Watched on Disney+ between 1st-??th January 2025
SEASON THREE
For the first two seasons, I’ve done retrospectives on What If? that cover my overall thoughts on them, but for this last batch of episodes, I’m doing something a bit different and going full circle; see, back in June of 2022 I reviewed the first season as individual episodes and I’m doing the same with season three, only here I’ll be posting my instant reactions as I go through them on this…
The Fourteenth/Fifteenth Doctors Ranked
ĦɇłłwȺŧȼħ Ranked
Live-watched on BBC iPlayer
Midnight 2.0 meets Event Horizon.
-OK, so Ncuti wasn't in it nor any other past Doctors or companions. This will most likely annoy several people wanting to have a typical anniversary story with people like Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi and Susan possibly appearing, but ... you know what, I don't care about any of that after having seen this because this was incredible. The best thing RTD has written…
The Fourteenth/Fifteenth Doctors Ranked
Live-watched on BBC iPlayer*
It’s like Saturday night in 2008 and I’m eight years old all over again. 🥰🥰🥰🥰
-It’s fascinating how Davies chooses to open this episode. Unlike Rose/The Eleventh Hour’s opening shot of Earth, it’s more akin to The Woman Who Fell to Earth; a character-driven fourth wall break only what separates it is it’s a catch-up to any casual viewers who need reminding of what happened in Journey’s End. Knowing Davies’ plans, he’ll presumably…
