This movie can't decide what it's trying to be. Or perhaps it's trying to be everything, sort of like a Bollywood (Mumbai) epic.
It starts out as a nostalgic period piece, and a musical at that, set in the Gay Nineties, or perhaps just after the turn of the 20th century. I thought at first that I had recorded it in error. Those who aren't old enough to remember "Sing Along With Mitch," much less "follow the bouncing ball," will probably not recognize most of the old standards that are performed here.
What we mostly see during this section, besides brass bands and barbershop quartets, is Jimmy Cagney engaging in fisticuffs with just about everyone he comes in contact with, because "that's just the sort of hairpin" he is. It is interesting to see a young George Reeves with a moustache.
Then, abandoning the songs, the movie turns into a comedy of the first water, a great deal better than I expected. If it had continued in this vein, I would have rated it at least a 7 and kept it. The dialog is clever and witty, with many unexpected lines, and Olivia de Havilland particularly shines as a Suffragette who's more talk than action when it comes to the pinch.
After the comedy portion, it becomes a fairly mundane love story for a while, with Cagney and Carson both chasing Hayworth and the loser ending up with de Havilland as the consolation prize.
Then suddenly the movie turns into a tear jerker! After this betrayal, I almost didn't finish it out.
But wait, we're not finished with our chameleon act yet! The final quarter of the movie is a didactic morality fable, with speeches and justice for all.
The acting is top notch throughout. De Havilland is head and shoulders above the others, but Cagney and Carson do a great job as well. Rita Hayworth crackles, several years before she even thought of putting the blame on Mame. George Tobias, who is probably most famous for portraying Abner Kravitz on "Bewitched," must have been at the peak of his career, as he gets fourth billing.
If you like pat, sappy Broadway musicals that are a bit on the heavyhanded side, you will like this film all the way through. Otherwise, if you were expecting a comedy, you will probably feel betrayed, as I did.
It starts out as a nostalgic period piece, and a musical at that, set in the Gay Nineties, or perhaps just after the turn of the 20th century. I thought at first that I had recorded it in error. Those who aren't old enough to remember "Sing Along With Mitch," much less "follow the bouncing ball," will probably not recognize most of the old standards that are performed here.
What we mostly see during this section, besides brass bands and barbershop quartets, is Jimmy Cagney engaging in fisticuffs with just about everyone he comes in contact with, because "that's just the sort of hairpin" he is. It is interesting to see a young George Reeves with a moustache.
Then, abandoning the songs, the movie turns into a comedy of the first water, a great deal better than I expected. If it had continued in this vein, I would have rated it at least a 7 and kept it. The dialog is clever and witty, with many unexpected lines, and Olivia de Havilland particularly shines as a Suffragette who's more talk than action when it comes to the pinch.
After the comedy portion, it becomes a fairly mundane love story for a while, with Cagney and Carson both chasing Hayworth and the loser ending up with de Havilland as the consolation prize.
Then suddenly the movie turns into a tear jerker! After this betrayal, I almost didn't finish it out.
But wait, we're not finished with our chameleon act yet! The final quarter of the movie is a didactic morality fable, with speeches and justice for all.
The acting is top notch throughout. De Havilland is head and shoulders above the others, but Cagney and Carson do a great job as well. Rita Hayworth crackles, several years before she even thought of putting the blame on Mame. George Tobias, who is probably most famous for portraying Abner Kravitz on "Bewitched," must have been at the peak of his career, as he gets fourth billing.
If you like pat, sappy Broadway musicals that are a bit on the heavyhanded side, you will like this film all the way through. Otherwise, if you were expecting a comedy, you will probably feel betrayed, as I did.