One of the Best Superhero Movies Ever Made The Ultimate Edition. Just wow. I remember first seeing the theatrical cut of BvS, and the only words that came to mind after was "what a mess". I didn't understand. It felt like the film was trying to both say a lot, but also say absolutely nothing. All subtext seemed contradicted by the narrative decisions being made. The plot was a disaster, and barely made sense.
Then, I believe 6-8 months later, Warner Brothers willingly released the Ultimate Edition, and everything finally made sense. You see, this was a movie where the true story tellers didn't have final cut. Where a studio had mandates to keep in every action sequence, regardless of it made narrative sense with the things they decided to cut. The editing itself in the theatrical cut isn't bad, but whoever made the decision to cut key story beats of the movie, made a massive mistake.
The Ultimate Edition, provides the context AND the subtext to the big punches, car chases and action sequences. It provides motive for Clark to not trust the Batman. It fleshes out why Bruce has turned to such extreme violence, and justifies indirect (and honestly sometimes even direct) murder. Things they were gigantic problems for me in the theatrical cut, finally make sense, and have purpose.
The shots, the action, the scale is all on a level no other super hero film had ever reached at that moment in time. We're talking about a film that came out the same year as Civil War, where the high point of the movie looked like they paid a bunch of A-Listers to punch each other in a Walmart parking lot, and they just rolled out a green screen behind them. In comparison, this film is lush, and rich to look at. Zach Snyder loves vignettes, and each frame he stages is essentially a painting unto itself.
Besides maybe Spider-Man 2, I think this may be my favourite superhero film of all time. Couldn't recommend it more.