Folly of a movie Folly of a movie. The only reason they made this a musical is that otherwise, it would've been over under an hour and still, they couldn't fully commit to it. Phoenix and Gaga are spectacular with the material they've given. The direction is great combining the cinematography and music to give the film a pretty good pace considering nothing at all happens in the movie. It can't be called a full-on musical but the musical parts of the movie were the only thing that actually entertained me even though it was mostly pointless. And the writing is horrible in this movie.
I loved the first part and thought a lot of the criticisms it got were actually things that the movie treated pretty well and it was the political climate the reasoning for so much criticism. But here, all those criticisms are made a lot more valid. The way it tries to empathise and criticize its protagonist is so dumb, and it doesn't exactly seem like the same character from the first one the way a lot of decisions are made. Lady Gaga's character is written as a template serial killer lover and nothing more even though she tries her best. So, naming that character Harley Quinn is such a disservice considering the history of that character.
A lot of the movie takes place in a courtroom and jail. In both of these areas, there are just a lot of things that don't make sense. The cops and lawyers in this movie say and do things that don't make any sense considering what they actually want from doing it. The Joker says a lot of things that amount to nothing while in the first movie, all of his rants and comedy had a cinematic purpose.
Considering they went for a musical, the movie had a lot of chances to be a lot more than it is even with its nonsensical paper-thin plot but they don't commit to it. And ending the movie abruptly like that, when the previous scene would've been enough just to reduce the drama of that event is so dumb. I mean, this is supposed to be a musical and such a big thing is presented in such a bland way?
The choice to be a musical and the ending are supposed to be the polarizing aspects of the movie. But I enjoyed the musical aspect and the ending being so bland is more of the issue than the choice to do that considering how the rest of the movie went. Overall, it's technically well-made but has a weak script. It should've been utterly boring if not for the atmosphere that it sets for the movie. Nonetheless, such a bad sequel.