One Tree Hill I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness (Season 4, Episode 5)
TV-14
TV Episode | 60 min | Drama, Romance, Sport

Primary photo for I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness

One Tree Hill

I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness (Season 4, Episode 5)

TV-14

TV Episode | 60 min | Drama, Romance, Sport

Peyton finally realizes that her brother Derek isn't her real brother but in fact the very same person that's been sending her online messages using the alias "watchmewatchyou". When she learns this and starts pushing him away, Derek ...See morePeyton finally realizes that her brother Derek isn't her real brother but in fact the very same person that's been sending her online messages using the alias "watchmewatchyou". When she learns this and starts pushing him away, Derek breaks into her house and tries to hurt her. She is saved in the last minute by her real brother Derek and Lucas. In the end, Derek disappears after surviving a bad fall through Peyton's window. Written by E See less

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness.

Cast	+ Add Cast
21 cast members

Name	Known for
Chad Michael Murray Lucas Scott Lucas Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
James Lafferty Nathan Scott Nathan Scott See fewer	Everyone Is Doing Great (2018)
Hilarie Burton Morgan Peyton Sawyer (as Hilarie Burton) Peyton Sawyer (as Hilarie Burton) See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Bethany Joy Lenz Haley James Scott (as Bethany Joy Galeotti) Haley James Scott (as Bethany Joy Galeotti) See fewer	Dexter (2006)
Paul Johansson Dan Scott Dan Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Sophia Bush Brooke Davis Brooke Davis See fewer	John Tucker Must Die (2006)
Barbara Alyn Woods Deb Scott Deb Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Lee Norris Marvin 'Mouth' McFadden (credit only) Marvin 'Mouth' McFadden (credit only) See fewer	Zodiac (2007)
Antwon Tanner Antwon 'Skills' Taylor (credit only) Antwon 'Skills' Taylor (credit only) See fewer	Coach Carter (2005)
Danneel Ackles Rachel Gatina (as Danneel Harris) Rachel Gatina (as Danneel Harris) See fewer	Ten Inch Hero (2007)
Barry Corbin Whitey Whitey See fewer	Tulsa King (2022)
Moira Kelly Karen Roe Karen Roe See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Matt Barr Derek Derek See fewer	Hatfields & McCoys (2012)
Ernest Waddell Derek Sommers Derek Sommers See fewer	The Wire (2002)
Rey Valentin Nick Chavez Nick Chavez See fewer	Generation Kill (2008)
Shawn Shepard Principal Turner Principal Turner See fewer	Dirty Grandpa (2016)
Brett Rice Detective Detective See fewer	Sully (2016)
Ashleigh Falls Nurse Nurse See fewer	Takers (2010)
Michael Burgess Officer Officer See fewer	Venom (2018)
Cari Moskow Girl Girl See fewer	Nights in Rodanthe (2008)
Juliet Krystina Taylor Cheerleader (uncredited) Cheerleader (uncredited) See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)