Stylish, mesmerizing, thought-provoking Movie critics make a lot out of "Close your eyes" (in Spanish, with English subtitle), and rightly so as this is what they are paid to do. These reviews display eye-catching words/phrases (doppelgängers, doubling motif, narratively elliptical) intending to conjure up an aura of depth, layering, allergies. Nothing wrong with that.
This movie, however, can also be enjoyed as a straightforward, simple story, splendidly well told. There is no conclusive evidence that it is something to the contrary, open-ending notwithstanding. Everything in this move can be explained with logical simplicity. There are indeed "pink herrings" (a term I just made up with obvious reference to "red herrings") leading you to think otherwise. For example, when the protagonist goes to a church-administered institution for seniors and psychiatric patients to look for a long-missing friend, you in the audience would automatically assume that said friend is a resident patient under treatment. It turns out that the friend only works there as a part-time handyman, as you'll soon find out.
One other thing I like to dwell on before I move on to the plot - songs. This movie makes very good use of songs. In no less than three places, songs (in Spanish) are used to re-connect people, with varying degrees of success. The one scene that I really love (at about the mid-point of the movie), though, has a song in English. I'll come to that scene later. The song, entirely unexpected, comes after some lazy guitar strumming, "The sun is sinking in the west; the cattle go down to the stream; the redwing settle in the nest; it's time for a cowboy to dream". "My rifle, my pony and me", originally with in indelible voice of Dean Martin, comes from western classic "Rio Bravo" (1959). As soon as the first line of this song is sung in "Close your eyes" I was ecstatic and grateful that I was not in a cinema but at home where I could sing along, about 2/3 of the lyrics I remember by heart anyway.
What follows has spoilers aplenty, be forewarned.
You might have heard a little bit about the movie. In this case the opening scene will be totally baffling, as it seems to have absolutely nothing to do with the context of the story. You see a rich man in his mansion hiring an investigator (not a true professional) to look for a 12-year old Chinese girl lost in Shanghai (his daughter, he intimates), giving him picture of this comely girl holding a Chinese fan. We expect to see next an exotic scene in Shanghai. However, a slightly advanced VO (an often used technique) brings us to Madrid. We come to realize that what we have just seen is from a reel of an unfinished movie which, together with another one, bookends the movie in a precise closure - a movie within a movie. Earlier, I mentioned "pink herring". "Close your eyes" is nowhere near being convoluted. Director Victor Erice just loves to stay a little ahead of you, making you think/wonder a little bit before showing you where it is heading. The details, as they unfold, are never mysterious or illogical.
The bookending movie-in-a-movie reels aside, this nearly 3-hour movie is structured in two parts, with a 15-20 minutes interlude (tonally speaking) in the middle, the most enjoyed part for me, as aforementioned. The first half starts with the protagonist Miguel (Manolo Solo) arriving at a TV studio, accepting an offer for him to appear in a popular program "Unsolved cases". He can well use the remuneration because his life as a director has gone downhill after a movie he was shooting 20 years ago (the reel we see as the opening scene0 comes to ab abrupt halt. Julio (Jose Coronado), the actor who played the investigator commissioned to go to Shanghai, disappeared right after shooting this scene. We are soon brought to understand that Miguel and Julio were lovers living together when this mysterious event happened.
What follows in the first half looks somewhat like a detective procedural, when Miguel's curiosity in what happened 20 years ago is revived. He proceeds with one lead after another, partly at the request of the TV program host Sor (Petra Martinez) and partly out of his own interest. These leads include producer of the movie Max (Mario Pardo), Jose's daughter Ana (Ana Torrent) and a once-glamorous woman Lola (Soledad Villamil) who had been intimate to both Miguel and Julio. Nothing conclusive comes out of these efforts, but the dialogues between Miguel and these three characters are rich in context though not necessarily philosophical.
Then comes this interlude that I find so elating. This is a small village, with humble structures that are more like shacks than houses. Up to this point we have been brought to understand that Miguel is not exactly financially comfortable. But even then, his accommodation is even shabbier than expected. The wonderful irony is that this setting is almost idyllic, although I readily acknowledge that this may not be the most appropriate word to use here. But you feel immediately warmed towards this place as he is greeted by his dog, which we soon learn has been under the care of a wonderful young couple while he is away. Over dinner joined by another chap who is closer to his age, the lively discussion evolves around naming the young wife's soon-to-be-born baby girl. After dinner, relaxing around the coffee table, the young neighbor starts lazily strumming his guitar which leads to, you've guessed right, "My rifle. My pony and me". This idyllic scene is as close as you can ever get to paradise in this movie, or any other movie, for that matter.
The final half is triggered by a phone call saying that Julio has been spotted, taking Miguel away from his humble abode again. His contact at the aforementioned senior home is a very helpful woman called Belen (Maria Leon). This is indeed Julio who, unfortunately, has lost the memory of his own history, but otherwise quite normal working as a part-time handyman there. The medical team that found Julio and attended to him has not found any specific cause for his loss of memory. Miguel brought Ana over but Julio does not recognize his own daughter.
Miguel's last hope is the aforementioned unfinished movie with Julio as the lead. In a small cinema in town, he shows the second part of the unfinished movie, which the audience sees for the first time. Julio's character has completed his assignment, bringing a young Chinese girl to the rich man's mansion. After the initial awkwardness, father and daughter begin to show signs of mutual recognition, culminating in their singing a song together before the rich man dies of a heart failure in the arms of the girl. In the audience are Julio, Miguel, Ana, Sor, Belen and a couple of nuns. The facial expression of each in the audience is shown individually. Julio's reaction to seeing himself on the screen is enigmatic, the concluding shot of the open-ended story.
This black-and-white movie in Spanish is stylish, mesmerizing, and leaves plenty of room for your mind to roam free.