I understand that some people might support the overall vision of the NDIS review, and because of that, they feel like this particular NDIS Amendment Bill is either net good, mostly good or just plain good.
But the Bill is not the review.
The review claimed to be about putting people with disability back at the heart of the scheme. It proposed doing away with the 'unhelpful' focus on primary disabilities, and focusing instead on support needs of an eligible population.
The Bill however, was drafted by Department of Social Services. Make no mistake, these people are not friends and these people come from an entirely different set of perspectives and principles than the creators of the NDIS. DSS are the people who brought you the Disability Support Payment Impairment Tables, you know the idea that you need 20 points from one impairment to be a CertifiedDisabledTM?
DSS' NDIS Bill puts impairments back at the heart of the Scheme.
Putting impairments back at the centre of the Scheme means walking away from an inclusion-focused, social-model approach. It means saying, "I don't care how much suffering is being caused because you can't walk, can't get out of bed, don't have the assistive technology you need to go to work, that's not your eligible impairment and it's not my problem." This is not the NDIS anyone fought for.
An impairment-driven scheme, where bureaucrats tell us how much of which supports we need for our certified impairments, is not more certainty.
I challenge supporters of the bill to consider it against, not the status quo, but against an alternate reform bill. A bill that didn't focus on raising debts against participants, entrenching the concept of an eligible impairment, putting people and supports into 'classes,' and limiting access to creative and mainstream supports. Imagine a bill that started with establishing navigators and foundational supports and cracking down on provider fraud. Think of how different the reaction might be? Think of what a different message that would send.
There is always an alternative. If you've convinced yourself there isn't, look again.