Reading/Web/PDF Functionality

Update on PDF rendering, July 15 2019

We’ve launched the new PDF renderer. We’re looking at feedback, but haven't so far seen any significant issues. We might incorporate some suggestions, but want to note that this is not an ongoing project with continuous development. In other words, now that it's deployed and proven to work, the new renderer is entering maintenance mode. The talk page of this page won’t be abandoned, but it could take a while before anyone reacts, simply because everyone's got so much else on their plate.

In terms of books, we've left it in the hands of volunteer developers and PediaPress. We'll be glad to reach out to them with questions, but we're not planning any involvement in terms of the technical implementation.

Update on PDF rendering, June 4, 2019

We have deployed the new renderer for single-article PDFs for all projects. We hope this will resolve the issues associated with the Electron renderer, which was often unable to generate PDFs as expected. Please feel free to try out the new renderer and let us know if you have questions or come across any bugs or other issues.

Update on PDF rendering, March 18 2019

We're getting close to the deployment of our new renderer, Proton, with only a few tasks remaining as blockers (as can be seen in the task graph in phab:T181084). We will post another update once the deployment date is set. This renderer will replace the electron renderer as the default PDF renderer for single-page PDFs.

Update on books, August 17 2018

Sample book from PediaPress

Here is an updated and more comprehensive sample of the new book renderer. The layout changed quite a from the first version presented at Wikimania. Thanks for all the feedback. The export still has a number of significant issues: page breaks, infoboxes, tables, and math formulas need to be improved substantially. This sample file focusing on international scripts and math formulas reveals some of the problems that still need to be solved. Math formulas are currently rendered using MathML - switching to LaTeX should lead to significant improvements.

Update on books, August 8 2018

We have been working with PediaPress on generating and styling the new books. They have provided us with a sample of the current output, which will be very similar to the final version. We discussed points of improvement with the PediaPress team, which they are addressing currently. If you have any feedback or other comments on these samples, please let us know on the talk page.

Update on books, April 2018

Books functionality will be returning via PediaPress. After investigating the new renderer in depth, we realized that core features of the original book creator (such as page numbers and table of contents) would be very difficult to implement using the new renderer. In addition, we had significant issues with our concatenation code. Thus, we had to look for alternatives in terms of bringing back the PDF books functionality on Wikimedia projects. We reached out to PediaPress, who were the original patrons of books on Wikipedia to see if they would be interested in taking up PDF rendering for books once again. They have agreed and we are currently working on the details and schedule. They will start by working on a temporary solution based on an older technology that has previously been used to create PDF. This might have some drawbacks when it comes to graphical elements, such as maps, but will mean a faster working solution. They then plan to work on a new HTML-to-PDF renderer afterwards, based on feedback on the first implementation.

Update January 2018

We're currently preparing performance tests of the PDF to book function. We should know more in early February.

Update September 2017

Our current PDF rendering service, the offline content generator (OCG), is no longer maintainable. Simply put, it's breaking down. The Reading team at the Wikimedia Foundation has been working towards replacing it for months. OCG has been running on outdated code which may introduce security vulnerabilities and other major issues in the future. Over the last three months, we’ve had banners on the PDF creation page asking for feedback on the prototype for our new renderer. The new renderer will have improved capabilities from OCG – it will be able to print tables and infoboxes and will contain styling focused on better readability. We've gathered a lot of good feedback on the prototype and are working on making the required updates to our new PDFs.

Later addendum: Turning PDF book rendering OFF for the short term

Unfortunately, major issues with our old renderer (OCG) will require us to remove it as a rendering option prior to completing the necessary updates for the books feature. This is earlier than we wanted. By the time we remove OCG, the work for rendering of single articles will be completed. However, the rendering of books will be paused while we evaluate and complete the necessary work. Our initial choice of renderer for the replacement, the Electron rendering service, is not capable of supporting PDFs of larger sizes and fails when attempting to render a book with multiple articles. We will be working to select a new rendering system for books which can handle the size of the files and support our requirements. This is not how we planned to do this. We never aimed to temporarily remove the book PDF functionality.

Timeline:

• Release of full-featured renderer for single articles (print to pdf) – Oct 1, 2017
• Pausing book PDF rendering – Oct 1, 2017
• Sunsetting of OCG renderer – Oct 1, 2017
• Release of new PDF renderer – Jan, 2018 (tentative based on research results into alternative rendering systems)

Functionality:

For a full list of current and upcoming functionality, see below.

In addition to this page being updated, this will be communicated in a banner on PDF creation page, in Tech News and on some Wikimedia mailing lists.

Introduction

Our current PDF rendering service, the offline content generator, is no-longer maintainable. Simply put, it's breaking down. Originally created by a third party, it currently runs on outdated code which may introduce security vulnerabilities and other major issues in the future. If we're to have the PDF functionality, we unfortunately have to replace it, or we might suddenly find ourselves in a situation where we'd have to take it down without having planned to do so.

Additionally, it does not support a number of rendering requests from the community, the main one being the ability to render tables. We have selected a new service, the electron rendering service, as a suitable replacement. Our next step is to duplicate the functionality provided by OCG using the electron rendering service. Below, we will describe the main portions of the functionality we have identified as necessary. We would like to invite conversation around what is missing or what is superfluous in the provided list. We would also like to highlight over our future plans for PDF rendering to gather initial feedback.

Known issues

• There is currently a bug within Firefox (upstream) that affects the styling of infoboxes displayed across multiple pages. Progress from Mozilla can be tracked here: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=688556.

Userbase

The following table shows a sample of traffic to the Electron "Download as PDF" service for over a 6 hour period. The traffic is broken down by operating system (OS), browser, and the browser major version (e.g. Windows 7, Chrome v61.*). Note well that the majority of our traffic appears to come from Windows based machines.

OS	Browser	Browser Major Version	% of requests
Other	Other	-	14.38
Windows 7	Chrome	61	12.42
Windows 10	Chrome	61	8.83
Windows 7	IE	11	7.33
Windows 7	Firefox	56	6.59
Windows 10	Firefox	56	3.82
Windows 10	Edge	15	3.24
Windows 8.1	Chrome	61	3.07
Windows XP	Chrome	49	2.2
Windows 10	Chrome	59	1.53
Windows 10	IE	11	1.51
Windows 8.1	Firefox	56	1.31
Windows XP	Firefox	52	1.22
Windows 8	Chrome	61	1.15
Windows 8.1	IE	11	1.15
Mac OS X	Safari	11	0.9
Windows 7	Firefox	53	0.89
Windows 7	Firefox	52	0.78
Ubuntu	Firefox	56	0.78
Windows XP	IE	6	0.7
Windows 7	Chrome	55	0.68
Windows 7	Firefox	55	0.62
Mac OS X	Chrome	61	0.62
Android	UC Browser	11	0.6
Windows 10	Edge	14	0.59
Windows 7	Opera	48	0.53
Android	Chrome Mobile	61	0.49
Windows 10	Opera	48	0.44
Windows 7	Chrome	60	0.4
Windows Vista	Chrome	49	0.39
Windows 7	Yandex Browser	17	0.37
Windows 10	Firefox	55	0.37
Mac OS X	Safari	10	0.36
Windows 10	Chrome	50	0.34
Android	Android	4	0.33
Mac OS X	Firefox	56	0.33
Windows 10	Chrome	60	0.32
Windows 8.1	Chrome	43	0.3
Android	Amazon Silk	60	0.29
Windows 7	Sogou Explorer	1	0.27
Windows 8	IE	10	0.26
Windows 7	IE	8	0.26
Windows 7	IE	9	0.25
Windows 8	Opera	12	0.25
Linux	Firefox	52	0.25
Mac OS X	Firefox	53	0.24
Windows 7	Firefox	45	0.24
Windows 10	Firefox	57	0.24
Windows 7	Firefox	38	0.22
Windows 10	Firefox	47	0.21

Current Functionality Requirements

The following is a list of the current requirements for PDF rendering for single-article PDF's and for books. The requirements different from the current implementation are displayed in bold.

History

• Rendering PDF articles and books from Wikipedia pages is handled by a service called OCG. When rendering "books" through the book creator, it uses OCG as embedded within the Collection extension. OCG has multiple issues, especially with tables.
• Multiple issues with OCG are identified, including complaints from the community around OCG's inability to render tables.
• Rendering of tables ranks as number 9 on the German-speaking Community Technical Wishlist.
• Wikimedia Deutschland begins on working on a solution for rendering tables in PDF's, and introduces Electron. They do this planning to run it alongside OCG, not to replace it.
• At the same time as Wikimedia Deutschland is working on the Electron service, the responsible maintainers of the OCG service at the Wikimedia Foundation come to the conclusion that OCG has to be replaced.
• The WMF Reading Team takes over the responsibility for the long term maintenance of PDF rendering and begins plans for implementing table rendering across all projects.
• The Reading team launches a community consultation for gathering feedback on Electron.
• The Reading Infrastructure and Web teams begin scoping the working necessary to port OCG functionality over to the Electron service.

Update After Consultation

Proposed PDF and print styles based on feedback from consultation

We launched a consultation on the current implementation of the PDF renderer in early June, 2017. After reviewing the consultation responses, we have made the following observations:

• A larger number of users preferred the single-column format over the double column format
• Users which prefered the double-column format highlighted that their preference was based in the styling and look and feel of double columns. Some users also expressed concerns with font size and wasting paper when printing PDF's in the single-column option
• The following feature requests were made:
  • Functional hyperlinks
  • Date and url, 'this page downloaded [date] from [URL]'
  • Customizable css for layout, title, TOC
  • Option for 2 column format
  • Include/exclude images versions
  • Modifiable margins
  • print by section - allows you to remove references, paragraphs you don’t want, index, etc
  • allowing configurable text size

Based on the feedback, we have incorporated the following into our new print styles:

• hyperlinks
• article information
• smaller font and book-like styling

The remainder of the requests above will be postponed until the second iteration of the PDF renderer, in which we plan to build a settings mode that will allow for customization of the available options.

Proposal

The following is a proposal for the scope of functionality necessary for PDF rendering:

• Individual articles will be rendered to PDF using the "Download as PDF" link in the sidebar
• Multiple articles will be rendered to PDF using the Book Creator tool
• All articles will contain attribution for text and images
• All PDFs rendered will be able to print tables
  • Users will be able to customize the layout of their PDF (optional)

Differences between current and future implementation

	OCG	New Service	Notes
Rendering individual articles	Yes	Yes
Rendering multiple articles using the book creator	Yes	Yes
Contains table of contents for multiple articles	Yes	Yes
Renders tables	No	Yes
Attribution	Yes	Yes	Open question: location of attribution within the new service
Styling	Latex	New styles
N-column layout	Yes	No
Default 2-column layout	Yes	Tentative	Default one column or two-column layout will be chosen based on feedback and quantitative and/or qualitative testing
Output format	PDF, Plaintext	PDF Only

Design

The new PDF styles will be designed for increased readability. Based on community feedback and qualitative or quantitative testing, support for a 2-column layout may be built for the book creator and/or for individual PDFs.

• 
  Examples of new PDF output - Styles will be updated based on feedback from the ongoing consultation
• 

Development and Deployment Roadmap

The following is a rough outline of the development and deployment roadmap. It is subject to change.

1. April – May 2017:
   1. The Reading team builds back-end support for functionality identified above
   2. Communities are consulted on expanding or shrinking proposed functionality
   3. Qualitative test performed for styling
2. June – July 2017:
   1. New styles implemented
   2. First iteration is launched along with OCG on all projects and performance is compared
   3. Iterations based on consultations and identified edge cases
3. August 2017 – September 2017
   1. Additional changes made if necessary
4. October 2017
   1. Second iteration launched without OCG on all projects

Single Articles

• A PDF for a single article will be created by selecting the "Download as PDF" link
• Upon selecting "Download as PDF", the PDF file will be generated. To download the file, users will select the "Download the file link"
• Each PDF file will contain the following:
  • Article title and text
  • Infobox (if any)
  • Tables (if any)
  • Single-column layout
  • Page number
  • All article images and captions
  • Links to pages linked from the article (blue links and external links)
  • Text and image sources, contributors, and licenses

Phabricator Tracking

All PDF-related changes including sunsetting OCG, replacing the Electron PDF renderer, and any updates to books or the collections extension are tracked under the phabricator project Proton. The project page will display any recent updates for all tasks related to PDFs.

Books

Functionality available in October, 2017

Note: no changes will be made to the current book creator workflow at this time

• User will launch the books creator by selecting "Create a book"
• This will navigate to the current book creation page
• To download a book, users will select the "download" link from the books page
• Users may only download books in PDF format
• Books will contain all elements from single article format as well as:
  • Book title page
  • The references for each article from the book will appear at the end of the article
  • Each article will begin on a new page
  • A single section for text and image sources, contributors, and licenses, that contains the collected contributions from all articles

Functionality available in November - December, 2017

• Books will contain a table of contents with page numbers
  • Selecting a section from the table of contents will navigate the user to the corresponding section within the book

Styles for books will be updated for improved readability

Alternative

There is an alternative way of exporting MediaWiki to LaTeX, PDF, ODT and EPUB:

http://mediawiki2latex.wmflabs.org/

The computational resources on the server are limited.

If you run Ubuntu Linux and want results faster, you can install the m2l-pyqt or mediawiki2latex packages.