Synopsis
A robin is shot so the woodland community holds a trial to investigate.
A robin is shot so the woodland community holds a trial to investigate.
¿Quien mató al petirrojo?, Qui a Tué le Rouge-Gorge ?, Кто убил петуха Робина?, Chi ha ucciso Cock Robin?, 谁杀了知更鸟, ¿Quién mató al jilguero Robin?
Animation Challenge 2019 - Week 15: A Silly Symphony
This was ... kind of weird, frankly. David Hand was an animator who would go on to work on a lot of Disney's classics, from Bambi to Fantasia, and his work here is squarely in what would be the Disney style--it's charming but somewhat unremarkable, with the Bird Town essentially being an excuse for half a dozen cheap puns before we get to the trial which is.......................feels sort of kafkaesque in its highlighting of a justice system that's completely dysfunctional (the judge and prosecutor just repeat the same question to a number of helpless witnesses over and over, the police engage in rampant and random brutality, particularly against racially-coded birds, the…
imagining Hitchcock seeing this and being like lmao gotta put this in my next picture
Probably the worst ride at Disney. The terror of being named Cock. Like everyone else here I am constantly on edge something is racist.
Its chilling depiction of the criminal justice system is either deeply flawed, or accurately depicts the system as deeply flawed. I’m leaning towards the latter.
About the weakest Silly Symphony I've seen yet. Less funny and creative than the others I've seen to date.
These bird designs are great, especially the parrot.
Depicts how casual police brutality can occur in society.
The love between Cock Robin and Jenny Wren is smoldering!
A classic short.
Disney in 1935 was depicting police brutality and exposing the issues of the death penalty. Wild to say the least.
At this point, I've been so jaded with the amount of racial fuckery unfortunately and unnecessarily shoehorned into (most?) classic cartoons that the appearance of every black or brown-colored bird made me worry that I was unknowingly witnessing some sort of racist humor that's just so dated it's lost its clarity as a caricature. I'm still not totally sure I didn't -- the blackbird was, I think, supposed to be Stepin Fetchit, and the jury looked just a little too minstrel-y. That being said, the rest of the cartoon is fine -- cute, not remarkable, although Jenny Wren as a Mae West caricature more than makes up for the price of admission.