasma
thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS)
than those in the control group [8].
In order to underline the importance of
redox blood modification on the lens, we mention
two studies:
Street et al. found an association between
atherosclerosis and cataract, which was strongest for
people aged 65–69 years; they raised the question of
whether a deficiency in the natural defenses against
free radicals contributes to the development of both
cataract and atherosclerosis [9].
Stahl et al. demonstrated that the regulation
of the glutathione system in the eye, at least in
aqueous humor, is dependent on plasma glutathione
levels; this correlation reflects the importance of
sufficient glutathione levels in venous plasma and
suggests the possibility of modulating the glutathione
system in the eye via manipulation of plasma
glutathione levels [10].
Within the strategy to maintain redox balance
against oxidant conditions, blood has a central role
because it transports and redistributes antioxidants
to each part of the body.
Nonenzymatic antioxidants such as: albumin,
uric acid, bilirubin, glutathione (GSH), ascorbic
acid, α-tocopherol, β-carotene, and flavonoids
constitute the first line of antioxidant defense
systems of the blood. Among the red blood cells
(RBC) enzyme systems (the second antioxidant
defense systems), superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase
(CAT) are very important.
Plasma antioxidant capacity (AC) is modulated
either by radical overload or by intake of dietary
2
antioxidants and can therefore be regarded as more
representative of the in vivo balance between
oxidizing species and antioxidant compounds than
the concentration of single, selected low molecular
antioxidant.
The aim of our study was to measure some
plasma and red blood cell oxidative stress markers in
cataractous patients. Correlations between these markers
and some inflammatory ones were calculated.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The patients were recruited from the ophthalmic
surgery department of “Oculus” Clinic, Bucharest.
The blood samples were collected from 38 patients
(aged 50 to 80) with cataract, without metabolic or
severe somatic diseases and from 15 age and sex
matched healthy subjects. Smokers and alcohol
consumers were excluded from the study. Because
of the advanced age, most of the patients had
different associated illnesses: high blood pressure,
hearing loss, other ocular age related diseases, etc.
Patients were subdivided according two criteria.
Considering age criteria, presenile and senile
cataract groups were formed. According to the
absence or presence of other ocular comorbidities
(age–related macular degeneration, glaucoma), pure
cataract and nonpure cataract (cataract associated
with other ocular diseases) groups were constituted.
Blood samples were taken into 10 ml vacutaine
tubes, containing heparin, from a peripheral vein after
12 hours of fasting and drugs break. The study
protocol was approved by the Ethical Commission of
“Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy
Bucharest and a written informed consent was
obtained from each study participant.
Plasma total cholesterol, uric acid, bilirubin
and glucose were analyzed by enzymatic methods,
using kits (Human Gesellschaft für Biochemica
und Diagnostica mbH, Wiesbaden Germany). For
total proteins and albumin we used kits from the
same source.
Protein thiols in plasma were measured by a
colorimetric method. We measured the absorption at
412nm of acids formed in the reaction between the
-SH groups and 5-5’-dithiobis-nitrobenzoic acid [11].
The plasma thiobarbituric acid-reacting
substances (TBARS) were determined by thiobarbituric acid reaction at 540 nm [12].
The globulins were calculated by the difference
between total plasma proteins and albumin.
3
281
Systemic redox modifications in cataract
Superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity was
measured in erythrocytes by the spectrophotometric
method described by Marklund S., [13]. The inhibition
of pyrogallol oxidation by SOD was monitored at
420 nm, and the amount of enzyme producing 50%
inhibition is defined as one unit of enzyme activity.
Erythrocyte catalase activity was determined
by using hydrogen peroxide as a substrate, at
240nm [14].
Plasma total antioxidant capacity (AC) was
determined by Miller et al. method and the antioxidant
gap was calculated according to the equation: (GAP) =
AC (mmol/l) – [albumin (mmol/l) X 0.69 + uric acid
(mmol/l) X 1)] [15].
The plasma ceruloplasmin level determination
was based on the o-dianisidine dihydrochloride endpoint method [16].
The hemoglobin quantity was measured using
the Drabkin method.
The results were analyzed statistically using
Student test. Data are expressed as mean ± s.d.
Two-tailed p-values <0.05 were considered statistically
significant. The relationship between the various
parameters was assessed by correlation (multiple
regression).
RESULTS
The characteristics of the groups are shown in
Table I.
The assessed parameters of oxidative stress
are shown in Table II.
Table I
Parameter
Age (years)
Sex (male/female)
Type of cataract:
SC/NC/NC+PSC/CC/MC
Healthy subjects Presenile cataract
group (n=15)
(n=15 )
57.18±6.6
57.27±5.9
5/10
–
5/10
Senile cataract Pure cataract Cataract associated with
group (n=23) group (n=25) other ocular illnesses (n=13)
73.12±4.6
68.94±8.17
70.5±9,06
p<0.02 vs. 1
8/15
9/16
4/9
1/6/6/1/1
2/5/8/1/7
2/7/9/2/5
1/4/5/0/3
SC/NC/NC+PSC/CC/MC = Subcapsular cataract/Nuclear cataract/nuclear and posterior subcapsular cataract/cortical cataract/mixt
cataract
Table II
Plasma parameter
Healthy controls
n=15 (group M)
Presenile cataract
group n=15
(group 1)
Senile cataract
group n=23
(group2)
Pure cataract
group n=25
(group B)
Plasma thiols
(µmol/g protein)
Plasma TBARS (µmol/l)
7.37±0.7
7.55±0.54
6.98±0.55
2.18±0.59
3.42±0.63
p<0.01 vs. M
200.68±33.49
p<0.04 vs. M
6.71±0.63
p<0.02 vs. 1
2.39±0.67
p<0.02 vs. group1
224.04±57
Cataract associated
with other ocular
illnesses n=13
(Group C)
7.05±0.73
3.03±0.65
3.01±0.62
232.35±56.69
192.53±35.95
p<0.05 vs. Group B
p<0.001 vs. M
4.33±0.29
Plasma cholesterol
[mg/dl]
243.45±46.85
Plasma albumin [g/dl]
4.52±0.33
4.11±0.27
p<0.002 vs. M
4.25±0.22
p<0.01 vs. M
Plasma proteins [g/dl]
7.51±0.49
7.55±0.20
Plasma bilirubin [mg/dl]
0.47±0.17
0.49±0.13
8.01±0.39
p<0.01 vs. group1
p<0.025 vs. M
0.54±0.15
Plasma uric acid [mg/dl]
4.05±0.44
3.77±0.59
Total antioxidant
capacity [mM Trolox]
Plasma residual
antioxidant capacity
[mM]
0.87±0.12
0.74±0.08
p<0.01 vs. M
0.093±0.03
p<0.005 vs. M
0.21±0.04
4.41±0.48
p<0.02 vs. group1
p<0.03 vs. M
0.75±0.07
p<0.01 vs. M
0.087±0.03
p<0.001 vs. M
4.04±0.42
p<0.004 vs. M
p<0.04 vs.
groupC
7.88±0.33
0.46±0.16
4.16±0.89
0.74±0.09
p<0.01 vs. M
0.12±0.03
p<0.04 vs. M
7.74±0.49
0.62±0.19
p<0.05 vs. group B
4.13±0.62
0.75±0.05
p<0.01 vs. M
0.06±0.01
p<0.01 vs. Group B
p<0.001 vs. M
Bogdana Vîrgolici et al.
282
4
Plasma globulins [g/dl]
3.30±0.64
3.44±0.29
3.76±0.37
p<0.03 vs. M
Albumin/globulins
1.42±0.26
1.21±0.17
1.13±0.11
p<0.026 vs. M
Plasma ceruloplasmin
[UI/l]
RBC SOD [UI/g Hb]
276.69±107.43
375.88±168.81
p<0.03 vs. M
470.07±111.75
p<0.05 vs. M
396.57±128.59
p<0.01 vs. M
469.46±107.56
p<0.05 vs. M
RBC Catalase [kat/g Hb]
146.95±68.2
Plasma glucose [mg/dl]
95.61±12.27
235.82±89
p<0.02 vs. M
98.49±10.46
253.13±137.54
p<0.01 vs. M
96.18±10.15
409.82±58.84
3.82±0.17
p<0.03 vs. M
p<0.04 vs.
groupC
1.09±0.16
p<0.01 vs.
groupC
p<0.004 vs. M
390.31±117.66
p<0.01 vs. M
398.33±93.77
263.99±129.2
p<0.01 vs. M
95.93±12.3
3.41±0.23
1.26±0.12
p<0.05 vs. M
386.98±134.99
p<0.02 vs. M
514.04±104.26
p<0.001 vs.group B
p<0.005 vs. M
251.08±89.13
p<0.01 vs. M
96.11±9.55
The correlations between blood oxidative markers and inflammatory markers are shown in Tables III and IV.
Table III
Correlated parameters
Plasma thiols [µmol/g protein]
Plasma TBARS [nmols/ml]
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
Plasma albumin [mg/dl]
Plasma albumin [mg/dl}
Plasma cholesterol [mg/dl]
Plasma ceruloplasmin [UI/l]
Plasma ceruloplasmin [UI/l]
Plasma TBARS [nmol/ml
RBC SOD [UI/l]
RBC Catalase [kat/g Hb]
Plasma cholesterol [mg/dl]
Plasma TBARS [nmols/ml]
Plasma TBARS [nmols/ml]
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
Albumin/globulins
[kat/g Hb]
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
r value
Presenile cataract Senile cataract group
group (n=15)
(n=23)
–0.76
–0.47
+0.53
–
+0.58
–0.72
–0.65
+0.74
–0.68
+0.58
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
+0.52
+0.55
+0.80
Table IV
Correlated parameters
Plasma globulins [mg/dl]
Plasma cholesterol [mg/dl]
Plasma albumin [mg/dl]
Plasma albumin [mg/dl]
Plasma albumin [mg/dl]
Plasma thiols [µmol/gprotein]
Plasma TBARS [nmol/ml]
Plasma Bilirubin [mg/dl]
RBC SOD [UI/l]
Plasma cholesterol [mg/dl]
DISCUSSION
The recognition of cataract in a growing number
of systemic diseases and syndromes has necessarily
prompted investigation into unifying mechanisms
[17]. Oxidative stress may be one of them.
Also, human cataract in older age groups
seems to be due to an accumulation of risk factors,
r value
Pure cataract group Non-pure cataract
(n=22)
group (n=16)
–
–0.48
+0.48
–0.56
–
+0.47
–
–0.63
+0.64
–
even if individual mean concentrations are
well within normal limits but, of course, differing
significantly from the corresponding means in
control population [18]. Case-control studies
showed that nuclear cataract was significantly
associated with raised serum bilirubin and that all
forms of cataract are significantly associated with
raised plasma albumin and reduced levels of
cholesterol [18–20].
5
Systemic redox modifications in cataract
Conflicting results concerning different levels
for plasma antioxidant capacity and erythrocyte
antioxidant systems in cataractous patients can be
found in literature [21–24].
In our study, for all groups of patients, the
measured markers of oxidative stress were modified
vs. control values. Plasma AC, plasma antioxidant
“gap”, cholesterol and albumin/globulin levels were
significantly decreased and RBC SOD activity, RBC
catalase activity and plasma ceruloplasmin were
significantly increased. Each of these parameters was
to be discussed.
Human lens membranes have the highest
cholesterol content of any known biological membrane.
Exogenous sources of cholesterol are essential for
the lens. Hockwin et al., working on bovine eye,
demonstrated a direct relation between the plasma
and aqueous humor cholesterol concentrations [25].
Disturbances in cholesterol homeostasis may
result in cell damage by a variety of mechanisms:
membrane ionic pumps, electrolytic imbalance and
calcium homeostasis.
The low serum levels of cholesterol together
with the high plasma levels of TBARS, obtained in
patients aged 50–65 years, may be responsible for
the early onset of senile cataract.
Knowing that cholesterol rises with age and
despite the age difference between the control
group and the group with cataract associated with
ocular comorbidities, it is interesting to notice that
plasma cholesterol was significantly lower in the
patient group. High statistical power studies have
demonstrated that all forms of cataract are
associated with low plasma cholesterol while
patients with age-related maculopathy have no
significant differences of plasma cholesterol level
vs. control subjects [26].
Positive correlations between plasma levels of
albumin and cholesterol and negative correlations
between TBARS either with albumin or cholesterol
were calculated. Albumin and cholesterol may be
oxidized in conditions of increased oxidative stress
reflected by high levels of TBARS.
It is known that oxidation of the protein thiol
groups, especially the ones from serum albumin, is
a sensible and specific oxidative stress marker in
the vascular compartment [27]. Albumin inhibits
oxidative damage by binding copper ions and it can
react with H2O2 and HOCl.
In this study, for all four groups of patients,
the low levels for albumin, the high values for
globulins, and the low albumin/globulin ratio can
283
be explained in an inflammatory context. Senile
cataract can be considered an illness with a low grade
inflammatory status. It is known that inflammation is
characterized by oxidative reactions and generation of
high oxygen reactive species. Also, the negative
correlations between plasma total thiols and globulins
represent an argument for a relation between
inflammation (high globulins) and the plasma
antioxidant defense (consumption of plasma thiols).
The association of systemic inflammation and senile
cataract has been demonstrated in recent studies.
Elevated levels of CRP are associated with future risk
of cataract in apparently healthy men [28]) and two
serum markers of systemic inflammation and vascular
endothelial dysfunction (interleukin-6 and intracellular
adhesion molecule-1) are associated with nuclear
cataract [29].
Donnelly et al. measured plasma constituents
in a population of 1000 pairs (healthy and
cataractous patients), with strict control of age in
matched pair protocol. The investigators found
high levels of albumin and of total protein in the
cataract group. The significant lower albumin/
(total protein-albumin) ratio, (an approximation for
albumin/globulin ratio) may imply an increase in
globulin, suggestive of possible (chronic) infection
in patients with senile cataract [14, 30]. Leske et al.
and Schoenfeld et al. obtained similar results
and both research teams reported that a high
albumin/globulin ratio decreased risk for mixed
cataract [31][32].
The positive correlation, calculated in this
study, between globulins and plasma ceruloplasmin
is not surprising in an inflammatory status. Maybe
the raised globulin level is due to the high α2
globuline fraction (including ceruloplasmin).
Human plasma normally contains 200–400 mg/l
of caeruloplasmin, accounting for at least 90% of
total plasma copper. The remaining plasma copper
is often claimed to consist of copper ions bound to
albumin, histidine or small peptides. Caeruloplasmin
is increased greatly in the acute phase reaction and it
has also a ferrroxidase activity: it oxidizes Fe2+ to Fe3+
and can facilitate iron loading on to transferrin [33].
Increased plasma level of caeruloplasmin was
found in patients with senile cataract and in
galactosaemic children with cataract and without
cataract [34][35]. Maybe this enzyme is induced by
reactive oxidative species and its high level is in
accordance with the raised PCR level observed in
cataractous patients. We emphasize that the high
ceruloplasmin values obtained in this study may
284
Bogdana Vîrgolici et al.
reflect that senile cataract is a systemic disease
with inflammatory status.
Peroxidation is associated with inflammation.
Lipid peroxidation, measured as TBARS concentration
was the highest in presenile cataract and these
modification may be linked to the premature
development of senile cataract [36].
The low molecular weight antioxidants in
plasma are “sacrificial” compounds. They rapidly get
consumed during the scavenging of reactive oxygen
species and need to be regenerated or replaced by
new dietary-derived compounds. It is essential to
measure these antioxidants in assessing in vivo
antioxidant status. However, the number of different
antioxidants in plasma or other biological samples
makes it difficult to measure each antioxidant
separately. The possible interaction among different
antioxidants in vivo could also make the
measurement of any individual antioxidant less
representative of the overall antioxidant status [37].
Recent literature indicates that antioxidants
may ameliorate the risk for age related cataract. As
an example, higher intakes of vitamin C or the
combined intake of antioxidants had long-term
protective associations against development of
nuclear cataract in a group of older population [38].
The results of observational studies suggest
that a healthy lifestyle with a diet containing food
rich in antioxidants, particularly lutein and zeaxanthin,
as well as n-3 fatty acids, appears beneficial in age
macular degeneration and possibly cataract [39].
While data from the observational studies
generally demonstrate a protective role for
antioxidants in foods or supplements, results from
intervention trials are less encouraging with respect
to limiting risk for age related cataract/ age related
maculopathy prevalence or progress through
antioxidant supplementations, or maintaining higher
levels of antioxidants either in diet or blood [40].
In our study all groups of patients had low
levels of plasma AC, reflecting a reduced plasma
antioxidant defense system. The lowest plasma
residual antioxidant capacity was calculated for
cataractous patients with ocular comorbidities. This
result underlines the importance of vitamins and
other low weight antioxidant defence compounds
in age-related macular degeneration and glaucoma.
Antioxidant capacity of plasma for 96 patients
with senile cataract was determined by Tissie et al.
[41]. Irrespective of the previous studies that
demonstrated a relationship between decreased levels
of antioxidant components in blood and the
6
occurrence of lens opacities, the investigators
couldn’t find any significant difference between the
subjects with and without senile cataract.
Regarding the antioxidant gap, it can be noticed
that the lowest value is present in cataractous patients
with ocular comorbidities. This value is another
strong argument for the importance of plasma
antioxidant defense in age related ocular diseases
and can justify the benefits of antioxidant therapy
for specific groups of cataractous patients.
Uric acid is an important antioxidant. The
contribution of uric acid to total antioxidative status
(Randox test) amounted to 38% in tear fluid, 10% in
aqueous humour and 37% in serum. Positive
correlations for uric acid levels in tear fluid, aqueous
humour and serum were demonstrated [42]. This is
another argument for a link between plasma
parameters and ocular ones, or between systemic
status and the lens one. We obtained the highest
significant uric acid plasma levels in senile cataract
group, characterized by nuclear and posterior
subcapsular cataract forms. Our result is in
accordance with those from literature, as it follows.
It was demonstrated that higher uric acid
levels increased the risk for mixed opacities (OR=1.74)
Leske et al. [31] or for posterior subcapsular
cataract (OR = 1.62) [the Italian-American Cataract
Study Group [43].
Bilirubin is a scavenger of O2.–, HO.. In both
Edinburgh studies its serum level was significantly
raised in cataractous patients compared to control
subjects [18][19]. The authors of the studies considered
that the significant rise in three plasma constituents:
alkaline phosphates, bilirubin, and γ-glutamyl
transpeptidase with the lack of significant increase
in alanine aminotransferase, would be consistent with
an association between mild intrahepatic cholestasis
and cataract. They mentioned that the mean values
estimated in both groups of subjects (cataractous and
normal ones) are within the generally accepted normal
reference range, which are 2 standard deviations from
the mean of a large parent population [18][19]. In our
study, cataractous patients with associated ocular
comorbidities had significant high plasma bilirubin
values compared to pure cataract group.
According to many studies, the antioxidant
enzymes (catalase, SOD, GPx, GR) in cataract lens
have lower activity then the enzymes from the
normal lenses [44–48]. However, the results of the
measurement of the activity of the RBC antioxidant
enzymes from the cataractous patients diverge, as
is illustrated in the following studies:
7
–
Systemic redox modifications in cataract
a small size case-control study did not show any
difference in the levels of erythrocyte SOD, GPx
and glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD)
in cataractous patients [21];
– Chinese researchers found a lower activity of
several RBC antioxidant enzymes (SOD, catalase)
and a significantly decreased erythrocyte GPx
level in subjects with senile lens changes [49];
– the POLA study showed a strong association of
high levels of erythrocyte SOD with increased
risk of nuclear cataract [50].
In a relatively recent published study,
the erythrocyte SOD activity was significantly
increased in the cataractous group compared with
healthy matched subjects and catalase activity was
not modified [51].
285
In this study, made in 38 patients with
predominant nuclear and posterior subcapsular
senile cataract, the erythrocyte SOD and catalase
activities were significantly raised in all studied
groups versus control group. The highest value was
determined in the group with cataract and ocular
comorbidities. These values may reflect an adaptive
protective response, which is indicative of mild
oxidative stress.
In conclusion, taking into account all the
modified blood parameters, senile cataract may be
considered an illness with systemic echo, not only
a local disease. But, it is still hard to say if the
modified oxidative stress parameters are cause or
effect in senile cataract.
Studii recente asupra cataractogenezei atrag atenţia asupra rolului primar al
stresului oxidativ sistemic, generat înafara cristalinului. Markeri plasmatici ai
inflamaţiei sunt asociaţi cu cataracta senilă.
Obiective. Scopul acestui studiu este de a determina corelaţii între markerii
sanguini de stres oxidativ şi câţiva markeri de inflamaţie, la pacienţii cu cataractă senilă.
Materiale şi metode. Probele de sânge au fost recoltate de la 38 pacienţi, cu
vârste între 50–80 ani. Pacienţii au fost împărţiţi după două criterii.
Considerând criteriul vârstei, s-au contituit două loturi, cu cataractă
presenilă şi respectiv senilă. Folosind criteriul comorbidităţilor oculare asociate
(degenerescenţa maculară, glaucom), s-au format lotul cataractei pure şi cel al
cataractei ce asociază alte afecţiuni oculare. Cincisprezece subiecţi control,
corespunzători ca vârstă şi sex au fost recrutaţi.
Resultate. În acest studiu, pentru toate loturile cu pacienţi, toţi parametrii de
stres oxidativ au fost modificaţi faţă de cei din lotul control. Astfel, la pacienţi,
capacitatea antioxidantă plasmatică, gap-ul antioxidant plasmatic, colesterolul,
raportul albumine/globuline au avut valori semnificativ reduse, în timp ce
activitatea eritrocitară a SOD, a catalazei, precum şi a ceruloplasminei plasmatice
au avut valori semnificativ crescute. Markerii inflamatorii, ceruloplasmina şi
raportul albumine/globuline s-au corelat cu diferiţi markeri de stres oxidativ.
Concluzie. Cataracta senilă este o boală sistemică cu componentă inflamatorie,
conform valorilor sanguine redox şi concentraţiei unor markeri plasmatici ai inflamaţiei.
Corresponding author: Bogdana Vîrgolici, MD
Biochemistry Department, Faculty of Medicine “Carol Davila” University,
8, Bd. Eroilor Sanitari, Bucharest, 050471, Romania
REFERENCES
1.
2.
TAYLOR A., JACQUES P.F., EPSTEIN E., Relations among aging, antioxidant status, and cataract. Am. J. Clin. Nutr., 1995,
62 suppl:1439 S–47 S.
TAYLOR A., Nutr. Rev., 1998, 47(8): 225–234.
286
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
Bogdana Vîrgolici et al.
8
GUL A., RAHMAN M.A., HASNAIN S.N., SALIM A., SIMJEE S.U., Could Oxidative Stress Associate with Age Products in
Cataractogenesis? Curr. Eye Res., 2008, 33(8):669–75.
HARDING J.J., Physiology, biochemistry, pathogenesis, and epidemiology of cataract. Current Opinion in Ophthalmolology,
1992; 3:3–12.
TRUSCOTT R.J., Age-related nuclear cataract-oxidation is the key. Exp. Eye Res., 2005, May; 80(5):709–25.
LI L., DUKER J.S., YOSHIDA Y., NIKI E., RASMUSSEN H., RUSSELL R.M., YEUM K.J., Oxidative stress and antioxidant
status in older adults with early cataract. Eye advance online publication, 19 September 2008; 10.1038/eye.2008.281.
ZORIC L., Parameters of oxidative stress in the lens, aqueous humor and blood in patients with diabetes and senile cataracts,
Srp. Arh. Celok. Lek., 2003 Mar.–Apr.; 131(3–4):137–42.
DONMA O., YORULMAZ E., PEKEL H., SUYUGÜL N., Blood and lens lipid peroxidation and antioxidant status in normal
individuals, senile and diabetic cataractous patients., Curr. Eye Res., 2002 Jul.; 25(1):9–16.
STREET D.A., JAVITT J.C., WANG Q., TIELSCH J.M., CANNER J.K., BASS E.B., STEINBERG E.P., Atherosclerotic
disease in patients undergoing cataract extraction: a nationwide case-control study. Arch. Ophthalmol., 1996, 114:1407–1411.
STAHL E., BUHL R., SCHNAUDIGEL O., STEINKAMP G., FRIES U., GÜMBEL H., OHRLOFF C., Regulation of
glutathione level in venous plasma and aqueous humor in cataracta senilis provecta. Der Ophthalmologe: Zeitschrift Der
Deutschen, Ophthalmologischen Gesellschaft, 1996, 93:54–58.
HALL N.D., BLAKE D.R.&BACON P.A., Serum sulphydryl levels in early synovitis. J. Rheumatol., 1982, 9, 593–396.
ESTERBAUER H., CHEESEMAN K.H., Determination of aldehyde lipid peroxidation products, malondialdehyde and
4-hydroxynonenal. Methods in Enzymol, 1990, Feb.; 93, 210–215.
MARKLUND S., MARKLUND G., Eur. J. Biochem., 1974, 47, 469–474.
MANNERVIK B., GUTHENBERG C., Methods in Enzymology, 1984, 77:231–237.
RICE-EVANS C., MILLER N.J., Methods Enzymol., 1994, 234: 279–293.
SCHOSINSKY K.H, LEHMANN P., BEELERM F. et al., Measurement of ceruloplasmin from its oxidase activity in serum by
use of o-dianisidine dihydrochloride. Clin. Chem., 1974, 20:1556–63.
CINDY M.L.H., BRUCE D.N., Cataracts in systemic diseases and syndromes, Current Opinion in Ophthalmology, 1999,
10:22–28.
DONNELLY, C.A., SETH, J., CLAYTON, R.M., PHILLIPS, C.I., CUTHBERT, J., PRESCOTT, R.J., Some blood plasma
constituents correlate with human cataract. Br. J. Ophthalmol., 1995, 79: 1036–1041.
CLAYTON, R.M., CUTHBERT, J., SETH, J., PHILLIPS, C.I., BARTHOLOMEW, R.S., REID, J.M., Epidemiological and
other studies in the assessment of factors contributing to cataractogenesis. CIBA Foundation Symposium, 1984, 106: 25–40.
DONNELLY C.A., SETH J., CLAYTON R.M., PHILLIPS C.I., CUTHBERT J., PRESCOTT R.J., Some plasma constituents
correlate with human cataract location and nuclear colour. Ophthalmic Res 1997; 29:207–17.
JACQUES, P.F., CHYLACK, JR. L.T., MCGANDY R.B., HARTZ, S.C., Antioxidant status in persons with and without senile
cataract. Arch. Ophthalmol., 1988, 106:337–340.
MOHAN, M., SPERDUTO, R., ANGRA, S.K., MILTON, R.C., MATHUR, R.L., UNDERWOOD, B.A., JAFFERY, N.,
PANDYA, C.B., CHHABRA, V.K., VAJPAYEE, R.B., KALRA, V.K., SHARMA, Y.R., India – US case control study of age
related cataracts. Arch. Ophthalmol., 1989, 107:670–676.
CASADO, A., DE LA TORRE R., LOPEZ-FERNANDEZ, E., Antioxidant enzyme levels in red blood cells from cataract
patients. Gerontology, 2001, 47: 16–18.
WONG, L., HO, S.C., COGGON, D., CRUDDAS, A.M., HWANG, C.H., HO, C.P., ROBERTSHAW, A.M., MACDONALD,
D.M., Sunlight exposure, antioxidant status, and cataract in Hong Kong fishermen. Journal of Epidemiology and Community
Health, 1993, 47: 46–49.
HOCKWIN O., KOJIMA M., CZUBAYKO F., VON BERGMANN K., Inhibition of cholesterol synthesis and cataract.
ortschritte Der Ophthalmologie: Zeitschrift Der Deutschen Ophthalmologischen Gesellschaft,1991, 88:393–395.
SANDERS T., HAINES A.P., WORMALD R., WRIGHT L.A., OBEID O.A., Essential fatty acids, plasma cholesterol, and fatsoluble vitamins in subjects with age-related maculopathy and matched control subjects. Am. J. Clin. Nutr., 1993 Mar.;
57(3):428–33.
RADI R., BUSH K.M., COSGROVE T.P., FREEMAN B.A., Reaction of xanthine oxidase derived oxidants with lipid and
protein of human plasma. Arch biocem biophys, 1991; 286:117–125.
SCHAUMBERG D.A., RIDKER P.M., GLYNN R.J., CHRISTEN W.G., DANA M.R., HENNEKENS C.H., High levels of
plasma C-reactive protein and future risk of age-related cataract), Ann. Epidemiol., 1999, Apr. 9(3):166–71).
KLEIN B.E.K, KLEIN R., LEE K.E., KNUDTSON M.D., TSAI M.Y., Markers of inflammation, vascular endothelial
dysfunction and age related cataract, American J. of Ophthalmology, 2006; 14:116–122.
DONNELLY C.A., SETH J., CLAYTON R.M., PHILLIPS C.I., CUTHBERT J., SCHOENFELD E.R., LESKE M.C., WU
S.Y., Recent epidemiologic studies on nutrition and cataract in India, Italy and the United States., J. Am. Coll. Nutr., 1993
Oct.; 12:521–6.
LESKE M.C., WU S.Y., HYMAN L., SPERDUTO R., UNDERWOOD B., CHYLACK L.T., MILTON R.C., SRIVASTAVA
S., ANSARI N., Biochemical factors in the lens opacities. Case-control study. The Lens Opacities Case-Control Study Group,
Arch. Ophthalmol., 1995 Sep.; 113:1113–9.
SCHOENFELD E.R., LESKE M.C., WU S.-Y., Recent epidemiologic studies on nutrition and cataract in India, Italy and the
United States. J. Am. Coll. Nutr., 1993, 12:521–6.
9
Systemic redox modifications in cataract
287
33. HALLIWELL, B., GUTTERIDGE, J.M.C., Free Radicals in Biology and Medicine, third edition, Oxford University Press,
1998.
34. SZCZYPKA, M., GAJEWSKI, J., LASKOWSKA-KLITA, T., ZBIEG-SENDECKA, E., Red blood cells and serum antioxidant
defence systems of galactosaemic children. Biomed. Biochim. Acta, 1990, 49(10): 1015–1019.
35. METELITSYNA, I.P., Metabolic disturbances in blood from patients with senile cataracts accompanied by somatic diseases.
Ukr. Biokhim. Zh. [Ukraine]1998, Mar–Apr, 70(2): 110–115.
36. VIRGOLICI B., STOIAN I., MUSCUREL C., MARACINE M., MORARU C., DINU V., Plasma redox status in age related
cataract, Romanian Journal of Internal Medicine, 2007, 45(1):59–67.
37. GHISELLI, A., SERAFINI, M., NATELLA, F., SCACCINI, C., Total antioxidant capacity as a tool to assess redox
status:critical view and experimental data. Free Radical Biology and Medicine., 2000, 29 (11):1106–1114.
38. TAN A.G., MITCHELL P., FLOOD V.M., BURLUTSKY G., ROCHTCHINA E., CUMMING R.G., WANG J.J., Antioxidant
nutrient intake and the long-term incidence of age-related cataract: the Blue Mountains Eye Study., Am. J. Clin. Nutr., 2008
Jun. 87(6):1899–905.
39. SEDDON J.M., Multivitamin-multimineral supplements and eye disease: age-related macular degeneration and cataract. Am.
J. Clin. Nutr., 2007 Jan.; 85(1):304S–307S.
40. CHIU C.J., TAYLOR A., Nutritional antioxidants and age-related cataract and maculopathy. Exp. Eye Res., 2007 Feb.;
84(2):229–45. Epub. 2006 Jul. 31.
41. TISSIÉ, G., FLANGAKIS, S., MISSOTTEN, L., D'HERMIES, F., DE LAEY, J.J., BOURGEOIS, H., ZENATTI, C.,
HERMET, J.R., RIGEADE, M.C., BONNE, C., Antioxidant activity of plasma from subjects with and without senile cataract.
Documenta Ophthalmologica. Advances in Ophthalmology, 1993, 83: 357–361.
42. HORWATH-WINTER J., KIRCHENGAST S., MEINITZER A., WACHSWENDER C., FASCHINGER C., SCHMUT O.,
Determination of uric acid concentrations in human tear fluid, aqueous humour and serum. Acta Ophthalmol., 2008 Jun. 11.
43. The Italian-American Cataract Study Group., Risk factors for age-related cortical, nuclear and posterior subcapsular cataracts.
American Journal of Epidemiology 1991, 133: 541–544.
44. SAXBY, L.A., Biochemistry, 1999, chap. 4.1–4.4, authors Yanoff M., Duker J.S., Ophthalmology, Mosby, International Ltd.
45. ZIGMAN, S., SCHULTZ, J.B., SCHULTZ, M. Curr. Eye Res. 1998, 2:115–119.
46. HUANG, Q.L., LOU, M.F., STRAATSMA, B.R., HORWITZ, J., Distribution and activity of glutathione-S-transferase in
normal human lenses and in cataractous human epithelia. Curr. Eye Res., 1993, 12(5): 433–437.
47. FECONDO, J.V., AUGUSTEYN, R.C., Superoxide dismutase, catalase and glutathione peroxidase in the human cataractous
lens. Exp. Eye Res., 1983, 36: 15–23.
48. SPECTOR, A., Oxidative stress-induced cataract: mechanism of action. Faseb J., 1995, 9:1173–1182.
49. XUE, A.N., CAI, Q.Y., WANG, S.Q., ZHOU, A.S., LI, W.X., FU, P., CHEN, X.S. Biomed. Environ. Sci., 1996, 9(2–3):144–148.
50. DELCOURT, C., CRISTOL, J.P., TESSIER, F., LEGER, C.L., MITCHEL, F., PAPOZ, L., Risk factors for cortical, nuclear, and
posterior subcapsular cataracts: the POLA study. Pathologies Oculaires Liees a l’Age. Epidemiol, 2000, Mar. 151(5): 497–504.
51. CASADO, A., DE LA TORRE R., LOPEZ-FERNANDEZ, E., Antioxidant enzyme levels in red blood cells from cataract
patients. Gerontology, 2001, 47: 16–18.
Received May 23, 2009
288
Bogdana Vîrgolici et al.
10
Protection of Erythrocyte Membrane Against Oxidative Damage by
Geriforte in Healthy Human Subjects
MARILENAăăGÎLC
1
,ăăIRINAăăSTOIAN1,2,ăăDANIELAăăLIXANDRU1,ăăLAURAăăG MAN1,ăă
BOGDANAăăVÎRGOLICI1,ăăV.ăATANASIU1ă
1ă
BiochemistryăDepartment,ăFacultyăofăMedicine,ă“CarolăDavila”ăUniversity,ăBucharest,ăRomaniaă
2ă
R&DăIRISTăLABMEDăSRL,ăBucharest,ăRomaniaă
Theă influenceă ofă Geriforte,ă ană Ayurvedică naturală supplement,ă onă theă antioxidantă defenseă
systemsă ină humană erythrocytesă andă plasmaă wasă investigatedă ină ană openă humană clinicală study.ă Theă
abilityăofăGeriforteătoăinhibitătheăazo-bisă2-amidinopropaneădihydrochlorideă(AAPH)ădependentălysisă
ofă erythrocytesă wasă alsoă evaluated.ă Geriforteă supplementationă increasedă theă activityă ofă erythrocyteă
catalaseă (265.745ă ±ă 15.768ă vsă 352,329ă ±ă 18.480ă K/gă Hb/mL,ă p<0.01ă )ă andă reducedă theă freeă radicală
mediatedă cytotoxicityă inducedă byă azo-bisă 2-amidinopropaneă dihydrochlorideă (AAPH),ă whichă wasă
measuredăbyăerythrocyteămembraneăstabilityăassayă(0.0439ă±ă0.0069ăvsă0.1291ă±ă0.0396ăC50-ăAAPHă
(mM),ă p<0.05).ăTheăinterventionă didă notăchangeăsignificantlyătheă activityă ofă erythrocyteă superoxideă
dismutaseăandătheăplasmaălevelsăofăantioxidantăagents.ăăTheăresultsăindicateăthatăGeriforteăpossessesă
cytoprotectiveăpropertiesăonăerythrocytesăagainstăoxidativeăchallengeăandăspecificăantioxidantăactivity,ă
whichăinvolvesămainlyătheăintracellularăprotectiveăsystemsăandătheămembranes.ă
Key words:ăantioxidant,ăerythrocyteămembraneăstability,ăGeriforte,ăaging.ă
List of abbreviations:ă AAPH:ă azo-bisă 2-amidinopropaneă dihydrochloride;ă ABTS·+:ă 2,2’azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonică acid)ă radicală cation;ă CAT:ă catalase;ă GAP:ă antioxidantă
gap;ă SOD:ă superoxideă dismutase;ă TAA:ă serumă totală antioxidantă activity;ă TEAC:ă Troloxă equivalentă
antioxidantăactivity.ăă
Recentă dataă stronglyă leadă toă theă ideaă thată
oxidativeăstressăisăaăsignificantămarkerăofăsenescence,ă
beingă establishedă ină agedă humansă andă laboratoryă
animals.ăThisăageărelated-oxidativeăstressăisăgeneratedă
byăaăcombinationăofăincreasedăfreeăradicalsăproduction,ă
decreasedă antioxidantsă levelsă andă impairedă repairă ofă
oxidativeădamagesă[1].ă
Ină recentă years,ă theă clinicală researchă ofă theă
anti-ageingăherbalădrugsăhasăreceivedă considerableă
attention,ă plantsă beingă richă sourcesă ofă compoundsă
withăantioxidantăactivity.ăTheăideaăofăsuperiorityăofă
multi-compoundădrugsă(e.g.ăcombinationăofădifferentă
phytochemicalsă oră naturală antioxidants)ă asă beingă
muchă moreă powerfulă thană single-compoundă drugsă
hasămoreăandămoreăgainedătheăinterestăofăscientists.ă
Hittingămultipleătargetsăhasăbeenărecentlyăproposedă
toă impactă theă complexă equilibriumă ofă theă wholeă
biomoleculară networkă moreă favorableă thană drugsă
thată actă onă aă singleă targetă [2–4].ă Thisă correspondsă
wellă withă theă mechanismă ofă actionă ofă medicinală
plants,ă whichă representă complexă mixturesă ofă
phytochemicalsă andă affectă hundredsă ofă differentă
enzymesăandăreceptorsăsimultaneously.ă
ROM.ăJ.ăINTERN.ăMED.,ă2009,ă47,ă3,ă289–295ă
PreviousăstudiesăshowedăthatăGeriforte,ăaăwellă
knownăAyurvedicămixtureăofăseveralăplantăingredientsă
andă minerals,ă haveă someă anti-ageingă andă antioxidantă
effectsăin vitroăexperimentsăorăinăanimalăstudies:ăită
reducesăage-relatedăchangesăinătheăliverăandătheăbraină
[5][6],ădecreasesăfreeăradicalămediatedăcytotoxicityăină
lymphocytesă [7],ă hasă goodă radioprotectiveă effectsă
basedă onă itsă capacityă toă scavenge·OH,ă O2·–,ă ABTS·+ă
andăNOă[8][9].ăă
Takingă intoă accountă thată erythrocytesă areă
particularlyăsensitiveătoăoxidativeăstressădueătoăhighă
O2ă tension,ă highă contentă ofă polyunsaturatedă lipids,ă
andă theă presenceă ofă transitionă metalsă [10][11],ă theyă
areăconsideredătoăbeăanăexcellentămodelăforătheăstudyă
ofătheăbiomembraneăoxidativeădamage.ăNevertheless,ă
theă effectsă ofă Geriforteă onă erythrocyteă membraneă
stabilityă haveă notă beenă previouslyă beenă addressed,ă
despiteă widespreadă interestă ină theă relevanceă ofă
antioxidantăpropertiesăofăGeriforte.ăă
Keepingă theă aboveă factsă ină view,ă theă presentă
studyă wasă designedă toă evaluateă theă cytoprotectiveă
activitiesă ofă Geriforteă againstă freeă radicală damageă
usingăerythrocytesăasămodelăsystem,ăandătoăestablishă
MarilenaăGîlc ăet al.ă
290ă
ă
theăpreferentialătargetăofăGeriforteăantioxidantăaction:ă
cellulară oră plasmaă antioxidantă systems.ă Weă studiedă
erythrocytesă andă plasmaă antioxidantsă ină healthyă
subjectsă beforeă andă afteră Geriforteă supplementationăă
(2ă tabletsă twiceă dailyă foră 8ă weeks).ă Thisă isă theă firstă
clinicalăstudy,ăwhichăevaluatedătheăeffectăofăGeriforteă
onăantioxidantăsystemsăinăhumans.ă
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Theă studyă wasă approvedă byă theă locală ethicală
committeeă andă conductedă accordingă toă theă ethicală
obligationsă ofă theă Declarationă ofă Helsinki.ă Theă
contentă ofă theă studyă wasă explainedă toă theă
volunteers.ăWrittenăinformedăconsentăwasăobtainedă
fromăsubjectsăpriorătoăinclusionăinătheăstudy.ăă
SUBJECTSă
Subjectsă wereă recruitedă fromă twoă Asylumsă
forăAgeingăPeople,ăadministrativeăandămedicalăstaffă
ofă “Carolă Davila”ă Universityă andă Universityă
Hospital,ă Bucharestă andă healthyă volunteersă whoă
haveăhelpedăinăotherăstudiesăwithinătheăDepartment.ă
Screeningă includedă aă medicală history,ă physicală
examinationă andă bloodă tests.ă Subjectsă withă anyă
acuteă oră chronică diseaseă (diabetesă mellitus,ă
cardiovasculară diseases,ă gastrointestinală diseases,ă
etc.),ă anyă medication,ă ingestionă ofă vitamin,ă herbală
oră minerală supplementsă oră withă haemoglobin,ă
albumină levelă belowă normală rangesă quotedă ină oură
laboratoryăwereăexcluded.ăă
94ă subjectsă wereă screenedă foră thisă study.ăă
40ăsubjectsăwereăexcludedăonătheăgroundsăofăseriousă
diseaseăorăabnormalăhaemoglobinăorăalbuminălevels,ă
whileă 7ă subjectsă wereă takingă vitamină oră herbală
supplements.ăAfterăscreening,ăaătotalăofă37ăsubjectsă
wereăincludedăinătheăstudy.ăă
STUDYăăDESIGNă
Thisăwasăanăopenăclinicalăstudy.ăTheădurationă
ofă theă trială foră eachă participantă wasă 8ă weeks.ă Theă
subjectsăwereăsupplementedăwithă2ătabletsăofăGeriforteă
twiceădailyăforă8ăweeks.ăTheădataăobtainedăafterătheă
supplementationă periodă wereă comparedă withă theă
meană valuesă obtainedă beforeă theă supplementation.ă
Allă subjectsă wereă freeă livingă andă consumedă selfselectedă dietsă throughoută theă study.ă Beforeă andă ată
theăendăofă8ăweekăsupplementationăperiodă10ămlăofă
ă
2
bloodăwasăcollectedăintoăheparinizedăvacutainerătubesă
andă5ămlăofăbloodăinăEDTA-coatedăvacuumătubesăfromă
overnightăfastingăandă10ăminăofărestingăindividuals.ăă
0.5ă mlă ofă EDTA-mixedă bloodă haveă beenă
immediatelyă usedă foră theă erythrocyteă membraneă
stabilityă assayă andă theă restăhasă beenă centrifugedă andă
processedă foră theă measurementă ofă theă otheră
parameters.ă Afteră centrifugationă theă plasmaă wasă
removedăandăretainedăonăiceăforătheăassayăofătotalăfreeă
thiolsă groupsă andă Troloxă equivalentă antioxidantă
activityă (TEAC).ă Theă remainingă erythrocytesă wereă
washedă threeă timesă withă 0.9%ă NaClă andă lysedă ină
ultrapureă Chelexă treatedă water.ă Theă redă cellă stromaă
wasă removedă byă centrifugationă (10ă minutesă ată 4ºC)ă
andăonăclarifiedăsupernatantă(keptăonăice)ăsuperoxideă
dismutaseăactivity,ăcatalaseăactivityăandătotalăandăfreeă
thiolsă levelsă wereă assayed.ă Followingă centrifugationă
theăplasmaăandăerythrocytesăaliquotsăwereăstoredăată–
80°Că untilă use.ă Reagentsă andă ultraă pureă wateră wereă
treatedăwithăChelexă100ă(Merck,ăDarmstadt,ăGermany)ă
toăbindătransitionalămetals.ăAllăreagentsăwereăofăpureă
analyticală qualityă andă wereă purchasedă fromă SigmaAldrichăChemieă(Steinheim,ăGermany),ăifănotăotherwiseă
indicated.ă Allă assaysă wereă performedă byă spectrophotometryă onă aă Perkin-Elmeră Lambdaă EZă 210ă
(Perkin-ElmerăInc,ăBoston,ăUSA),ăexceptingăerythrocyteă
membraneăstabilityăassay,ăwhichăwasăperformedăonă
aă Microplateă Readeră BIO-RADă (USA),ă andă wereă
carriedă oută onă triplicateă samples.ă Theă followingă
parametersăwereămeasured:ă
ERYTHROCYTESăăăMEMBRANEăăăSTABILITYă
Theă assayă isă basedă onă theă sensitivityă toă
haemolysisă ofă aă 0.6–0.8%ă erythrocyteă suspensionă
(obtainedăfromăbloodăsamples)ăonătheăintroductionăofă
AAPHă (azo-bisă 2-amidinopropaneă dihydrochloride),ă
aăradicalăinitiatoră[12].ă
Theăerythrocytesăwereăisolatedăbyăcentrifugationă
ată300×găforă15ăminutesăată4ºCăandăplasmaăremoved.ă
Phosphate-bufferedă salineă (PBS:ă 10mMă sodiumă
phosphate,ă Phă7.4,ă150ă mMăNaCl)ă wasăaddedăbackă
toă theă originală wholeă bloodă volume,ă andă 0.5ă mlă ofă
theă resuspendedă cellsă dilutedă intoă 25ă mlă PBSă toă
obtainăaă0.6–0.8%ăerythrocyteăsuspension.ă100ăµlăofă
thisă suspensionă wasă mixedă withă 100ă µlă solutionă ofă
differentăAAPHăconcentrationsăină96-wellămicroplatesă
andă theseă mixturesă wereă incubatedă ată 37ºCă underă
gentleăstirringăată1000ărpmăforă20ăhours.ăTheăproperă
concentrationă ofă AAPHă andă incubationă timeă wereă
determinedă byă preliminaryă experiments.ă Theă sameă
3ă
ProtectionăofăerythrocyteăandăGeriforte
amountă ofă AAPHă wasă addedă toă controlă wellsă
containingă erythrocytesă lysedă byă additionă ofă Tritonăă
X-100ă toă aă finală concentrationă ofă 1%.ă Thisă controlă
allowedăcorrectionăforătheăamountăofăerythrocytesăină
theăbloodăsample,ăasăwellăasăforătheăeffectăofăAAPHă
onă absorbanceă ofă hemoglobin.ă Afteră 20ă hours,ă theă
microplatesăwereăcentrifugedăată900×găforă3ăminutesă
andă theă supernatantă containingă theă releasedă
hemoglobină(Hb)ăfromătheălysedăcellsăwasăevaluatedă
byămeasuringătheăabsorbanceăată405ănmă(Soretăbandă
absorptionă ofă hemoglobin).ă Theă absorbanceă ofă eachă
wellăwasăreadăată405ănmăusingăaăMicroplateăReaderă
(BIO-RAD,ăUSA).ăTheăpercentageăofăhaemolysisăwasă
determined.ă Erythrocyteă stabilityă wasă expressedă asă
AAPHăconcentrationănecessaryătoăobtaină50%ăofătotală
haemolysisă afteră 20ă hoursă (C50-AAPH).ă C50-AAPHă
wasă calculatedă accordingă toă theă methodă ofă Stagstedă
[12]ă fromă aă fită ofă dataă toă aă sigmoidă curve,ă usingă
GraphPadă Prism4ă (Sană Diego,ă CA,ă USA).ă Theă
experimentăwasăperformedăinătriplicate.ă
Erythrocyte catalase (CAT)ăactivityăwasămeasuredă
usingătheămethodădescribedăbyăMannervikă[13].ăTheă
erythrocyteă lysateă wasă dilutedă ină 0.05Mă potassiumă
phosphateă bufferă (pH=7)ă andă theă reactionă wasă
startedă byă addingă 10mMă hydrogenă peroxide.ă Theă
decreaseăinăabsorbanceăată240nmăwasămeasuredăforă
30ăseconds.ăTheăenzymeăactivityăwasăcalculatedăasăaă
functionă ofă theă rateă constantă ofă theă firstă orderă
reactionă(k)ăandăwasăexpressedăasăk/găHb.ă
ERYTHROCYTEăăSUPEROXIDEăăDISMUTASEă(SOD)ă
SODă activityă wasă determinedă accordingă toă
Marklundămethodă[14].ăTheămethodăisăbasedăonătheă
abilityă ofă SODă toă inhibită pyrogallolă autoxidation.ă
CuZnSODăfromăerythrocytesăwasăextractedăwithăcoldă
ethanol/chloroformă 62.7/37.5ă (v/v).ă Theă supernatantă
fluidă wasă mixedă withă0.2ă mMăpyrogallolăandăTRISă
bufferă(tris-hydroxymethyl-aminomethane-ăhydrochloride)ă
containingă cacodylică acidă andă ethyleneă diaminopentaaceticăacidă(pH=8.2),ăinătheăpresenceăofăoxygen.ă
Theă auto-oxidationă ofă pyrogallolă wasă monitoredă ată
420nmă foră 3ă minutesă againstă theă blankă sample.ă SODă
activityăwasăexpressedăasăU/găHb,ăoneăunitărepresentingă
theăamountăofăenzymeărequiredătoăinhibitătheărateăofă
pyrogallolăautoxidationăbyă50%ăată25°C.ă
Serum total antioxidant activity (TAA)ăefficientlyă
reflectsă theă reală totală antioxidantă effect,ă takingă intoă
accountă theă synergismă betweenă antioxidantsă andă alsoă
exogenousăantioxidantsă(e.g.ăherbalăflavonoids,ăetc.).ăAă
summationă ofă individuală measurementsă mayă notă
291
accuratelyăreflectătheătotalăantioxidantăeffect.ăTherefore,ă
TAAă isă moreă adequate,ă cheaperă andă lessă timeconsumingătoămeasureătheăserumăantioxidantăstatusăofă
subjectsăthanăindividualămeasurementăofăantioxidants.ă
TAAăwasădeterminedăbasedăonătheă6-hydroxy2,5,7,8-tetramethylchroman-2ăcarboxylicăacidă(Trolox)ă
equivalentăantioxidantăcapacityă(TEAC)ăassayădevelopedă
byăMillerăet al.ă[15],ăwithăminorămodificationsă[16].ă
Theă TEACă assayă measuresă theă relativeă abilitiesă ofă
antioxidantsă ină plasmaă oră otheră biologicală fluidsă toă
scavengeătheă2,2’-azino-bisă(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6sulfonică acid)ă (ABTS)ă radicală cationă (ABTS+)ă ină
comparisonăwithătheăantioxidantăpotencyăofăstandardă
amountsă ofă Trolox,ă theă wateră solubleă vitamină Eă
analog.ă Theă ABTS+ă radicală wasă generatedă fromă theă
interactionăbetweenăABTSăandăpotassiumăpersulphate.ă
Solutionă containingă ABTS+ă wasă addedă toă theă serumă
samplesăandătheăabsorbanceăwasăreadăafteră1ăminăată
734ă nmăagainstăaăreagentăblankă(preparedăwithă5ămMă
phosphateăbufferătreatedăasătheăsample).ăTheăpercentageă
inhibitionă ofă theă absorbance,ă whichă isă directlyă
proportională toă theă antioxidantă activityă ofă theă sample,ă
wasă calculated.ă Theă assayă wasă calibratedă againstă aă
calibrationă curveă withă Troloxă asă standard,ă andă theă
resultsăwereăexpressedăasămmol/LăTrolox.ă
SERUMăăRESIDUALăăANTIOXIDANTăăACTIVITYă
(“ANTIOXIDANTăăGAP”;ăăGAP)ă
Theă principală antioxidantsă (byă massă andă
activity)ă ofă humană plasmaă areă albumină andă urică
acid,ă whichă accountă foră 51–57%ă ofă theă totală
antioxidantă activityă [15,17].ă Antioxidantă gapă reflectsă
theă combinedă activityă ofă otheră extracellulară antioxidantsă andă wasă calculatedă byă subtractingă theă
antioxidantă activityă ascribableă toă albumină andă urică
acidă fromă theă TAAă valueă foră eachă sampleă
accordingătoătheăformula:ăă
GAPă =ă TAAă –ă [(Albumineă ×ă 0.69)ă +ă urică
acid]ă where:ă 0.69ă isă theă TEACă valueă foră humană
serumă albumină whileă 1.0ă isă theă TEACă valueă foră
serumăuricăacidă(GAPă=ăserumăresidualăantioxidantă
activity;ă TAAă =ă serumă totală antioxidantă activity;ă
Albumină =ă serumă albumină concentrationă (expressedă
asămmol/L);ăUricăacidă=ăserumăuricăacidăconcentrationă
(expressedă asă mmol/L)).ă Theă resultsă wereă expressedă
asămmol/LăTroloxăactivity.ă
TOTALăăPLASMAăăFREEăăTHIOLSăăLEVELă
Foră theă estimationă ofă totală –SHă groupsă
contentă aliquotsă ofă plasmaă wereă mixedă withă
MarilenaăGîlc ăet al.ă
292ă
ă
phosphateă bufferă (pHă =ă 8)ă andă 10%ă sodiumă
dodecylă sulphate.ă Thenă Ellmană reagentă wasă addedă
andă samplesă wereă incubatedă ată 37Că foră oneă hour.ăă
Theă absorbanceă wasă readă ată 412nmă againstă aă
reagentă blank.ă Resultsă wereă calculatedă usingă aă
calibrationă curveă withă GSHă asă standardă andă wereă
expressedăasă…mol/găproteină[18].ă
Erythrocyte cell free thiols (glutathione)ăwereă
determinedă onă erythrocyteă lysateă afteră precipitationă
ofăproteinsăusingăaăprecipitatingăsolutionăcontainingă
metaphosphorică acid,ă disodiumă ethylenediamineă
tetraacetică acidă andă sodiumă chloride.ă Theă mixtureă
wasăallowedătoăstandăforă5ăminutesăandăthenăfiltered.ă
0.3MăsodiumăphosphateăsolutionăandăEllmanăreagentă
wereă thenă addedă toă theă filtrateă andă theă absorbanceă
wasă readă ată 412ă nm.ă Resultsă areă calculatedă usingă aă
calibrationă curveă withă GSHă asă standardă andă areă
expressedărelativeătoăhemoglobinăcontentă[19].ă
Plasma uric acid, plasma total proteins, plasma
albumină wereă measuredă usingă standardă laboratoryă
techniquesă (kită Humană Gesellschaftă füră Biochemicaă
undăDiagnosticaămbH,ăWiesbadenăGermany).ă
ă
4
STATISTICS
Theăresultsăwereăexpressedăasămeană±ăstandardă
erroră ofă theă meană (SEM).ă Theă dataă wereă analyzedă
usingă GraphPadă Instată andă GraphPadă Prism4ă (Sană
Diego,ăCA,ăUSA)ăstatisticalăanalysisăprogram.ăAllătheă
valuesă wereă normallyă distributed.ă Theă statisticală
significanceă ofă differencesă betweenă individuală valuesă
wasă assessedă byă Students’să pairedă t-test.ă Differencesă
wereăconsideredăstatisticallyăsignificantăatăpă<ă0.05.ăă
RESULTS
Theă statisticală analysisă foră theă comparisonsă
betweenă theă twoă momentsă isă shownă ină Tableă I.ă
Significantă differencesă observedă wereă asă follows.ă
Erythrocytesă membraneă stabilityă measuredă asă C50AAPHă(mM)ăandăcatalasaăactivitytăwereăsignificantlyă
increasedă (pă <ă 0.01,ă respectivelyă pă <ă 0.05)ă afteră
Geriforteăsupplementation.ăThereăwereănoăsignificantă
differencesă ină serumă levelsă ofă theă individuală
antioxidantsăbeforeăandăafterăGeriforteăadministration.ăăă
Table I
MedicinalăplantsăcontainedăinăGeriforteătabletsă
Extracts
mg/tb
mg/tb
100mgă
13.8mgă
Ashvagandhaă(Withania somnifera)ă
Shatavariă(Asparagus racemosus)ăă
30mgă
20mgă
Kasaniă(Cichorium intybus)ă
Daruharidraă(Berberis aristata)ă
13.8mgă
10mgă
Mandukaparniă(Centella asiatica)ă
Haritakiă(Terminalia chebula)ă
20mgă
15mgă
Vasakaă(Adhatoda vasica)ăă
Arjunaă(Terminalia arjuna)ăă
Biranjasiphaă(Achillea millefolium)ă
Kasamardaă(Cassia occidentalis)ăă
10mgă
6.4mgă
3.2mgă
3.2mgă
Vriddadaruă(Argyreia speciosa)ă
Musaliă(Asparagus adscendens)ă
Udakiryakaă(Caesalpinia digyna)ăă
Bhringarajaă(Eclipta alba)ă
Jatiphalamă(Myristica fragrans)ă
Kapikachchuă(Mucuna pruriens)ă
Jaatipatreeă[Myristica fragransă(Mace)]ă
Pippaliă(Piper longum)ă
Kumkumaă(Crocus sativus)ă
Yawaniă(Carum copticum)ă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
10mgă
7mgă
5mgă
Jyothishmatiă(Celastrus paniculatus)ă
5mgă
Haridraă(Curcuma longa)ă
5mgă
DISCUSSION
Theăpresentăstudyăindicatedăstrongăcytoprotectiveă
activityăofăGeriforteăinăerythrocytesăagainstăoxidativeă
challengeă inducedă byă AAPH.ă Theă hydrophilică azoă
compoundă (AAPH)ă usedă ină thisă studyă isă knownă toă
decomposeă spontaneouslyă ină theă aqueousă regionă ată
37ºCă intoă carbon-centeredă radicalsă that,ă ină turn,ă
ă
Powders
Chyavanprashăconcentrateă
Himsraă(Capparis spinosa)ă
produceă peroxylă radicalsă ină theă cellă membranesă
leadingătoătheăhemolysisă[20].ăAfterăsupplementationă
withă Geriforte,ă theă C50-AAPHă valueă significantlyă
increased,ă indicatingă aă higheră resistanceă ofă erythrocytesăagainstăAAPH-inducedăoxidation.ăă
Theăerythrocyteăhasăseveralărobustăsystemsătoă
protectă itselfă againstă oxidativeă damageă andă
hemolysis,ă includingă CATă andă SOD,ă whichă mightă
beăoverwhelmedăbyăaălargeăoxidantăinsultălikeăthată
5ă
293
ProtectionăofăerythrocyteăandăGeriforte
otheră naturală antioxidantsă thată haveă beenă revealedă
toă protectă biologicală membranesă againstă AAPHă
inducedă oxidativeă damageă [21,22],ă oură resultsă
mightă beă correlatedă withă thisă abilityă ofă Geriforteă
ingredientsătoăinteractăwithătheăerythrocyteămembraneă
oră differentă cytoplasmică components,ă otheră thană
SODăorăevenăCAT.ăTheălackăofăcorrelationăbetweenă
C50-AAPHă andă CATă activityă isă supportedăă
alsoă byă theă factă thată AAPHă doesă notă passă theă
membrane,ă bută generatesă reactiveă radicalsă outsideă
theă cells,ă whichă reactă withă moleculesă ină proximityă
toă theă siteă ofă generationă (e.g.ă membraneă lipidsă oră
proteins)ă[12].ă
inducedă byă AAPH.ă Althoughă erythrocyteă CATă
valuesă wereă significantlyă increasedă afteră Geriforteă
supplementation,ă noă significantă changesă wereă
detectedă ină theă erythrocyteă SODă values,ă whenă
comparedă withă initială values.ă Moreover,ă noă
correlationă wasă foundă betweenă C50-AAPHă valuesă
andăCATăactivity.ăTherefore,ăneitherătheăincreaseăofă
CATă activityă oră SODă activityă cană explaină theă
Geriforteă protectionă againstă AAPHă inducedă
hemolysis.ăTakingăintoăaccountăthatăGeriforteăingredientsă
(e.g.ăPhyllantus emblica, Withania somnifera, Centella
asiatica, Tinospora cordifolia,ă Curcuma longa,ă zincă
oxide,ăetc.)ăareăpotentialăsourcesăofăflavonoidsăandă
ă
Table II
InfluenceăofăGeriforteăonăerythrocyteămembraneăstabilityăandăantioxidantăagentsăinăhealthyăsubjectsă
Parameter
Before the intervention
with Geriforte (n= 37)
Average ± SEM
After the intervention
with Geriforte (n =37)
Average ± SEM
Student’s test
P
Erythrocyteămembraneăstabilityăă
C50-AAPHă(mM)ă
Erythrocyteăcatalaseăă
K/găHb/mlă
Totalăplasmaăfreeăthiolsă
µmol/mgăproteine/mlă
Erythrocyteăfreeăthiolsă
(glutathione)ăµmol/găHb/mlăă
Serumătotalăantioxidantăactivityă
(TAA)ămMăTroloxă
Serumăresidualăantioxidantăactivityă
(GAP)ămMăTroloxă
ErythrocyteăSODăactivityăU/găHbă
0.0439ă±ă0.0069ă
0.1291ă±ă0.0396ă
P<0.05ă
265.745ă±ă15.768ă
352.329ă±ă18.480ă
P<0.01ă
7.135ă±ă0.450ă
7.318ă±ă0.276ă
n.s.ă
221.268ă±ă10.248ă
206.751ă±ă8.951ă
n.s.ă
1.440ă±ă0.019ă
1.432ă±ă0.026ă
n.s.ă
0.652ă±ă0.031ă
0.629ă±ă0.052ă
n.s.ă
403.243ă±ă37.74ă
368.436ă±ă16.601ă
n.s.ă
SEMă–ăstandardăerrorăofătheămean;ăn.s.ă–ănon-significantă
Ană increaseă ină serumă TAAă andă GAPă wereă
expectedădueătoătheăfollowingăfacts:ă
1) Antioxidantă activityă ofă variousă Geriforteă
ingredients:ă vită Că ină Phyllantus emblica [23],ă
curcuminăinăCurcuma longa [22],ă sitoindosidesă
VII–XăandăwithaferinăAăinăWithania somniferaă
[24,25],ăetc.ă
2) AAPH,ă whichă isă hydrophilic,ă generatesă radicalsă
inătheăaqueousăregionă(e.g.ăserum,ăplasma),ăwhileă
hydrophilică antioxidants,ă suchă asă vitamină Că andă
uricăacid,ăwhichăareăwellăknownăasăscavengersăofă
radicalsă ină thisă aqueousă phase,ă suppressă theă
oxidationăinitiatedăwithăAAPHă[26].ă
Paradoxically,ă allă theă antioxidantsă evaluatedă
ină theă plasma,ă includingă TAA,ă GAP,ă totală plasmaă
freeă thiolsă showedă noă significantă changesă withă
Geriforteăsupplementation.ă
Aă newă reviewă ofă theă literatureă concerningă
Geriforteăpropertiesăsuggestedăusăaăpossibleăexplanation.ă
ă
Ită hasă beenă alreadyă showedă theă selectiveă influenceă
ofăGeriforteăonădifferentătissueăorămolecularătargets.ă
Foră instance,ă Geriforteă producesă lesseră changeă ină
extrahepatică(e.g.ălungs)ăthenăinăhepaticăantioxidantă
defense,ă maybeă dueă toă theă factă thată herbală
constituentsă haveă firstă undergoă moreă oră lessă
metabolismă byă liveră ină theă caseă ofă orală routeă ofă
administrationă beforeă findingă theiră wayă intoă theă
systemicăcirculationă[27].ăEvenăinătheăsameăorgan,ă
Geriforteă hasă specifică effectsă onă theă differentă
antioxidantă agentsă (e.g.ă increasesă theă activityă ofă
hepaticăcatalase,ăGPXăandăSOD,ăbutăhasănoăchangeă
inătheăhepaticăactivityăofăglutathioneăreductaseăandă
hepaticălevelăofăreducedăglutathione).ă
Oură results,ă suggestingă ană increaseă ină
erythrocyteă bută notă plasmaă antioxidantă defense,ă
correlatedă withă literatureă data,ă suggestă aă possibleă
differentialăaffinityăofăGeriforteăphytochemicalsăforă
certaină cellulară compartmentsă andă biomoleculesă
294ă
ă
MarilenaăGîlc ăet al.ă
(e.g.ă membrane,ă CAT).ă Ită wasă proposedă thată AAPHă
enhancedă lipidă peroxidationă ină cellulară systemsă andă
oxidationă ofă methionine,ă tyrosine,ă andă tryptofană
residuesă thată leadsă toă theă alterationă ofă surfaceă
hydrophobicityă andă precipitationă ofă proteinsă [28,29].ă
Therefore,ă hydrophobică structuresă (e.g.ă membranes)ă
representăpotentialătargetsăofăAAPH-inducedăoxidation.ă
Geriforte,ă whichă reducesă theă susceptibilityă towardsă
AAPH-ă inducedă damage,ă bută doesă notă modifyă theă
majoră plasmaă hydrophilică antioxidantsă (glutathione,ă
uricăacid,ăalbumin),ămightăhaveăaăspecialăaffinityăforă
certainăhydrophobicăstructures.ăă
Oură studyă supportsă theă conceptă thată theă
consumptionă ofă naturală antioxidantă supplementsă cană
beă associatedă withă improvementă ină antioxidantă
defenseă mechanisms.ă Weă suggestă thată theă aboveă
6
resultsăcontributeătoătheăreportedăpositiveăneurologicală
healthăbenefitsăofăGeriforteăadministration.ă
Nevertheless,ătheămainăquestionăisăstillăwithoută
answer:ăDoesăGeriforteăprolongătheălifeăspan?ăă
Althoughă Geriforteă cană selectivelyă enhanceă
certainăantioxidantădefenseămechanismsăandăreduceă
theă erythrocyteă biomembraneă oxidativeă damage,ă ită
isă notă cleară yetă ifă thisă herbominerală geriatrică tonică
managesătoăextendălifeăspan.ăă
Furtheră workă involvingă theă characterizationă
ofă theă membraneă bindingă andă membraneă actionăă
ofă Geriforteă ingredientsă isă clearlyă warranted.ăă
Also,ă additională studiesă areă requiredă toă findă theă
effectiveă doseă andă durationă foră whichă Geriforteă
mayă beă takenă orallyă toă bringă clinicală anti-ageingă
effectsăinăhumans.ă
Studiul prezent a investigat influenţa Geriforte, un remediu natural indian,
asupra sistemelor antioxidante eritrocitare şi plasmatice la subiecţi umani
sănătoşi. A fost evaluată deasemenea capacitatea Geriforte de a inhiba liza
eritrocitelor indusă de dihidroclorura de azo-bis 2-amidinopropan (AAPH).
Suplimentarea cu Geriforte creşte activitatea catalazei eritrocitare (265.745 ±
15.768 vs 352,329 ± 18.480 K/g Hb/ml, p<0.01) şi reduce citotoxicitatea mediată
de radicali liberi indusă via AAPH, care a fost estimată prin intermediul stabilităţii
membranare eritrocitare (0.0439 ± 0.0069 vs 0.1291 ± 0.0396 C50- AAPH (mM),
p<0.05). Intervenţia nu a modificat semnificativ activitatea superoxide dismutazei
eritrocitare şi concentraţiile plasmatice ale agenţilor antioxidanţi. Rezultatele
indică faptul că Geriforte posedă activitate citoprotectoare în cazul eritrocitelor
stresate oxidative şi deasemenea o activitate antioxidantă specifică ce implică în
special sistemele protectoare intracelulare şi membranele.
ă
ă
ă
Corresponding author: Assist.ăProf.ăMarilenaăGîlc ,ăMD,ăPhD,ăă
BiochemistryăDepartment,ăFacultyăofăMedicineă“CarolăDavila”ăUniversity,ă
8,ăBd.ăEroilorăSanitari,ăBucharest,ă050471,ăRomaniaă
E-mail:ă
[email protected]ă
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
ă
BECKMANăK.B.,ăAMESăB.N.,ăThe free radical theory of aging matures.ăPhysiologicalăReviews,ă1998,ă78ă(2):ă547–81.ă
AGOSTONă V.,ă CSERMELYă P.,ă PONGORă S.,ă Multiple weak hits confuse complex systems: a transcriptional regulatory
network as an example.ăPhys.ăRev.ăE.ăStat.ăNonlin.ăSoftăMatterăPhys.,ă2005,ă71:ă1–8.ă
CSERMELYă P.,ă AGOSTONă V.,ă PONGORă S.,ă The efficiency of multi-target drugs: the network approach might help drug
design.ăTrendsăPharmacol.ăSci.,ă2005,ă26:178–82.ă
KOEHLERăK.F.,ăHELGUEROăL.A.,ăHALDOSENăL.A.,ăWARNERăM.,ăGUSTAFSSONăJ.A.,ăReflections on the discovery and
significance of estrogen receptor β.ăEndocrineăReviews,ă2005,ă26(3):ă465–78.ă
BARDHANăP.,ăSHARMAăS.K.,ăGARGăN.K.,ăEffect of Geriforte in vivo and in vitro on age related enzyme change in liver and
brain of rats.ăInd.ăJ.ăExp.ăBiol.,ă1985,ă23:ă323–26.ă
SINGHă B.,ă SHARMAă S.P.,ă GOYALă R.,ă Evaluation of Geriforte, a herbal geriatric tonic, on antioxidant defense system in
Wistar rats.ăAnn.ăNYăAcad.ăSci.,ă1994,ă717:ă170–3.ă
BANSALă A.,ă SAIRAMă M.,ă PRASADă D.,ă SHARMAă S.K.,ă ILLAVAZHAGANă G.,ă KUMARă D.,ă SELVAMURTHYă W.,ă
Cytoprotective and immunomodulatory properties of Gerifote, a herbomineral preparation, in lymphocytes.ă Phytomedicine,ă
2001,ă6(86):ă438–44.ă
7ă
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
ProtectionăofăerythrocyteăandăGeriforte
JAGETIAăG.C.,ăRAOăS.K.,ăBALIGAăM.S.,ăSăBABUăK.,ă The evaluation of nitric oxide scavenging activity of certain herbal
formulation in vitro: a preliminary study.ăPhytother.ăRes.,ă2004,ă18(7):ă561–65.ă
JAGETIAă G.C.,ă BALIGAă M.S.,ă Evaluation of the radioprotective action of Geriforte in mice exposed to different doses of
gamma-radiation.ăAm.ăJ.ăChin.ăMed.,ă2004,ă32(4):551–67.ă
CHIUăD.,ăLUBINăB.,ăSHOHETăS.,ăPeroxidative reactions in red cell biology.ăIn:ăPryorăW.,ăEd.ăFreeăRadicalsăinăBiology.ăNewă
York:ăAcademicăPress,ăvol.ăV.ă1982;ă115–160.ă
PUPPOă A.,ă HALLIWELLă B.,ă Formation of hydroxyl radicals form hydrogen peroxide in the presence of iron.ă Biochem.ă J.,ă
1988,ă249:185–90.ă
STAGSTEDă J.,ă YOUNGă Y.,ă Large differences in erythrocyte stability between species reflect different antioxidative defense
mechanisms.ăFreeăRadic.ăRes.,ă2002,ă36(7):779–89.ă
MANNERVIKăB.,ăGUTENBERGăC.,ăGlutathione transferase (human placenta).ăMethodsăEnzymol.,ă1984,ă77:ă231–37.ă
MARKLUNDă S.,ă MARKLUNDă G., Involvement of the superoxide anion radical in the autoxidation of pyrogallol and a
convenient assay for superoxide dismutase.ăEur.ăJ.ăBiochem.,ă1974,ă47:ă469–74.ă
MILLERăN.J.,ăRICE-EVANSăC.A.,ăSpectrophotometric determination of antioxidant activity.ăRedoxăreport,ă1996, 2:ă161–71.ăă
REăR.,ăPELLEGRINIăN.,ăPROTOGENTEăA.,ăPANNALAăA.,ăYANGăM,ăRICE-EVANSăC.A.,ăAntioxidant activity applying an
improved ABTS radical cation decolorization assay.ăFreeăRad.ăBiol.ăMed.,ă1999,ă26:ă1231–37.ă
MILLERă N.J.,ă JOHNSTONă J.D.,ă COLLISă C.S.,ă RICE-EVANSă C.A.,ă Serum total antioxidant activity after myocardial
infarction.ăAnn.ăClin.ăBiochem.,ă1997,ă34:ă85–90.ă
RICE-EVANSăC.A.,ăDIPLOCKăA.T.,ăSYMONSăM.C.R.,ăIn:ăTechniques in free radicals research, Amsterdam,ăLondon,ăNewă
York,ăTokyo,ăElsevier,ă1991,ă207–234.ă
BEUTLERă E.,ă DURONă O.,ă KELLYă M.B.,ă Improved method for the determination of blood glutathione.ă J.ă Lab.ă Clin.ă Med.,ă
1963,ă882–88.ă
YAMAMOTOă Y.,ă NIKIă E.,ă KAMIYAă Y.,ă MIKIă M.,ă TAMAIă H.,ă MINOă M.,ă Free radical chain oxidation and hemolysis of
erythrocytes by molecular oxygen and their inhibition by vitamin E.ăJ.ăNutr.ăSci.ăVitaminol.,ă1986,ă32:475–9.ă
SOMPARNă P.,ă PHISALAPHONGă C.,ă NAKORNCHALă S.,ă UNCHERNă S.,ă MORALESă N.P.,ă Comparative antioxidant
activities of curcumin and its demethoxy and hydrogenated derivatives.ăBiol.ăPharm.ăBull.,ă2007,ă30(1):74–8.ă
KITAGAWAă S.,ă SAKAMOTOă H.,ă TANOă H.,ă Inhibitory effects of flavonoids on free radical-induced hemolysis and their
oxidative effects on hemoglobin.ăChem.ăPharm.ăBull.,ă2004,ă52(8):ă1999–2001.ă
SCARTEZZINIăP.,ăANTOGNONIăF.,ăRAGGIăM.A.,ăPOLIăF.,ăSABBIONIăC.,ăVitamin C and antioxidant activity of the fruit
and of the Ayurvedic preparation of Emblica officinalis Gaertn.ăJ.ăEthnopharmacol.,ă2006,ă104(1–2):ă113–18.ă
MISHRAăL.C.,ăSINGHăB.B.,ăDAGENAISăS.,ăScientific basis for the therapeutic use of Withania somnifera (Ashwagandha): a
review.ăAltern.ăMed.ăRev.,ă2000,ă5(4):ă334–46.ă
GUPTAăS.K.,ăDUAăA.,ăVOHRAăB.P.,ăWithania somnifera (Ashwagandha) attenuates antioxidant defense in aged spinal cord
and inhibits copper induced lipid peroxidation and protein oxidative modifications.ă Drugă Metabol.ă Drugă Interact.,ă 2003,ă
19(3):211–22.ă
NIKIă E.,ă SAITOă M.,ă YOSHIKAWAă Y.,ă YAMAMOTO,ă KAMIYAă Y.,ă Oxidation of lipids: XII. Inhibition of oxidation of
soybean phosphatidylcholine and methyl linoleate in aqueous dispersions by uric acid.ăBull.ăChem.ăSoc.ăJpn.,ă1986,ă59:471–77.ă
PATHANIAăV.,ăSYALăN.,ăHUNDALăM.K.,ăKHANDUJAăK.L.,ăGeriforte stimulates antioxidant defense system.ăInd.ăJ.ăExp.ă
Biol.,ă1998,ăAprilă(36):ă414–17.ă
MIKIăM.,ăTAMAIăH.,ăMINOăM.,ăYAMAMOTOăY.,ăNIKIăE.,ăFree-radical chain oxidation of rat red blood cells by molecular
oxygen and its inhibition by α-tocopherol.ăArch.ăBiochem.ăBiophys.,ă1987,ă258:ă373–80.ă
CHIEN-CHUNGă C.,ă YAN-SHANă M.A.,ă EARLă R.ă STADTMAN,ă Modification of protein surface hydrophobicity and
methionine oxidation by oxidative systems.ăProc.ăNatl.ăAcad.ăSci.ăUSA,ă1997,ă94:ă2969–74.ă
ReceivedăMayă25,ă2009ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
295
ă
296ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
MarilenaăGîlc ăet al.ă
8
CASE REPORTS
Young Woman with Polyserositis, Ovarian Cystic Mass and Increased
Level of CA-125.
Case Report of Peritoneal and Pleural Tuberculosis
C. JURCU 1, CRINA FILIŞAN1, CLAUDIA POPOVICI2, LIANA TOMA3,
B. PANAITE4, O. NICODIN4, I. COPACI1
1
3rd Internal Medicine Department,
2
Pneumology Department,
3
Pathology Department,
4
Gynecology Department,
“Dr. Carol Davila” Central Clinical Emergency Military Hospital, Bucharest, Romania
A 21-year old woman was addressed to our department for progressive abdominal swelling,
fatigue and fever. The clinical examination, the ultrasound examination and the computed
tomography showed the presence of polyserositis (ascites and pleural effusion) and revealed a cystic
mass at the level of right ovary. The laboratory work-up showed an increased level of CA-125,
suggesting a malignancy. The thoracoscopy with visualization of the pleura revealed disseminated
small white spots. The laparoscopic exploration of the pelvis and of the peritoneum also showed the
same disseminated lesions and a cystic-like mass at the level of the right ovary which was excised and
diagnosed as a benign cyst. At the analysis of the frozen and paraffin sections, the diagnostic of
pleural and peritoneal tuberculosis was made and the specific quadruple treatment was started with a
good evolution at two months and with the normalization of the CA-125 level. This case report
underlines the importance of tuberculosis in the differential diagnosis of patients with polyserositis
and increased levels of CA-125.
Key words: peritoneal tuberculosis, pleural tuberculosis, ascites, ovarian cystic mass, CA-125.
CASE REPORT
A 21-year old woman was addressed to our
department for progressive abdominal swelling,
fatigue, fever and dry cough beginning in the last 2
weeks before admissions. She was treated with a
short-course of empiric antibiotic therapy, but with
the persistence of fever. Subsequently, an
ultrasound examination performed upon her GP
indication revealed the presence of ascites.
At presentation she was very anxious. The
appetite was normal and there was no history of
weight loss. She had no past history of any
diseases. There was no family history of
tuberculosis or other infectious, inflammatory or
genetic diseases or any cancers. The physical
examination revealed a distended abdomen due to
ascites, discretely tender at the level of right iliac
fossa. Dullness and the diminution of the pulmonary
sounds were noted at the lower zones of both lungs.
She had fever (up to 38.8°C). There were no
palpable lymph nodes, no hepatomegaly or splenomegaly and the bowel sounds were audible.
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 297–299
The standard thoracic X-ray revealed the
presence of the bilateral pleural fluid without other
lesions. The ultrasound examination showed the
moderate ascites and a cystic-like mass at the level
of right ovary. The genital examination and the
intravaginal ultrasound confirmed the cystic-like
lesion of the right ovary, the ascites and the
thickening of the pelvic peritoneum. The computed
tomography confirmed also the bilateral pleural
effusion and the presence of moderate ascites, as
well as the cystic lesion of the right ovary, without
abdominal or pelvic adenopathies. The laboratory
work-up revealed a mild anemia (Hbţ10.2 g/dL), a
mild thrombocytosis (602 000/mm3), monocytosis
and lymphopenia, an increased C-reactive protein
(96 mg/L) and fibrinogen (937 mg/dL), negative
rheumatoid factor, negative antinuclear factor. The
serology for hepatitis B and C virus and for HIV
were negative. An increased level of CA-125 was
noted (286.1 UI/mL; normal values Ţ 35 U/mL).
The analysis of the ascites and pleural fluid
showed exudate features, with an increased number
C. Jurcu et al.
298
of the lymphocytes without malignant cells and
without acid fast bacilli at the Ziehl-Nielsen stain.
The bronchoscopy examination was unremarkable,
with no acid fast bacilli at the Ziehl-Nielsen stain of
the aspirate. The thoracoscopy with visualization of
the pleura revealed disseminated small white
deposits suggestive of carcinomatosis or miliary. A
pleural biopsy was performed.
The laparoscopic exploration of the pelvis
and of the peritoneum revealed disseminated
miliary lesions, a normal uterus and the cystic-like
2
mass at the level of right ovary which was excised
and diagnosed as being a benign cyst.
At the analysis of the frozen and paraffin
sections, the diagnostic of pleural and peritoneal
tuberculosis was made (Fig. 1) and the specific
quadruple treatment was started (Isoniazid, Rifampicine,
Pyrazinamide and Ethambutol).
The evolution at two months was excellent
with the resolution of the ascites and of the pleural
fluid and with the normalization of CA-125 level
(23.1 UI/mL). She will continue the same treatment,
according to standard recommendations.
Fig. 1. – Peritoneal tuberculous granuloma with lymphocytes, epithelioid cells, Langhans giant cell surrounding the central caseous
necrosis (Hematoxylin and eosin stain, original magnification 20×).
DISCUSSION
The cancer antigen 125 (CA-125) is a “clasical”
marker used for the diagnosis and the follow-up of
the patients with ovarian carcinoma. However,
increased values of the CA-125 were reported in
other malign or benign conditions [1].
There are some reported isolated cases and
small series of patients with tuberculous peritonitis
and concomitent increased levels of CA-125 [2][3].
In the study of Mas et al, the levels of CA-125
were increased in 10 patients with proven
tuberculous peritonitis, and these levels were
significantly lower after 4-month of antituberculous
treatment [4]. The median value of CA-125 in
patients with peritoneal tuberculosis was 331 U/ml
in the cohort of 10 patients with peritoneal
tuberculosis of Bilgin et al. [5], but values higher
than 1000 U/ml were also cited [6].
In our patient, the presence of a benign ovarian
cyst was coincidental and created differential diagnosis
difficulties. Some authors [2][5][6] reported cases of
peritoneal tuberculosis mimicking ovarian cancer,
underlying the importance of the correct differential
diagnosis. Thus, the diagnosis of tuberculosis was
established in 1.2% of women suspected to have
ovarian cancer [6]. Therefore, even if the diagnosis of
peritoneal tuberculosis is rare among suspected
women, it must be keept always in mind especially in
developing countries with an increased incidence of
tuberculosis, as well as in imunocompromised patients.
The diagnosis is usually established at pathological examination after taking biopsies during
laparoscopy or laparotomy performed in the gynecology
3
Peritoneal and pleural tuberculosis
clinics. However, the place of the internist might be
important, some of the patients being initially referred
to internal medicine clinics because of systemic
features, like fever or polyserositis.
CONCLUSIONS
In patients with peritoneal tuberculosis the
values of CA-125 were reported to be increased and to
normalize after the specific treatment. The diagnostic
299
of peritoneal tuberculosis must be kept in mind in
women with ascites and increased levels of CA-125.
The diagnostic needs a multidisciplinary
approach, but is establish at the pathological
examination of the biopsies specimens obtained by
laparoscopy or laparotomy. Some of the patients
are initially reffered to internal medicine clinics
because the systemic symptoms. Therefore, the
internists should be aware of the diagnostic of
peritoneal tuberculosis and of the conditions that
may increase the CA-125 levels.
Pacienta, în vârstǎ de 21 de ani, a fost îndrumatǎ cǎtre serviciul nostru
pentru creşterea progresivǎ în volum a abdomenului, fatigabilitate şi febrǎ.
Examenul clinic, explorarea ultrasonograficǎ şi tomografia computerizatǎ pun în
evidenţǎ poliserozita (lichid de ascitǎ şi la nivel pleural) şi prezenţa unei
formaţiuni chistice la nivelul ovarului drept. Un nivel crescut al CA-125 este
evidenţiat la bilanţul de laborator, sugerând o posibilǎ etiologie neoplazicǎ.
Toracoscopia cu vizualizarea pleurei relevǎ multiple leziuni albicioase de mici
dimensiuni diseminate la nivel pleural. Explorarea laparoscopicǎ a pelvisului şi
peritoneului evidenţiazǎ leziuni similare. Formaţiunea chisticǎ ovarianǎ a fost
excizatǎ şi diagnosticatǎ ca fiind de origine benignǎ. Examenul histopatologic al
fragmentelor pleurale şi peritoneale stabileşte diagnosticul de leziuni
tuberculoase. Evoluţia clinicǎ a pacientei a fost favorabilǎ la douǎ luni de
cvadruplǎ terapie tuberculostaticǎ, cu normalizarea valorilor CA-125. Cazul
subliniazǎ faptul cǎ tuberculoza este un element important în diagnosticul
diferenţial al pacienţilor cu poliserozitǎ şi valori crescute ale CA-125.
There are no conflicts of interest to be disclosed.
Corresponding author: C. Jurcu , MD, PhD Student
3rd Internal Medicine Department,
“Dr. Carol Davila” Central Clinical Emergency Military Hospital,
Str. Mircea Vulcanescu 88, Bucharest, Romania
Tel: +40213193051, Fax: +40213193079
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
SEVINC A., ADLI M., KALENDER M.E., CAMCI C., Benign causes of increased serum CA-125 concentration. Lancet Oncol
2007; 8:1054–1055.
NISTAL DE PAZ F., HERRERO FERNÁNDEZ B., PÉREZ SIMÓN R., FERNÁNDEZ PÉREZ E., NISTAL DE PAZ C.,
ORTOLL BATTLE P. et al., Pelvic-peritoneal tuberculosis simulating ovarian carcinoma: report of three cases with elevation
of the CA 125. Am. J. Gastroenterol., 1996; 91:1660–1661.
UZUNKOY A., HARMA M., HARMA M., Diagnosis of abdominal tuberculosis: experience from 11 cases and review of the
literature. World J. Gastroenterol., 2004; 10:3647–3649.
MAS M.R., CÖMERT B., SAĞLAMKAYA U., YAMANEL L., KUZHAN O., ATEŞKAN U. et al., CA-125; a new marker for
diagnosis and follow-up of patients with tuberculous peritonitis. Digest Liver Dis., 2000; 32:595–597.
BILGIN T., KARABAY A., DOLAR E., DEVELIOĞLU O.H., Peritoneal tuberculosis with pelvic abdominal mass, ascites and
elevated CA 125 mimicking advanced ovarian carcinoma: a series of 10 cases. Int. J. Gynecol. Cancer, 2001; 11:290–294.
KOC S., BEYDILLI G., TULUNAY G., OCALAN R., BORAN N., OZGUL N. et al., Peritoneal tuberculosis mimicking
advanced ovarian cancer: a retrospective review of 22 cases. Gynecologic Oncology, 2006; 103:565–569.
Received June 18, 2009
298
C. Jurcu et al.
2
Incidental Findings During ENT Routine Examination
for Head and Neck Trauma
DIANA ZANFIR1, SABINA ZURAC2, FLORICA STĂNICEANU2,
B. ANDREESCU3, A. REBOŞAPCĂ3
1
Department of ENT, “Grigore Alexandrescu” Hospital, Bucharest, Romania
Department of Pathology, “Colentina” University Hospital, Bucharest, Romania
3
Department of Plastic Surgery, “Colentina” University Hospital, Bucharest, Romania
2
Several patients with head and neck disorders are incidentally diagnosed during clinical
examination for traumatic events. Our study refers to 76 patients with head and neck trauma evaluated
in the emergency ward of Phonoaudiology and ENT Functional Surgery dr Dorin Hociota Institute in
2007. During routine ENT consultation, 13 patients were identified with trauma unrelated lesions:
nasal septum deviations (5 cases), basal cell carcinomas (3 cases), lentiginous malignant melanoma,
keratoacantoma, branchial cyst, nasal lobular capillary hemangioma, squamous cell carcinoma of the
tongue (one case each). We strongly recommend ENT examination in patients with head and neck
trauma not only for establishing the gravity and the extend of the traumatic lesions in the forensic
approach but also for revealing unknown underlying disease in some cases with incredible results for
the well-being of the patient.
Key words:head and neck trauma, incidental findings, nasal septum deviation, skin tumor.
Head and neck trauma represents one of the
most frequent location of a traumatic event and a
major cause of death or debilitating disease due to
mechanic injuries. However, even in major trauma,
most of the lesions of the cephalic extremity are
minor injuries, most often not requiring any ENT or
oral surgical treatment [1]. In these circumstances,
especially in severe trauma, ENT exam is postponed
until life-threatening lesions are stabilized. Due to
minor symptoms, frequently spontaneously resolved
during recovery for other lesions, the patient will
skip the head and neck examination. Our study
underlies the opportunity of an ENT complete
examination that may disclose unknown lesions,
some of them with heavy impact onto the prognosis
of the patient and the quality of its life.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Our study refers to 76 patients reported in
2007 at the emergency ward of Phonoaudiology
and ENT Functional Surgery dr. “Dorin Hociota”
Institute for head and neck trauma.
We analyzed several parameters: age, sex,
cause of trauma, complexity of the trauma, location
of the head and neck injuries, severity of the
traumatic lesions, trauma unrelated lesions. We
ROM. J. INTERN. MED., 2009, 47, 3, 301–305
studied also the association between the location of
the traumatic injuries, severity of the symptoms and
the location of the trauma unrelated lesions. Statistical
analysis was performed – Chi test (χ test) – with a
level of statistical significance of P < 0.05. Whenever
it was necessary Fisher distribution was used to ensure
an extrapolation to a more homogeneous distribution
of the cases. The statistical calculations were performed
using EXCEL and EPIINFO programs.
RESULTS
Most of patients were injured through
heteroaggression, few of them during car crashes
and one patient in a work accident (Table I). There
was a female predilection (male to female ratio =
1:2) (Table II). The female predilection may be
related to the main cause of the trauma, i.e. heteroaggression some of them in family environment, as
previously reported [2]. Most of the patients were
young (63.16% of the patients being 20–39 years
old), also in conjecture with cause of the trauma
(Table III).
Two thirds of the patients presented head and
neck limited trauma (67.11% of the cases, Table IV).
There are two possible explanations for this finding:
either the heteroaggression as main cause of the
Diana Zanfir et al.
302
trauma associates a head and neck likelihood of the
injury location or the pre-presentation selection of
the patients considering the specific of the institute
and the gravity of the associated lesions (a severe
injured patient with multiple traumatic injuries with
head and neck, chest and abdominal location will be
referred to an emergency department with multi
disciplinary possibilities of diagnosis and treatment
and not to an ENT hospital).
Table I
–
–
–
–
–
2
3 patients with basal cell carcinoma of the left
temporal area, right nasal wing, right inferior
eyelid (3.95%)
one patient with lentiginous malignant melanoma
of the left malar area, Breslow index of 0,42 mm,
Clark score II (1.32%)
one patient with a branchial cyst (1.32%)
one patient with a lobular capillary hemangioma
(pyogenic granuloma) of the nasal mucosa (1.32%)
one patient with a squamous cell carcinoma of
the tongue (1.32%)
Cause of trauma
Cause of trauma
Heteroaggression
Number of cases
63
Car crash
12
Work accident
Total
1
76
Table V
%
15.79%
1.32%
–
Table II
Sex distribution
Cause of trauma
Number of cases
%
Male
25
Female
Total
51
76
32.89%
67.11%
–
Anatomic area
Facial area
Temporal bone, petrous part
Number
of cases
62
11
Cervical region
2
Two areas associated
1
Total
76
Age (years)
Number of cases
%
20–29
30–39
40–49
50–59
60–69
Over 70
Total
26
22
10
7
8
3
76
34.21%
28.95%
13.16%
9.21%
10.53%
3.95%
–
Moderate (controlled with nonsteroid
anti inflammatory drugs)
Severe (controlled with opioid drugs)
Total
Trauma complexity
Polytraumatisms
25
Total
76
14.47%
2.63%
1.32%
–
Number
of cases
%
45
59.21%
28
3
76
36.84%
3.95%
–
Soft tissue lesions
Table IV
Number of cases
51
81.58%
Severity of the lesions
Pain
Mild (analgesics not required)
Age distribution
%
Table VI
Signs and symptoms
Table III
Complexity of the case
ENT area limited lesions
Location of the injury
82.89%
Swellings
76
Bruises
Erosions
Hematoms
59
16
5
Deep cuts (fatty tissue)
5
6.58%
6.58%
59.21%
Bone lesions
%
67.11%
Present
45
32.89%
–
Absent
31
Total
76
Most of the patients presented facial
lesions (81.58%, Table V) with mild symptoms and
lesions (Table VI). 13 patients presented trauma
unrelated lesions:
– 5 patients with nasal septum deviation (6.58%)
– one patient with keratoacantoma of the left
temporal area (1.32%)
100.00
%
77.63%
21.05%
40.79%
–
The presence of nasal septum deviation was
far more frequent in our group of study. 56 patients
were diagnosed with this lesion, but in most of the
cases (40 patients) the posttraumatic nature of the
illness was easily traceable (severe edema and
fracture of the nasal bones). At the opposite part of
the spectrum there were 5 patients with nasal septum
3
303
ENT incidental findings in trauma patients
deviation without any lesion, no matter how mild, in
the nasal area; also, they denied the nasal location of
the trauma (ocular region, frontal area, temporal area
and lateral mandibular area in two patients were
acknowledged as site of trauma). However, there
were quite a significant number of patients (11 cases,
19.64% of the patients with nasal septum deviation)
presenting both nasal septum deviation and mild
trauma of the nose. In these cases it is very difficult
to establish the pretraumatic or post-traumatic nature
of the septum deviation and we preferred to exclude
them from our study.
The five patients with skin tumors were
referred to plastic surgeons. The lesions were
resected, the final diagnosis being established after
histopathologic diagnosis. Four of the cases were
tumor lesions with low impact on the prognosis of
the patients, at least in the moment of the diagnosis
(3 cases of basal cell carcinomas and one keratoacantoma). However, one patient presented an
irregular pigmented lesion on left cheek clinically
suspicious for a dysplastic nevus; after surgical
resection, the tumor was histopathologically diagnosed
as lentiginous malignant melanoma with minute
areas of vertical invasion within the papillary dermis
(Clark score II) (Fig. 1); the overall prognosis of the
patient is favorable, considering the Breslow index of
0.42 mm – thin melanoma; the patient is well, without
any recurrences or metastases, 23 months after resection.
The patient with the branchial cyst presented
abnormal slightly fluctuent tumefaction in the
lateral cervical area. He was a victim of a street
altercation and he received one direct blow in the
face with subsequent fracture of the nasal bones,
but no trauma of the neck was acknowledged. An
open excision biopsy of the lesion was performed,
the histopathological diagnosis being that of a
branchial cyst (Fig. 2).
The patient with the pyogenic granuloma of
the nasal mucosa was also the victim of a
heteroaggression in domestic environment with
multiple lesions in the facial area (bruises of the
left eye, left cheek and nose and several erosions of
the left cheek). The trauma was less than 24 h old.
During complete ENT examination a small cherrylooking nodule (1.2 cm in the biggest diameter)
was identified adherent of the nasal mucosa
covering the vestibular part of the septum; the
lesion looked ulcerated in the surface and bled
easily when touched. It was unclear if the nodule
was secondary to trauma but the size and presence
of ulceration were arguments in favor of a
preexisting lesion. The nodule was surgically
removed; the histopathologic examination revealed
a pyogenic granuloma (lobular capillary hemangioma)
(Fig. 3) that was obvious preexisting to the
traumatic event. No supplementary burden from the
legal point of view was added to the situation of
this patient.
The most impressive case was that of a
42 years old male, victim of a car crash. His head
injuries were minor (mild pain and tumefaction of
the face) but the examination of the oral cavity
reveal a white area adherent to the underlying
mucosa (leucoplakia) on the left lateral margin of
the tongue. The lesion was slightly elevated with
irregular surface. Based on his history of heavy
smoking (30 cigarettes a day for the last 19 years)
and moderate alcohol consumption, a biopsy was
performed revealing microinvasive squamous carcinoma
(Fig. 4). An MRI of the neck was perfomed without
revealing enlarged nodules. A tongue partial resection
with tumor invasion up to 1.1 cm from the nearest
lateral resection margin and 0.4 cm from the deepest
resection margin was performed. Clean surgical
margins were present in respect of dysplastic
lesions. The patient was referred to a Radiotherapy
Department for further treatment. He is free of
disease 2 years and 9 month after first diagnosis.
Most of the trauma unrelated lesions were
present in the same location as the traumatic ones
(Table VII); however, 3 cases (almost one quarter
of the cases) had lesions incidentally discovered in
nontraumatized areas: the patient with keratoacanthoma, the patient with branchial cyst and the
patient with squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue
who presented with cervical, facial and ear trauma,
respectively.
Table VII
Location of the trauma unrelated lesions versus the location of
the trauma
Location of the trauma
unrelated lesions
in the area of the trauma
outside the area of the trauma
Total
Number of
cases
10
3
13
%
76.92%
23.08%
–
We compared the severity of the traumatic
lesions in patients with trauma unrelated lesions
with severity of the traumatic lesions in the whole
group (Table VIII). No association was present
Diana Zanfir et al.
304
between the severity of the pain and presence of
trauma unrelated lesions (P chi test 0.07), the
severity of the soft tissue lesion and presence of
trauma unrelated lesions (P chi test 0.76) or the
presence of fractures and presence of trauma
unrelated lesions (P chi test 0.14).
Table VIII
Severity of the traumatic lesions in patients with trauma
unrelated lesions
Signs and symptoms
Number
of cases
%
Mild (painkillers not required)
12
Moderate (controlled with
nonsteroid anti inflammatory drugs)
Severe (controlled with opioid drugs)
Total
1
92.31%
Pain
0
13
7.69%
0.00%
–
Swellings
13
Bruises
6
100.00%
Erosions
2
Hematoms
1
Deep cuts (fatty tissue)
0
Soft tissue lesions
Bone lesions
Present
0
Absent
13
Total
13
46.15%
15.38%
7.69%
0.00%
0.00%
100.00%
–
DISCUSSION
Several patients with head and neck disorders
are incidentally diagnosed during clinical examination
for different complaints. One of these situations is the
ENT examination in forensic medicine onset. Some
patients are diagnosed with severe diseases previously
unsuspected or unreported by the patient [3][4]. In our
group, five patients presented skin tumors; diagnosing
these lesions was mere consequence of patient
presentation in a medical institution and not ENT
examination related.
Eight of our patients benefit from the ENT
consultation because their previously unknown
illnesses were diagnosed during specific maneuvers
4
performed by ENT doctor. We included in this
group 5 patients with nasal septum deviation. This
lesion is usually difficult to analyze because there
are no clear cut criteria to link it to the current
trauma or to establish its occurrence before the
traumatic event. For this reason we decide to
include in patients with trauma unrelated lesions
group the patients with nasal septum deviation
without any evidence of trauma in the nasal area,
no matter how mild. It is obvious that a patient
with severe swelling and bruises of the nose and
maybe fracture of the nasal bones has a trauma
related nasal septum deviation while a patient with
mild edema of the nose has a nontraumatic nasal
septum deviation. Based on these principles, it is
more likely that the real incidence of nasal septum
deviation not related to the traumatic event is
actually higher than we considered [5–7].
These cases underline the importance of a
complete ENT examination in trauma. There is not
any correlation between the location or the signs or
symptoms of the traumatic and nontraumatic
lesions, but there were several cases where the
nontraumatic lesions were present in patients with
mild symptoms and different location to that of the
trauma. Their discovery was possible only due to a
complete ENT screening not required by the
current clinical onset.
The type of the lesion incidentally discovered
during ENT exam for head and neck trauma
revealed 6 malignancies or tumors with uncertain
behaviour, two of them with extreme impact on the
prognosis of the patient (malignant melanoma and
squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue). The other
4 tumors (keratoacanthoma and basal cell carcinomas)
grow slowly; basal cell carcinomas represent a source
of aesthetic impairment and invasive potential in the
deep structures, imposing disfiguration surgical
excisions to accomplish complete excision [8–10].
We strongly recommend ENT examination in
patients with head and neck trauma, not only for
establishing the gravity and the extend of the traumatic
lesions in the forensic approach, but also for revealing
unknown underlying disease in some cases with
incredible results for the well-being of the patient.
Mai mulţi pacienţi cu afecţiuni ale capului şi gâtului sunt diagnosticaţi
întâmplător în cursul examinării clinice pentru evenimente traumatice. Studiul
nostru se referă la 76 de pacienţi cu traumatisme ale capului şi gâtului evaluaţi la
camera de gardă a Institului de Fonoaudiologie şi Chirurgie Funcţională ORL
5
ENT incidental findings in trauma patients
305
dr. Dorin Hociotă în 2007. În cursul examinării ORL de rutină au fost identificaţi
13 pacienţi cu leziuni netraumatice: 5 cazuri de deviaţii de sept nazal, 3 carcinoame
bazocelulare şi câte un pacient cu melanom malign lentiginos, keratoacantom,
hemangiom capilar lobular nazal şi carcinom scuamocelular de limbă. Recomandăm
examinarea ORL la pacienţii cu traumatisme de cap şi gât, nu numai pentru
stabilirea gravităţii şi extinderii leziunilor traumatice din punct de vedere medicolegal, dar şi pentru identificarea unor afecţiuni anterior ignorate de către pacient, în
unele cazuri cu rezultate incredibile pentru starea de sănătate a acestuia.
Corresponding author: Diana Zanfir
Department of ENT,
“Grigore Alexandrescu” Hospital
30, Iancu de Hunedoara Street, Bucharest, Romania
E-mail:
[email protected]
REFERENCES
GASSNER R., TULI T., HÄCHL O., RUDISCH A., ULMER H., Cranio-maxillofacial trauma: a 10 year review of 9,543 cases
with 21,067 injuries J. Craniomaxillofac. Surg., 2003; 31:51–61.
2. COULTHARD P., YONG S., ADAMSON L., WARBURTON A., WORTHINGTON H.V., ESPOSITO M., Domestic violence
screening and intervention programmes for adults with dental or facial injury. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev., 2004;
(2):CD004486.
3. GLADWELL M., VIOZZI C., Temporal bone fractures: a review for the oral and maxillofacial surgeon. J. Oral Maxillofac.
Surg., 2008; 66:513–22.
4. HOLMES P.J., KOEHLER J., MCGWIN G. JR., RUE L.W. 3rd., Frequency of maxillofacial injuries in all-terrain vehicle
collisions. J. Oral Maxillofac. Surg., 2004; 62:697–701.
5. EVANS R.W., Post-traumatic headaches. Neurol. Clin., 2004 Feb.; 22(1):237–49.
6. HÄCHL O., TULI T., SCHWABEGGER A., GASSNER R., Maxillofacial trauma due to work-related accidents. Int. J. Oral
Maxillofac. Surg., 2002; 31:90–3.
7. IMOLA M.J., DUCIC Y., ADELSON R.T., The secondary correction of post-traumatic craniofacial deformities. Otolaryngol.
Head Neck Surg., 2008 Nov.; 139(5):654–60.
8. BEN SLAMA L. [Precancerous lesions of the buccal mucosa] Rev. Stomatol. Chir. Maxillofac., 2001 Apr.; 102(2):77–108.
9. JOSE R.M., KISKU W., PRADHAN A., PRINSLOO D., Management of complex melanomas of head and neck region. J. Plast.
Reconstr. Aesthet. Surg., 2009 Feb. 25. [Epub ahead of print].
10. NAPIER S.S., SPEIGHT P.M., Natural history of potentially malignant oral lesions and conditions: an overview of the
literature. J. Oral Pathol. Med., 2008 Jan.; 37(1):1–10.
1.
Received July 15, 2009
306
Diana Zanfir et al.
6