Ken Russell's most fully realized, gloriously and thematically integrated film (although some make a good case for The Devils, see the Joseph Gomez book) is FINALLY in letterboxed widescreen DVD! No more pan-and-scan!
Those not fortunate, as I was, to see it in a theater (it was once popular on the art-house/revival circuit) can now see that when Nina has her panic attack, her mother is also in the room, saying nothing, looking at her from behind with knowing disdain; that Madame Von Meck has both twin sons on the couch when we first meet them, and on either side of her in the carriage when it passes Tchaikovsky in the forest, each son turning to look down at her swoon with pity and alarm (a good laugh in the theater), the parallel of Tchaikovsky and Chiluvsky on either side of Nina at the outdoor Swan Lake ballet, the full scale of the thrilling winter festival opening sequence, and the satisfaction of seeing the full lush design. Watch how a former TV director stretches a low budget to appear lavish!
Not being an audiophile/videophile, I can't speak with technical precision to the look and sound, but while no extra effort seems to have gone into remastering or cleanup, a quality print was used, and the sound is markedly superior to the VHS tracks. I'd quibble with the mix for the 1812 Overture sequence, the orchestra too quiet under the cannons. Included is the interesting theatrical trailer, but no other extras, and no chapter divisions -- you can only navigate forward and back at 10-minute intervals. But so what? You need to watch it all from start to finish, the way David Lynch likes his DVDs to be watched, eliminating divisions entirely.
To be fair, one Russian's take: a dear friend of mine from Kazan, taking up my probably tactless invitation to watch, questioned the whole point of the film. Putting aside her annoyance at the knock at her country's greatest composer (an old friend is from Tchaikovsky's home village), she asked what we gain from this portrait? That when he composed his piano concerto, he was thinking of his sister? Etc. I gave her Russell's own answer, and the reason the film isn't titled "Tchaikovsky": it's really about dreamers, and their need to live in dreams to the avoidance of engaging with their lives, or drive themselves to bring gauzy dreams to life, and spoil or ruin the lives around them. Russell's immediate inspiration was the false reality in TV commercials, and the piano concerto/sister fantasy a deliberate mockery.
And it's STILL seductive, of course! Which lends the film its immense visual and emotional impact.
The hazy, dewy memory of Tchaikovsky as a little boy playing piano while his beautiful, beloved mother sings, kisses and praises him with shining eyes and the prettiest, most loving smile I've ever seen on film, is followed by his panic and horror at being carried out of the room when she dies from cholera, blighting his entire emotional life, it would seem.
(This answer didn't persuade my friend. I gather that Russians are more realistic generally than Westerners, and less apt to lose themselves in romantic fantasies. So it's a film for us, about us, as The Devils was really about the modern political era, not 17th-century France. But she loved Savage Messiah, Women in Love, and The Rainbow.)
Anyway: GET THIS DVD -- spread the word -- do not let this near-masterpiece be forgotten!
Russell recently had a stroke or TIA, and may not be with us much longer. There will be a burst of interest when he finally passes, may it be delayed (he's still working!) but will likely fade thereafter. When he visited the Dallas USA Film Festival to show off The Fall of the Louse of Usher, I had the pleasure of standing up and informing the crowd that Francis Ford Coppola had said he intentionally shot Apocalypse Now in Russell's style. To which Russell responded, as I expected, "I wish I had his budget." I also pointed out how so many younger directors and editors have adopted his style, whether they realize it or not. Maybe they think they take after Orson Welles, or Ridley Scott, or Paul Greengrass, or music videos.
I'm getting one for my musician sister.
While you're at it, get the Savage Messiah DVD too. Not just for the chance to see a voluptuous young Helen Mirren totally nude, with Henri's hilarious rejoinder to her silly artistic fantasies; it's 2nd only to The Music Lovers, in my opinion
Image Unavailable
Image not available for
Color:
Color:
-
-
-
- Sorry, this item is not available in
- Image not available
- To view this video download Flash Player
The Music Lovers (La Symphonie Pathetique)
Rated: Format: DVD
Unrated
IMDb7.2/10.0
$92.03 $92.03
Save 2% at checkout Terms
Additional DVD options | Edition | Discs | Price | New from | Used from |
DVD
"Please retry" | — | 1 | $92.03 | $92.03 | — |
DVD
October 6, 2011 "Please retry" | — | 1 |
—
| — | $19.55 |
Watch Instantly with | Rent | Buy |
{"desktop_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"$92.03","priceAmount":92.03,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"92","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"03","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"ypgamaj0wyZrObefQWL%2F%2F2qDZoFTFCZ03DM6KvIhY2LPOkfWL13cwcpXZI39kXZWpSIOb1w25xo%2FaSXCzeq8sc5hih4N6G3Q1%2Bhkw9VKulBt2nQ8OWdq4JxPIrGKU%2FwFIL9Oxs4S%2BbW39XRKy58c6ep%2BHTTcDNmkngxSgZq2%2BZCqONIpBoQTQQGfWSGykuyo","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}]}
Purchase options and add-ons
Format | NTSC, PAL, DVD |
Language | French, English |
Number Of Discs | 1 |
Playback Region 2 : This will not play on most DVD players sold in the U.S., U.S. Territories, Canada, and Bermuda. See other DVD options under “Other Formats & Versions”. Learn more about DVD region specifications here
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Product Description
Quick Shipping !!! New And Sealed !!! This Disc WILL NOT play on standard US DVD player. A multi-region PAL/NTSC DVD player is request to view it in USA/Canada. Please Review Description.
Product details
- Aspect Ratio : 2.35:1
- MPAA rating : Unrated (Not Rated)
- Package Dimensions : 7.1 x 5.42 x 0.58 inches; 2.88 ounces
- Media Format : NTSC, PAL, DVD
- Subtitles: : French
- ASIN : B009D21VD6
- Number of discs : 1
- Best Sellers Rank: #307,555 in Movies & TV (See Top 100 in Movies & TV)
- #238,715 in DVD
- Customer Reviews:
Customer reviews
4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5
277 global ratings
How customer reviews and ratings work
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on October 13, 2011
Reviewed in the United States on December 1, 2011
After literally decades of waiting, it is a joy to at last have this remarkable and grievously neglected masterwork available on DVD. The good news is that it's a clean and complete print with fine image and sound. The crying shame is how cavalierly it has been packaged. The manufacturers simply took no pains whatever. Inconceivably, there is no discrete chaptering. One starts the movie playing and is able to advance or reverse through it at 10 minute intervals. That is all. Well, aside from having the original theatrical trailer included which, under the circumstances, feels like a bone thrown to a dog. Looking past this unforgivable disregard for the work, however, it remains one of the great masterpieces of the early 1970s. It is a must-have for any serious film buff.
It's especially important to cut through the totally false reputation with which it was saddled by vicious critics at the time of its release. First among these was Vincent Canby of the New York Times, who accused it of being a fantasy that completely falsified Tchaikovsky's life. One can only marvel at the arrogance of someone so respected making a charge which is so mind-bogglingly false. Any look at the facts reveals that Russell and his co-writer Melvyn Bragg stick closely to recorded history, only dovetailing certain events and combining certain characters to achieve well-paced dramatic action. They add absolutely nothing to the narrative which isn't either a direct event from the composer's life or which combines aspects of characters or personality traits into bundles that most powerfully communicate the underlying truths surrounding his tempestuous life.
Among its prime virtues are its incandescent performances. Richard Chamberlain captures the gentility of his character while masterfully navigating its frequent hysteria, along with giving one of the most credible on-screen representations of piano virtuosity. Glenda Jackson, alternately ingratiating, steely, pathetic, and finally insane, is a tower of creative fire. They're beautifully supported by Christopher Gable's wonderfully effeminate Russian count, Kenneth Colley's scheming brother, Max Adrian's pompous impresario, Izabella Telezynska's cunning benefactress, and Maureen Pryor's venal matriarch.
Best of all, though, is Russell's almost preternatural feel for the music itself, every note of it by Tchaikovsky. From the opening, a little-known scherzo whose jarring shift from major to minor underlines the film's title, to the notorious 1812 Overture sequence where the lead characters are decapitated by canon fire, we are treated to a marriage of sight and sound unequalled in all cinema. No film before or since has ever approached the brilliance of Russell's musical visualizations, the standout being the first Piano Concerto's second movement, given in full and tying together all the film's conceptual and emotional threads in perfect synchronization with Tchaikovsky's music.
Perhaps one day the DVD makers will deign to give this wonderful film the respect it is due. But for now, the fine print alone is more than worth the price.
It's especially important to cut through the totally false reputation with which it was saddled by vicious critics at the time of its release. First among these was Vincent Canby of the New York Times, who accused it of being a fantasy that completely falsified Tchaikovsky's life. One can only marvel at the arrogance of someone so respected making a charge which is so mind-bogglingly false. Any look at the facts reveals that Russell and his co-writer Melvyn Bragg stick closely to recorded history, only dovetailing certain events and combining certain characters to achieve well-paced dramatic action. They add absolutely nothing to the narrative which isn't either a direct event from the composer's life or which combines aspects of characters or personality traits into bundles that most powerfully communicate the underlying truths surrounding his tempestuous life.
Among its prime virtues are its incandescent performances. Richard Chamberlain captures the gentility of his character while masterfully navigating its frequent hysteria, along with giving one of the most credible on-screen representations of piano virtuosity. Glenda Jackson, alternately ingratiating, steely, pathetic, and finally insane, is a tower of creative fire. They're beautifully supported by Christopher Gable's wonderfully effeminate Russian count, Kenneth Colley's scheming brother, Max Adrian's pompous impresario, Izabella Telezynska's cunning benefactress, and Maureen Pryor's venal matriarch.
Best of all, though, is Russell's almost preternatural feel for the music itself, every note of it by Tchaikovsky. From the opening, a little-known scherzo whose jarring shift from major to minor underlines the film's title, to the notorious 1812 Overture sequence where the lead characters are decapitated by canon fire, we are treated to a marriage of sight and sound unequalled in all cinema. No film before or since has ever approached the brilliance of Russell's musical visualizations, the standout being the first Piano Concerto's second movement, given in full and tying together all the film's conceptual and emotional threads in perfect synchronization with Tchaikovsky's music.
Perhaps one day the DVD makers will deign to give this wonderful film the respect it is due. But for now, the fine print alone is more than worth the price.
Top reviews from other countries
Yvette Ratson
5.0 out of 5 stars
I have always loved this movie so finally decided to buy it for ...
Reviewed in Canada on May 6, 2018
I have always loved this movie so finally decided to buy it for myself to enjoy it whenever I wanted to, it arrived very quickly and in good condition
momo76
5.0 out of 5 stars
enfin un DVD qui respecte le consommateur !
Reviewed in France on January 21, 2020
The Music Lovers en zone 2 & son français/anglais et sous-titres disponibles.
Le chapitrage est correct, image 2.35 16/9 de très bonne qualité pour un écran TV LED.
BelAir classiques, HollywoodClassic et le concours de la CNC ont réédité ce chef d'oeuvre.
Surement une étude de marché a été faite pour cette nouvelle version française !
J'ai attendu 49 ans pour revoir un des meilleur film de Ken Russel.
Formidable Richard Chamberlain dans le rôle de Tchaîkovski, de profil avec son tout premier concert pour piano et orchestre devant une salle bondée d'étudiants, de professeurs et de mélomanes...
J'attend maintenant WEST SIDE STORY (restauration faite en 2012 pour HD 720p) en version 4k bientôt ?
et Lawrence d'Arabie en 4k ?
(Il reste en France 3 films exploitables en version 70 mm image 2.20 durée 227 mn stéréo 6 pistes film passé par l'équipe de CANAL+ aux abonnés de Week-end - Cinéma ....)
Le chapitrage est correct, image 2.35 16/9 de très bonne qualité pour un écran TV LED.
BelAir classiques, HollywoodClassic et le concours de la CNC ont réédité ce chef d'oeuvre.
Surement une étude de marché a été faite pour cette nouvelle version française !
J'ai attendu 49 ans pour revoir un des meilleur film de Ken Russel.
Formidable Richard Chamberlain dans le rôle de Tchaîkovski, de profil avec son tout premier concert pour piano et orchestre devant une salle bondée d'étudiants, de professeurs et de mélomanes...
J'attend maintenant WEST SIDE STORY (restauration faite en 2012 pour HD 720p) en version 4k bientôt ?
et Lawrence d'Arabie en 4k ?
(Il reste en France 3 films exploitables en version 70 mm image 2.20 durée 227 mn stéréo 6 pistes film passé par l'équipe de CANAL+ aux abonnés de Week-end - Cinéma ....)
momo76
Reviewed in France on January 21, 2020
Le chapitrage est correct, image 2.35 16/9 de très bonne qualité pour un écran TV LED.
BelAir classiques, HollywoodClassic et le concours de la CNC ont réédité ce chef d'oeuvre.
Surement une étude de marché a été faite pour cette nouvelle version française !
J'ai attendu 49 ans pour revoir un des meilleur film de Ken Russel.
Formidable Richard Chamberlain dans le rôle de Tchaîkovski, de profil avec son tout premier concert pour piano et orchestre devant une salle bondée d'étudiants, de professeurs et de mélomanes...
J'attend maintenant WEST SIDE STORY (restauration faite en 2012 pour HD 720p) en version 4k bientôt ?
et Lawrence d'Arabie en 4k ?
(Il reste en France 3 films exploitables en version 70 mm image 2.20 durée 227 mn stéréo 6 pistes film passé par l'équipe de CANAL+ aux abonnés de Week-end - Cinéma ....)
Images in this review
JunJos Godobarro
5.0 out of 5 stars
Conocer un poco la vida de ese gran compositor
Reviewed in Spain on July 25, 2019
Amazon, deveria precisar en su oferta en que lengua esta la pelicula . Esta esta en ingles y en frances, no es un problema para mi pues hablo las 2 lenguas, pero lo es para los miembros de mi familia.
Dr.Eliu Victor
4.0 out of 5 stars
Älteres Highlight
Reviewed in Germany on December 15, 2014
Habe ich mal in den 80-gern gesehen und dann aus dem Sinn verloren. Jahre später gesucht und jetzt erst zu einem guten Preis gefunden. Abgespeckte Version, keine Untertitel, Sprachauswahl, soundauswahl, aber immerhin der Film!
ivan stefanutti
5.0 out of 5 stars
Commovente
Reviewed in Italy on February 12, 2013
Immagini e musica, in questo capolavoro, sono commoventi e delicati. Chamberlain e la Jackson sono insuperabili.
Tanto romantica la storia quanto melanconica. Un finale durissimo nel manicomio
Tanto romantica la storia quanto melanconica. Un finale durissimo nel manicomio