Articles by Kirstin Munro
Review of Radical Political Economics, 2024
These are comments on David McNally’s 2024 David Gordon Memorial Lecture. In this response, I poi... more These are comments on David McNally’s 2024 David Gordon Memorial Lecture. In this response, I point to the immanent critique present in Professor McNally’s remarks. I then show the potential usefulness of immanent critique for an engagement with neoclassical economics, and I consider the consequences for Marxist economics of characterizing the critique of political economy as a critical theory of economic categories.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Review of Radical Political Economics, 2021
Social Reproduction Theory, as advanced by scholars such as Bhattacharya (2017) and Ferguson (201... more Social Reproduction Theory, as advanced by scholars such as Bhattacharya (2017) and Ferguson (2019) is at its core a theory of the revolutionary capacity of "unproductive" workers such as teachers, nurses, and social workers who are disproportionately women and disproportionately employed by the state. However, Social Reproduction Theory overlooks the contradictory and antagonistic role of the state in the lives of people, as the reproduction of labor-power in capitalism proceeds via antagonism and state repression. The task of teachers, nurses, and social workers is the production of not just any life but that of a docile, exploitable worker.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Marxism and the Capitalist State: Towards a New Debate, 2023
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Marx: Key Concepts, 2023
Over the past five decades, Marxist-feminist theorizing has been hampered by confusions over the ... more Over the past five decades, Marxist-feminist theorizing has been hampered by confusions over the multiple meanings of “reproduction” (Barrett [1980] 2014, 19-29). Overcoming the haziness with which these concepts are too often treated is especially urgent given the current popularity of Social Reproduction Theory, a recent offshoot of Marxist-feminism. The potential for misunderstanding is exacerbated by the existence of an additional use of the term “Social Reproduction” outside of Marxist scholarship—in a Bourdieu-influenced subfield in education scholarship. I will argue that precision in the application of political economic categories related to reproduction is not merely desirable for precision’s sake—these categories lose their critical explanatory power when applied carelessly. The reproduction of capitalist society as a whole—that is, social reproduction— can’t be examined without an understanding of the contribution of the reproduction of labour-power and the reproduction of capital to social reproduction. Indeed, the concepts of labour-power and the reproduction of capital from Marx’s critique of political economy are meaningless if divorced from their explicit roles in the perpetuation of capitalist society as a whole, and from their recursive relationship to each other in the reproduction of capitalist social relations of production. In this chapter, I will define these concepts drawing on Marx and Marxist-feminism, use these definitions to demonstrate the relationships between these concepts, show how these concepts have been misapplied in some strains of recent Marxist-feminist research. Finally, I will discuss the consequences of the incorrect application of these concepts.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Capital and Class, 2022
This paper builds on Marxist-feminist analyses of the links between the household, the economy, a... more This paper builds on Marxist-feminist analyses of the links between the household, the economy, and the state through a discussion of recycling, pointing to the ways the unwaged work of household waste sorting contributes to capitalism’s crisis-prone dynamic of overaccumulation. Household waste sorting is an instance of work transfer—a reorganization of labor and day-to-day life by the state and industry in which production is shifted from industry into households without compensation. A periodization of “waste regimes” reveals how the state management of waste both mirrors and is implicated in accumulation regimes, their crises, and their resolutions. The current recycling crisis demonstrates the contradictory nature and futility of recycling in capitalism, and the specific manner in which the work transfer involved in household waste sorting contributes to accumulation and crisis.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Critical Sociology, 2022
Against the backdrop of deindustrialization and the rise of the service economy, small artisan bu... more Against the backdrop of deindustrialization and the rise of the service economy, small artisan businesses have been promoted as a liberatory alternative to large-scale enterprise and mass production in the wake of the 2007 global financial crisis. We analyze advice manuals for aspiring artisan entrepreneurs by adapting Boltanski and Chiapello's (2005) framework and analysis of management textbooks to investigate books for would-be artisan business owners. These texts are "manuals of moral instruction" (58) that offer the reader the promise of a more fulfilling and ethical life through self-employment. We reveal that the artisan economy promoted by these advice manuals represents a further evolution in capitalism's co-optation of the artistic critique via the oppositional strata of punk and indie youth subcultures-and their style.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space, 2021
This paper describes the household waste management habits and practices of self-described sustai... more This paper describes the household waste management habits and practices of self-described sustainable households, focusing on the intentional actions the members of these households take to reduce environmental harm. Data from qualitative interviews about household waste management practices related to the disposal of trash, “packaging”, and recycling are analyzed using a Marxist-feminist model of household production. For the households in this study, packaging is a powerful reminder of their collusion with capital, eliciting powerful and unexpected negative reactions in interviews. At the same time, practices that involve allowing organic matter to decompose in the backyard, leaving urine unflushed, or placing human feces in the clothes washing machine or bathtub elicited few negative reactions, and recycling made people feel happy. Packaging and waste are necessary in capitalism because of the spatial division of labor and production, part of the constitutive contradiction between social needs and private production. I show how a division of labor and production that is necessary for accumulation manifests itself in an inherent antagonism towards human well-being in a discussion of the exhaustion, frustration, and conflict generated for highly ecologically-oriented parents who are just trying to do their best to live a sustainable life in capitalist society despite the limits to the efficacy of these efforts.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Science & Society, 2021
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Science & Society, 2019
In redefining social reproduction to mean only the reproduction of labor-power, Social Reproducti... more In redefining social reproduction to mean only the reproduction of labor-power, Social Reproduction Theory has deemphasized a central insight of Marxist-feminism—the necessary role that household production plays in the reproduction of capitalist society. This article presents a model of production in capitalism in which households, capitalist firms, and the state rely on inputs from the other sectors in their production process to perpetuate their own existences and in turn that of capitalist society as a whole. This model shows it is necessary to tie the household and household production to the dynamics of production and reproduction in capitalist society. There is no social reproduction without “societal reproduction,” as all production and reproduction in capitalist society is shaped by accumulation. Thus, promoting human and environmental well-being requires fundamentally changing the production processes that take place in households and elsewhere, not merely redistributing the costs and benefits of that production.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Energy Policy, 2018
This paper examines potential property value impacts when a nuclear power plant closes and spent ... more This paper examines potential property value impacts when a nuclear power plant closes and spent fuel remains on site. We confirm earlier research that fails to find an impact on property values of proximity to a nuclear power site. Another contribution of this paper is our finding that a one percentage point increase in property taxes is associated with a 4.31 percent decrease in the sale price of a home. These results provide evidence for a positive impact of operating nuclear facilities on surrounding communities in the form of reduced residential property taxes for a given level of public expenditures.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Review of Radical Political Economics, 2018
An investigation of household sustainability production makes possible the evaluation of the trad... more An investigation of household sustainability production makes possible the evaluation of the trade-offs inherent in these pro-environmental activities. The results suggest that policies promoting household-level sustainability efforts may be misguided. Without accompanying radical transformations in infrastructures and institutions—including the household—these efforts will always fall short of what is needed to promote human flourishing and protect the environment from harm.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Review of Radical Political Economics, 2017
Small artisan businesses have been promoted as a liberatory alternative to large-scale enterprise... more Small artisan businesses have been promoted as a liberatory alternative to large-scale enterprise. We analyze advice manuals for aspiring artisan entrepreneurs by extending Boltanski and Chiapello's framework. While they analyze the transformation of large firms, we show the same themes have been adopted by small businesses. Focusing on themes of autonomy and creativity, we reveal that the artisan economy promoted by these texts represents a further evolution in capitalism's co-option of the artistic critique.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Energy Research & Social Science, 2017
Several environmental advocacy organizations have emerged that use narrative persuasion technique... more Several environmental advocacy organizations have emerged that use narrative persuasion techniques to change climate change opinions and overcome climate change inaction. Written from the perspective of parents and grandparents (particularly mothers), the narratives in these testimonials reproduce the socio-cultural values of readers to motivate environmental concern. This article identifies pernicious hegemonic themes in the testimonial stories that have been featured on the websites of environmental advocacy organizations and critically analyzes these narratives using feminist and queer theoretical frameworks. Two themes are highlighted for analysis: first, themes about the special knowledges, powers, emotions, and duties of motherhood; and second, themes about the importance of preserving the environment for children and their offspring in the future. The oppressive influence of these particular narratives has been argued at length in previous research. Efforts to mitigate climate change are important, but attempts to shape public opinion should not simultaneously reproduce harmful myths about women and motherhood.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Book Reviews by Kirstin Munro
Review of Political Economy, 2020
Birth Strike: The Hidden Fight over Women’s Work, by Jenny Brown, Oakland, PM Press, 2019, 225 pp... more Birth Strike: The Hidden Fight over Women’s Work, by Jenny Brown, Oakland, PM Press, 2019, 225 pp., $19.95 (paperback), ISBN 978-1-62963-638-2
Full Surrogacy Now: Feminism against the Family, by Sophie Lewis, London, Verso, 2019, 240 pp., $22.95 (hardcover), ISBN 978-1-786637-29-1
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Conference Presentations by Kirstin Munro
RED MAY , 2023
In 1983, Lise Vogel published the book "Marxism and the Oppression of Women. Towards a Unitary Th... more In 1983, Lise Vogel published the book "Marxism and the Oppression of Women. Towards a Unitary Theory". 40 years later, this conferences reflect on the book and its impacts.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Uploads
Articles by Kirstin Munro
Book Reviews by Kirstin Munro
Full Surrogacy Now: Feminism against the Family, by Sophie Lewis, London, Verso, 2019, 240 pp., $22.95 (hardcover), ISBN 978-1-786637-29-1
Conference Presentations by Kirstin Munro
Full Surrogacy Now: Feminism against the Family, by Sophie Lewis, London, Verso, 2019, 240 pp., $22.95 (hardcover), ISBN 978-1-786637-29-1