Jump to content

The Snowden Files

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by LokiiT (talk | contribs) at 02:14, 21 April 2015 (move critic response to appropriate section). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The Snowden Files: The Inside Story of the World's Most Wanted Man (ISBN 978-0-8041-7352-0) is a 2014 book by Luke Harding, published by Vintage Books.

Greg Miller of The Washington Post described the book as the first single-book account of Edward Snowden's 2013 leaking of National Security Agency (NSA) documents.[1]

Due to the portions of the book focused on the British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), Kakutani wrote that those portions "seem particularly aimed at a British audience".[2] Miller argued that the "British perspective" of the book "overlooks some significant U.S. developments and underplays important work done by other journalists, including Barton Gellman of The Washington Post."[1]

Reception

Miller concluded that "Harding has delivered a clearly written and captivating account of the Snowden leaks and their aftermath, succeeding beyond his most basic ambition, which was to arrive in bookstores first."[1]

The book received positive reviews from the The Guardian[3] and the London Review of Books, who called it "a super-readable, thrillerish account of the events surrounding the reporting of the documents".[4] Conversely, The Daily Telegraph's David Blair wrote: "Harding's story crackles with verve, but complexity and nuance are banished. In particular, the real dilemmas of intelligence work are ignored."[5]

The Snowden Files was initially criticised by Snowden associate, journalist Glenn Greenwald, when he had only read extracts from Harding's book. Later, after reading the whole book, he conceded that it did not criticise Snowden. On February 14, 2014 Greenwald told the Financial Times: "They are purporting to tell the inside story of Edward Snowden but it is written by someone who has never met or even spoken to Edward Snowden. Luke came here and talked to me for half a day without [my] realising that he was trying to get me to write his book for him. I cut the interview off when I realised what he was up to." The Financial Times has since amended the article stating: "Harding insists that when he spoke to Greenwald in Rio, he made it very clear he was doing research for his book on Snowden."[6]

Wikileaks founder and Snowden associate Julian Assange harshly criticized both the book and its author, calling The Snowden Files "a walloping fraud, written by frauds to be praised by frauds". Assange stated, "the most disappointing thing of all about The Snowden Files is that it is exploitative. It should not have existed at all. We all understand the pressures facing print journalism and the need to diversify revenue in order to cross-subsidize investigative journalism. But investigative journalism involves being able to develop relationships of trust with your sources."[7]

Michiko Kakutani wrote that in the book the story of Snowden "reads like a le Carré novel crossed with something by Kafka."[2]

Movie

The Snowden Files, along with the fictionalized Time of the Octopus by Snowden's Russian lawyer Anatoly Kucherena, will form the basis of the upcoming Oliver Stone movie Snowden.

References

Notes