Commons:Deletion requests/File:MikeandtheMaddogSuperBowl40Detroit.JPG: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Content deleted Content added
Mikerussell (talk | contribs) |
Mikerussell (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
* {{vk}}: I'm not sure what other source would be more likely than the uploader's own camera, considering the camera position and that it doesn't appear to be a staged or intentional portrait shot. Filename implies ''[[:en:Mike and the Mad Dog|Mike and the Mad Dog]]'' (New York City radio show) broadcasting from [[:en:Super Bowl XL|Super Bowl XL]] in Detroit in February 2006. Maybe it's just cropped from a relatively cheap pre-2006 digital camera shot; remember that optical zoom wasn't common on pocket cameras at the time. "Self made" was explicitly typed in the description in addition to using {{tl|own}}, and uploader [[:en:User:Mikerussell]] appears to be a professional writer, so he probably understands what "own work" means. --[[User:Closeapple|Closeapple]] ([[User talk:Closeapple|<span class="signature-talk">talk</span>]]) 03:09, 21 November 2012 (UTC) |
* {{vk}}: I'm not sure what other source would be more likely than the uploader's own camera, considering the camera position and that it doesn't appear to be a staged or intentional portrait shot. Filename implies ''[[:en:Mike and the Mad Dog|Mike and the Mad Dog]]'' (New York City radio show) broadcasting from [[:en:Super Bowl XL|Super Bowl XL]] in Detroit in February 2006. Maybe it's just cropped from a relatively cheap pre-2006 digital camera shot; remember that optical zoom wasn't common on pocket cameras at the time. "Self made" was explicitly typed in the description in addition to using {{tl|own}}, and uploader [[:en:User:Mikerussell]] appears to be a professional writer, so he probably understands what "own work" means. --[[User:Closeapple|Closeapple]] ([[User talk:Closeapple|<span class="signature-talk">talk</span>]]) 03:09, 21 November 2012 (UTC) |
||
* {{comment}}: I've also notified the original Wikipedia uploader at [[:en:User talk:Mikerussell#MikeandtheMaddogSuperBowl40Detroit.JPG nominated for deletion]]. (One has to watch out for files uploaded by {{user|BotMultichill}} or {{user|File Upload Bot (Magnus Manske)}}; they are originally from another uploader on Wikipedia usually.) |
* {{comment}}: I've also notified the original Wikipedia uploader at [[:en:User talk:Mikerussell#MikeandtheMaddogSuperBowl40Detroit.JPG nominated for deletion]]. (One has to watch out for files uploaded by {{user|BotMultichill}} or {{user|File Upload Bot (Magnus Manske)}}; they are originally from another uploader on Wikipedia usually.) |
||
* This is ridiculous, I took the photo myself at the RenCen, ever been to Detroit jackass [[User talk:INeverCry|<font face="AR Cena" color="black"><b>INeverCry</b></font>]]? No, they wouldn't let you get out alive. Why would I lie, nominating jerk. Find something useful to do with your life willya.--[[User:Mikerussell|Mikerussell]] ([[User talk:Mikerussell|<span class="signature-talk">talk</span>]]) 05:05, 21 November 2012 (UTC) |
:* {{vk}}: This is ridiculous, I took the photo myself at the RenCen, ever been to Detroit jackass [[User talk:INeverCry|<font face="AR Cena" color="black"><b>INeverCry</b></font>]]? No, they wouldn't let you get out alive. Why would I lie, nominating jerk. Find something useful to do with your life willya.--[[User:Mikerussell|Mikerussell]] ([[User talk:Mikerussell|<span class="signature-talk">talk</span>]]) 05:05, 21 November 2012 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 05:17, 21 November 2012
possible copyvio - small size - no EXIF - own work claim doubtful INeverCry 01:29, 21 November 2012 (UTC)
Keep: I'm not sure what other source would be more likely than the uploader's own camera, considering the camera position and that it doesn't appear to be a staged or intentional portrait shot. Filename implies Mike and the Mad Dog (New York City radio show) broadcasting from Super Bowl XL in Detroit in February 2006. Maybe it's just cropped from a relatively cheap pre-2006 digital camera shot; remember that optical zoom wasn't common on pocket cameras at the time. "Self made" was explicitly typed in the description in addition to using {{Own}}, and uploader en:User:Mikerussell appears to be a professional writer, so he probably understands what "own work" means. --Closeapple (talk) 03:09, 21 November 2012 (UTC)
Comment: I've also notified the original Wikipedia uploader at en:User talk:Mikerussell#MikeandtheMaddogSuperBowl40Detroit.JPG nominated for deletion. (One has to watch out for files uploaded by BotMultichill (talk · contribs) or File Upload Bot (Magnus Manske) (talk · contribs); they are originally from another uploader on Wikipedia usually.)
- Keep: This is ridiculous, I took the photo myself at the RenCen, ever been to Detroit jackass INeverCry? No, they wouldn't let you get out alive. Why would I lie, nominating jerk. Find something useful to do with your life willya.--Mikerussell (talk) 05:05, 21 November 2012 (UTC)
