This is a solid collection for the great tales. The boxset is of a good quality and the dust jackets have a nice shine to them. The artwork by Alan Lee is absolutely gorgeous. If you’re looking for a new set and haven’t read these, this is the one!
My review for The Children of Húrin:
This is one or part of Tolkien’s ‘great tales’, and it is apparently one of the earlier things he worked on, continuously altered, and made further notes on, until his death. The editing work from his son included completing the work and making it a cohesive linear story for readers, and was published in 2007. This is also a part of the Unfinished Tales and The Silmarillion.
I had intended to read through some more of Tolkien’s work prior to September, and the release of The Rings of Power. When I realized it was already august, I knew I had to get it in gear. Now the great tales aren’t the storyline from tRoP, but I still wanted to conquer them as I have already read the appendices before. Due to time, I decided to go with the audio, which sadly means I missed the great illustrations on this first read through, but it is narrated by the late Christopher Lee…his performance is explosive. However it was a bit weird, because the audio is broken into 7 chapters for an 18 chapter book, with seemingly no reason whatsoever for it.
Tolkien called this The Lay of the Children of Húrin, a lay being a narrative poem (typically sung). In many ways it also comes off as very epic, both in the style of poem, and the things happening. I really found myself thinking about this quote from Tolkien’s son (about Jackson’s LotR trilogy): “They eviscerated the book by making it an action movie for young people aged 15 to 25.” And although film cannot mimic the lyrical and powerful nature of Tolkien’s ability to write, this story includes some heavy things, descriptions, and themes that would almost read more as George R. R. Martin. It’s for that reason I kept thinking of the quote. Tolkien writes of dismemberment, torture, orcs beheading huge groups of people, humans hanging large groups of orcs from trees, suicide, unwitting incest. I mean there’s a lot to digest, but a lot of these things kind of resonated with me as the kind of violence translated into Jackson’s films.
Regardless of that, or with that being said, Tolkien still gives us the history, or almost overview of the story. The description is light, not exactly glossing over things, but he does not dwell on action and terror stroke by stroke. A huge battle is simply talked about as having happened, you’re never really inside the moment. It’s for that reason that Tolkien always translates into history for me. This is much more linear than the Silmarillion as a whole, but they can still be viewed as almost textbook like writing. None of this is meant as a negative in any way though, as I absolutely love Tolkien and I absolutely loved this story.
My review for Beren and Lúthien:
This one opens with a preface by Christopher, at the age of 93, that I found truly astounding. It kind of continues throughout the book, as the tale is rather short, and has several versions. I think that Tolkien fans are really fortunate that he felt himself to be a protector/scholar of his father’s work, rather than living in its shadow, because he’s the only reason a lot of these things saw the light of day. In this preface he spoke to how his father would often change things, or names, or themes, and how an addition of a single character or thing could influence him rewriting something entirely. I loved how Christopher spoke to how he did not take these versions of the great tales to be canon, or to uncanonize other versions, he was just striving to give fans the most linear, narrative story possible.
Beren and Lúthien, or The Tale of Tinúviel (as the story and chapter are entitled—from The Book of Lost Tales Two), is an extracted version of their love and stealing of a Silmaril from Melkor/Morgoth. I personally kind of found this edited version to erase Beren, in the sense that it did not really include any background on him and his heroics. Lúthien runs from her father and even frees Beren, which is in no way an issue for me, but I think it weighs even heavier when you include who he was. Aka he felt a little useless to me.
Luckily however, this is a rather short extraction. (And that’s not at all to say that I actually found it to be bad! At all!!). The remainder of the book continues on with additional context from Christopher throughout, as well as additional excerpts from various versions and histories that he’s chosen to highlight for this combined edition of the great tale. These excerpts are from the actual lay, and therefore are genuine poetry in rhyme. That’s never been my cup of tea, but you can tell the lyrical prowess that Tolkien had, and the audio most definitely flowed effortlessly. I once again for my first read through miss out on all the illustrations, but we are hightailing it for The Rings of Power prep.
I of course would be remiss if I did not include the fact that it’s said the story originated from Tolkien taking woodland walks with his wife-to-be Edith, and that he found himself to be the mortal in the presence of greatness, a beauty of the Eldar. That is why Beren and Lúthien are inscribed on their tombstones, and I can only imagine the story was continually rewrote as their love grew and changed, and Tolkien wove it into the fabric of middle-earth.
My review for The Fall of Gondolin:
The final book edited by Tolkien’s son, and the final of the great tales. Again, I’ll express my great respect for all of the scholarly work Christopher did with his father’s work.
This one followed the same format as Beren and Lúthien, with there being a preface as well as additional notes from Christopher throughout, as well as the actual content from Tolkien. I again did the audio, which was done very well by Timothy and Samuel West—with one of them reading for Christopher, and the other for Tolkien. Sadly, missed out on the illustrations again though.
This one was again a rather short narrative tale that Christopher put together. It was roughly an hour and 45 minutes out of an 8:18 audiobook. For me that just goes to show the historical or textbook style writing that Tolkien had employed with these, not to mention he never finished entirely anyway. That’s not to say they aren’t poetic, or lyrical, it’s just that it was giving the information in a textbook/history way, it gives important events and major characters, without deeper detail. That’s again not to say I did not enjoy, I love the way the stories are told, it was just short!
The only thing I dislike about this formatting choice is that it once again takes away from the linear tale itself. Whereas The Children of Húrin was for the most part the entire book, Beren and Lúthien and The Fall of Gondolin are only a piece of the full book. It is true that Húrin has the most pieces anyway though. The Fall of Gondolin is a pretty dark tale of the might of Melko(r)/Morgoth, with balrogs, dragons, orcs, and men. He orchestrated the deaths of several named characters, as well as the overall downfall of the kingdom. I would love to see something done with this one day.
A big thing I’d love to talk about with this book is that the fall of Gondolin features a Legolas Greenleaf! And seemingly not the fellowships Legolas, who was born in the second age?! It has been remarked that if Tolkien continued his work he would more than likely have changed this name entirely, as elf names were not typically reused.
Another thing Christopher touched on that I really liked and wanted to highlight was that Tolkien considered TLotR to be one story, but in a referenced letter he had stated that he was fine with ANY of it being published for people to read, even calling it “this stuff.” So I am sorry Tolkien purists (I myself am kind of at least halfway in this camp…), but he was ultimately the approver of the trilogy it seems.
Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
The chilling story of the abduction of two teenagers, their escape, and the dark secrets that, years later, bring them back to the scene of the crime. | Learn more
Frequently bought together
$49.98
Get it as soon as Thursday, Jul 25
In Stock
Total price:
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Choose items to buy together.
More items to explore
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
From the Publisher
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The History of Middle-earth Boxed Set | The History of Middle-earth, Part One | The History of Middle-earth, Part Two | The History of Middle-earth, Part Three | The Silmarillion | Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth | |
| Customer Reviews |
1,184
|
116
|
55
|
114
|
21,519
|
2,196
|
| Price | $133.98 | $47.08 | $49.81 | $52.55 | $11.49 | $10.89 |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Silmarillion | The Nature of Middle-earth | The Atlas of Middle-earth | A Middle-earth Traveler | The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien | |
| Customer Reviews |
21,519
|
1,738
|
2,654
|
1,807
|
903
|
| Price | $22.89 | $17.69 | $15.13 | $17.99 | $17.99 |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Videos
Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1
Videos for this product
1:40
Click to play video
The Great Tales - My honest review - Likes and dislikes
Gaming Indoors
Videos for this product
0:05
Click to play video
Customer Review: INTRICATE AND AMAZING!! QUALITY BOOKS
John Boatfield
About the author
Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Reviews with images
INTRICATE AND AMAZING!! QUALITY BOOKS
I love the covers and designs for these books! They are incredible and I can’t wait to start reading these adventures!
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on September 9, 2022
Reviewed in the United States on June 1, 2024
I love the covers and designs for these books! They are incredible and I can’t wait to start reading these adventures!
Images in this review
Reviewed in the United States on October 31, 2020
Reviewed in the United States on November 1, 2023
Reviewed in the United States on November 20, 2020
So this review won't be delving into the content of the books or Tolkiens writing. I figure if you're here you are well versed in Middle Earth and a lover of the works of one of the greatest writers ever. So I will focus on the books presentation, artwork and overall quality. Short review : buy this. 10 outta 10 fully recommend.
Longer review : these books are beautifully done. The art within is gorgeous and very fitting to Tolkiens writing style, while not trying to replicate the authors personal art that he originally made for his work. The dust covers are beautiful as you can see in the pictures I provided. Each depicts a scene that portrays to the literature inside. They feel about as good quality as you could hope for with a dust cover. We keep ours in the box they came with and have had no issues with them being damaged. The box itself is also very aesthetically pleasing. It's cardboard so don't be expecting a wooden frame of some sort but if you keep your books inside and in a place they won't be hurt it'll hold up just fine. Under the dust covers the books look very classic for hard backed books, not too much to say about that I believe we all have standard hard back books in our collections. I love these books, I gifted them to my husband as he is also a die hard Tolkien lover and he was ecstatic to receive them, especially The Fall of Gondolin as we have been looking for that particular tale for awhile. If you or someone you love can't get enough Tolkien, this set is perfect.
Longer review : these books are beautifully done. The art within is gorgeous and very fitting to Tolkiens writing style, while not trying to replicate the authors personal art that he originally made for his work. The dust covers are beautiful as you can see in the pictures I provided. Each depicts a scene that portrays to the literature inside. They feel about as good quality as you could hope for with a dust cover. We keep ours in the box they came with and have had no issues with them being damaged. The box itself is also very aesthetically pleasing. It's cardboard so don't be expecting a wooden frame of some sort but if you keep your books inside and in a place they won't be hurt it'll hold up just fine. Under the dust covers the books look very classic for hard backed books, not too much to say about that I believe we all have standard hard back books in our collections. I love these books, I gifted them to my husband as he is also a die hard Tolkien lover and he was ecstatic to receive them, especially The Fall of Gondolin as we have been looking for that particular tale for awhile. If you or someone you love can't get enough Tolkien, this set is perfect.
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
יוגו מדינה מלגון
Indispensable para los fans de Tolkien y de la fantasía épica
Reviewed in Mexico on April 20, 2021
יוגו מדינה מלגון
Reviewed in Mexico on April 20, 2021
"Los Hijos de Húrin", la primera de dichas obras es la más elaborada debido a que Tolkien sí la concluyó en vida, aunque nunca la publicó. Las otras dos, "Beren y Luthien" y "La Caída de Gondolin" están atestiguadas en fragmentos que el editor recopiló y contextualizó para que el lector tenga idea de lo que el autor tenía en mente pero no concluyó.
Respecto a la calidad de la edición, es buena, de pasta dura con cubrepolvos. El papel no es tan fino como el de otras ediciones en boxset de pasta dura como la de "Historia de la Tierra Media", pero sigue siendo buena y cumple con su objetivo. Además tienen bonitas ilustraciones impresas en papel fotográfico, y mapas que son muy útiles para el lector. Los tres volúmenes vienen en una caja de cartón duro con acabado en mate, estéticamente se ve bien.
Por último, el boxset llegó muy rápido y en perfectas condiciones. Lo recomiendo ampliamente para los fans de Tolkien, y de la fantasía épica en general. Fue una buena compra.
Images in this review
Garnet
Amazing set for Tolkein’s other works
Reviewed in Canada on February 24, 2021