A misunderstood gem When it was announced that this film was going to be a musical, I fully expected for the whole world to love it, and I'd be the single human who hated every minute of it. Seemingly, we are in quite the opposite situation. I loved this film, and I suspect I know why most other people did not. I have a feeling 'Joker: Folie à Deux' will go down as one of the most misunderstood films of all time.
Where the misunderstanding is coming from, I believe, is that people think this is just another iteration of the 'Joker' that we have come to love over the years. It's not, and it never was. This is an entirely original character. This is not a 'Joker' who could mastermind heists, or set up master plans to bring down Gotham or go toe-to-toe with 'Batman'.
People didn't notice this as much in the original because it was an origin story. So they thought it normal that we wouldn't see all the theatrics we are used to from the 'Joker'. We are so used to sequels being bigger and bolder in every way that people thought this sequel would be him coming into his own, and doing all the things we have become used to seeing this character do.
So I think people went in with an expectation and didn't get anything remotely like what they expected/wanted, and for that reason deemed it a bad film. When in reality it is anything but. I can't imagine how Todd Phillips feels making a film this good, a film most directors could only dream of producing, and having the whole world criticise it.
The acting in the film is incredible. Both Lady Gaga and Joaquin Phoenix are more than deserving of Oscar nominations, but it will be very interesting to see what the Academy does after the critical response the movie has received. It shouldn't matter, but it often does.
I'm not a big fan of musicals. And that was my least favourite part of the movie. Having said that, watching Gaga sing is rarely ever a bad thing. I could watch that all day. Phoenix on the other hand, not so much. Would I have preferred it not to be a musical? Yes. Did it ruin the film for me? No, but it certainly did hold it back from being a 10/10.
I have been immensely curious about this film ever since it was announced. Going in I really thought anything from a 1 to a 10 was on the cards. And then I just sat there loving every minute of it, and before I knew it 140 minutes had passed. I hope this film finds its audience along the way, even if it takes some time for people to appreciate it. 9/10.