Tale of the tape – here’s the inside story on how the data describes who wins and who loses in UK grocery. First up: Waitrose & Partners and their win in the ‘Choice’ category.
Headlines:
📰 Waitrose’s win comes from super performance in produce and packaged, as well as good premium (though not quite as good as M&S).
📰 In ‘Choice – Produce’ they had more varieties of apples, berries and bagged salads (all good indicators of choice depth) than M&S or Tesco.
Beneath that, let’s look at the variables that count towards the win. Scores are gathered from the signals that feed each variable. For example, ‘Range – Meat’ is fed by three observable and measurable signals ‘Categories’, ‘Range Logic’ and ‘Packs’.
🍷Premium Path / Position
🍷Range - Produce
🍷Choice - Meat
🍷Choice - Produce
🍷Choice – Packaged Grocery
🍷Range - Grocery
🍷Range - Meat
🍷Premium Availability
🍷Out Of Stock – Grocery
Choice, range (assortment in the US), and OOS are three dimensions on the same question but each tells a different and specific story. Choice is about exactly that, in a given category how many choices are observably present? Range looks at how deep and broad that choice is AND at how it is logically presented (if at all). OOS – Grocery is your classical gaps count, I would have hated my District Managers having this measure when I was in stores! The white glove Tricker used to wear to ‘measure’ levels of dust on top of products was bad enough…
Premium helps Waitrose to some extent but it is not the whole story. If we turn off the two ‘premium’ related variables then Tesco wins, but even then Waitrose finishes a decent second. M&S drop to 6th. That’s describing a critical difference between Waitrose and M&S in premium; the former has come to rely less on premium than has M&S. Right strategy? Given their very different fortunes in recent quarters, one can easily argue ‘no’. Giving up its premium positioning is hurting Waitrose.
This was a close run category and it was good to see Waitrose come out on top. If I were at the helm, I would be using the wider data outside of Choice to bench-test strategy, change and transformation. How do we line up on experience across the rest of journey? What are our gaps to competitors in the context of our most valuable customer stories?
Elsewhere:
In premium, M&S wins on Availability (100% observation of premium options throughout the store, versus Waitrose's 75%) and premium setting, where M&S used more premium materials (63% observed frequency at M&S versus 25% at Waitrose), and higher prices as an indicator (63% vs 50%) - that last is a great one to explore.
#retail #experienceanalytics #grocery
Retail Marketing Manager at Trust Payments
3moGreat news ! 👏