Nangnang Kingdom: Difference between revisions
m Task 43 - Avoid unnecessary wiktionary linking in template call |
Rescuing 0 sources and tagging 2 as dead.) #IABot (v2.0.9.5) (Nintendofan885 - 16730 |
||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
=== Chinese and Japanese perspective === |
=== Chinese and Japanese perspective === |
||
The Chinese and Japanese scholars state that the Nakrang Kingdom was just another name used to refer to the Lelang Commandery of the Chinese [[Han dynasty]]. This perspective claims that it was referred to with the name of a [[Monarchy|kingdom]] because the residents were [[Autonomy|autonomous]] but were ultimately controlled by the Chinese commandery. The King of Nakrang was also interpreted to be the same title as the governor of the commandery.<ref>{{cite book|last=Mason|first=David A.|title=Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ChSfCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA150|year=2016|publisher=lulu.com|isbn=978-1329565937|page=150}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|last=Mason|first=David A.|title=Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ChSfCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA151|year=2016|publisher=lulu.com|isbn=978-1329565937|page=151}}</ref> |
The Chinese and Japanese scholars state that the Nakrang Kingdom was just another name used to refer to the Lelang Commandery of the Chinese [[Han dynasty]]. This perspective claims that it was referred to with the name of a [[Monarchy|kingdom]] because the residents were [[Autonomy|autonomous]] but were ultimately controlled by the Chinese commandery. The King of Nakrang was also interpreted to be the same title as the governor of the commandery.<ref>{{cite book|last=Mason|first=David A.|title=Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ChSfCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA150|year=2016|publisher=lulu.com|isbn=978-1329565937|page=150}}{{Dead link|date=February 2024 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref><ref>{{cite book|last=Mason|first=David A.|title=Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ChSfCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA151|year=2016|publisher=lulu.com|isbn=978-1329565937|page=151}}{{Dead link|date=February 2024 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref> |
||
Kenji Takahisa (Professor of [[History of Korea|Korean history]] at [[Senshu University]]) mentions “In that theory, there were Nakrang Kingdom which founded by old Korean ethnic group in Pyongyang, not Lelang Commandery of Han. However, it is difficult to prove this theory because there are many tombs influenced by Han culture found in Pyongyang, while there were not related archaeological and historical resources related to Lelang Commandery in Liaoning area.”<ref>{{Cite book |author=高久健二 |url=http://doi.org/10.34360/00008640 |date=2012-03-08 |title=楽浪郡と三韓の交易システムの形成 |series=専修大学社会知性開発研究センター東アジア世界史研究センター年報 |volume=6 |publisher=専修大学社会知性開発研究センター |page=8|doi=10.34360/00008640 }}</ref> |
Kenji Takahisa (Professor of [[History of Korea|Korean history]] at [[Senshu University]]) mentions “In that theory, there were Nakrang Kingdom which founded by old Korean ethnic group in Pyongyang, not Lelang Commandery of Han. However, it is difficult to prove this theory because there are many tombs influenced by Han culture found in Pyongyang, while there were not related archaeological and historical resources related to Lelang Commandery in Liaoning area.”<ref>{{Cite book |author=高久健二 |url=http://doi.org/10.34360/00008640 |date=2012-03-08 |title=楽浪郡と三韓の交易システムの形成 |series=専修大学社会知性開発研究センター東アジア世界史研究センター年報 |volume=6 |publisher=専修大学社会知性開発研究センター |page=8|doi=10.34360/00008640 }}</ref> |
||
Revision as of 01:31, 6 February 2024
| Korean name | |
| Hangul | 낙랑국 |
|---|---|
| Hanja | |
| Revised Romanization | Nakrangguk |
| McCune–Reischauer | Nakrangkuk |
Nakrang Kingdom (Korean: 낙랑국; Hanja: 樂浪國) was a kingdom located in the northwestern part of the Korean Peninsula according to Samguk Sagi. The kingdom's independence, however, is debated.[1] According to the ancient Korean record of Samguk Sagi, the King of Nakrang named Choi Ri met the Prince Hodong of Goguryeo and let him marry his daughter, the Princess of Nakrang. When Prince Hodong asked the princess to break drums and horns in the Nakrang's armory to prevent the kingdom's guards from alerting the attack by Goguryeo, the princess followed Hodong's instructions, leading to Nakrang being conquered by Goguryeo.[2]
Dispute regarding independence
The view regarding Nakrang's independence is disputed. While Chinese and Japanese scholars claim that the name Nakrang actually refers to the Lelang Commandery of China's Han dynasty and Choi Ri was Lelang's governor rather than a King,[3][4] Korean scholars often view Nakrang as an independent kingdom.[2]
Korean perspective
Korean scholars tend to view Nakrang as an independent kingdom given that the ancient Korean record Samguk Sagi referred to Nakrang as a kingdom and Choi Ri as Nakrang's King (樂浪王).[2] They also point out the lack of Chinese record mentioning Choi Ri as the official of Lelang.[2] It is also noted that Goguryeo must had attacked Lelang Commandry during the time period mentioned in Samguk Sagi if the name Nakrang indeed referred to Lelang. However, there is no record of such war between Goguryeo and Lelang at the mentioned time, suggesting that Nakrang was possibly a different state than Lelang.[2]
Because the record of Samguk Sagi also suggested that Choi Ri and Hodong met near modern-day Hamhung, some South Korean scholars speculate Nakrang to be a kingdom centered around Hamhung, possibly related to the several states that briefly evolved and lived after the abolishment of Lelang Commandery, before being absorbed by Goguryeo.[2]
North Korean academia fully assert that Nakrang was an independent country that existed in modern-day Pyongyang and composed Mahan confederacy, arguing Lelang Commandery to be actually located near Liao River of Liaodong Peninsula.[3] The North Korean academia also speculate the Chinese-style ruins and relics found in Pyongyang to be either the war bounties, introduced through trade, or even forged. They also emphasize that the Korean characteristics found in the ruins and relics should not be negated.[3]
Chinese and Japanese perspective
The Chinese and Japanese scholars state that the Nakrang Kingdom was just another name used to refer to the Lelang Commandery of the Chinese Han dynasty. This perspective claims that it was referred to with the name of a kingdom because the residents were autonomous but were ultimately controlled by the Chinese commandery. The King of Nakrang was also interpreted to be the same title as the governor of the commandery.[5][6]
Kenji Takahisa (Professor of Korean history at Senshu University) mentions “In that theory, there were Nakrang Kingdom which founded by old Korean ethnic group in Pyongyang, not Lelang Commandery of Han. However, it is difficult to prove this theory because there are many tombs influenced by Han culture found in Pyongyang, while there were not related archaeological and historical resources related to Lelang Commandery in Liaoning area.”[7]
Shouei Mishina criticized the claim that Nakrang Kingdom was different from the Lelang Commandery and said that it ignored the situation of Lelang Commandery of the Eastern Han dynasty.[8]
References
- ^ 崔泰永,張泰煥 (1993). 韓國上古史. 三志社. p. 54.
- ^ a b c d e f "Goguryeo Bongi Vol. 14 Ch. 2". Samguk Sagi. National Institute of Korean History.
- ^ a b c Ch'oe, Yŏng-ho (1980). "An Outline History of Korean Historiography". Korean Studies. 4: 23–25. doi:10.1353/ks.1980.0003. S2CID 162859304.
- ^ Armstrong, Charles K. (1995). "Centering the Periphery: Manchurian Exile(s) and the North Korean State". Korean Studies. 19. University of Hawaii Press: 11–12. doi:10.1353/ks.1995.0017. S2CID 154659765.
- ^ Mason, David A. (2016). Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won. lulu.com. p. 150. ISBN 978-1329565937.[permanent dead link]
- ^ Mason, David A. (2016). Solitary Sage: The Profound Life, Wisdom and Legacy of Korea's "Go-un" Choi Chi-won. lulu.com. p. 151. ISBN 978-1329565937.[permanent dead link]
- ^ 高久健二 (2012-03-08). 楽浪郡と三韓の交易システムの形成. 専修大学社会知性開発研究センター東アジア世界史研究センター年報. Vol. 6. 専修大学社会知性開発研究センター. p. 8. doi:10.34360/00008640.
- ^ 旗田巍先生古稀記念会 (1979). 朝鮮歴史論集 上. 龍渓書舎. p. 82.