So bad, but so good. Alas, one of my least favorite subcategory of films. I do not refer to any genre, but the type of films that are so good in some ways and so bad in others- making it quite difficult to grade. "The Miracle of Morgan's Creek" started out with so much promise. Then it quickly became increasingly absurd and fanciful. From silly funny to unbelievable but still good, to being so completely outlandish that nothing could be taken seriously. But I guess that was the goal?
The "mood " of the film is supposed to be funny and feel good- but more than that, it is a frenzied, close to manic environment and pace that, frankly, can cause some anxiety! All of the characters are played so over the top, implausible characters. Norval started out as an endearing nice guy, but as each scene went by where he did absolutely ridiculously, cluelessly, stupid things, it became unbelievable and no longer endearing. The main characters are the Kockenlockers, which yes, I am sure was so much fun to say so the time. The father and her sister Emmy were both loud and everything they did was with such exaggeration. The father is the character that probably developed the most, from super strict domineering father to a more doting out of love and understanding one. Trudy started out as a selfish, superficial person, but did eventually come around to realize that Norval, always right there for her, was a great guy who deserved her love. However, this change was sudden and came with no explanation. He said some things, the next thing we know, she suddenly realizes that she loves him.
The plot is absurd right from the beginning and only gets more and more inconceivable. The female protagonist, Trudy, not remembering who she married, but "sure" she did, without much more to go on but fuzzy memories. The human brain is quite fallible even in the best of times, without amnesia! And then she decides to fake a marriage with Norval so she can have the marriage certificate to avoid a scandal in the town? Then he accidentally signs his real name, when he was supposed to be posing as a soldier? Then he is arrested for impersonation and abducting Trudy, but then her father, the town constable, lets him escape- actually has to literally push him into escaping in one of the most frustrating scenes ever with Norval not being able to understand anything the father is suggesting because he is so "good", such a nice, morally superior boy.
The ridiculousness does not end there. Norval needs some money, because he plans to find the original soldier, whom we don't even know really even exists but for the pregnancy, a ring on her hand, and her vague recollection that she was with a soldier that had a "Z" in his name. Considering that the party at which she supposedly met this mystery husband was also attended by dozens of other soldiers, it is possible it could have been any one of them, or even somebody not attending the party that she ran into later, since she does not remember anything else. Furthermore, it is completely possible that they slept together but never actually married.
Anyhow, to get this said money to aid in his escape, they stage a bank robbery, which Norval happens to work at. Because of course that would be smarter than quietly finding a way to borrowing some money or getting the money after hours. Obviously, he messes it up and the bank alarm blares into the night. More shenanigans ensue, the father- remember he is the constable that was supposed to be guarding Norval- is fired, and he goes into hiding with his two daughters. Fast forward a few months, Norval has returned, with no success on locating the mysterious man that may or may not exist. And of course, he is seen by the bank manager, and he is arrested again.
By this time, Trudy is ready to give birth. And here is where we learn what the titular "Miracle* is that occurs in this town called "Morgan's Creek". She- gasp- gives birth to sextuplets, and they are all boys. And we still are not done. Next comes a montage, which I guess is supposed to be very humorous, where everyone around the world, from Mussolini to Hitler to great leaders continents away in Asia, all express their awe. Indeed, this is such an unbelievable miracle that a "recount" is demanded. Cue several more punny newspaper headlines! And such is the inspiring nature of this miracle that the governor of the state and local leaders decide that all is forgiven! Trudy's first marriage, which we don't even know really occurred without a paper trail, is inexplicably annulled anyhow. And even though he gave the court a fake name, Norval and Trudy are decidedly now officially married. The governor makes Norval a state guard, even though he was refused service in the army in all his previous applications. Last but not least, the father is not only rehired, but also given a promotion!
Finally, we have the icing on this unbalanced, overflowing with ingredients fancy cake- Norval is released from his cell, and chased by a clamoring crowd of nosy citizens, governmental figures, and newspaper reporters with their paparazzi- he is reunited with a resting Trudy, who doesn't even know what she has given birth to. She asks Norval whether it was a boy or girl. Norval is led by sister Emmy to see his babies- remember, not his, but he has so nobly agreed to raise as his own- and finds out it is not one, but six babies! We proceed with the necessary dramatics, fainting and screaming, be even tried to run away. And then, a saving grace maybe, but completely abrupt- given the film has taken more than 1.5 hours to get this far- the scene ends. Nay, not only the scene, but the entire film. Title card reads:
"But Norval recovered and
became increasingly happy
for, as Shakespeare said:
"Some are born great, some
achieve greatness, and some
have greatness thrust upon
them."
It is like the cast and film crew were having such a great time, lost track of time, and suddenly realized they had to end the film, so why not throw in an intertitle to finish it all. Hooray?
Given all this, it is more than generous to give this film 6/10 stars. After all, one is unlikely to report boredom. Maybe annoyance and frustration, but as long as the audience is prepared for this, and you are a viewer that is fine with fantastical plots, over the top theatrics with an uneven pace, and an abrupt conclusion that seems very lazy- literally using a title card to replace what should have been at least several more scenes- then this could actually be described as fun. As long as you do not find verisimilitude a necessary component of the story, "The Miracle of Morgan's Creek" is rather entertaining, with many funny moments and a cute if not very plausible story. As is expected from the talented Preston Sturges, there is clever dialogue, engaging repartee, and some slapstick humor. The most grievous flaw, ironically, is that one can recognize the potential in this film that could have easily been better in so many ways.