Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
Received: 8.12.2023
Revised: 15.05.2024
Accepted: 17.07.2024
Published: 26.07.2024
Music and children with autism spectrum disorder: A case study
Jasna ŠULENTIĆ BEGIĆ•, Marija KOLAR••
Abstract
Autism spectrum disorder is a complex neurological disorder characterized by impairments in
communication and social interaction, limited patterns of behavior, interests and activities. Given the
different forms of autism spectrum disorder and the fact that no two people are the same, an individual
approach to each individual is required. Musical ability is one of the special talents that a child with an
autism spectrum disorder can have. Such a child should be allowed to practice music. As a therapy, music
therapy has proven to be effective in working with children with autism spectrum disorder, i.e. it has a
positive effect on communication, vocalization, joint attention, eye contact, concentration, cooperation,
cognitive functions, social skills, etc. This paper presents the observations obtained through the study
case. The aim of the research was to show the behavior of students with autism spectrum disorder in the
Music culture class and the impact of music therapy on their behavior. For the purposes of the research,
two interviews were conducted, i.e. with a teaching assistant who worked with a student with an autism
spectrum disorder and with the student's parents. The case study showed that the student has a
developed musical ability, that he participates actively, with reserved attention, only in the Music culture
classes, and that music therapy helped him in his expression and speech. It is essential to give these kids
the tools they need to further develop their musical abilities. It will contribute to children with autism
spectrum disorder feeling safe, happy, and accepted in their environment.
Keywords: children with autism spectrum disorder, teaching of Music culture, music
therapy, musical ability, case study
1. Introduction
Autism spectrum disorder is a complex neurological disorder that affects the functioning of
the brain and prevents a person from understanding what s/he sees, hears, or feels. About
•
PhD, Associate Professor, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek, Academy of Arts and Culture in
Osijek, Croatia,
[email protected]
••
Bachelor's degree in Music, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek, Academy of Arts and Culture in
Osijek, Croatia,
[email protected]
219
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
50% of people with autism spectrum disorder cannot develop functional speech, and for
those who can, speech may have limited communicative functions and may be unusual in
terms of quality. In addition to speech difficulties, there are also difficulties in social
interactions and behavior. On the one hand, there are individuals who are extremely reticent,
and on the other hand, there are those who are excessively active. Also, people may develop
unusual preferences for objects (AZOO, 2008). Children with an autism spectrum disorder
do not have the ability to direct attention to more areas than a healthy person (Bujas
Petković, 2000). Some common characteristics of people with autism spectrum disorder are
communication, social interaction and learning, and unusual behavior (AZOO, 2008). Autism
spectrum disorder is specific disorder because the child seemingly develops properly until
the age of 18 to 20 months, i.e., speaks the first words, plays, and communicates with the
environment. Around the second birthday, changes occur in the child, i.e., s/he stops talking,
is no longer interested in the environment and people, has no eye contact, and does not
respond to her/his name. Bizarre behaviors also begin: for example, the child twirls his
fingers in front of his eyes, spins around herself/himself, runs from one end of the room to
the other, continuously spins wheels on toys, holds oblong objects such as shoelaces, ropes,
or shakes them continuously (Kardum, 2021). The disorder is three to four times more
common in boys than in girls (Bujas Petković, 2000).
There are different forms of autism spectrum disorder, and they are: Kanner syndrome,
or autistic disorder; Asperger syndrome, or autistic personality disorder; Atypical autism, or
unspecified pervasive developmental disorder; Rett syndrome; Heller syndrome, or
disintegrative disorder. Each form of autism spectrum disorder is characterized by specific
symptoms. Kanner's syndrome (autistic disorder, infantile autism, autistic syndrome,
autism) is diagnosed when six symptoms from the following areas are present: a) qualitative
impairment of social interactions; b) qualitative impairment of communication; and c)
limited, repetitive, and stereotyped patterns of behavior, interests, and activities (SmolićRočak, 2013). Children and young people with Asperger's syndrome (autistic personality
disorder) have less pronounced deficits in social interaction and have pronounced average
and above-average intelligence. Psychotic episodes are possible in adolescence and later
(Bujas-Petković, 2000). Asperger's syndrome most often occurs and is diagnosed between
the ages of five and nine (Smolić-Ročak, 2013). Atypical autism (unspecified pervasive
developmental disorder) is a disorder when there is a pervasive developmental disorder due
to its appearance after the age of three or when the disorder does not meet the criteria for
an autistic disorder in all three areas. Children with this disorder usually have reduced
intelligence with autistic characteristics (Remschmidt, 2009). Rett syndrome is
characterized by the fact that it almost always leads to regression, i.e., to dementia
(Remschmidt, 2009). Heller's syndrome (disintegrative disorder, childhood dementia,
psychosis, and symbiotic psychosis) is a progressive impairment of language understanding
220
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
and expression and intellectual, social, and communication skills in children (Remschmidt,
2009). This disorder appears in a child between two and ten years of age after completely
normal development, and at the beginning of the disease there is a sudden and permanent
loss of already acquired skills in all developmental areas over several months (BujasPetković, 2000).
Autism spectrum disorder has been increasingly present since the beginning of the 21st
century. Table 1 shows the prevalence of autism spectrum disorder in some European countries.
Table 1. Prevalence of autism spectrum disorder (Kardum, 2021)
Country
per10,000
children
1 child on
Poland
3
3333
Germany
38
263
Netherlands
48
208
Norway
51
196
Finland
54
185
Estonia
60
167
Belgium
60
167
Denmark
69
145
Croatia
100
100
Switzerland
145
69
Ireland
153
65
In the continuation of the paper, the influence of music on children with difficulties on
the autism spectrum disorder will be presented, and in the research part of the paper, the
observations obtained through a case study, i.e., through two structured interviews, will be
presented. The first interview was conducted with the teaching assistant of a student with
an autism spectrum disorder, and the second was conducted with her/his parents.
2. Theoretical background
Music, music therapy and children with autism spectrum disorder
Musical ability is one of the special talents of children with autism spectrum disorder. Some
people with autism spectrum disorder like to listen to music, feel the structure of music, and
recognize melodies. Some of them can remember and sing long melodic phrases; sometimes
they have the ability to remember and play melodies they have only heard once; and they
can have perfect relative or absolute pitch (Baron-Cohen & Bolton, 2000). Students with
some of the disorder on the autism spectrum disorder can be included in regular elementary
221
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
schools. Therefore, in a regular class environment, they also attend Music culture classes, in
which some children with autism spectrum disorder are happy to participate. Thus, in the
research carried out by Zrilić et al. (2022), it was shown through a case study that the thirdgrade student with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder enjoys the teaching of Musical
culture and that he is happy to participate in it. At the beginning of learning to sing a new
song, he showed difficulties, but after listening to it several times, he remembered the
melody. He sang the song he adopted softly and the words as he heard them, i.e., he often
sang them wrong. He has a developed sense of rhythm and likes to dance (Zrilić et al., 2022).
Kardum (2008) emphasizes that for students with autism spectrum disorder, music serves
as a medium rather than a goal in itself. She believes that for the benefit of the child, we must
give up the methodical thinking that is the starting point when it comes to regular music
lessons in elementary general education schools. Program music (for example, the
composition of Vltava (B. Smetana) can be a stimulus for students with autism spectrum
disorder because some of the autistic children have a very pronounced sensibility and
associative potential, and some of them also express manifestations of synesthesia as they
"see" music in colors or experience it as a taste. Therefore, they are very happy to participate
in conversations about music, while for analysis (melody, rhythm, etc.), they generally do not
have sufficient perceptive abilities and refuse it (Kardum, 2008). Also, the author believes
that it is useful to use popular music because we do not evaluate the artistic value of pop
music but rather its role in creating an atmosphere of relaxation and trust, getting rid of
stereotypes, creating meaningful movement, awareness of the sense of rhythm, and
adequate motorically response (Kardum, 2008). Musical games are also useful for acquiring
concepts related to self-care, understanding one's own body and creating an image of
oneself, understanding one's own behavior, and for the purpose of acquiring elementary
concepts about nature, people, and relationships. Children are taught to interact with other
children, to participate together, and to take turns participating (Kardum, 2008). Simpson
(2013) points out that the activity of playing, i.e., the exchange of instruments during group
class music, develops the skill of exchanging and sharing instruments because, while some
students play, for example, a solo drum, others wait and thus learn how to participate jointly
and alternately.
Unlike music lessons, which may or may not have a therapeutic purpose, music therapy
implies the therapeutic use of music and its elements (melody, rhythm, harmony, etc.). Music
therapy was initially used for people with traumatic brain injuries, neurological conditions,
and fatigue. It was later concluded that the therapy has a good effect on stress disorder and
psychological trauma and on children and youth with difficulties in emotion regulation,
behavior, concentration, and verbal expression (Sausser & Waller, 2006). It has been shown
that music therapy has a positive effect in children with autism spectrum disorder on their
social communication, vocalization, attention, eye contact, concentration, cooperation,
222
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
interactive behavior (Bujanović & Martinec, 2019), participation in games and playing
together, speech (Yılmaz et al., 2014), intelligence (Goldstein, 1964), and expression of
feelings (Zorba, Akçamete & Özcan, 2020), language skills, i.e. verbal and non-verbal
communication (Hanser 1999 according to Burić Sarapa & Katušić, 2012) and reduces
undesirable forms of behavior (Pasiali, 2004), negative emotions and obsessive behaviors
(Jagudina & Johansson, 2011 according to Burić Sarapa & Katušić, 2012).
Goldstein (1964) conducted one of the first studies on the effects of music therapy on
the cognitive functions of a child with autism spectrum disorder. He examined the impact of
music therapy on attention retention and intelligence. After three months of music therapy,
a significant improvement in intelligence was recorded. He believes that the increased
interest in dancing, movement, and singing is connected with the inner experience of the
outside world of a child with autism spectrum disorder (Goldstein, 1964). Vocal
improvisation, which is a combination of vowels and consonants, can help improve prosodic
forms of speech and serves to stimulate or shape vocal expression. Children who
communicate through non-verbal communication through music therapy express feelings
and thoughts (Hanser, 1999 according to Burić Sarapa & Katušić, 2012). Edgerton (1994)
conducted research on the effects of musical improvisation on communication skills.
Children with autism spectrum disorder between the ages of six and nine participated in the
research. Children came for treatment once a week for ten weeks. Research has shown that
musical improvisation can have a positive effect on the development of communication
skills, and changes in the social behavior of children with autism spectrum disorder occur
during the music therapy process. Researchers believe that the continuous adaptation of the
therapist to each individual is an important element of music therapy. Wimpory et al. (
(1995) conducted a study showing the effect of music therapy on the social skills of a child
with autism spectrum disorder. Namely, they monitored the interaction between mother and
child, i.e., different games were used between mother and child, including singing. The result
of the therapy was manifested in the improvement of the child's eye contact and interaction
with the mother (teasing) during symbolic play. The social skills that were developed
through music therapy remained twenty months after the treatment. Research conducted by
Pasiali (2004) studied the effect of individualized therapy songs on the development of social
skills and the reduction of undesirable behaviors in children with autism spectrum disorder.
The researcher created the lyrics of the song following the current guidelines for writing the
lyrics of social stories developed by special education teachers to modify the barriers in
functioning of children with autism spectrum disorder. Then the text of the song was set to
music with the melody of the child's favorite song. The research results showed that
individualized therapeutic songs can reduce undesirable forms of behavior even after three
weeks of music therapy. Research conducted by Jagudina and Johansson (2011 according to
Burić Sarapa & Katušić, 2012) showed that, under the influence of music, negative emotions
223
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
and obsessive behaviors are reduced and the creation of social relationships is encouraged
in children with autism spectrum disorder. Sila Zorba et al. (2020) conducted a study to
examine the effect of music therapy on two specific skills of an eight-year-old child with
autism spectrum disorder: 1) exchange-sharing of feelings; 2) expressing feelings. Music
therapy had the effect of improving both skills during therapy and monitoring the classroom
teaching in which the child was involved. Mamić et al. (2010) conducted research in which
Tomatis therapy was applied. The music of W. A. Mozart was used, which had the effect of
raising the threshold of tolerance to sounds, better attention, greater social interaction, and
greater willingness to engage in activities in students with autism spectrum disorder.
We can conclude that numerous studies show that music has a deep meaning and
influence on some children with autism spectrum disorder. Therefore, in the continuation of
the paper, research, more precisely a case study, is presented that aims to contribute to the
mentioned topic, i.e., show how music and music therapy can help children with autism
spectrum disorder overcome difficulties.
3. Methodology
Case study description
This paper will present the observations obtained through the research through a case study.
For the purposes of the research, two structured interviews were conducted with
predetermined content and a list of questions asking for specific information. The first interview
was conducted in 2021 with a teaching assistant who worked with a student with autism
spectrum disorder in an elementary school for two school years. In 2023, a second interview
was conducted with the student's parents because the student underwent music therapy
treatments in Croatia and Belgium in the period from 2014 to 2023, and the treatments were
also performed at home. During the interview, the teaching assistant and the parents
answered questions regarding the following topics: a) development and symptoms; b) a
student in a school environment; c) music and music therapy. The aim of the research was
to show the behavior of students with autism spectrum disorder in the Music culture class
and the impact of music therapy on their behavior.
Research participant
The participant in this research is a student with an autism spectrum disorder who has a
pervasive developmental disorder and, in addition, a hyperactivity disorder. During
kindergarten, the teachers pointed out to the boy's parents the changes in his behavior
compared to before. The boy's parents also noticed the same, i.e., that he stopped playing
224
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
with the toys he had loved until then. As an example, the parents state that until then he liked
to play with toy cars, but that they no longer interested him, and he became interested in
unusual objects such as candles. The educators also noticed his stereotypical play and the
absence of social interaction, i.e., the absence of appropriate socializing with peers and an
unusual way of communicating. The boy was then four years and six months old. Because of
the above, the parents took the boy for detailed specialist treatment, which confirmed a
developmental disorder on the autism spectrum.
Due to the diagnosis, the student's enrollment in the first grade of elementary school was
postponed for one school year, i.e., he started the first grade at the age of eight. Upon starting
school, the boy was assigned a teaching assistant. From the first grade, he attends classes
partly in a special department and partly in the regular one, i.e., in the special department he
takes the subjects Croatian language, Mathematics, nature, and Society, and in the regular
class he takes Music culture, Art culture, Physical and health culture, and Religious studies,
while a foreign language enters. In the special department, there are about 10 students with
different diagnoses, from mild to severe, and in the regular class, there are 21 students.
4. Results
First interview: interview with the teaching assistant
The interview with the teaching assistant was conducted in 2021. The teaching assistant
worked with the boy during two school years, i.e., she was his teaching assistant in the
second and third grades (school years 2017/18 and 2018/19). At that time, the student
was between 9 and 10 years old.
a) Development and symptoms
According to the teaching assistant, symptoms that indicate a disorder on the autism
spectrum are: lack of social eye contact, attention deficit disorder, easy loss of attention,
sensitivity to stimuli, difficulties in longer communication and understanding,
misunderstanding of social rules, etc. The student has developed speech and language, has
social and emotional skills, and achieves short communication. In addition to autism
spectrum disorder, he is also hyperactive, has a need for constant movement and going
out to the school yard without prior notice, and requires constant supervision due to the
possibility of running away from the classroom and the school building. Also, the boy easily
and strongly connects with things and people, so if any change happens by chance, he
starts to cry uncontrollably. When his condition worsens or when he gets upset, he starts
screaming, crying, punching his head, and throwing himself on the floor. What
distinguishes him from most children with autism spectrum disorder is that he is never
aggressive towards others but only self-harms. The specific actions of the boy are that he
225
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
always has a toy in one hand, and in the other hand, he holds a straw that he keeps
spinning. The student is very picky when it comes to food; he only eats certain dishes, he
hardly eats fruits and vegetables, and he eats the same food and drinks the same juice
every day at school. The aforementioned characteristic of all people with autism spectrum
disorder is that they do not like change.
b) A student in a school environment
The assistant supports the student from the beginning to the end of the school day,
especially in tasks that require communication, sensory, and motor activity. In addition,
she helps him with his hygiene needs when taking food and drinks in the classroom and
during extracurricular activities. As for the respective teachers, each teacher has an
individual approach to the student. Some subject teachers who are trained try to choose
the best methods of work and have understanding and empathy for the boy. Subject
teachers who do not understand his difficulties are in the minority. The professional
service (pedagogue, psychologist) is very understanding towards the student. Nonteaching staff have unrealistic expectations and do not understand his behaviors or the
general needs of children with autism spectrum disorder. All subject teachers have criteria
for evaluation according to a special program. Nevertheless, the assistant concludes that
it is difficult for the subject teachers to be objective, so sometimes they only reward the
effort and not the knowledge of the students. The student answers orally and in writing,
depending on the subject. During the written exam, the assistant helps him understand the
questions and continuously directs his attention. She believes that the student is extremely
smart and knows a lot, but his short attention span creates a problem.
Given that the student has developed speech, he occasionally communicates with
other people in a way that is specific to him. For example, he approaches the other students
and subject teachers, tells them what he has in mind, and immediately runs away without
waiting for the reaction. Also, the student knows the names of all students from both
classes, addresses them by their first name, and calls them to come and play "hunting" with
him. From the above, it can be concluded that the student has developed social skills. As
for emotional skills, the student constantly follows the facial expressions of the teaching
assistant and recognizes whether she is happy, smiling, sad, or ignoring him due to
undesirable behavior. When the assistant is dissatisfied about his undesirable behavior,
he asks her the question, "How are you?" and apologizes for his behavior. Also, he often
"gets it in her face" and smiles to make her smile too. Likewise, the student is very sensitive
and reacts to the emotional states of other children. For example, if he sees one of his
friends crying, he immediately starts crying too. On the other hand, what he doesn't like is
other children screaming. When they do, he covers his ears with his hands.
226
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
c) Music and music therapy
The teaching assistant states that the student's favorite subject is Music culture. During
these lessons, he manages to keep his attention; he is focused on the teacher and on the
musical activities they are currently doing. His favorite activity is singing, and the student
knows a lot of songs by different artists by heart and often performs them. The written
exam in the Music culture class is the same as for regular class students, only to a reduced
extent. For the written exam, he must learn to recognize several compositions by ear, i.e.,
after listening to the composition, he must write the name of the composer and the name
of the composition, and recognize and name the instruments. He always solves such tasks
with the maximum number of points and with satisfaction. During the Musical culture
classes, he sits quietly, listens and enjoys all the musical content.
The teaching assistant knows from the conversation with the parents that he has been
going to Tomatis therapy in Croatia and Belgium for a long time (there will be more about
this therapy in the rest of the paper). The teachers, parents, and teaching assistant have
noticed a great improvement after the therapy because the boy is much calmer, has
significantly greater attention and concentration, is in a better mood, and, most
importantly, self-harm has decreased.
Second interview: interview with the parents of the student
In the 2022–23 school year, immediately after the end of the school year, an interview with
the parents was conducted, i.e., when the student finished the seventh grade and was 14
years old.
a) Development and symptoms
The boy's parents state that the symptoms of autism spectrum disorder are as follows:
repetitive actions, desire for everything to happen in a fixed order, difficulty accepting
changes, inability to understand the conveyed meaning, etc. Specific and undesirable
actions change in phases over the years, and there were many of them. Some of them were
throwing different things out the window, tearing leaves from flowers and plants, tearing
pages from school notebooks and books, and opening products in shops, for example,
puddings and chocolate bars. Because of some of the aforementioned actions, the mother
used to have problems, for example, in the store, and she had to explain that he was a child
with an autism spectrum disorder and that she would pay for everything destroyed. Today,
when the boy is in puberty, he often speeks ugly and inappropriate words (swear words).
Similar to this, he experiences times throughout the day when, as a result of his inner
world, he starts shouting loudly and talking about things that did not actually happen.
Then his mother talks to him, distracting his attention and thoughts.
227
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
b) A student in a school environment
The mother believes that not everyone at school has enough understanding of the specific
needs of children with autism spectrum disorder. She states that the behavior of such
children is very specific and that they often have undesirable behaviors that are part of
their diagnosis, but that such children are often stigmatized as disobedient and naughty.
She also states that there are teachers who really try to gain the trust of the boy, so she
points out the boy's current teacher. Likewise, she believes that our educational system is
not sufficiently developed and adapted to children with disabilities. In terms of teaching
and evaluation, the student's mother believes that the teachers adapt as much as possible
to each individual student's difficulties. An individual program is made for each student,
according to her/his possibilities and abilities. Knowledge is mostly tested in writing,
except when it comes to reciting songs. If the student has not mastered the teaching
content, the teacher will not start with new content but will try to get the student to learn
everything.
c) Music and music therapy
The mother states that the boy loves music very much and that he could listen to it all day
at home, and that he wants that the TV or YouTube channel where he listens to music is
always on. In addition, the boy recognizes the songs already after the first few bars and
can often interpret the songs correctly. The mother often uses listening to music as a
reward for a task well done.
In addition to the music he listens to in his free time, the boy goes to Tomatis therapy
treatments.33 The mother states that when the boy was younger, he listened to her voice,
the way he heard it while he was in her womb. For the purposes of therapy, the mother
recorded herself telling a certain story that the boy was listening to. According to the
instructions she was given, the mother would change the frequencies on the device and
the boy would hear the sound of her voice as he did when he was in her womb before birth.
This method within the framework of Tomatis therapy is used in children of preschool and
early school age. For older children, Tomatis therapy is based on listening to artistic music
at different frequencies that are determined individually for each child. It is based on brain
mapping, i.e., imaging of the brain, and therapy is determined according to the results of
33
French otolaryngologist Alfred Tomatis (1920–2001) is the founder of the Tomatis method. The Tomatis method is
a discipline that studies the relationship between the ear and the voice and between the ear and spontaneous mental
activity and helps people who have various hearing difficulties, i.e., attention and learning dissabilities, barriers in
functioning in the area of speech and language. It also serves to improve emotional control, coordination, and motor
skills in people with autism spectrum disorder (Šarić, 2020). The Tomatis method is also known as auditory training,
auditory stimulation, and listening therapy. Alfred Tomatis observed how different frequencies and sound rhythms
can have an impact on a person's state. He also observed that W. A. Mozart's music is extremely useful for reducing
difficulties due to its melodies, rhythms, symmetry, purity, simplicity, and high frequency tones (Mamić, FulgosiMasnjak & Pintarić Mlinar, 2010).
228
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
that imaging. The mother states that Tomatis therapy has been used since the boy was six
years old. The therapy is carried out in sessions lasting 90 minutes, with breaks of 60
minutes, and thus repeated three times a day for a week. After that, there is a break of five
weeks, and the procedure is repeated. Several children listen to the therapy in the same
room. Children put together puzzles while listening to music and flip through picture
books, and therapists warn that there must be complete silence in the room. In the
beginning, they went to Zagreb and Belgium for therapy, which required financial costs,
and the journey was tiring for the boy. This is why the parents decided to buy a Tomatis
therapy device and use it at home. The mother states that she underwent training that
lasted a week and trained herself to play music at home. She emphasizes that she is trained
to conduct therapy exclusively for her child. They received five programs, and every other
week, the boy listens to a different program for a year. After a year, the parents go with the
boy to Belgium, where a new brain scan is done again, according to which he receives new
listening programs. A program is determined separately for each boy's ear. The choice of
compositions that the parents will listen to is given in the program, and the composers
whose compositions the boy often listens to are W. A. Mozart and J. Strauss.
Another method that the boy's mother talked about is nighttime Tomatis. Before going
to bed, the boy lies down, listens to music, and it soothes him and puts him to sleep. After
that, the boy had a better and more beautiful dream. What the mother points out is the fact
that the parents were warned about in Belgium, which is that Tomatis therapy should not
be combined with drugs because they cancel out the effects of music therapy.
As a conclusion of the conversation, the boy's mother said the following: With the help
of Tomatis therapy, my son managed to overcome his difficulties in expressing himself and
became a fully verbal boy who puts together complex sentences without difficulty and has
quite good diction, which is very rare in children with autism spectrum disorder. As they told
us in Belgium, hearing and speech are closely related and influence each other, so listening
to music affected his speech and expression.
6. Discussion and conclusions
The purpose of this study was to examine how students with autism spectrum disorder
behaved in the Music culture class and how music therapy affected their behavior. The case
study showed that a student with autism spectrum disorder has a developed musical ability
and that he actively participates, with sustained attention, only in music lessons at school,
that he loves music very much, memorizes songs, and performs them. He also recognizes
compositions and artists and remembers the names of compositions and composers. The
stated results are in accordance with the research of Zrilić et al. (2022), in which a boy with
229
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
autism spectrum disorder gladly participated in music lessons, had a developed sense of
rhythm, and loved to dance to music. As for music as therapy, the student has been going to
Tomatis therapy for several years now, and progress can be seen in his behavior. He is
calmer, has much greater attention and concentration, is in a better mood, and his self-injury
has decreased. Also, the boy managed to overcome difficulties in expression and speech and
became a fully verbal boy who enjoys every form of music. The above results coincide with
research that has shown that music therapy has a positive effect on communication,
vocalization, joint attention, and concentration (Bujanović and Martinec, 2019; Hanser, 1999
according to Burić Sarapa and Katušić, 2012) and reduces undesirable forms of behavior
(Jagudina and Johansson, 2011). according to Burić Sarapa and Katušić, 2012; Pasiali, 2004).
This research included one student with an autism spectrum disorder, and we believe that a
case study that would follow more participants would give a more complete insight into the
investigated issue. In this research, we conducted interviews with the boy's parents and the
boy's teaching assistant. To gain a more comprehensive understanding, we recommend
interviewing the music teacher who instructs a student with an autism spectrum disorder in
a regular classroom in our next study. Therefore, we can conclude that early diagnosis and
response are important for children with autism spectrum disorder. Therefore, Luştrea et al.
(2017) point out that parents of children with autism spectrum disorder and experts must
act as a team in which each member has a role. They believe that professionals should not
only teach parents how to deal with all aspects of autism spectrum disorder but also help
parents adjust their parenting styles. Our thinking is in this direction, considering that a
developed musical ability is one of the gifts that children with autism spectrum disorder can
have. As a result, it is essential to give these kids the tools they need to further develop their
musical abilities. The parents can do this by learning the aforementioned and allowing their
kids to practice music. It will contribute to children with autism spectrum disorder feeling
safe, happy, and accepted in their environment.
References
AZZO (2008). Poučavanje učenika s autizmom: školski priručnik [Teaching students with autism spectrum
disorder:
a
school
handbook].
Zagreb:
Agencija
za
odgoj
i
obrazovanje.
https://www.azoo.hr/app/uploads/uvezeno/datoteke/poucavanje-ucenika-s-autizmom1536872369.pdf
Baron-Cohen, S., & Bolton, P. (2000). Autizam: činjenice [Autism: the facts]. Split: Centar za odgoj i obrazovanje
Juraj Bonači.
Bujanović, G., & Martinec, R. (2019). Utjecaj muzikoterapije na socijalnu komunikaciju u osoba s poremećajem
iz spektra autizma [The impact of music therapy on social communication among people with autism
spectrum disorder]. Medica Jadertina, 49(3-4), 205-215. https://hrcak.srce.hr/234929
230
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
Bujas Petković, Z. (2000). Autizam i autizmu slična stanja (pervazivni razvojni poremećaji) [Autism and
autism-like conditions (pervasive developmental disorders)]. Paediatria Croatica, 44(1), 217-222.
https://hpps.com.hr/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/33.pdf
Burić Sarapa, K., & Katušić, A. (2012). Primjena muzikoterapije kod djece s poremećajem iz autističnog
spektra [Application of music therapy to children with autism spectrum disorder]. Hrvatska revija za
rehabilitacijska istraživanja, 48(2), 124-132. https://hrcak.srce.hr/87776
Edgerton, C. L. (1994). The effect of improvisational music therapy on the communicative behaviors of autistic
children. Journal of Music Therapy, 3(1), 31-62. https://doi.org/10.1093/jmt/31.1.31
Goldstein, C. (1964). Music and creative arts therapy for an autistic child. Journal of Music Therapy, 1, 135138. https://doi.org/10.1093/jmt/1.4.135
Kardum, A. (2021). Odrednice roditeljskog ponašanja u obiteljima djece s poremećajem iz spektra autizma
[Determinants of parental behavior in families of children with autism spectrum disorder] [Unpublished
doctoral
dissertation].
Zagreb:
Filozofski
fakultet
u
Zagrebu.
URL:
https://dr.nsk.hr/islandora/object/ffzg:3903
Luştrea, A., Alghazi, L., & Borca C. (2017). Innovative Academic Course on Integrative Interventions for
Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Revista de Științe ale Educației – Journal of educational
sciences, 18(2), 56-68. https://rse.uvt.ro/pdf/2017/NR2/6.pdf
Mamić, D., Fulgosi Masnjak, R., & Pintarić Mlinar, Lj. (2010). Senzorna integracija u radu s učenicima s
autizmom [Sensory integration in working with students with autism]. Napredak, 151(1), 69-84.
https://hrcak.srce.hr/82837
Pasiali, V. (2004). The use of prescriptive therapeutic songs in a home-based environment to promote social
skills acquisition by children with autism: Three case studies. Music Therapy Perspectives, 22(1), 11-20.
https://doi.org/10.1093/mtp/22.1.11
Remschmidt, H. (2009). Autizam: Pojavni oblici, uzorci, pomoć [Autism: Manifestations, causes, help].
Jastrebarsko: Naklada Slap.
Sausser, S., & Waller, R. (2006). A model for music therapy with students with emotional and behavioral
disorders. Arts in Psychotherapy, 33, 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2005.05.003
Sila Zorba, R., Akçamete, G., & Özcan, D. (2020). The Analysis of the Music Therapy Program’s Effect on Taking
Turn-Sharing Skills and Expressing Feelings of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Croatian
Journal of Education, 22(2), 631-656. https://doi.org/10.15516/cje.v22i2.3405
Simpson, J. (2013). The effect of music therapy on social skills training in a preschool setting [Unpublished
dissertation].
College
of
Music
The
Florida
State
University
in
Florida.
http://purl.flvc.org/fsu/fd/FSU_migr_etd-7606
Smolić-Ročak, A. (2013). Simptomi autizma i drugih pervazivnih poremećaja [Symptoms of autism and other
pervasive disorders]. Istraži me. https://www.istrazime.com/klinicka-psihologija/simptomi-autizma-idrugih-pervazivnih-poremecaja/
Šarić, L. (2020). Primjena Tomatis metode u edukaciji, rehabilitaciji i terapiji [Application of the Tomatis
method in education, rehabilitation, and therapy] [Unpublished dissertation]. Zagreb: Edukacijskorehabilitacijski fakultet. https://repozitorij.erf.unizg.hr/islandora/object/erf%3A767
Wimpory, D., Chadwick, P., & Nash, S. (1995). Brief report: Musical interaction therapy for children with
autism: An evaluative case study with two-year follow-up. Journal of Autism and Developmental
Disorders, 25(5), 541-552. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02178299
Yılmaz, F. E., Topaloğlu, G., & Akyüzler, M. (2014). Description of the effect of musical activity with group on
social skills of children with autism. Bartın University Journal of Faculty of Education, 3(1), 252-276.
https://doi.org/10.14686/BUEFAD.201416217
231
Journal of Educational Sciences, XXV, 1(49)
DOI: 10.3592/JES.2024.1.13
Zrilić, S., Valjan Vukić, V., & Demin, A. (2022). Odgojno-obrazovna postignuća učenika s poremećajem iz
spektra autizma – primjer dobre prakse [Educational achievements of students with autism spectrum
disorder: an example of good practice]. In J. Ivanović (Ed.), 11. Međunarodna metodička konferencija
Promena paradigme u obrazovanju i nauci [International methodological conference Paradigm change in
education and science]. (pp. 194-200). Subotica: Sveučilište u Novom Sadu, Učiteljski fakultet na
mađarskom
nastavnom
jeziku
Subotica.
https://magister.uns.ac.rs/files/kiadvanyok/konf2022/Method_ConfSubotica2022.pdf#page=194
232