Lost Heart This film is one of my personal favorites in the drama genre, a genre that's not my normal wheelhouse but one that I visit occasionally, if there's a film that's I fancy. But also, mystery genre as this film is also a mystery film. This is one of those films that is just timeless, film buffs even non buffs know about this film; heck there are reference jokes in numerous shows about this film from "The Simpsons" to an episode of "The Real Ghostbusters" which was part of how I heard about the film. I remember seeing this film during my senior year in "Auburn High School" in my Mass Media class, it really captivated me then and it still does now. It's one of those films that may require rewatches because sometimes you can uncover more that I sometimes never even knew was there, but just enhances my appreciation for the story even more.
It was truly unique and ahead of its time, in visual storytelling and how we do filmmaking in general, another prime example once again showing how you can take filmmaking beyond it's limits to tell the story you want to tell. But other than that, I really like the story, which is interesting and intriguing but also makes this one of the saddest films I've ever seen.
The film is kind of a cautionary tale, seeing this film now as an adult made me even more grateful for my life and how it's gone. Personally, I'm glad I never became this guy, I honestly never wanted to be the guy despite how much he had, because I also know how much he doesn't have and worst of all how much he's lost.
There isn't much I can say that hasn't already been said, let alone you could probably make an extremely long syllabus just writing about the film, so I'll just keep it as simple as possible and with a small analysis or two.
There are those visuals that stick out that show the old saying of a picture is worth a thousand words. Like near the final half of the film we see the interior of Kane's mansion as he's residing in it on what we know are his final days. I'll admit this is a mansion I wouldn't want to live in, I don't even think Bruce Wanye/Batman would even like to either. It's too spacious and sterile for my taste, but what really gets to me about the mansion is that there is no warmth, it just doesn't feel like home.
We see from how big the mansion is from every environment that Kane walks in, from the staircase he descends to even near fireplace where literally giant logs were being burned Kane just looks small. This reflects how truly lost he has become, that he's become a shadow of his own greatness, but also how spiritually empty Kane has let himself become.
This goes with this sad irony but also this contrasting parallel dynamic with his stepfather Thacher, which I'll get into more latter. Another visual that strikes me is when we see some records building that Thacher owns. As we see how big the interior is along with a self-portrait of Thacher and how big that journal book the unnamed reporter reads. You can say this reflects how egotistical he really is, but it also shows that the guy is nothing but one big empty shell of a man, despite how big the place is, it's just simply that a place. There is just nothing spiritually going on, nothing interesting about the guy as the place is just one big empty crypt. At least with Kane despite his mansion being his giant crypt, there were lots of things in it that made him interesting, that showed he at least did the best he can to live out his life to the fullest which is all any of us can ask for.
I really love the storytelling style, which was unique for its time and has been echoed throughout the years, but this film was one of the first and still one of the best of its kind. The film does have the format of a noir/mystery as we have the whole MacGuffin throughout the film on the unanswered question on what Rosebud is; much like how with the TV show "Twin Peaks" there the question of was "Who Killed Laura Palmer". But just like with that show I personally found myself not concerned with what Rosebud is, because the real mystery is who Charles Foster Kane is.
The storytelling style is realistic when you think about it, as putting together a news story or simply making a story in general is practically putting together a puzzle in order to get the whole big picture. From what you see and hear about him you do get a good feel for the guy, where at first, he seems like a good guy that was on the right track, and you'd almost want to ally and be friends with. But then as you learn more about what's happened to him as time went on, we see how much he's changed and not for the better. This makes you feel sad for the guy because as we see he's become the very thing he's never wanted to be, unhappy.
One of the other things about Kane at least for me is that this guy has a bit of a identity crisis and that was not just because he never really found what he really wants out of life but that he never really let it all find him. For example, his love life which wasn't great, like with his first marriage that occurred in less than a matter of weeks which isn't good. It just showed one of Kane's weaknesses which is trying to short cut his way to getting what he wants, and we all know that love, real love has no short cuts; in fact, when you do you cheat yourself out of it. As we see in a montage of his marriage with his first wife Susan, at first things are alright but slowly but surely as time goes on things of course start to sour to the point where we see despite both eating at the same table they're not together, and worst of all love is just gone. Had Kane given himself time by going thought the proper channels like dating Susan for a span of time, he would have seen better whether she was the one or not, let alone a better perspective on what true love really is, instead of winding up in bitter disappointment.
As I mentioned even though it's not a big part of the film, it's still there as there is almost this contrasting parallel between both Kane and Thatcher. Thatcher, we don't know a lot about, but we get a good idea on the kind of person he is, an elitest who only pursuit and purpose in life is to simply make more money. As time went on, he became bitter and miserly, but most of all seems to have this hatred toward Kane despite the fact he was his stepfather.
The real reason for this hatred is that he actually envy Kane, and in reality hates himself. Despite Thatcher's success, he couldn't get the fame and attention that Kane was able to acquire as he was attaining his own success as we see Thatcher wasn't charismatic, he lacked imagination, too technical in his thinking, but worst of all just antisocial as he seems like he has no friends or even a love life, as least none I know about.
Really liked one thing the character Berstein said about Thatcher's success which is one of my favorite quotes believe it or not, "It's no trick to make a lot of money, if all you want is to make a lot of money." And it's true because that is the only think Thatcher is known for is in the money he's made. Thatcher is literally a caricature of himself as he literally has no life outside of his own business.
We see Kane has that same in fact outdoes the success that Thacher ever had. But sadly, just like with Thatcher he's become embittered mainly because just like him he's let himself get roped in by power and corruption, despite Kane trying to avoid it. Some say part of the reason Kane life has led to downfall and has become a broken old man is because he's never changed and that is part of the reason why he has changed.
Because he never let himself see the truth about what was really going on around him and the truth about what really matters in life in general. Like in one scene when we see Kane rip up a declaration, he created for himself a long time ago; seeing this shows Kane has betrayed himself and worst of all his own dreams and ideals. Though he admits this in one scene when he says another memorable quote "I could have become a great man." and he's right as we see from his whole life it felt like he came close but never made it. Finally, like with Thatcher, his mansion in a way is a crypt on it's own, even though it has just this giant assortment of things they might as well be nothing, because none of them really added up to anything, except for one thing of real value which is revealed in the end.
The ending reveal is true by today's standards probably doesn't have the same impact as it does anymore as it's not that big a secret anymore, it's one of those things where you had to of been there when it happened. But it's still one of the best reveals ever because of the weight it carries that makes it even more haunting and tragic. Because it shows how much a corrupt heart can lose his/her soul and can never get it back. But also reminds me of the old saying "you can have everything your heart desires, but not the way it used to be".
Rating: 4 stars.