Louise Mensch

Louise Mensch
Member of Parliament for Corby
In office 6 May 2010 – 29 August 2012
Preceded by	Phil Hope
Succeeded by	Andy Sawford
Majority	1,951 (3.6%)
Personal details
Born	Louise Daphne Bagshawe (1971-06-28) 28 June 1971 London, England, U.K
Political party	Conservative (Before 1996, 1997–present) Labour (1996–1997)
Spouse(s)	Anthony LoCicero ​ ​ (m. 2000; div. 2009)​ Peter Mensch ​ (m. 2011)​
Children	3
Relatives	Tilly Bagshawe (sister)
Residence(s)	New York City, New York, U.S.
Alma mater	Christ Church, Oxford

Louise Daphne Mensch (née Bagshawe; born 28 June 1971) is an English-American author, journalist, blogger, and former British MP. After a period working public relations for the music industry in the early 1990s, she became known, as Louise Bagshawe, as a writer of "chick-lit" novels. She was elected Conservative MP for Corby in the 2010 UK general election, but resigned from Parliament in August 2012 to move to New York City to live with her second husband, American music manager Peter Mensch. In 2014, she began working for News Corporation, and co-launched its Heat Street website in February 2016. Since leaving Heat Street in mid-December 2016, she has published primarily on her blog Patribotics, which she launched in January 2017, and her Twitter account. She left News Corp entirely in March 2017.

Before the US presidential election in November 2016, a Heat Street post written by Mensch reported that in October 2016 the FBI had been granted a FISA Warrant to investigate suspected ties between people involved in Donald Trump's presidential campaign and Russia based on alleged communications between Russian banks and a private computer server based in Trump Tower. In January 2017, Paul Wood in BBC News reported a FISA warrant issued on 15 October 2016 to intercept the electronic records from two Russian banks in relation to the Trump campaign; a week later McClatchy independently confirmed the BBC report, and in February 2017 The Guardian stated that "former officials said they believed that the Mensch and BBC account of the Fisa warrants was correct." Since the election she has published multiple unverified claims about the Trump administration and Russia that have led to her being criticised for propagating conspiracy theories.

Early life

Mensch was born in Westminster, London, the daughter of Nicholas Wilfrid Bagshawe and Daphne Margaret Triggs, and was raised a Catholic. She was educated at Beechwood Sacred Heart School, Tunbridge Wells, and Woldingham School, a Catholic girls' boarding school in Surrey. She read English Language and Literature at Christ Church, Oxford and was Secretary of the Oxford Union. She has a brother and two sisters, one of whom, Tilly Bagshawe, is a freelance journalist and author.

Fiction writing

At age 18, Mensch was named Young Poet of the Year. Following a six-month internship at MTV Europe she worked as a press officer with EMI Records, and then as a marketing official for Sony Music.

Under her maiden name, Louise Bagshawe, she wrote in the chick lit fiction genre, publishing seventeen works which sold a total of over 2 million copies. Her first novel, Career Girls, was published in 1995. Her sister, Tilly Bagshawe, has also published works in the genre. In her role as an MP, Louise Mensch was denigrated for her work as an author of fiction intended for a female audience. Mensch is an outspoken advocate of the genre and has stated that it encourages girls to be ambitious. Reflecting on her books, she stated, “All of them feature feminist heroines making it on their own. I simply couldn’t write about some drippy Cinderella because I don’t admire those women.”

Political career

With parents who were active in the party, Mensch had joined the Conservatives when she was 14. Subsequently, in 1996, she switched to the Labour Party, saying she believed Tony Blair to be "socially liberal but an economic Tory". By 1997 she had returned to the Conservatives, helped her mother, Daphne, win a seat in East Sussex County Council from the Liberal Democrats, and campaigned in the 1997, 2001 and 2005 general elections. In 2001, Mensch co-founded the Oxonian Society, later renamed the Hudson Union Society, with Joseph Pascal and Princess Badiya bint El Hassan of Jordan.

Conservative party leader David Cameron placed Mensch on his "A-List" of Conservative candidates in 2006. In October 2006 she was selected to stand in the constituency of Corby, which she won in the 2010 general election with a majority of 1,951, defeating Labour incumbent Phil Hope. In June 2010 she was elected by other Conservative MPs to serve on the Select Committee for the Department of Culture, Media and Sport.

Murdoch phone hacking affair

On 19 July 2011, in the hearings of the House of Commons Select Committee for Culture, Media and Sport, Mensch interrogated James and Rupert Murdoch concerning their roles in the News of the World phone hacking scandal.

Political blogger Bagehot in The Economist named Mensch as the "surprise star" of the hearing, writing that her "sharp, precise, coolly scornful questions" contrasted with her "waffling, pompous" fellow committee members, and citing her clever confrontation of the Murdochs. In the course of the hearings, Mensch erroneously stated that Piers Morgan had written in his autobiography about conducting phone hacking while he was the editor of the Daily Mirror. When challenged on CNN by Morgan, Mensch cited the protection of parliamentary privilege and declined either to withdraw the allegation or to repeat it. She later apologised to Morgan and stated that she had misread a newspaper report about Morgan's book.

Three days after the hearing, Mensch received an email that alleged, among other things, that she had taken drugs and danced while drunk with violinist Nigel Kennedy at a club in Birmingham in the 1990s. Mensch publicly released the email, stating that the allegations were "highly probable" but said that she regretted only that others had to see her dancing and that she would not be deterred from asking further questions about phone hacking. Members of the Parliamentary committee denounced the attempt to intimidate Ms. Mensch, who subsequently admitted using class A drugs in The Sunday Times.

The Culture, Media and Sport select committee finalised its report in April 2012. Mensch disagreed publicly with Tom Watson and Paul Farrelly, two Labour members of the committee, over whether the conclusion that Rupert Murdoch was unfit to run an international company, had been discussed before Watson tabled a Commons amendment on 30 April. Mensch and the other three Conservative members of the committee had opposed it, and could not support the report with the MP herself saying the report had become "partisan" as a result of the statement's inclusion. Mensch insisted on Newsnight on 2 May that it had not been discussed and was not part of its remit. Watson later accused Mensch of tabling pro-Murdoch amendments which would have "exonerated" James Murdoch in the report and, in Twitter exchanges with her, alleged private committee conversations had been leaked to News Corp.

Resignation

On 6 August 2012, Mensch announced her decision to resign as the MP for Corby in order to move in with her second husband, American music manager Peter Mensch, in New York City. Mensch had appeared likely to be promoted in the expected September government reshuffle. She told her local newspaper that she had intended to stand down at the next election, but brought the date forward as she was concerned her children would be too settled in Britain by then. She was appointed to the nominal position of Crown Steward and Bailiff of the Manor of Northstead on 29 August 2012, thus vacating her seat.

Regulation of social networking websites

Following the rioting in England in 2011, Mensch called for social media services Twitter and Facebook to be shut down or to "take an hour off" during disturbances to stop the spread of false rumours wasting police resources. She compared the action with brief interruptions to road and rail networks during emergencies. However, other Twitter users compared such action to the online censorship of regimes such as Iran and China, whilst Sussex police said they had used Twitter to stop rumours.

In June 2012, a man was given a 26-week prison sentence suspended for two years for sending Mensch an offensive and threatening email including threats against her children. Following his conviction, Mensch called for networking sites to identify anonymous bullies saying it was impossible for the victim to ascertain the seriousness of the threat posed, while the bullies felt they could do as they pleased without fear of retribution.

Cyberbullying

In May 2012, Mensch used her Twitter account to condemn abusive and threatening tweets that she had received, describing them as "misogyny and bullying". The tweets were subsequently reported in the mainstream press, and she drew praise and support for drawing attention to the issue from Twitter users as well as public figures such as Jeremy Vine and Isabel Hardman.

In May 2015, after that year's general election, Mensch was accused of cyberbullying Abby Tomlinson, the teenaged leader of the 'Milifandom'. Mensch denied the accusation, asserting that she had only criticised Tomlinson. Shortly afterwards, she wrote a 4,000-word blog entry to reiterate that she had not bullied Tomlinson and made new assertions about the sixth-form student.

Journalism and internet ventures

In June 2012, Mensch joined forces with former Labour digital adviser Luke Bozier to set up a social networking website – a politics-based rival to Twitter. The site, named Menshn – pronounced "mention" – allowed users to select their topic of interest. Mensch hoped to raise venture capital finance. The site was initially criticised by IT industry experts for using http instead of secure https to communicate passwords. Bozier disputed this claim, but the site switched to the secure protocol. Menshn closed in February 2013.

After leaving Parliament and moving to the US in 2012, Mensch began working as an independent journalist and also wrote articles for several newspapers, including The Times, The Sun, and The Guardian. In The Guardian she wrote two articles advocating "reality-based feminism", in particular "Conservative feminism" or "Tory feminism", and critical of Britain's "modern feminist movement" (including Equality impact assessment), which she called "ultra-feminism" and contrasted unfavourably with "American feminism".

After the closure of Menshn, Mensch set up a style and fashion blog called Unfashionista in early 2013, devoted to "Fashion. Feminism. Fitness. And a little inspiration." The website was covered widely in the British press and received mixed reviews. One of Mensch's pieces on Unfashionista was a reaction to allegedly sexist comments by Nobel Prize winner Tim Hunt. After researching the backgrounds of various people involved in the luncheon at which he spoke, Mensch wrote an exhaustive blog post criticizing the ethics of Connie St Louis, Deborah Blum and Ivan Oransky, the first three journalists to condemn Hunt's speech. Mensch's last post on the site was on October 29, 2015.

In May 2014, she started developing new digital projects for News Corporation. In February 2016 she co-launched Heat Street, a libertarian news, opinion and commentary website, with television executive Noah Kotch. On Heat Street, Mensch interviewed Adam Baldwin regarding the movement involved in the Gamergate controversy, claiming that it was Baldwin who created the Gamergate hashtag to "describe the scandal of falsely accused young men", and suggesting it is a hashtag that "divided the feminists – like me – and the fauxminists".

Mensch left Heat Street in mid-December 2016, and launched her own political blog, Patribotics, in January 2017. The blog is controversial and cites unnamed sources in the intelligence community. Mensch has stated that she prefers the freedom of self-publishing, which having her own blog affords; she told The Guardian, “I didn’t want to be subject to an editing process. Editors would ask: who are your sources? And I can’t tell them.”

Mensch left News Corp entirely in March 2017.

Commentary on the 2016 U.S. Presidential election

FISA warrant claim

In November 2016, Heat Street published an article titled "Exclusive: FBI 'Granted FISA Warrant' Covering Trump Camp's Ties To Russia", written by Mensch.This article claimed that the alleged FISA warrant giving permission to investigate the Trump campaign, was granted in October 2016, in "connection with the investigation of suspected activity between the server [in Trump Tower] and two banks, SVB Bank and Alfa Bank." The article also alleged that "it is thought in the intelligence community that the warrant covers any 'US person' connected to this investigation, and thus covers Donald Trump and at least three further men." In January 2017, Paul Wood in BBC News reported a FISA warrant issued on 15 October 2016 to intercept the electronic records from two Russian banks in relation to the Trump campaign; a week later McClatchy independently confirmed the BBC report, and in February 2017 The Guardian stated that "former officials said they believed that the Mensch and BBC account of the Fisa warrants was correct."

In March 2017, the Trump administration cited the Heat Street and BBC stories as evidence for Trump's claims on Twitter that President Barack Obama had illegally wiretapped his phones. This claim was examined by factcheck.org, which found there was no evidence for it. According to the Washington Post on March 5, the BBC's account differed substantially from that of Mensch, since the BBC alleged that: "Neither Mr Trump nor his associates are named in the FISA order, which would only cover foreign citizens or foreign entities — in this case the Russian banks." The Post stated "The Washington Post for months has sought to confirm this report of a FISA warrant related to the Trump campaign but has been unable to do so. Presumably, other major news organisations have tried to do so as well. So one has to take this claim with a huge dose of skepticism." The Post noted that the assertion that the FISA warrant was to examine possible activity between two Russian banks and a computer server in the Trump Tower had not been confirmed by U.S. news organisations, and that the Trump Organisation server communicating with Russian banks may have actually been located in Philadelphia, not Trump Tower, and that, according to the FBI as reported by the New York Times in October 2 "there could be an innocuous explanation, [for the server traffic] like a marketing email or spam."

In April 2017, the Washington Post reported that, during the summer of 2016, the FBI obtained a FISA warrant to monitor Carter Page, an advisor to the Trump campaign. The warrant was granted as part of an investigation into possible links between Russia and the Trump campaign [1]

Comments on Trump and Russia

During and after the 2016 US presidential election, Mensch's political commentary has been criticized for putting forth conspiracy theories about the Russian government, Donald Trump and people in Trump's circle. Mensch has said that she "absolutely believes" and has evidence that Vladimir Putin had Andrew Breitbart murdered to make room for Steve Bannon at Breitbart. She has stated that the 2017 Istanbul nightclub shooting was a Russian false flag operation, with Russia posing as ISIL; that "Bannon and his team" were behind bomb threats to Jewish community centres; and that Russian intelligence planted Hillary Clinton's emails on Anthony Weiner's laptop. Mensch has also accused numerous people and organizations of being Russian "shills", "moles" and "agents of influence," including Mark Zuckerberg and Peter Thiel. An analysis by Joseph Bernstein of BuzzFeed News found that "Mensch has accused at least 210 people and organizations of being under Russian government influence"; Mensch disputed the figure, stating: "No, I doubt that number is accurate. I am quite certain the number is going to be a lot larger than 210 people or organizations once the trials are finished. It takes a village to elect a President who is working hand in glove with the Kremlin both in terms of propaganda and hacking collusion—and that's before we even get to the money laundering."

Mensch stated that President Obama should have responded with "precision bombing raids" and "massive cyber war" in response to Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections.

Personal life

In 2000, she married Italian-American real estate developer Anthony LoCicero. They have three children, but separated in 2009. The marriage ended in divorce. In June 2011, she married American music manager Peter Mensch, whom she had first met 20 years earlier; she has resided with him in New York City since 2012.

Mensch is diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which made her realise she was "self medicating" with wine for stress, and she has now almost completely given up alcohol. She has also commented, on BBC Question Time during a debate on calls to decriminalise hard drugs, about taking hard drugs in her 20s; she subsequently told the press "It is something that I regret incredibly, that, in my youth, I messed with my brain. I said ‘we all do stupid things when we are young’. It’s had long-term mental health effects on me. It’s caused me to be more anxious than I need to be."

Bibliography

Novels

Writing as Louise Bagshawe:

• Career Girls (1995)
• The Movie (1996) aka Triple Feature
• Tall Poppies (1997)
• Venus Envy (1998)
• A Kept Woman (2000) aka For All the Wrong Reasons
• When She Was Bad... (2001)
• The Devil You Know (2003)
• Monday's Child (2004) aka The Go–To Girl
• Tuesday's Child (2005)
• Sparkles (2006)
• Glamour (2007)
• Glitz (2008)
• Passion (2009)
• Desire (2010)
• Destiny (2011)

Writing as Louise Mensch:

• Beauty (2014)
• Career Game (2015)

Anthology

• Five Romantic Reads (2005; with Donna Hay, Laura Wolf, Jane Elizabeth Varley and Stella Chaplin)

External links

• Profile at Parliament of the United Kingdom
• Contributions in Parliament at Hansard
• Voting record at Public Whip
• Record in Parliament at TheyWorkForYou
• Louise Mensch at IMDb
• Template:Worldcat id
• Louise Mensch on Twitter
• Articles authored as Louise Bagshawe at Journalisted