Before reviewing this story I feel the need to get a few disclaimers out of the way. First up, spoiler warning. I’ll try not to explicitly spoil anything, but some of the things I mention may lead you to get ahead of the twists before they’re revealed. Second, gore. I’m really not the best person to rate gore as (not to blow my own horn) I’ve got a pretty high tolerance for gore, but this story does revolve around a mad scientist, so if you don’t like hearing about experiments and the like I’d steer clear of this one. Third, there are a few places that may warrant a trigger warning, specifically for domestic abuse, and sexual assault, though these aren’t terribly big or often. (Maybe a little often on emotional abuse)
Still here? Great, let’s begin!
The Madman’s Daughter, by Megan Shepherd
One thing I’d like to get out of the way is the love triangle. I’m not one to hide my disdain for love triangles, and I think that the world is growing more and more aware of how absolutely terrible they are. More specifically the Twilight TM kind, where there are two gorgeous and amazing guys fighting over a really blah chick. I’m happy to say that the only damsel moments that I noticed were when she actually couldn’t do anything, more specifically times that involve swimming, but that is reasonable considering the day and age this is set, 1 it makes sense for her not to be able to swim because she was raised a lady, 2 she’s a girl, she’s in dresses and corsets, I’m pretty sure Olympic swimmers wouldn’t be terribly eager to jump into the ocean in one of those monstrosities. But, I digress, and to make things easier the three characters in le’ love triangle are named Juliet, Edward (har har), and Montgomery. Now, another big problem with love triangles is that it’s usually very obvious who the chick is going to pick. Let’s be real, it’s usually the one introduced as a love interest first. But, in this story I actually found myself bouncing back and forth on who I thought she’d end up with. As the story progresses there are some very interesting developments in the love interests that give genuine cause to revaluate who is the better man.
Next thing I’d like to talk about is her father. I find that estranged fathers often fall into two categories, either the child detests actually likable guys, or the child adores and defends literal scum. This story falls into neither category as Juliet doesn’t try to defend his awful actions, and is often the one who hates him the most. But, one thing that I don’t think I’ve ever seen before with terrible parents is the horror one can feel realizing that you share traits with them. Juliet often has to take a step back, realizing that she also shows some of the traits that made her label him as ‘mad’ and in this, the audience can do the same thing. With stories involving experimentation the audience may be horrified by what they learn, but let’s be real, who among us would read something like this and not want to find out everything. It’s morbid curiosity that’s told in a way that would make anyone consider their own labeling of this 'mad’ scientist.
Again, I don’t want to spoil it for anyone, this is a mystery story, and as everyone knows mysteries aren’t any fun when you know the ending. Learning about all of the things going on on the island, the Doctor’s experiments, his surgeries, why he needs all of the things he sent Montgomery to London for in the first place, it unravels at a delicious pace, little seeds for the story planted early on and carefully nurtured, then, as with most gore stories it’s descriptions that cinch it. The time when this takes place lends to the difficulty that Juliet had describing some things, giving an uneasy feeling of knowing some things simply defy description. Juliet tries her best to make sense of things but is limited by her time. As far as the medical terms go she is fairly well versed in terminology there, but it can be difficult to balance proper terminology for things with terms that the average reader will actually know. This story does a good job of it. Unfortunately, there are few of the experiments and procedures described that suspend disbelief a little too far, but they’re easy to put aside while focussing on the action.
Finally, the climax. Good god, the climax. Another spoiler warning here, because I’m telling you now, it takes a lot to bring me to tears. This ending had me literally sobbing. It cranks up the adrenaline, holds your interest in revealing the mystery, and tying up so many loose ends. It is beautifully catastrophic in a way that lends itself to the revealing twist. It keeps your attention on an exceedingly worrying decision, one that completely consumes Juliet’s every thought as it reaches the end then rips the rug out from under you in an equally heart-shattering ending that I for one did not see coming. This story literally left me sobbing for a good five minutes straight as it wound to a close, and I absolutely recommend it for anyone who enjoys mystery, horror, and suspense.