Talk:Babymetal: Difference between revisions
Line 100: | Line 100: | ||
The term 'idol' should be used as Babymetal fits most criteria of being a [[Japanese idol|Japanese idol group.]] So it should be called a 'metal idol group' instead. If the term 'idol' is not accepted by people here then at least the term 'group' should be used as it will the least contentious. [[User:Lucems|Lucems]] ([[User talk:Lucems|talk]]) 07:17, 22 July 2023 (UTC) |
The term 'idol' should be used as Babymetal fits most criteria of being a [[Japanese idol|Japanese idol group.]] So it should be called a 'metal idol group' instead. If the term 'idol' is not accepted by people here then at least the term 'group' should be used as it will the least contentious. [[User:Lucems|Lucems]] ([[User talk:Lucems|talk]]) 07:17, 22 July 2023 (UTC) |
||
:Comment: I have no opinion on the matter, but I wanted to talk about the dictionary definitions you include here. Fundamentally, dictionaries do not define how languages should work, so their descriptions should not be taken as gospel. A dictionary is not infallible, and picking a single definition from a single reference work does not determine how a word is used within a given language. Specifically, your definition of "musician" derived from Oxford's Advanced Learners Dictionary is simply one reference point. I've looked in several other dictionaries, and they all define "musician" as a person who creates and/or performs music ([https://www.dictionary.com/browse/musician], [https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/musician], [https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/musician]), which categorically includes the singers of Babymetal. Dictionary definitions should not be used to demarcate article subjects regardless, as articles are based entirely on what reliable secondary sources say about a topic; whether to describe Babymetal as a metal band or an idol group is entirely contingent on what reliable sources call it. |
|||
:I'm not familiar with the history of this article beyond what I've personally added to it, so I can't comment on any potential bias, but try to keep such accusations to a minimum unless you can support them with evidence (e.g. with [[WP:diffs|diffs]] or links to prior discussion on talk pages). Comment on content, not the contributor (see also [[Wikipedia:No personal attacks]]). [[User:ArcticSeeress|ArcticSeeress]] ([[User talk:ArcticSeeress|talk]]) 07:48, 22 July 2023 (UTC) |
Revision as of 07:48, 22 July 2023
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Babymetal article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. |
Article policies
|
Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
Archives: Index, 1, 2, 3Auto-archiving period: 90 days ![]() |
This article must adhere to the biographies of living persons (BLP) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libellous. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to this noticeboard.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see this help page. |
![]() | This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
|
|
![]() | Material from Babymetal was split to Babymetal discography on 21:34, 19 January 2015. The former page's history now serves to provide attribution for that content in the latter page, and it must not be deleted so long as the latter page exists. Please leave this template in place to link the article histories and preserve this attribution. |
![]() | Daily pageviews of this article
A graph should have been displayed here but graphs are temporarily disabled. Until they are enabled again, visit the interactive graph at pageviews.wmcloud.org |
![]() Archives (Index) |
This page is archived by ClueBot III.
|
The word 'band' is misleading and should be replaced with 'idol group'.
The word 'band' is misleading and should be replaced with 'idol group' or simply 'group' because:
It is inconsistent with the cited source material.
You can go through all the cited source material, and vast majority of them refer to them as "idol", "metal idol", "idol group" or something along those lines. For example the very first citied sources states:
"BABYMETAL" was formed in 2010 with the concept of "fusion of idol and metal". It is a derivative unit in which three members of the idol group "Sakura Gakuin" work as "Juonbu", and they are quite unusual in the idol market where the group is divided." (translated from Japanese).
The very first English language source cited in the article states:
"The Japanese pop-metal group’s third album, which arrives October 11th, will contain 14 songs and feature a bevy of guest artists."
It is inconsistent with the literary definition of the word 'band'.
Oxford dictionary defines the term band as:
"a small group of musicians who play popular music together, often with a singer or singers" [band_1 noun - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and usage notes | Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary at OxfordLearnersDictionaries.com
Cambridge dictionary defines:
"a group of musicians who play music together" [BAND | English meaning - Cambridge Dictionary]
So it is safe to assume that the term band refers to a group of musicians. Are Babymetal musicians by definition? Let's see how the term musician is defined. According to Oxford dictionary:
"a person who plays a musical instrument or writes music, especially as a job"
The Babymetal girls neither play musical instruments nor write music. So they are singers and dancers, not musicians according to the literary definition, and hence not a "group of musicians" i.e. a band.
It is to be noted that the Kami band is not a part of Babymetal according to Babymetal's own official website, they are essentially just a backing band. Many musical acts use backing bands, even solo artists use backing bands during live performances, that doesn't make them a 'rock band' or a 'metal band'. For examples Ayumi Hamasaki uses a backing band during live performances, it is also more or less a permanent band since many instrumentalists are long standing members, who have also appeared in her music videos, just like kami band, but it doesn't make the act a band. it is still a solo act, since those guys aren't official members.
It is inconsistent with other Wikipedia articles.
Wikipedia articles about other similar musical acts like Passcode and Necronomidol clearly define them as "metal idol group", which would make defining Babymetal as a "metal band' inconsistent with other Wikipedia articles. This will cause confusion among readers at the very least. Other metal idol groups also use backing bands but are still defined as "idols".
It is inconsistent with the historical precedent in terms of the usage of the 'metal band'.
Historically the term 'boy band' and 'girl band' have been used for groups who only sing and dance like Backstreet Boys, One Direction, Spice Girls etc. The term 'boy/girl band' have never been interchangeable with 'rock/metal band'. Even the origin of the word band lies in the group of instrumentalists used by armies, and have always been linked to playing instruments as described here: https://www.etymonline.com/word/band
Instrumentalists were intrinsically linked to the word 'band'. The word 'one man band' conjures an image of a man who plays all the instruments by himself. A group of instrumentalists have historically been referred to as a band, but a group of singers were usually not.
The term 'band' is not universally accepted in context of Babymetal.
A large section of the music community including professionals, other artists and music critics refuse use the term 'metal band' for Babymetal. Referring to them as such is 'contentious' at best. If we strictly go by the definitions then, Babymetal is 'metal' but not a 'band'.
It seems like a case of personal bias/personal preference of the author(s) of the article.
Considering all the points mentioned above and the fact that the introductory lines lack any citation makes it seems like it was written to suit the personal beliefs/opinions of the author(s). It disregards the literary definitions, cited sources, historical precedence in addition to being inconstant with other Wikipedia articles. Even large number of people involved in Japanese music industry (if not most) do not refer to them as a 'metal band'.
Referring to Babymetal as a 'metal band' presents an inaccurate image to the people who are unfamiliar with the group. It does not reflect the true nature of the group. Referring to Babymetal as a 'metal band' while other heavy metal vocal-dance groups with a backing band are referred to as "metal idol groups" is misleading.
The term 'idol' should be used as Babymetal fits most criteria of being a Japanese idol group. So it should be called a 'metal idol group' instead. If the term 'idol' is not accepted by people here then at least the term 'group' should be used as it will the least contentious. Lucems (talk) 07:17, 22 July 2023 (UTC)
- Comment: I have no opinion on the matter, but I wanted to talk about the dictionary definitions you include here. Fundamentally, dictionaries do not define how languages should work, so their descriptions should not be taken as gospel. A dictionary is not infallible, and picking a single definition from a single reference work does not determine how a word is used within a given language. Specifically, your definition of "musician" derived from Oxford's Advanced Learners Dictionary is simply one reference point. I've looked in several other dictionaries, and they all define "musician" as a person who creates and/or performs music ([1], [2], [3]), which categorically includes the singers of Babymetal. Dictionary definitions should not be used to demarcate article subjects regardless, as articles are based entirely on what reliable secondary sources say about a topic; whether to describe Babymetal as a metal band or an idol group is entirely contingent on what reliable sources call it.
- I'm not familiar with the history of this article beyond what I've personally added to it, so I can't comment on any potential bias, but try to keep such accusations to a minimum unless you can support them with evidence (e.g. with diffs or links to prior discussion on talk pages). Comment on content, not the contributor (see also Wikipedia:No personal attacks). ArcticSeeress (talk) 07:48, 22 July 2023 (UTC)
- Biography articles of living people
- B-Class biography articles
- B-Class biography (musicians) articles
- Low-importance biography (musicians) articles
- Musicians work group articles
- WikiProject Biography articles
- B-Class Japan-related articles
- Mid-importance Japan-related articles
- WikiProject Japan articles
- B-Class Pop music articles
- Low-importance Pop music articles
- Pop music articles
- B-Class Heavy Metal articles
- WikiProject Metal articles
- B-Class Women in music articles
- Low-importance Women in music articles
- WikiProject Women in Music articles
- Wikipedia pages with to-do lists