Inside the Soviet Army: Difference between revisions
add significance to Lead |
m adding "1982 book by Viktor Suvorov" as short description via DescDash |
||
(7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{short description|1982 book by Viktor Suvorov}} |
|||
{{infobox book |
{{infobox book |
||
|author = [[Viktor Suvorov]] |
| author = [[Viktor Suvorov]] |
||
| pub_date = 1982 |
| pub_date = 1982 |
||
| image = File:Inside_the_Soviet_Army.jpg |
|||
}} |
|||
'''''Inside the Soviet Army''''' ({{ISBN|0-241-10889-6}}; Hamish Hamilton, 1982; also published in the United States, Prentice Hall, {{ISBN|0-02-615500-1}}), is a book by [[Viktor Suvorov]], which describes the general organisation, doctrine, and strategy of the Soviet armed forces (the term "Army" being used to cover not only the land force, but also [[Strategic Rocket Forces|strategic rocket]], [[soviet Anti-Air Defense|air defence]], air, and naval forces). United States military reviewers described this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade.<ref name="AF"/> |
'''''Inside the Soviet Army''''' ({{ISBN|0-241-10889-6}}; Hamish Hamilton, 1982; also published in the United States, Prentice Hall, {{ISBN|0-02-615500-1}}), is a book by [[Viktor Suvorov]] (published under his pseudonym), which describes the general organisation, doctrine, and strategy of the Soviet armed forces (the term "Army" being used to cover not only the land force, but also [[Strategic Rocket Forces|strategic rocket]], [[soviet Anti-Air Defense|air defence]], air, and naval forces). United States military reviewers described this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade.<ref name="AF"/> |
||
Suvorov was a veteran of the Soviet armed forces and military intelligence. He had defected to the United Kingdom in 1978 and published his first book there in 1981. All of his books have first been published in Russian; several have been translated into English, as these first two were. |
|||
==Description== |
==Description== |
||
Suvorov, a Russian-Ukrainian who was a former veteran and intelligence agent in the Soviet Union before defecting to the United Kingdom in 1978, explains his view on Soviet political realities. He portrays the military as an institution in which everything is subordinated to |
Suvorov, a Russian-Ukrainian who was a former veteran and intelligence agent in the Soviet Union before defecting to the United Kingdom in 1978, explains his view on Soviet political realities. He portrays the military as an institution in which everything is subordinated to maintaining the communist regime's dominance, thus explaining the rationale behind Soviet strategic planning. Marxism is treated as a science to govern military strategy as well. He notes that at the time, three forces were always at work with the military: the Party, through the [[Politburo]]; the [[KGB]]; and the Soviet Army officers and hierarchy.<ref name="AF"/> |
||
He describes the organisation of the Soviet armed forces, from the top down, emphasizing the land forces/[[Soviet Army]]. Technical details are presented when they are useful, but he is primarily concerned with explaining the underlying philosophy and culture. He often contrasts these with the Western military approach.<ref name="AF"/> |
He describes the organisation of the Soviet armed forces, from the top down, emphasizing the land forces/[[Soviet Army]]. Technical details are presented when they are useful, but he is primarily concerned with explaining the underlying philosophy and culture. He often contrasts these with the Western military approach.<ref name="AF"/> |
||
Line 15: | Line 19: | ||
==Critical reception== |
==Critical reception== |
||
In "An Insider's Warning to the West", Lt. Col. Gregory Varhall and Major Kenneth M. Currie note that in this second book, Suvorov "regards the Soviet military as a formidable adversary despite its shortcomings."<ref name="AF"/> They describe this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade (1970s-to early 1980s), and say that it gave the "first comprehensive look inside the Soviet military since ''The Penkovsky Papers.''" (These were published in 1965, material smuggled by Soviet agent [[Oleg Penkovsky]].) |
In "An Insider's Warning to the West", published in 1983, Lt. Col. Gregory Varhall and Major Kenneth M. Currie note that in this second book, Suvorov "regards the Soviet military as a formidable adversary despite its shortcomings."<ref name="AF"/> They describe this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade (1970s-to early 1980s), and say that it gave the "first comprehensive look inside the Soviet military since ''The Penkovsky Papers.''" (These were published in 1965, a compilation of material smuggled by the late Soviet agent [[Oleg Penkovsky]], who was executed in 1963 in the USSR for espionage.) |
||
The reviewers note that Suvorov emphasizes how different the "experiential and cognitive basis" is for Soviet actions, compared to those of the US. He claimed the Soviets learned about US character by watching films of the Western genre.<ref name="AF">{{cite journal|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=lpo_ZclRfhIC& |
The reviewers note that Suvorov emphasizes how different the "experiential and cognitive basis" is for Soviet actions, compared to those of the US. He claimed the Soviets learned about US character by watching films of the Western genre.<ref name="AF">{{cite journal|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=lpo_ZclRfhIC&q=Reviews+of+Suvorov+The+Liberators+%281981%29&pg=RA5-PA102|title=An Insider's Warning to the West| last1= Varhall|first1=Lt. Col. Gregory| last2= Currie|first2= Major Kenneth M.|journal=Air University Review|volume=35|date=1983|publisher=US Department of the Air Force|pages=101–107}}</ref> |
||
Allan Weeks noted in footnote #16 to his article, "The Soviet View Toward Prognostication" (1983), that Suvorov had emphasized in this second book, in Part 5: "Strategy and Tactics," that the Soviets' offensive strategy was directed at using what they believed to be their superior prediction skills to catch the US and other Western nations off guard. Suvorov noted their success in the surprise invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, and said that there was a Chief Directorate for Strategic Camouflage.<ref>{{cite journal|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WFwJTX43UWwC& |
Allan Weeks noted in footnote #16 to his article, "The Soviet View Toward Prognostication" (1983), that Suvorov had emphasized in this second book, in Part 5: "Strategy and Tactics," that the Soviets' offensive strategy was directed at using what they believed to be their superior prediction skills to catch the US and other Western nations off guard. Suvorov noted their success in the surprise invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, and said that there was a Chief Directorate for Strategic Camouflage.<ref>{{cite journal|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=WFwJTX43UWwC&q=Reviews+of+Suvorov+The+Liberators+%281981%29&pg=RA2-PA57|title=The Soviet View Toward Prognostication |last=Weeks |first=Allan L.|journal=Military Review| volume=63 |date= July 1983 |publisher= US Army Command and General Staff College |pages=57}}</ref> |
||
==References== |
==References== |
||
Line 28: | Line 32: | ||
* [http://militera.lib.ru/research/1/abc/s.html Online books of Viktor Suvorov (mostly in Russian)] |
* [http://militera.lib.ru/research/1/abc/s.html Online books of Viktor Suvorov (mostly in Russian)] |
||
* [http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/index.html Text of the book] |
* [http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/index.html Text of the book] |
||
[[Category:1982 non-fiction books]] |
[[Category:1982 non-fiction books]] |
||
Line 35: | Line 38: | ||
[[Category:Books about the Soviet Union]] |
[[Category:Books about the Soviet Union]] |
||
[[Category:Hamish Hamilton books]] |
[[Category:Hamish Hamilton books]] |
||
{{mil-hist-book-stub}} |
|||
{{USSR-hist-book-stub}} |
Latest revision as of 13:50, 5 June 2024
Author | Viktor Suvorov |
---|---|
Publication date | 1982 |
Inside the Soviet Army (ISBN 0-241-10889-6; Hamish Hamilton, 1982; also published in the United States, Prentice Hall, ISBN 0-02-615500-1), is a book by Viktor Suvorov (published under his pseudonym), which describes the general organisation, doctrine, and strategy of the Soviet armed forces (the term "Army" being used to cover not only the land force, but also strategic rocket, air defence, air, and naval forces). United States military reviewers described this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade.[1]
Suvorov was a veteran of the Soviet armed forces and military intelligence. He had defected to the United Kingdom in 1978 and published his first book there in 1981. All of his books have first been published in Russian; several have been translated into English, as these first two were.
Description
[edit]Suvorov, a Russian-Ukrainian who was a former veteran and intelligence agent in the Soviet Union before defecting to the United Kingdom in 1978, explains his view on Soviet political realities. He portrays the military as an institution in which everything is subordinated to maintaining the communist regime's dominance, thus explaining the rationale behind Soviet strategic planning. Marxism is treated as a science to govern military strategy as well. He notes that at the time, three forces were always at work with the military: the Party, through the Politburo; the KGB; and the Soviet Army officers and hierarchy.[1]
He describes the organisation of the Soviet armed forces, from the top down, emphasizing the land forces/Soviet Army. Technical details are presented when they are useful, but he is primarily concerned with explaining the underlying philosophy and culture. He often contrasts these with the Western military approach.[1]
Suvorov concludes with descriptions of the daily life inside the Soviet Army for the soldier and the officer, including the bullying and the hazing known as dedovshchina. This was almost unknown in the West when he published his book. It has since been reported as notorious in the Russian Ground Forces of the post-Soviet period and contributing to poor morale.[citation needed]
First published in Russian, this book was translated into English and published in editions in the UK and US.
Critical reception
[edit]In "An Insider's Warning to the West", published in 1983, Lt. Col. Gregory Varhall and Major Kenneth M. Currie note that in this second book, Suvorov "regards the Soviet military as a formidable adversary despite its shortcomings."[1] They describe this book as one of the most important in its field published in the previous decade (1970s-to early 1980s), and say that it gave the "first comprehensive look inside the Soviet military since The Penkovsky Papers." (These were published in 1965, a compilation of material smuggled by the late Soviet agent Oleg Penkovsky, who was executed in 1963 in the USSR for espionage.)
The reviewers note that Suvorov emphasizes how different the "experiential and cognitive basis" is for Soviet actions, compared to those of the US. He claimed the Soviets learned about US character by watching films of the Western genre.[1]
Allan Weeks noted in footnote #16 to his article, "The Soviet View Toward Prognostication" (1983), that Suvorov had emphasized in this second book, in Part 5: "Strategy and Tactics," that the Soviets' offensive strategy was directed at using what they believed to be their superior prediction skills to catch the US and other Western nations off guard. Suvorov noted their success in the surprise invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, and said that there was a Chief Directorate for Strategic Camouflage.[2]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d e Varhall, Lt. Col. Gregory; Currie, Major Kenneth M. (1983). "An Insider's Warning to the West". Air University Review. 35. US Department of the Air Force: 101–107.
- ^ Weeks, Allan L. (July 1983). "The Soviet View Toward Prognostication". Military Review. 63. US Army Command and General Staff College: 57.
External links
[edit]- Viktor Suvorov, Inside the Soviet Army, text in English, available for 2-week download at Internet Archive
- Online books of Viktor Suvorov (mostly in Russian)
- Text of the book