Home Ad Exchange News This Problem Is Meta-stisizing; The New Social Growth Club Of One

This Problem Is Meta-stisizing; The New Social Growth Club Of One

SHARE:
Comic: The Gravity Of The Situation

Here’s today’s AdExchanger.com news round-up… Want it by email? Sign up here.

At What Point Do We Reference Myspace?

Meta faces an existential crisis. It was a trillion-dollar company one year ago and is now worth a mere $370 billion.

“Mere” is relative – that’s still big. But this is a make-or-break moment for Meta.

CNBC attributes Meta’s crisis primarily to the ebb and flow of people (mostly ebbing in the case of Meta and the flagship Facebook app). Recruiting engineers is a problem, and users are leaving for other apps.

One analyst, Needham’s Laura Martin, actually has a “Sell” rating on Meta. 

The main issue, and what makes this an existential crisis despite Meta’s huge cash flow, is that Meta is almost 100% dependent on ads. Meta has billions of users across its portfolio of apps, and it could handle some users sloshing between buckets (from Facebook to Instagram, for example). And it could even deal with some outright spillage. But ATT has left its mark, and Meta hasn’t been able to reestablish the prospecting and personalization flywheel that used to make its ad platform hum. 

The math hurts: Meta has more than enough users, but not scaled conversion data. 

Also, being reliant on ads means being reliant on advertisers – and advertisers can be fickle.

“I’m not sure there’s a core business that works anymore at Facebook,” says Needham’s Martin. 

The Growth Torch

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

TikTok’s annual revenue in the UK and Europe increased from $172 million last calendar year to more than $990 million this year.

That’s impressive. However, the company’s losses in the region are up by a third to $896 million, the Financial Times reports based on a filing to the UK business administration agency. 

TikTok attributes these losses to hiring and expansion, including almost doubling its costs in sales and marketing.

Social media companies like Facebook, Pinterest, Snap and Twitter can only look on in envy. For most of the past decade, they’ve been considered growth investments by public market standards. Investors accepted losses on the grounds that each platform would eventually graduate to profitability. But that is no longer the case.

Wall Street is getting impatient and investors want to see mature behavior and sustainable profitability … and that has meant heavy layoffs, restructuring and shuttering wholesale business units.

TikTok, however, has more freedom to operate as a private company. It can hire through the downturn (which pays dividends) and ramp up advertising. Last month, Snap CEO Evan Spiegel yearningly spoke of TikTok’s “unimaginable” ad budget. 

But even if TikTok was a public company, it’d be in a good position. It’s got the magic-multiplier allure of a growth-stage investment.

A Bust For Trustbusters

The Big Tech antitrust bill penned by Senators Amy Klobuchar and Chuck Grassley has buzz and momentum – everywhere except in the halls of Congress.

The so-called “American Innovation and Choice Online Act” would prevent companies like Google, Meta and Apple from self-preferencing their own products across platforms they operate. 

But only 26% of US lawmakers support the bill as written, according to a survey of congressional aides conducted by Punchbowl News. That’s better than the 17% of lawmakers who outright oppose the bill, but the rough stat is 57% undecided.

The bill’s backers need a surge of advocacy and interest to move it along. But the issue just hasn’t surfaced on the radars it needs to. (And Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer has also been dragging his heels.)

This is despite the fact that the bill has been touted as a rare example of bipartisan legislation, with sponsors from both parties.

But the Punchbowl survey casts doubt on how widespread – and how bipartisan – the bill’s support really is. Currently, 41% of Democrats support the bill and 7% oppose, whereas only 11% of Republicans support it and 28% oppose. That suggests support for the bill has divided along the usual ideological lines, which is usually a bad sign for legislation looking to get across the finish line.

But Wait, There’s More!

The next big battle for Google and Apple is for the soul of your car. [WSJ]

TikTok to launch live shopping in the US using outsourced technology. [FT]

The tech site that took on China’s surveillance state. [The Atlantic]

Mike Shields: Why Vox Media is hedging its bets in ad tech and data. [blog]

What are the top 10 alternative ID solutions and how do you use them? [AdMonsters]

FuboTV touts ad spend growth from Unified ID 2.0 platform. [Fierce Video]

You’re Hired!

Steve Silvers has left Neustar to become Kantar’s new EVP of product development, global media and creative. [LinkedIn]

FreeWheel’s former general manager, Dave Clark, takes on the TripleLift CEO gig. [tweet]

Must Read

Google filed a motion to exclude the testimony of any government witnesses who aren’t economists or antitrust experts during the upcoming ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.

Google Is Fighting To Keep Ad Tech Execs Off the Stand In Its Upcoming Antitrust Trial

Google doesn’t want AppNexus founder Brian O’Kelley – you know, the godfather of programmatic – to testify during its ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.

How HUMAN Uncovered A Scam Serving 2.5 Billion Ads Per Day To Piracy Sites

Publishers trafficking in pirated movies, TV shows and games sold programmatic ads alongside this stolen content, while using domain cloaking to obscure the “cashout sites” where the ads actually ran.

In 2019, Google moved to a first-price auction and also ceded its last look advantage in AdX, in part because it had to. Most exchanges had already moved to first price.

Thanks To The DOJ, We Now Know What Google Really Thought About Header Bidding

Starting last week and into this week, hundreds of court-filed documents have been unsealed in the lead-up to the Google ad tech antitrust trial – and it’s a bonanza.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

Will Alternative TV Currencies Ever Be More Than A Nielsen Add-On?

Ever since Nielsen was dinged for undercounting TV viewers during the pandemic, its competitors have been fighting to convince buyers and sellers alike to adopt them as alternatives. And yet, some industry insiders argue that alt currencies weren’t ever meant to supplant Nielsen.

A comic depicting people in suits setting money on fire as a reference to incrementality: as in, don't set your money on fire!

How Incrementality Tests Helped Newton Baby Ditch Branded Search

In the past year, Baby product and mattress brand Newton Baby has put all its media channels through a new testing regime for incrementality. It was a revelatory experience.

Colgate-Palmolive redesigned all of its consumer-facing sites and apps to serve as information hubs about its brands and make it easier to collect email addresses and other opted-in user data.

Colgate-Palmolive’s First-Party Data Strategy Is A Study In Quality Over Quantity

Colgate-Palmolive redesigned all of its consumer-facing sites and apps to make it easier to collect opted-in first-party user data.